Quarry School

Trigonometric identities: crash course

7 lessons15 questions to tryUnit 9 of 11

Short view. Each lesson's rule, its steps and its trap. Switch to Full for a worked example and a question to try in every lesson.Full view. Each lesson's rule, its steps, one worked example with Watch it solved, the trap, and one question to try.

Starts here no skill from another unit needed first

1 What an identity is and how it differs from an equation

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined.

One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.

How

  1. Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.
  2. Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.
  3. Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.
  4. Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.
  5. If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.
  6. If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.

Worked example

Worked example

Is sin t + cos t = 1 an identity?

Decide whether sin t + cos t = 1 is an identity. If it is not, give an angle that shows it.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 30° the point is (32, 12): its two legs add up to 1+32, which is more than the radius 1.
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 45° both legs are 22: going along both legs is longer than going straight along the radius of length 1.
  1. Say what the question asks: does the sine of an angle plus its cosine come to 1 at every angle, or only at some angles?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides are defined, so one angle where the sides differ settles the question.
  2. Look for angles to leave out. Neither side has a fraction, so no angle is left out.Here only a bottom equal to 0 could make a side undefined. Every angle lands on a point of the unit circle, so sin t and cos t always have values.
  3. Test t=0°. Left side: sin0°+cos0°=0+1=1. Right side: 1. They agree.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), so cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0.
  4. Test t=90°. Left side: sin90°+cos90°=1+0=1. Right side: 1. They agree again.The point at 90° is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1. Two agreements still prove nothing: infinitely many angles are unchecked, and at both of these angles one of the two numbers being added was 0.
  5. Test t=30°, where neither sine nor cosine is 0. Left side: sin30°+cos30°=12+32=1+32.sin 30° = 12 and cos 30° = 32. The two fractions have the same bottom, 2, so add the tops and keep the 2.
  6. Compare with the right side, 1. The fraction 1+32 equals 1 only if its top equals its bottom: 1+3=2, that is, 3=1. But 3 is the number that times itself gives 3, and 1·1=1, so 3 is not 1. The sides differ. In decimals, 1+32≈1.366, rounded.A fraction equals 1 exactly when its top and bottom are the same number. Both sides are defined at 30° and give different numbers, so 30° is a counterexample.
  7. Conclude: sint+cost=1 is not an identity. It is an equation that is true at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, and false at others, such as 30°.One angle where both sides are defined and differ breaks a promise about every angle, however many angles agreed before it.
Answer
  • Not an identity.
  • Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is 1+32 ≈ 1.366 and the right side is 1.
  • It holds at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, so it is an equation, not an identity.
Double-check A second way, with a picture: at 45° the point on the unit circle has legs x = cos 45° and y = sin 45°, and the radius to it has length 1. Walking along both legs is a longer trip than walking straight along the radius, because a straight line is the shortest path, so sin 45° + cos 45° is more than 1. Exactly: 22 + 22 = 222 = 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded), not 1. A second angle breaks the claim too, so the verdict stands.

The trap

Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is 1+32 ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 3 of 6 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 3 of 6

One test angle breaks a claim

Is sin(2t) = 2 sin t an identity?

Show the steps and the answer
π/2π3π/22π−2−112
y = sin(2t) (solid) and y = 2 sin t (dashed) meet only at t = 0, π and 2π (0°, 180° and 360°), so a test at…
  1. Say what the question asks: is the sine of a doubled angle always twice the sine of the angle?If one angle gives different values on the two sides, the answer is no.
  2. Look for angles to leave out: there are no fractions, so none.Sine has a value at every angle, since every angle lands on a point of the unit circle.
  3. Test t=0°. Left: sin(2·0°)=sin0°=0. Right: 2sin0°=2·0=0. They agree.This settles nothing: one agreement never proves a promise about every angle.
  4. Test t=30°. Left: sin(2·30°)=sin60°=32. Right: 2sin30°=2·12=1.On the left, double the angle first, inside the parentheses, then take the sine. On the right, take the sine first, then double. Gotcha: sin is not a number multiplying 2t, so the 2 cannot be moved out front.
  5. Compare: 32≈0.866 (rounded) and 1 are different numbers.Both sides are defined at 30° and differ, so 30° is a counterexample.
Answer
  • Not an identity.
  • Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is 32 and the right side is 1.
Double-check A second way: test t = 90°. Left: sin(2 · 90°) = sin 180° = 0. Right: 2 sin 90° = 2 · 1 = 2. You can see the clash without working out the left side: a sine is the height of a point on a circle of radius 1, so it is never more than 1, yet the right side reaches 2 here.

2 The reciprocal and quotient identities

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

Reciprocal identities: csct=1sint,sect=1cost,cott=1tant; flipped back, sint=1csct,cost=1sect,tant=1cott.

