Quarry School

Trigonometry / Trigonometric equations

Trigonometric equations

Subject: Mathematics

All 8 lessons, in order.

The unit at a glance

  1. What it means to solve a trigonometric equation

    A trigonometric equation has sine, cosine or another trig function of an unknown angle t in it, like sin t = 12.

  2. Solving sin t = c, cos t = c and tan t = c on one turn

    Until now you went forward, from an angle to its sine.

  3. Writing every solution with the period

    Picture a Ferris wheel that takes 10 minutes to go around once.

  4. Equations with a multiple of the angle

    Picture two runners on a round track, starting side by side.

  5. Equations that factor like a quadratic

    A trigonometric equation such as 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0 looks crowded. (sin2 t means sin t times itself.) The trick: cover every sin t with a sticky note marked u.

  6. Rewriting with an identity first

    Picture a wallet with dollars and euros, and a bill to pay in dollars.

  7. Equations a calculator finishes

    Some trigonometric equations, like sin t = 0.4, do not land on a special angle, so no triangle or unit circle point you know gives the answer.

  8. Checking for extra solutions after squaring

    Some trigonometric equations mix sine and cosine in a way none of the earlier methods can untangle, so you square both sides.

Rules (8)
  • What it means to solve a trigonometric equation

    A solution of a trigonometric equation is an angle t that makes it true. For sin t = c with −1 < c < 1 and c ≠ 0, one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π, holds exactly two solutions, in the two quadrants where sine has the sign of c; and if t is a solution, so is t plus or minus any number of full turns 2π.

  • Solving sin t = c, cos t = c and tan t = c on one turn

    For 0 ≤ t < 2π, when c is not an axis value and the function can reach it: the size of c gives the reference angle α, the table angle whose sine, cosine or tangent has that size; the sign of c gives the two quadrants where that function has that sign; the answers are α in I, π − α in II, π + α in III and 2π − α in IV. The axis values, 0, 1 and −1 for sine and cosine and 0 for tangent, put the answers on the axes instead, and sine and cosine have no answer when c is above 1 or below −1.

  • Writing every solution with the period

    If t = a solves sin t = c or cos t = c, so does t = a + 2kπ for every integer k; if t = a solves tan t = c, so does t = a + kπ. The general solution: each solution on one turn + 2kπ for sine and cosine, the one solution in [0, π) + kπ for tangent, where k is any integer.

  • Equations with a multiple of the angle

    To solve a trigonometric equation such as sin(nt) = c, cos(nt) = c or tan(nt) = c for 0 ≤ t < 2π: the inside angle u = nt runs over 0 ≤ u < 2nπ, which is n full turns. Find every u on that stretch, then divide each one by n. For a positive whole number n, that gives n times as many solutions as the plain equation, such as sin t = c, has on one turn.

  • Equations that factor like a quadratic

    An equation a·sin2 t + b·sin t + c = 0, with a ≠ 0, is a quadratic in sin t: writing u = sin t gives au2 + bu + c = 0. Its solutions are the angles t with sin t = u, for each answer u of the quadratic with −1 ≤ u ≤ 1; an answer outside [−1, 1] gives no angle. Cosine works the same way. For tangent, keep every real answer, since tangent takes every real value.

  • Rewriting with an identity first

    sin2t + cos2t = 1 at every angle, so sin2t = 1 − cos2t and cos2t = 1 − sin2t: replace the squared function and keep the lonely one.
    Where cos t ≠ 0, sintcost = tan t, so sin t = cos t becomes tan t = 1, and a·sin t = b·cos t (a ≠ 0) becomes tan t = ba. First test t = π2 and t = 3π2 in the original, because a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions.

  • Equations a calculator finishes

    To find each solution on one turn [0, 2π) of sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c when c is not a special value (and −1 ≤ c ≤ 1 for sine and cosine): in radian mode, the inverse key gives α = arcsin c, arccos c or arctan c. The second solution is π − α for sine, 2π − α for cosine and α + π for tangent. Add 2π to any negative answer. Round only at the end, usually to four decimal places, and write ≈.

  • Checking for extra solutions after squaring

    If a = b, then a2 = b2, but a2 = b2 only tells you that a = b or a = −b. So squaring both sides never loses a solution and can add extraneous solutions: keep a candidate only if it makes the original equation true.

