What an identity is and how it differs from an equation
Quick review (2 minutes)
An equation is a question: for which angles do the two sides come out equal?
An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined. One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.
Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.
Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.
Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.
Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.
If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.
If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.
Write the left side and the right side apart, so you work on each on its own.
List the angles to leave out: those that make some bottom 0.
Choose an allowed test angle with exact values; 30° and 60° are the safest.
Work out each side exactly and compare the two numbers.
Different numbers: the claim is not an identity, and you have a counterexample. Same numbers: no verdict; test again or look for a reason that covers every allowed angle.
Decide whether sin t + cos t = 1 is an identity. If it is not, give an angle that shows it.
Not an identity.
Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is ≈ 1.366 and the right side is 1.
It holds at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, so it is an equation, not an identity.
Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.
identity
An equation whose two sides are equal at every angle where both sides make sense. You do not solve an identity for t; you use it to trade one expression for an equal one.
1 In plain words
An equation is a question: for which angles do the two sides come out equal? Usually only some angles work. An identity is a different kind of claim. It says two calculations give the same number for every angle you put in, as long as both make sense at that angle. Think of clocks. A clock stopped at 3:00 matches the real time twice a day. That is like an equation. Two working clocks set to the same time match at every moment. That is like an identity. Now notice what one glance can tell you. If you glance once and the clocks disagree, they are not always the same. If you glance once and they agree, you may have caught the stopped clock at its lucky moment.
2 Picture it
Reminder
Reminder: Sine and cosine on the unit circle, Special angle values, Full turns, Dividing by zero, Adding fractions with the same bottom, Multiplying fractions, What t means, Difference of squares and dividing out, Solving a one-step equation
- Sine and cosine on the unit circle. The point at angle t on the unit circle is (cos t, sin t): cosine is the x coordinate and sine is the y coordinate. At 90° the point is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1.
- Special angle values. sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1; sin 30° = and cos 30° = ; sin 45° = cos 45° = ; sin 60° = and cos 60° = . The point at 180° is (−1, 0), at 225° it is (−, −), and at 270° it is (0, −1).
- Full turns. Adding or taking away 360° lands on the same point of the unit circle: 450° = 90° + 360° lands where 90° does, and −90° = 270° − 360° lands where 270° does.
- Dividing by zero. A fraction whose bottom is 0 has no value. has no answer because no number times 0 is 6; has no single answer because every number times 0 is 0.
- Adding fractions with the same bottom. Add the tops and keep the bottom: + = , and + = = .
- Multiplying fractions. Multiply the tops and multiply the bottoms: · = , and · = = , because · = 2.
- What t means. t means (sin t: find sin t, then square it. At 30°, 30° = ( = and 30° = ( = . It does not mean the sine of .
- Difference of squares and dividing out. − = (a − b)(a + b) for any two numbers: − = 25 − 9 = 16 and (5 − 3)(5 + 3) = 2 · 8 = 16. A piece on both the top and the bottom divides out only when it is not 0: = 5 + 3 = 8.
- Solving a one-step equation. Do the same thing to both sides: in x + 3 = 7, take 3 from each side to get x = 4. Check by plugging in: 4 + 3 = 7.
3 Why
An identity is a promise about every angle. A promise about every case is broken by one case that fails: if a single angle makes the two sides different numbers, the claim is false. A case that works shows only that the promise held there. There are infinitely many angles, so you can never test them all one at a time. To show a claim is an identity you need a reason that covers every angle at once, such as an algebra rule that holds for all numbers. An angle where a side would divide by zero is left out: there is no number there to compare.
4 The rule
An identity is an equation whose two sides are equal at every angle t where both sides are defined.
One angle where both sides are defined and come out different, called a counterexample, proves a claim is not an identity; no number of angles where the sides agree proves that it is.
The same idea, five ways
this is an identity, so the two sides are equal at every angle where both make sense. When the three-bar sign ≡ is used, read A ≡ B as A is identically equal to B.
An identity is an equation that is true at every angle where both of its sides are defined. An equation that is true at only some angles, also called a conditional equation, is not an identity.
- Left side = right side at every t where both sides are defined
- A ≡ B: some writers use three bars in place of = to mean equal for every value
- t − t = (sin t − cos t)(sin t + cos t), for every t
- = 1 for every t in {t | cos t ≠ 0}
- Graph words: the graphs of the two sides lie exactly on top of each other
Two working clocks set to the same time agree at every moment, like an identity. A stopped clock agrees with them only twice a day, like an equation that is true at only some angles.