Quotient identities: tant=sintcost and cott=costsint.Each holds at every angle where both sides are defined. tan t and sec t are undefined (have no value) where cost=0: t=π2+kπ, which is 90°+k·180°. csc t and cot t are undefined where sint=0: t=kπ, which is k·180°. Here k is any integer: …, −2,−1, 0, 1, 2, …

How

  1. Say what the question asks: which angle goes in, and which function's value must come out.
  2. Pick the identity: a flip of sine, cosine or tangent is a reciprocal identity; sine and cosine divided one by the other is a quotient identity.
  3. Write the function as a fraction in sin t and cos t: csc t = 1sint, sec t = 1cost, tan t = sintcost, cot t = costsint.
  4. Look at the bottom. If it is 0 at your angle, the function is undefined there, and you are done.
  5. Otherwise put in the numbers from the point (cos t, sin t) and divide: multiply by the flip, cancel, and rationalize any square root left in the bottom.
  6. Check: multiply the answer by its partner at the same angle (sin with csc, cos with sec, tan with cot). The product must be 1. An answer of 0 is the one exception: its partner is undefined there, so check instead that the top of your fraction is 0 and the bottom is not.

Worked example

Worked example

All four values at 150°

The point on the unit circle at 150° is (−32, 12). Find tan 150°, csc 150°, sec 150° and cot 150° exactly.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 150° the point sits up and to the left.
  1. Say what it asks: the input is the angle 150°, and four outputs are wanted, the values of tan, csc, sec and cot there.Naming the input and the outputs first tells you which identities to reach for.
  2. Read the point: cos150°=−32 and sin150°=12. Neither is 0.The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t). With no 0 in either possible bottom, all four values exist.
  3. tan150°=sin150°cos150°=12÷(−32)=12×(−23)=−223=−13.Quotient identity: tangent is sine over cosine. Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip; a positive times a negative is negative; then the 2s cancel.
  4. −13=−1·33·3=−33, so tan150°=−33.Rationalize: multiplying top and bottom by 3 keeps the value and clears the root from the bottom, since 3 · 3 = 3.
  5. csc150°=1sin150°=1÷12=1×2=2.Reciprocal identity: cosecant is the flip of sine, and the flip of 12 is 2.
  6. sec150°=1cos150°=1÷(−32)=−23=−233.Reciprocal identity: secant is the flip of cosine. The flip of −32 is −23, and multiplying top and bottom by 3 rationalizes it.
  7. cot150°=cos150°sin150°=(−32)÷12=(−32)×2=−3.Quotient identity: cotangent is cosine over sine. Multiply by the flip of 12, which is 2, and the 2s cancel.
Answer
  • tan150°=−33
  • csc 150° = 2
  • sec 150° = −233
  • cot 150° = −3
Double-check Each value times its partner must be 1. sin 150° · csc 150° = 12 · 2 = 1. cos 150° · sec 150° = (−32) · (−23) = 2323 = 1. tan 150° · cot 150° = (−33) · (−3) = 33 = 1. All three products are 1.

The trap

Matching by first letter. Secant starts with s like sine, so it is tempting to write sec t = 1sint. It is the other way round: secant is the flip of cosine, and cosecant is the flip of sine. Use the memory device each pair has one co (sine with cosecant, cosine with secant, tangent with cotangent), then test with a number: sec 0° must be 1cos0° = 1, while 1sin0° = 10 has no value.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 4 of 7 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 4 of 7

All four from a point

The point (35, 45) lies on the unit circle at some angle t. Find csc t, sec t, tan t and cot t.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The point (35, 45) sits at an angle of about 53.13° (rounded).
  1. Say what it asks: the point is given; find four outputs at its angle.The angle itself is never needed, only its cosine and sine, and the point gives both.
  2. Check the point: (35)2+(45)2=925+1625=2525=1.Every point on the unit circle has x2 + y2 = 1, so this confirms the point really lies on it.
  3. cost=35 and sint=45. Neither is 0.The point is (cos t, sin t), and bottoms that are not 0 mean all four values exist.
  4. csct=1÷45=54 and sect=1÷35=53.Reciprocal identities: cosecant flips sine and secant flips cosine; dividing 1 by a fraction gives its flip.
  5. tant=45÷35=45×53=2015=43.Quotient identity, sine over cosine: multiply by the flip, then divide top and bottom by 5.
  6. cott=35÷45=35×54=1520=34.Quotient identity, cosine over sine: the same steps the other way up, then divide top and bottom by 5.
Answer
  • csc t = 54
  • sec t = 53
  • tant=43
  • cot t = 34
Double-check tan t · cot t = 43 · 34 = 1212 = 1. The other route agrees: cot t = 1tant = 1 ÷ 43 = 34.

3 The Pythagorean identities from the unit circle

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

sin2t+cos2t=1 for every angle t.

1+tan2t=sec2t for every angle t with cost≠0.1+cot2t=csc2t for every angle t with sint≠0.