Recipes (8)
  • What it means to solve a trigonometric equation
    1. Read the question in plain words. 'Solve sin t = c on [0, 2π)' asks for every solution on one turn: every angle from 0 up to, but not including, 2π whose sine is c.
    2. To test one angle, work out its sine and compare it with c. Equal means the angle is a solution; different means it is not.
    3. To find every solution on one turn, follow the strategy in this lesson. When −1 < c < 1 and c ≠ 0, do not stop until you have two angles.
    4. To list solutions on other turns, add 2π to each answer once for every turn forward, or take 2π away once for every turn back.
  • Solving sin t = c, cos t = c and tan t = c on one turn
    1. Get the function alone on one side: sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c.
    2. Say what the question asks: every angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π whose sine (or cosine, or tangent) equals c.
    3. Rule out the special cases. For sine or cosine, c > 1 or c < −1 has no solution. If c is 0, or 1 or −1 for sine and cosine, the answers sit on the axes: read them off the circle, check them and stop.
    4. Drop the sign of c and find that size in your function's column of the table. The angle at the start of that row is the reference angle α.
    5. Use the sign of c and All Students Take Calculus to pick the two quadrants where your function has that sign.
    6. Place α in each of those quadrants: α in I, π − α in II, π + α in III, 2π − α in IV. Rewrite π or 2π with the same bottom as α, then combine the tops.
    7. Check: put each answer back into the original equation. Name its quadrant and reference angle, read the size from the table, attach that quadrant's sign, and confirm you get c.
  • Writing every solution with the period
    1. Find every solution on one turn, [0, 2π), with the reference angle and quadrant method from the lesson before.
    2. Sine or cosine: write each one-turn answer + 2kπ. Each such list is a family: one starting angle plus every whole number of full turns, forward or back.
    3. Tangent: keep the one answer in [0, π) and write it + kπ. The other one-turn answer is that one + π, so the family already holds it.
    4. Finish with the words: where k is any integer.
    5. Check: put k = 1 and k = −1 into each family and confirm that each angle lands on a point with the right value.
  • Equations with a multiple of the angle
    1. Say what is asked: every solution on one turn, that is, every angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π that makes the equation true.
    2. Get the sine, cosine or tangent alone on one side, the way you would solve for x.
    3. Give the inside angle, the angle the function acts on, a nickname: u = 2t (or u = 3t, and so on).
    4. Stretch the interval: multiply both ends of 0 ≤ t < 2π by the number in front of t. For 2t that gives 0 ≤ u < 4π, two turns.
    5. Solve for u on the first turn with the reference angle and the quadrant signs.
    6. Add 2π to each of those answers, again and again, keeping every result that is below the new end.
    7. Divide each u by the number in front of t, and simplify the fraction.
    8. Check: the count should be the number of turns times the count on one turn; then put each t back into the original equation.
  • Equations that factor like a quadratic
    1. Get 0 on one side: add or subtract on both sides until every term sits on the left and the right side is 0.
    2. Make sure only one trig function appears (all sin t, or all cos t, or all tan t), with its square in one term.
    3. Write u for that function, so sin2 t becomes u2 and sin t becomes u.
    4. Factor the quadratic in u: pull out a common factor when there is no plain number term; otherwise split the middle term and group. Multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored, such as (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0, skips this step.
    5. Set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u (the zero-product rule). Plug each u back into the factored form to see the product is 0.
    6. Put the function back: each value of u becomes a basic equation such as sin t = −12.
    7. Throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1: no angle has it. Keep every value of tangent.
    8. Solve each remaining basic equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants. For sine or cosine, the values 1 and −1 give one angle each; the other values give two.
    9. List all the angles in order and put each one back into the original equation.
  • Rewriting with an identity first
    1. Say what the equation asks: every solution on one turn, each t in [0, 2π) that makes the two sides equal.
    2. Rewrite with an identity until one trigonometric function of t is left; the strategy in this lesson says which identity. Write each swap inside parentheses.
    3. If you divide by cos t, first put t = π2 and t = 3π2 into the original equation and keep any that work.
    4. Get a 0 on one side. If the equation is a quadratic in the function or has a common factor, factor it, treating the function as a single unknown.
    5. Solve each piece with the reference angle and the quadrants. Throw out any value of sine or cosine outside [−1, 1].
    6. Put every answer into the original equation, not the rewritten one.
  • Equations a calculator finishes
    1. Get the trig function alone: sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c.
    2. Look at c. A special value is solved exactly, with no calculator. For sine or cosine, a c above 1 or below −1 means no solution: stop.
    3. Put the calculator in radian mode.
    4. Press the inverse key (sin−1, cos−1 or tan−1) on c. Call the result α and keep every digit.
    5. Find the second solution: π − α for sine, 2π − α for cosine, α + π for tangent.
    6. If an answer is negative, add 2π to it so it lands in [0, 2π).
    7. Round each answer to four decimal places, write ≈, and put each one back into the equation to check.
  • Checking for extra solutions after squaring
    1. Write the original equation where you will see it at the end. It is the judge.
    2. Square both sides, the whole of each side at once, keeping the middle term: (a + b)2 = a2 + 2ab + b2.
    3. Use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1, get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
    4. Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π). Every answer you get is a candidate.
    5. Put each candidate into the original equation, not the squared one. Keep it only if the two sides match, sign included.
    6. Each kept solution on one turn, a, gives the general solution t = a + 2kπ, k any integer.
Traps (8)
  • What it means to solve a trigonometric equation