The same idea, other ways
Draw each side as its own curve. For an identity the two curves lie exactly on top of each other: at every angle where both are defined they are at the same height. For an equation that is not an identity, the curves are apart at some angle where both are defined. They may still meet at other angles, and the angles where they meet are the ones that make the equation true. The curve y = sin t meets the flat line y = only twice in one turn, at 30° and 150°, so sin t = is an equation, not an identity.
A friend says a vending machine always gives the right change. You buy one snack and the change is right. Is your friend proved right? No: the next purchase could still go wrong. But if one purchase gives the wrong change, the claim that it always works is broken, however many purchases went fine before. A claimed trig identity is an always about every angle where both of its sides are defined. One angle where the sides differ breaks it. Each angle that works is like one purchase that went fine: good to see, but no guarantee.
Look at = x. At x = 0: = 0, and the right side is 0, so they agree. At x = 1: = 1, and the right side is 1, so they agree again. At x = 2: = 4, but the right side is 2, so they differ. Two yeses, then one no, and the no wins: = x is true at 0 and 1 but false at 2, so it is an equation, not an identity.
The claim says: at every allowed angle (every angle where both sides have a value), the left side equals the right side. The opposite of every angle works is at least one angle fails. So a single failing angle is exactly what it takes to make the claim false. To make it true by testing, you would have to check every angle, and there are infinitely many: 1°, 1.5°, 1.25°, and endlessly more between any two. No list of tests can finish, so a proof has to be a reason that covers all angles at once, like an algebra rule that works for every number.
One no is enough; a hundred yeses are not. Test angles are the tool for breaking a false claim. A reason that covers every angle is the tool for confirming a true one.
One no is enough.
A hundred yeses are not.
A test angle can break a claim.
Only a reason can confirm it.
| Claim | At 0° | At 90° | At 30° | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| sin t + cos t = 1 | 1 = 1 | 1 = 1 | Not an identity | |
| sin t · cos t = 0 | 0 = 0 | 0 = 0 | Not an identity | |
| 1 = 1 | Identity: the difference of squares rule works for all numbers | |||
| 1 = 1 | : undefined, left out | 1 = 1 | Identity where cos t ≠ 0 |
5 How
- Say in plain words what the claim promises: the left side equals the right side at every angle where both are defined.
- Find the angles to leave out: any angle where a side has no value. In this unit that happens where the bottom of a fraction is 0, or where a square root would hold a negative number. Those angles count neither for nor against the claim. Every other angle is allowed.
- Pick an allowed test angle whose sine and cosine you know exactly, preferably 30° or 60°, where neither is 0 and the two are different.
- Work out the left side and the right side separately, with exact values.
- If the two numbers differ, stop: the claim is not an identity, and your angle is a counterexample, an example that breaks the claim.
- If they agree, you have no verdict yet. Test another angle, or find a reason that works for every allowed angle at once; only such a reason shows the claim is an identity.
Testing a claimed identity
- Write the left side and the right side apart, so you work on each on its own.
- List the angles to leave out: those that make some bottom 0.
- Choose an allowed test angle with exact values; 30° and 60° are the safest.
- Work out each side exactly and compare the two numbers.
- Different numbers: the claim is not an identity, and you have a counterexample. Same numbers: no verdict; test again or look for a reason that covers every allowed angle.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Is sin t + cos t = 1 an identity?
Decide whether sin t + cos t = 1 is an identity. If it is not, give an angle that shows it.
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: does the sine of an angle plus its cosine come to 1 at every angle, or only at some angles?An identity has to hold at every angle where both sides are defined, so one angle where the sides differ settles the question.
- Look for angles to leave out. Neither side has a fraction, so no angle is left out.Here only a bottom equal to 0 could make a side undefined. Every angle lands on a point of the unit circle, so sin t and cos t always have values.
- Test . Left side: . Right side: 1. They agree.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), so cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0.
- Test . Left side: . Right side: 1. They agree again.The point at 90° is (0, 1), so cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1. Two agreements still prove nothing: infinitely many angles are unchecked, and at both of these angles one of the two numbers being added was 0.
- Test , where neither sine nor cosine is 0. Left side: .sin 30° = and cos 30° = . The two fractions have the same bottom, 2, so add the tops and keep the 2.