How

  1. Write the parent identity: sin2t + cos2t = 1.
  2. Choose what to divide by: cos2t to reach tangent and secant, sin2t to reach cotangent and cosecant.
  3. Set cos t (or sin t) equal to 0 to find the angles to throw out: cos t = 0 at 90° and 270°, sin t = 0 at 0° and 180°, and at every angle ending at those same points.
  4. Divide every term on both sides by the chosen amount, the 1 included.
  5. Split the left side into one fraction per term.
  6. Rename each fraction: a term over itself is 1, and each of the others is a quotient identity or a reciprocal identity, squared.
  7. Test the result at one angle where it should hold, such as 30° or 60°.

Worked example

Worked example

Divide by cos2t: the tangent and secant identity

Start from sin2t + cos2t = 1. Divide by cos2t to get an identity that uses tangent and secant, and say for which angles it holds.

Show the steps and the answer

sin2t+cos2t=1

÷ cos2t, every term, the 1 too

sin2tcos2t+cos2tcos2t=1cos2t

tan2t + 1 = sec2t

not where cos t = 0: 90°, 270°, ...

x = cos θy = sin θP
At 90° the point is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and dividing by cos2t is impossible there.
  1. Say what it asks: turn the sine and cosine identity into one written with tangent, secant and numbers only, and list the angles the new identity must leave out.Tangent and secant both have cos t on the bottom, which is why dividing by cos2t is the move that reaches them.
  2. Write the starting identity: sin2t+cos2t=1.It holds for every angle, from the point (cos t, sin t) on the unit circle.
  3. Find the angles to leave out by setting cost=0. On the unit circle x=0 only at the top point (0, 1) and the bottom point (0,−1), that is at t=90° and t=270°, and at every angle that ends at those points (90° plus any multiple of 180°). Plug one in: cos90°=0, so cos290°=0.We are about to divide by cos2t, and dividing by 0 has no answer. This step finds the angles where the division is impossible, so we can throw them out first.
  4. For every other angle, divide both sides by cos2t: sin2t+cos2tcos2t=1cos2t.Dividing both sides of a true equation by the same nonzero amount keeps it true. The 1 on the right gets divided too.
  5. Split the left side: sin2tcos2t+cos2tcos2t=1cos2t.A fraction whose top is a sum splits into one fraction per term over the same bottom: adding fractions with a common denominator, run backwards.
  6. Rename the first fraction: sin2tcos2t=(sintcost)2=tan2t.Squaring a fraction squares its top and its bottom, and tan t = sintcost is the quotient identity.
  7. Rename the second fraction: cos2tcos2t=1.Any amount other than 0 divided by itself is 1, and step 3 made sure cos2t is not 0.
  8. Rename the right side: 1cos2t=(1cost)2=sec2t.12 = 1, so 1cos2t is the square of 1cost, and sec t = 1cost is the reciprocal identity.
  9. Put the pieces together: tan2t+1=sec2t, usually written 1+tan2t=sec2t.Adding in either order gives the same sum.
Answer
  • 1 + tan2t = sec2t
  • It holds for every angle t with cos t ≠ 0: every angle except 90°, 270° and the other angles that end at the top or bottom of the circle (90° plus any multiple of 180°, or π2 plus any multiple of π in radians).
Double-check Test two angles where it should hold. At t = 60°: tan 60° = 3, so 1 + tan260° = 1 + 3 = 4; cos 60° = 12, so sec 60° = 1 ÷ 12 = 2 and sec260° = 4. At t = 135°: tan 135° = 22 ÷ (−22) = −1, so the left side is 1 + 1 = 2; cos2135° = (−22)2 = 12, so sec2135° = 1 ÷ 12 = 2. Both sides agree each time. Test angles can never prove an identity, but a slip in the steps would almost always show up here; the proof is the chain of steps above.

The trap

Keeping only the positive square root. A Pythagorean identity gives the size of the missing value, not its sign. With sin t = 35 and t in quadrant II, cos2t = 1 − 925 = 1625, so cos t is 45 or −45; in quadrant II the point sits left of the y-axis, so cos t = −45. After every square root, write both signs and let the quadrant choose.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 4 of 7 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 4 of 7

A root that does not come out whole

cos t = −23 and t is in quadrant III. Find sin t.

Show the steps and the answer
QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
In quadrant III sine and cosine are both negative; only tangent and its reciprocal, cotangent, are positive.
  1. Say what it asks: you know the cosine; find the sine of the same angle, with the sign quadrant III allows.Sine and cosine sit together in sin2t + cos2t = 1.
  2. Put in the known value: sin2t+(−23)2=1, so sin2t+49=1.Square the whole value, sign included: (−2)2 = 4 and 32 = 9, and the minus sign is gone.
  3. Get sin2t alone: sin2t=99−49=59.Subtract 49 from both sides, writing 1 as 99 to share the bottom.
  4. Take the square root: sint=53 or sint=−53. Plug back: (53)2=59.The root of a fraction is the root of the top over the root of the bottom, and the root of 9 is 3. No whole number squares to 5, so 5 stays as it is.
  5. Choose the sign: in quadrant III the point is below the x-axis, so its y reading, sin t, is negative. sint=−53.In quadrant III only tangent (with its reciprocal) is positive.
Answer
sint=−53
Double-check Put both values back: (−53)2 + (−23)2 = 59 + 49 = 99 = 1. With rounded decimals: sin t ≈ −0.745 and cos t ≈ −0.667, and 0.7452 + 0.6672 ≈ 0.555 + 0.445 = 1.000.