    Stopping at the first angle you find. When −1 < c < 1 and c ≠ 0, sin t = c has a second solution on one turn, the mirror image across the vertical axis, and every solution comes back after each full turn. Before you finish, ask two questions: did I find both points, and does the question want one turn or more?

  • Solving sin t = c, cos t = c and tan t = c on one turn

    Stopping at the table. The table gives only the size of c, so answering t = π6 to sin t = −12 loses the sign: sin π6 is +12. After the table, always pick the two quadrants from the sign of c, write an angle in each, and put both answers back into the equation.

  • Writing every solution with the period

    Mixing up the two steps. A family of sine or cosine solutions steps by a full turn, + 2kπ; a family of tangent solutions steps by a half turn, + kπ. For cos t = −22, writing 3π4 + kπ would make 7π4 (k = 1) a solution, but cos 7π4 = 22, the wrong sign. Before you write + kπ, ask: is this tangent? The one other case is sin t = 0 or cos t = 0, whose two families sit half a turn apart and may be joined into one with + kπ.

  • Equations with a multiple of the angle

    Solving for 2t only on the usual one turn, 0 ≤ 2t < 2π, and then dividing by 2. That finds only the answers with t less than π and quietly loses the rest: for sin 2t = 12 it gives t = π12 and 5π12 and misses 13π12 and 17π12. Stretch the interval before you solve, 0 ≤ 2t < 4π, and do all the adding of 2π on 2t before you divide.

  • Equations that factor like a quadratic

    Stopping at the values of sin t. Factoring hands you numbers such as sin t = −12 and sin t = 4, not angles. Each number still needs two more steps: throw it out if it is below −1 or above 1, and otherwise turn it into every angle on one turn with that sine (one angle for 1 and −1, two for the others). Only those angles are the answers.

  • Rewriting with an identity first

    Dividing both sides by cos t, or by sin t, without testing where it is zero. Division by zero is not allowed, so every solution with cos t = 0, at t = π2 or t = 3π2, disappears without any warning; for sin t the angles are t = 0 and t = π. In 2 sin t cos t = cos t, a division loses π2 and 3π2. Test those angles in the original equation before dividing, and when the function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.

  • Equations a calculator finishes

    Stopping at the calculator's answer. The inverse key shows one angle, but sin t = 0.4 has two on one turn. After every key press, ask which other quadrant shares the sign, and find the second angle with π − α, 2π − α or α + π.

  • Checking for extra solutions after squaring

    Writing the candidates as the answer. After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, the list 0, π2, π, 3π2 looks finished, but at t = π the left side is sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, and 3π2 fails the same way. Put every candidate back into the original equation, never the squared one, before you write the answer.