- Compare with the right side, 1. The fraction equals 1 only if its top equals its bottom: , that is, . But is the number that times itself gives 3, and , so is not 1. The sides differ. In decimals, , rounded.A fraction equals 1 exactly when its top and bottom are the same number. Both sides are defined at 30° and give different numbers, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Conclude: is not an identity. It is an equation that is true at some angles, such as and , and false at others, such as .One angle where both sides are defined and differ breaks a promise about every angle, however many angles agreed before it.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is ≈ 1.366 and the right side is 1.
- It holds at some angles, such as 0° and 90°, so it is an equation, not an identity.
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 6
Rung 1: an identity and an equation with plain numbers
Which of these claims is an identity: that 4x − x always equals 3x, or that 2x + 7 always equals 1?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: for each claim, is it true for every number x, or only for some numbers?That is exactly the difference between an identity and an equation.
- Test at : left , right . Test it at : left , right . Both tests agree.Agreements are encouraging, but they cover two numbers out of infinitely many, so they prove nothing yet.
- Give a reason that covers every x: 4x means four copies of x, and taking one copy away leaves three copies, which is 3x. So is an identity.The reason never uses which number x is, so it works for all of them at once.
- Test at : left , right 1. They differ.One number where the sides differ shows the claim is not true for every x, so 2x + 7 = 1 is not an identity.
- Find where is true: take 7 from both sides, , then divide both sides by 2, . Plug it back in: .Taking the same amount from both sides, and dividing both sides by the same number, keeps them equal. This step finds the one number that makes the equation true, and plugging it back in shows that it works.
- 4x − x = 3x is an identity.
- 2x + 7 = 1 is an equation, true only at x = −3.
Rung 2 of 6
Rung 2: an identity with angles left out
Is = 1 an identity? Which angles are left out?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: at every angle where the fraction has a value, does the cosine divided by itself come out to 1?An identity only has to hold where both sides are defined.
- Find the angles where the bottom is 0, that is, where . Cosine is the x coordinate on the unit circle, and x is 0 on the vertical axis: in one turn, at and at .This finds the angles where the left side would divide by zero, so we can leave them out.
- Plug them back in: and , so at both angles the left side is , which has no value.The points there are (0, 1) and (0, −1). So 90°, 270°, and every angle that lands on the same points after full turns, such as 450° and −90°, are left out. Gotcha: they are not counterexamples, because there is nothing there to compare.
- At every other angle, cos t is a number that is not 0, and such a number divided by itself is 1.1 times the number gives the number back, so the number divided by itself is 1. This reason works for every allowed angle at once.
- Conclude: is an identity, with , and the angles a full turn from them left out.It holds at every angle where both sides are defined, which is what identity means.
- Yes, it is an identity.
- Left out: 90°, 270°, and every angle that lands on the same point after full turns, such as 450° and −90°.
Rung 3 of 6
Rung 3: one test angle breaks a claim
Is sin(2t) = 2 sin t an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the sine of a doubled angle always twice the sine of the angle?If one angle gives different values on the two sides, the answer is no.
- Look for angles to leave out: there are no fractions, so none.Sine has a value at every angle, since every angle lands on a point of the unit circle.
- Test . Left: . Right: . They agree.This settles nothing: one agreement never proves a promise about every angle.
- Test . Left: . Right: .On the left, double the angle first, inside the parentheses, then take the sine. On the right, take the sine first, then double. Gotcha: sin is not a number multiplying 2t, so the 2 cannot be moved out front.
- Compare: (rounded) and 1 are different numbers.Both sides are defined at 30° and differ, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is and the right side is 1.
Rung 4 of 6
Rung 4: four agreements, still false
Is sin t · cos t = 0 an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the sine of an angle times its cosine always 0?One angle where the product is not 0 will settle it.
- Test the four angles on the axes. At : . At : . At : . At : . All four agree with the right side, 0.At these angles the point sits on an axis, at (1, 0), (0, 1), (−1, 0) and (0, −1), so one coordinate is 0, and anything times 0 is 0.
- Notice why they agreed: at each of those angles one of the two numbers being multiplied was 0. That comes from the angles we picked, not from a reason that covers every angle.Gotcha: an agreement caused by a zero says nothing about the angles where neither sine nor cosine is 0.
- Test : .Multiply tops and multiply bottoms: 1 · = and 2 · 2 = 4.
- Compare: (rounded), which is not 0.A fraction is 0 only when its top is 0, and is not 0. Both sides are defined at 30°, so 30° is a counterexample.
- Not an identity.
- Counterexample: at t = 30°, the left side is and the right side is 0.