4 Even and odd: what a negative angle does

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

cos(−t)=cost and sin(−t)=−sint for every angle t, and so tan(−t)=−tant wherever cost≠0.

These are identities. A function f is an even function when f(−t)=f(t), and an odd function when f(−t)=−f(t), for every t where f has a value: cosine is even; sine and tangent are odd.

How

  1. Look at the angle: a minus sign in front of it means the same size of turn in the other direction.
  2. Name the function in front of the angle.
  3. Cosine or secant: drop the minus, because they are even. cos(−t) becomes cos t.
  4. Sine, cosecant, tangent or cotangent: move the minus out in front of the function, because they are odd. sin(−t) becomes −sin t.
  5. If the function is squared or cubed, rewrite inside the parentheses first and apply the power after.
  6. Finish the work at the positive angle, then combine the signs: a minus times a minus is a plus.
  7. Check: add 360° to the negative angle (as many times as needed) and read the point at the new angle.

Worked example

Worked example

Cosine, sine and tangent at −60°

Find the exact values of cos(−60°), sin(−60°) and tan(−60°).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
P, the point for 60°, sits above the x-axis at (12, 32).
x = cos θy = sin θQ
Q, the point for −60° (the same spot as 300°), sits straight below P at (12, −32).
  1. Say what it asks: the input is −60°, a turn of 60° clockwise. Find three outputs there as exact numbers (fractions and roots, no decimals): the cosine (the x of the point), the sine (the y) and the tangent.Naming the input and the outputs first keeps you answering the question that was asked.
  2. cos(−60°)=cos60°=12.Cosine is an even function: the mirror across the x-axis keeps the x. The special-angle value is cos 60° = 12.
  3. sin(−60°)=−sin60°=−32.Sine is an odd function: the mirror flips the sign of the y. The special-angle value is sin 60° = 32.
  4. tan(−60°)=sin(−60°)cos(−60°)=(−32)÷12=−32·2=−3.The quotient identity says tangent is sine over cosine. Dividing by 12 is multiplying by 2, and one minus sign makes the result negative.
  5. Compare with the odd rule for tangent: −tan60°=−3, the same value.tan 60° = 3, and tangent is odd, so tan(−60°) must be −3. Two routes agreeing is a good sign.
Answer
  • cos(−60°)=12
  • sin(−60°)=−32
  • tan(−60°)=−3
Double-check A second way, without the even and odd rules: −60° + 360° = 300°, so −60° ends where 300° ends, in Quadrant IV, 60° below the positive x-axis, at (12, −32). Its x, 12, is cos(−60°). Its y, −32, is sin(−60°). And y ÷ x = −32 · 2 = −3 is tan(−60°). All three match.

The trap

The most common slip is pulling the minus out of cosine: writing cos(−t) = −cos t. Only the odd functions (sine, cosecant, tangent, cotangent) carry the minus out in front. Cosine and secant are even and drop it, because the mirror across the x-axis never moves the x. Say cos keeps, sin flips before you write the next line.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 4 of 7 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 4 of 7

Values given, angle unknown

An angle t has sin t = 1237 and cos t = 3537. Find sin(−t), cos(−t), tan(−t) and csc(−t).

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: you do not know t itself, only its sine and cosine. Find four outputs at the input −t.The even and odd rules need only the values at t, not the angle.
  2. sin(−t)=−sint=−1237.Sine is an odd function.
  3. cos(−t)=cost=3537.Cosine is an even function.
  4. tan(−t)=sin(−t)cos(−t)=(−1237)÷3537=−1237·3735=−1235.The quotient identity, then dividing by 3537 is multiplying by its flip, 3735; the 37 on top and the 37 on the bottom cancel.
  5. csc(−t)=1sin(−t)=1÷(−1237)=−3712.The reciprocal identity; 1 divided by a fraction is its flip, and the sign stays.
Answer
  • sin(−t)=−1237
  • cos(−t)=3537
  • tan(−t)=−1235
  • csc(−t) = −3712
Double-check Another route: work at t first, then use the odd rules. tan t = 1237 ÷ 3537 = 1235, so tan(−t) = −1235. csc t = 1 ÷ 1237 = 3712, so csc(−t) = −3712. Both match. Also, (3537, −1237) is on the unit circle, since 12251369 + 1441369 = 13691369 = 1, as the point for −t must be.

5 Simplifying an expression step by step

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

Simplify by replacing an expression, one step at a time, with a shorter one that has the same value.