Lesson 1 of 8

What it means to solve a trigonometric equation

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Reading sine off the unit circleLeans on: The sign of sine in each quadrantLeans on: Adding a full turn to a fraction of πLeans on: Reading the interval [0, 2π)Leans on: Negative anglesLeans on: t and θOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

A trigonometric equation has sine, cosine or another trig function of an unknown angle t in it, like sin t = 12. It asks: at which angles does the sine come out to 12? Picture a Ferris wheel with spokes 1 unit long. Your seat starts level with the hub, the wheel's center, on the right. After the wheel turns counterclockwise through angle t, sin t is how high your seat is above the hub. Most of the time it is not at height 12, so the equation is false at most angles. Each ride, your seat passes that height twice: once climbing on the right, once sinking on the left. The next ride repeats both moments. Solving means finding every one of them.

2 Picture it

π/65π/613π/617π/6one periodπ2π3π4π−11π/65π/613π/617π/6one periodπ2π3π4π−11
Plot the height sin t against the angle t and you get this wave.

Reminder

Reminder: Reading sine off the unit circle, The sign of sine in each quadrant, Adding a full turn to a fraction of π, Reading the interval [0, 2π), Negative angles, t and θ
  • Reading sine off the unit circle. sin t is the y coordinate, the height, of the point at angle t on the unit circle: the point at π6 is (32, 12), so sin π6 = 12.
  • The sign of sine in each quadrant. Sine is positive above the horizontal axis, in quadrants I and II, and negative below it, in III and IV: sin 5π6 = 12, but sin 7π6 = −12.
  • Adding a full turn to a fraction of π. Write 2π over the same bottom first: π6 + 2π = π6 + 12π6 = 13π6.
  • Reading the interval [0, 2π). The square bracket means 0 is in; the round bracket means 2π is out. So [0, 2π) is one trip around the circle with each point counted once.
  • Negative angles. A negative angle turns clockwise: −π3 ends where 5π3 ends, because 5π3 − 2π = 5π3 − 6π3 = −π3.
  • t and θ. Both letters name an angle. The pictures label the angle θ; this unit calls it t, so y = sin θ in a picture means sin t here.

3 Why

On the unit circle, sin t is the height of the point at angle t. A level (horizontal) line at height 12 cuts the circle at exactly two points, so the equation holds at their angles and fails everywhere else. The circle is the same on both sides of the vertical axis, so the two points are mirror images with equal heights. Both are above the horizontal axis, in quadrants I and II, the two quadrants that share sine's plus sign. A full extra turn, 2π, puts every point back where it was, so each solution comes back on every turn.

4 The rule

A solution of a trigonometric equation is an angle t that makes it true.

For sint=c with −1<c<1 and c≠0, one turn, 0≤t<2π, holds exactly two solutions, in the two quadrants where sine has the sign of c; and if t is a solution, so is t plus or minus any number of full turns 2π.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Say it out loud: sine of t equals one half. Which angles t, in one turn, make that true?

Write it

Find every angle t, from 0 up to but not including 2π, whose sine is one half.

In math
  • sin t = 12 with 0 ≤ t < 2π
  • solve sin t = 12 on [0, 2π)
  • {t | 0 ≤ t < 2π and sin t = 12} = {π6, 5π6}
  • graph words: the values of t where the wave y = sin t meets the line y = 12
Like

At which moments of a Ferris wheel ride is your seat half a spoke above the hub? Two moments each ride, and the same two on every ride after it.

See it
x = cos θy = sin θ5π/6
The point at 5π6 sits at height 12, level with the point at π6 on the right: two angles, one value of sine.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Draw the unit circle and a level line at height 12. The line cuts the circle at two points: one on the right, in quadrant I, at the angle π6, and its mirror image on the left, in quadrant II, at 5π6. Because sin t is the height of the point, those two angles make sin t = 12 true, and no other angle in one turn does.

x = cos θy = sin θπ/6
The point at π6 is 12 above the horizontal axis; its mirror image on the left, at 5π6, is at the same height.
As a story

You ride the Ferris wheel, and a friend on the ground wants a photo of you when your seat is half a spoke above the hub. Your friend gets two chances each ride: once as you climb on the right, once as you sink on the left. Miss both, and the next ride gives the same two chances at the same spots on the wheel. Two chances per turn, repeated every turn: that is the pattern of a sine equation whose value lies strictly between −1 and 1. A photo at the very top or the very bottom of the wheel gets one chance per turn, and a photo above the top gets none.