Rung 5 of 6
Rung 5: a true identity and its reason
Is (sin t + cos t = 1 + 2 sin t cos t an identity?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: is the square of always the same number as 1 plus twice the product sin t cos t?An identity must hold at every allowed angle; there are no fractions here, so every angle is allowed.
- Test : left ; right . They agree.sin 0° = 0 and cos 0° = 1; add first, then square, since the square sits outside the parentheses.
- Test t = 30°, left side: .Add the two fractions over the bottom 2, square top and bottom, and expand (1 + as + 2 · 1 · + (. Then split into + .
- Right side at : . The two sides agree.Multiply the tops, 2 · 1 · = 2, and the bottoms, 2 · 2 = 4, then reduce by 2.
- Agreement still proves nothing, so look for a reason. Write a for sin t and b for cos t. The left side is , and the refresher's says at every angle. So the left side is , the right side.The expansion of a square is true for any two numbers a and b, and the point (cos t, sin t) sits on the unit circle at every angle, so both facts hold at every angle at once: it is an identity.
Rung 6 of 6
Rung 6: a true identity with angles left out
Is = sin t + cos t an identity? Which angles are left out?
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what the question asks: wherever the fraction on the left has a value, does it always equal ?An identity only has to hold where both sides are defined.
- Find the angles where the bottom is 0: means , a point of the unit circle whose x and y are equal. In one turn that happens at and at .This finds the angles where the left side would divide by zero, so we can leave them out. At 45° both coordinates are ; at 225°, halfway around the circle from 45°, both are −.
- Plug them back in: at ; at .Both bottoms are 0, so 45°, 225°, and every angle that lands on those points after full turns are left out. Gotcha: they are not counterexamples, even though the right side has a value there; a counterexample needs both sides defined.
- Test an allowed angle, : left ; right . They agree.The point at 180° is (−1, 0), so sin 180° = 0 and cos 180° = −1. Agreement is good news, but still not a proof.
- Find a reason. The difference of squares rule, , is true for any two numbers a and b, and at every angle sin t and cos t are two numbers. So the top, t, equals at every angle, and the left side is .Two things that are equal at every angle can be swapped for each other, so the top can be replaced by the product.
- Divide out the piece , which sits on both the top and the bottom: , the right side.At every allowed angle that piece is a number that is not 0, and such a number divided by itself is 1, as with = 1 in rung 2. This reason covers every allowed angle at once, so the claim is an identity.
- Yes, it is an identity.
- Left out: 45°, 225°, and every angle that lands on the same point after full turns.
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: one no is enough; a hundred yeses are not. A test angle can break a claim. Only a reason that covers every allowed angle can confirm one.
- Pick 30° or 60° as test angles: there sine and cosine are different, and neither is 0 or 1. At 0°, 90°, 180° and 270° one of them is 0, and a 0 can hide a difference: sin t · cos t = 0 agrees at all four and is still false.
- Be careful with 45°: sine and cosine are equal there, so a false claim that trades one for the other, such as sin t = cos t, passes the test. At 30° it fails, since is not .
- Before you compare, make sure both sides are defined at your test angle. If a bottom is 0 there, the angle is left out; pick another.
- If two decimals differ only in the last digit, suspect rounding, not a counterexample. For example, 2 · = is true, yet with rounded decimals 2 · 0.8660 = 1.7320 while ≈ 1.7321. Redo the test with exact values before you call a claim false.
- A graph that shows the two sides on top of each other is strong evidence, not proof: it shows many angles, never every angle.
- Why identities matter: the two sides are equal at every allowed angle, so you may swap one for the other anywhere. The rest of this unit uses that swap to rewrite things in simpler forms and to prove that two sides are the same.
7 The trap
Testing one angle, seeing the two sides agree, and calling the claim an identity. Agreement proves nothing: sin t + cos t = 1 agrees at 0° and at 90° and is still false, since at 30° the left side is ≈ 1.366, not 1. Use test angles only to disprove; to prove, give a reason that covers every allowed angle.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
What does an identity claim that an ordinary equation does not?
- It claims the two sides are equal at every angle where both are defined, like two working clocks set to the same time.
- An ordinary equation usually holds only at some angles, like a stopped clock that is right twice a day.
When you check a claim with cos t in the bottom of a fraction, why do you leave out 90°?
The claim sin t = cos t is true at 45°. Is it an identity?
- No. The sides match at 45° only because sine and cosine are both there.
- At 30° the left side is but the right side is ≈ 0.866, so 30° is a counterexample.