Each step is a named identity (reciprocal identity, quotient identity, Pythagorean identity, or the even function and odd function rules for a negative angle) or an algebra move that keeps the value (common bottom, multiply across, flip and multiply, factor, cancel a shared factor). The result equals the original at every angle where the original is defined.

How

  1. Say what the question asks: a shorter expression with the same value wherever the original is defined.
  2. Rewrite every tan, cot, sec and csc in sine and cosine, and write quotient identity or reciprocal identity beside the line.
  3. If an angle is negative, swap cos(−t) for cos t (cosine is an even function) and sin(−t) for −sin t (sine is an odd function).
  4. Tidy the fractions: multiply straight across, flip and multiply to divide, and put added fractions over one bottom before adding the tops.
  5. Look for a Pythagorean pattern, such as sin2t + cos2t, 1 − sin2t or 1 + tan2t, swap it for its partner, and name the Pythagorean identity.
  6. Factor the top and the bottom, then cancel every factor they share.
  7. If a quotient or reciprocal is left, such as sintcost or 1sint, you may rename it tan t or csc t.
  8. Check: work out the start and your answer at one angle, such as 30° or 60°. They must give the same number.

Worked example

Worked example

All four moves in one problem

Simplify 2csct−2sintcott, naming the identity used at each step.

Show the steps and the answer
30°60°√31245°45°11√2
The two special right triangles supply the check values, such as sin 30° = 12 and cos 30° = 32.
  1. Say what is asked: find the shortest expression with the same value as 2csct−2sintcott at every angle where it is defined.Knowing the goal tells you when to stop: when nothing more can be rewritten, combined, swapped or canceled.
  2. Rewrite csc t and cot t in sine and cosine, reading the big fraction bar as divided by: (2sint−2sint)÷costsint.Reciprocal identity: csc t = 1sint, so 2 csc t = 2sint. Quotient identity: cot t = costsint. A fraction bar means divide.
  3. Give 2 sin t the bottom sin t: 2sint=2sin2tsint.Fractions are subtracted over one bottom. Multiplying top and bottom by sin t multiplies by sintsint = 1, and sin t · sin t = sin2t.
  4. Subtract the tops: 2sint−2sin2tsint=2−2sin2tsint.With one bottom, the tops combine and the bottom stays.
  5. Factor 2 out of the top: 2(1−sin2t)sint.Both terms on top, 2 and 2 sin2t, share the factor 2, and pulling it out shows the pattern 1 − sin2t.
  6. Swap 1−sin2t for cos2t: 2cos2tsint.Pythagorean identity: sin2t + cos2t = 1; subtracting sin2t from both sides gives 1 − sin2t = cos2t.
  7. Divide by costsint by flipping it and multiplying: 2cos2tsint·sintcost=2cos2t·sintsint·cost.Dividing by a fraction is multiplying by its flip; then multiply tops together and bottoms together.
  8. Cancel sin t and one cos t: 2·cost·cost·sintsint·cost=2cost.cos2t is cos t · cos t. The factors sin t and cos t each multiply the whole top and the whole bottom, so each pair divides to 1.
  9. Say where the answer holds: wherever sint≠0 and cost≠0.The original needs sin t ≠ 0 for csc t and cot t, and it needs cot t ≠ 0, that is cos t ≠ 0, because cot t is its bottom. At all those angles every swap kept the value.
Answer
2 cos t, wherever sin t ≠ 0 and cos t ≠ 0
Double-check At t = 30°: sin 30° = 12 and cos 30° = 32, so csc 30° = 1 ÷ 12 = 2 and cot 30° = 32 ÷ 12 = 3. The start's top is 2 · 2 − 2 · 12 = 4 − 1 = 3, and 3 ÷ 3 = 3, because 3 · 3 = 3. The answer: 2 cos 30° = 2 · 32 = 3. Both give 3. One angle cannot prove the two always agree, but a mismatch would have exposed a mistake.

The trap

Canceling a term instead of a factor. You may cross out only a piece that multiplies the entire top and the entire bottom. In cost+sintcost the cos t on top is added to sin t, so it does not cancel; the fraction splits into costcost + sintcost = 1 + tan t. When the piece is in every term on top, factor first and then cancel: cost+sint·costcost = cost(1+sint)cost = 1 + sin t.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 4 of 7 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 4 of 7

Rewrite, combine, swap

Simplify 3 cot t · cos t + 3 sin t, that is, find a shorter expression with the same value wherever cot t is defined.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Rewrite cot t as costsint and multiply: 3·costsint·cost=3cos2tsint.Quotient identity: cot t = costsint. Multiplying the fraction by 3 and by cos t multiplies its top, and cos t · cos t = cos2t.
  2. Give 3 sin t the bottom sin t: 3sint=3sin2tsint.Fractions are added over one bottom; multiplying top and bottom by sin t multiplies by 1.
  3. Add the tops: 3cos2t+3sin2tsint.With one bottom, the tops add and the bottom stays.
  4. Factor 3 out of the top: 3(cos2t+sin2t)sint.Both terms on top share the factor 3.
  5. Swap cos2t+sin2t for 1: 3sint.Pythagorean identity: sin2t + cos2t = 1, and the order of adding does not matter.
  6. Rename: 3sint=3·1sint=3csct.Reciprocal identity read backwards: 1sint = csc t.
Answer
3 csc t, wherever sin t ≠ 0 (the same answer can be written 3sint)
Double-check At t = 30°: cot 30° = 32 ÷ 12 = 3 and cos 30° = 32, so 3 · 3 · 32 = 92, and 3 sin 30° = 32. The start is 92 + 32 = 6. The answer: 3 csc 30° = 3 · 2 = 6. Both give 6.

6 Proving an identity by working on one side

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

To prove an identity in this course, work on one side.

Start with the more complicated side and rewrite it one step at a time, using only facts already known: the reciprocal, quotient and Pythagorean identities, the negative-angle facts, and fraction rules that keep the value (a common denominator, factoring, canceling a common factor, multiplying the top and the bottom by the same expression where it is not 0). Stop when the line reads exactly as the other side: the chain of equal lines proves the identity at every angle where every line is defined, and an angle a step leaves out, where both sides of the claim are defined, is checked on its own.
An argument that instead starts from the claim and does the same thing to both of its sides, such as moving a term (a piece joined to the rest by + or −) across the equals sign, shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to run backwards, with any angle where a step cannot run backwards checked on its own. Working on one side needs no such check, which is why it is the method used here.

How

  1. Read the claim and decide which side is more complicated: more functions, more fractions, more terms or higher powers.
  2. Copy that side alone. The other side is the target: do not write on it, and do not move anything across the equals sign.
  3. Rewrite the side one step at a time. Each step is a new line that begins with =, made with the strategies in this lesson: sine and cosine, Pythagorean substitution, factoring, or multiplying by a conjugate.
  4. Beside each step, name the identity or fraction rule that makes it true.
  5. Stop when the line reads exactly as the target, and say that the identity holds.
  6. Check at a test angle such as 30° or 60°: both sides of the claim must give the same number. This catches slips; it does not replace the proof.

Worked example

Worked example

From (csc t − sin t)·tan t to cos t

Prove that (csc t − sin t)·tan t = cos t is an identity. In plain words: start with one side and rewrite it, using only facts you already know, until it reads exactly as the other side.

Show the steps and the answer

(csc t − sin t)·tan t

= (1sint − sin t)·sintcost sine and cosine

= 1−sin2tsint·sintcost common bottom

= cos2tsint·sintcost Pythagorean

= cos t cancel sin t and one cos t

  1. Choose the left side, (csct−sint)·tant, and leave cos t alone as the target.The left side has three functions, a subtraction and a product; the right side is one function. The more complicated side gives you moves to make.
  2. (csct−sint)·tant=(1sint−sint)·sintcostSine and cosine: the reciprocal identity csc t = 1sint and the quotient identity tan t = sintcost.
  3. =(1sint−sin2tsint)·sintcostTo subtract, sin t needs the bottom sin t: multiply it by sintsint, which is 1, to get sin2tsint.
  4. =1−sin2tsint·sintcostThe two fractions now share the bottom sin t, so subtract the tops.
  5. =cos2tsint·sintcostPythagorean identity: sin2t + cos2t = 1 rearranged gives 1 − sin2t = cos2t.
  6. =cos2t·sintsint·costMultiply fractions: top times top, bottom times bottom.
  7. =cost·cost·sintsint·cost=costcos2t is cos t · cos t. The factors sin t and cos t each sit on the whole top and the whole bottom, so they cancel, and one cos t is left.
  8. The last line, cos t, is exactly the right side, so the proof is done.Every line equals the line before it by a fact you can name, so the first line equals the last.
Answer
(csc t − sin t)·tan t = (1sint − sin t)·sintcost = 1−sin2tsint·sintcost = cos2tsint·sintcost = cos t, so the identity holds.
Double-check Test t = 30°, where csc 30° = 2, sin 30° = 12, tan 30° = 33 and cos 30° = 32. The left side is (2 − 12) · 33 = 32 · 33 = 336 = 32, which matches cos 30°. One angle cannot prove an identity, but a wrong step would most likely have shown up here.

The trap

The most common mistake is treating the claim like an equation to solve by moving a term across its equals sign, as in turning sec2t − tan2t = 1 into sec2t = 1 + tan2t. That starts from the claim before it is proved, so it shows only where the claim leads, and it is a proof only if every step can be run backwards. Copy one side alone, write = and the next form of that same side, and keep going until it reads exactly as the other side.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 4 of 7 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 4 of 7

Two fractions over a common denominator

Prove that 11−sint + 11+sint = 2sec2t. In plain words: rewrite the left side until it reads 2sec2t.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Work on the left side, 11−sint+11+sint.It has two fractions to combine; the right side is one term.
  2. =1+sint(1−sint)(1+sint)+1−sint(1−sint)(1+sint)Common denominator: multiply the top and the bottom of each fraction by the other fraction's bottom, which is multiplying by 1.
  3. =(1+sint)+(1−sint)(1−sint)(1+sint)Same bottom, so add the tops.
  4. =21−sin2tTop: sin t − sin t = 0 and 1 + 1 = 2 (gotcha: the sines cancel, so the top is not 2 + 2sin t). Bottom: difference of squares, (1 − sin t)(1 + sin t) = 1 − sin2t.
  5. =2cos2tPythagorean identity: 1 − sin2t = cos2t.
  6. =2·1cos2t=2sec2tsec t = 1cost, so sec2t = (1cost)2 = 1cos2t. This is the right side.
Answer
11−sint + 11+sint = 21−sin2t = 2cos2t = 2sec2t, so the identity holds.
Double-check At t = 30°: 11−sin30° = 1 ÷ 12 = 2 and 11+sin30° = 1 ÷ 32 = 23, so the left side is 2 + 23 = 83. The right side is 2 · sec230° = 2 · (23)2 = 2 · 43 = 83.

7 The usual mistakes in a proof

Open the full lessonOnly this lesson

The rule

A proof of an identity leads from facts already known to the claim.

The method of this course starts from one side alone and changes only that side, one known identity or algebra move at a time, until it becomes the other side.
An argument that starts from the whole claim and does the same thing to both sides shows only where the claim leads. It becomes a proof once every step is shown to walk back, with any angle where a step cannot walk back checked on its own. Squaring both sides walks back only where the two sides are known to have the same sign. Multiplying both sides by an expression does not walk back where that expression is 0, and dividing both sides by it is not possible there.

How

  1. Pick the more complicated side of the claim. It is the only side you will change.
  2. Write that side alone as your first line, with no equals sign and no other side yet.
  3. Change it one step at a time, with an identity you name or an algebra move: combining fractions, factoring, or multiplying one fraction's top and bottom by the same expression.
  4. Before you cancel, check that the factor sits in both the top and the bottom of one fraction.
  5. Do not square, multiply or divide the two sides of the claim: each of those moves starts from the claim and needs a walk-back check that this method never needs.
  6. Stop when your line is exactly the other side. If you are stuck, test an angle: two different values there mean the claim is false and no proof exists.

Worked example

Worked example

Repairing an argument that works both sides

Someone wants to show that sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1 is an identity and writes:
Line 1: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1
Line 2: sin2t1−cost = 1 + cos t (add cos t to both sides)
Line 3: sin2t = (1 + cos t)(1 − cos t) (multiply both sides by 1 − cos t)
Line 4: sin2t = 1 − cos2t (multiply out)
Line 5: sin2t + cos2t = 1 (add cos2t to both sides), which is true.
They stop there. Say what the five lines show when read from top to bottom, what has to be checked before they count as a proof, and then write a proof that starts from one side.

Show the steps and the answer

sin2t1−cost−cost

=1−cos2t1−cost−cost

=(1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost−cost

=1+cost−cost

= 1

  1. Say what the question asks: what the five lines show as written, what they still need, and a proof from one side.A proof is judged by how its lines are built, not only by whether the last line is true.
  2. Read Line 1: it is the whole claim, left side = right side.The argument starts from the claim, the very thing to be shown, so the lines under it show where the claim leads.
  3. Read Lines 2, 3 and 5: each does the same thing to both sides (adds cos t, multiplies by 1−cost, adds cos2t).Doing the same thing to both sides is how you solve an equation. Each such step says: if the line above is true, the line below is true.
  4. Say what the lines show from top to bottom: if the claim is true, then sin2t+cos2t=1. A true last line does not by itself make the first line true.False starts can reach true finishes too: squaring the false 3 = −3 gives the true 9 = 9.
  5. Check whether every step can be walked back, from Line 5 up to Line 1: subtracting cos2t undoes Line 5, Line 4 only rewrites the right side of Line 3, dividing by 1−cost undoes Line 3, and subtracting cos t undoes Line 2.Dividing by 1 − cos t is allowed here because 1 − cos t is the bottom of the claim's left side, so it is not 0 at any angle where the claim's sides are defined. With this check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof; without it they are not.
  6. Now the method that needs no such check. Start from the left side alone: sin2t1−cost−cost.It is the more complicated side; the right side, 1, has nothing to rewrite.
  7. Replace sin2t with 1−cos2t: =1−cos2t1−cost−cost.The Pythagorean identity sin2t + cos2t = 1 gives sin2t = 1 − cos2t, so the value stays the same.
  8. Factor the top as a difference of squares: =(1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost−cost.1 − cos2t has the shape a2 − b2 with a = 1 and b = cos t, and a2 − b2 = (a − b)(a + b).
  9. Cancel the factor 1−cost from the top and the bottom: =1+cost−cost.Wherever the left side makes sense, its bottom 1 − cos t is not 0, so dividing top and bottom by it keeps the value. This is canceling inside one fraction, not dividing both sides.
  10. Combine: 1+cost−cost=1, which is the right side.cos t − cos t = 0, and every line equals the one before it, so the left side equals the right side.
Answer
  • Read from top to bottom, the five lines show only that if the claim is true, then sin2t + cos2t = 1.
  • To count as a proof they need a check that every step can be walked back. Here each one can, at every angle where the claim's sides are defined, because 1 − cos t is not 0 at those angles. With that check written down, the lines read from bottom to top are a proof.
  • A proof from one side, with nothing to walk back: sin2t1−cost − cos t = 1−cos2t1−cost − cos t = (1−cost)(1+cost)1−cost − cos t = 1 + cos t − cos t = 1.
Double-check Test two angles. At t = 90°: sin 90° = 1 and cos 90° = 0, so the left side is 11−0 − 0 = 1. At t = 60°: sin260° = 34 and 1 − cos 60° = 12, so 34 ÷ 12 = 32 and 32 − 12 = 1. Both equal the right side, 1, as an identity must; the tests can only catch a false claim, and the chain from one side is the proof.

The trap

The most common mistake is writing the claim as the first line and then doing the same thing to both sides until a true line appears. It feels like solving an equation, but it starts from the very thing you are proving, and the same moves can carry a false claim to a true line, so the true line proves the claim only if every step can be walked back. Start from one side alone and turn it into the other.

Quick check

Try it before you open its steps. It is question 3 of 6 in the full lesson, where they run from easy to exam-hard.

Try it · level 3 of 6

Squaring hides a minus sign

Someone claims that cos t and −cos t are the same number at every angle, because their squares, cos2t and (−cos t)2, are the same number at every angle. Is the claim right?

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ(1, 0)
At 0° the point is (1, 0), so cos 0° = 1 while −cos 0° = −1.
  1. Say what the question asks: is cos t equal to −cost at every angle?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides make sense, and here both sides make sense at every angle.
  2. Flag the squaring step: (−cost)2=cos2t is true, but it says nothing about cos t and −cost themselves.A negative times a negative is positive, so squaring wipes out the minus sign: two numbers with the same square can still be opposites.
  3. Test t=0°: cos0°=1, so the left side is 1 and the right side is −1.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), and cos t is its x coordinate.
  4. Compare: 1≠−1, so the claim fails at 0°.One angle where both sides make sense and differ is enough to show a claim is not an identity.
Answer
  • No: at t = 0°, cos t = 1 but −cos t = −1, so cos t = −cos t is not an identity.
  • Squaring made a false claim look true.
Double-check Test a second angle, t = 180°: cos 180° = −1, so the left side is −1 and the right side is 1, and again they differ.

8 Quick checks for the whole unit

8 questions

Quick check 1 of 8

Is sin t = cos t an identity? Use t = 0° to decide.

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
  • No. sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1, and 0 ≠ 1
  • one angle where the sides differ is enough.

Quick check 2 of 8

Write sec t and cot t using only sin t and cos t.

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
  • sec t = 1cost, the flip of cos t
  • cot t = costsint, the flip of tan t = sintcost

Quick check 3 of 8

From 0° up to 360°, at which angles is tan t undefined?

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
90° and 270°. tan t = sintcost, and cos t = 0 at those angles, so the fraction would divide by 0.

Quick check 4 of 8

sin t = 817 and cos t < 0. Find cos t.

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
cos t = −1517. From sin2t + cos2t = 1, cos2t = 1 − 64289 = 225289, and cos t is negative, so it is −1517 rather than 1517.

Quick check 5 of 8

Divide each term of sin2t + cos2t = 1 by sin2t. Which identity comes out?

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
1 + cot2t = csc2t, because sin2tsin2t = 1, cos2tsin2t = cot2t and 1sin2t = csc2t.

Quick check 6 of 8

Find sin(−45°) and cos(−45°).

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
  • sin(−45°) = −22 because sine is odd
  • cos(−45°) = 22 because cosine is even

Quick check 7 of 8

Simplify cot t · sec t.

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
csc t. costsint·1cost = 1sint once cos t cancels, and 1sint = csc t (where sin t ≠ 0 and cos t ≠ 0).

Quick check 8 of 8

To prove 1 − sin2t = cos2t, someone adds sin2t to both sides, gets 1 = cos2t + sin2t, which is the Pythagorean identity, and stops. What does the argument still have to say to be a proof, and what is the proof from one side?

Show the steps and the answer
Answer
  • It starts from the claim, so it has to say that its step can be run backwards: subtracting sin2t from both sides of the known identity 1 = cos2t + sin2t gives the claim.
  • From one side there is nothing to run backwards: replace 1 with sin2t + cos2t, and sin2t + cos2t − sin2t = cos2t.