By the signs

Sine is positive above the horizontal axis, in quadrants I and II, and negative below it, in quadrants III and IV. Each sign is shared by two quadrants. So a positive value such as 12 shows up once in quadrant I and once in quadrant II (π6 and 5π6), and a negative value such as −12 shows up once in quadrant III and once in quadrant IV (7π6 and 11π6).

QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
Sine is + in I and II and − in III and IV.
With numbers

Test five angles in sin t = 12; the table in the picture shows each angle with its sine. The cells under π6, 5π6 and 13π6 hold 12, so those angles are solutions. The cell under π3 holds 32, about 0.87 (rounded), and the cell under 7π6 holds −12, so the equation is false at those two. 13π6 works because it is π6 plus one full turn: the same point, reached again.

input toutput sin tπ/61/2π/3(√3)/25π/61/27π/6−1/213π/61/2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
The three cells holding 12 have arrows up to π6, 5π6 and 13π6.
Why it must be true

Fold the unit circle along the vertical axis and the left half lands exactly on the right half, so every point on one side has a twin at the same height on the other. A level line strictly between the top and the bottom meets the circle once on each side: exactly two points. When the height is not 0, neither twin is on an axis, so they sit in two quadrants on the same side of the horizontal axis, the two where sine has that sign. And a full turn of 2π ends where it started, so every solution comes back each turn: sine repeats with period 2π.

30°390°same terminal side
A turn of π6 and a turn of 13π6, one full turn more, end on the same side, so they have the same sine.
Value of c in sin t = cSolutions on one turnWhere the points areExample
c > 10the level line passes above the circlesin t = 32: none
c = 11the top pointsint=1:t=π2
0 < c < 12quadrants I and II, mirror imagessin t = 12: t = π6 and 5π6
c = 02the two ends of the horizontal axissin t = 0: t = 0 and π
−1<c<02quadrants III and IV, mirror imagessin t = −12: t = 7π6 and 11π6
c=−11the bottom pointsint=−1:t=3π2
c<−10the level line passes below the circlesin t = −2: none

5 How

  1. Read the question in plain words. 'Solve sin t = c on [0, 2π)' asks for every solution on one turn: every angle from 0 up to, but not including, 2π whose sine is c.
  2. To test one angle, work out its sine and compare it with c. Equal means the angle is a solution; different means it is not.
  3. To find every solution on one turn, follow the strategy in this lesson. When −1 < c < 1 and c ≠ 0, do not stop until you have two angles.
  4. To list solutions on other turns, add 2π to each answer once for every turn forward, or take 2π away once for every turn back.

Finding every solution of sin t = c on one turn

1
Is c greater than 1 or less than −1?
YesNo solution: no point of the unit circle is that high or that low. Stop.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is c equal to 1?
YesOne solution, the top point: t = π2.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Is c equal to −1?
YesOne solution, the bottom point: t = 3π2.
NoGo on.
↓
4
Is c equal to 0?
YesTwo solutions, the two ends of the horizontal axis: t = 0 and t = π.
NoGo on.
↓
5
Is c positive?
YesTwo solutions, mirror images in quadrants I and II.
NoTwo solutions, mirror images in quadrants III and IV.
  1. Say what it asks: the output of sine is c; find every angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π that gives it.
  2. Picture the unit circle and a level line at height c.
  3. Use the decision map to count the points where the line meets the circle and to see where they are.
  4. Name each point's angle: one from the special angles, the other as its mirror image across the vertical axis, which the special angles also list.
  5. Put every angle back into sin t = c to make sure it is true.
  6. If the question covers more than one turn, add 2π to each answer (or take 2π away) once for each extra turn.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Every angle whose sine is 32

Solve sin t = 32 on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π. Then give the two solutions on the next turn, 2π ≤ t < 4π.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θπ/3
The point at π3 stands 32 above the horizontal axis.
x = cos θy = sin θ2π/3
Its mirror image at 2π3 stands at the same height on the left.
  1. Say what it asks: the output of sine is 32; find every angle t in one turn that gives that output, then the ones in the turn after.Solving means finding all the angles that make the equation true, not stopping at the first one.
  2. Size up the value: 32≈0.87 (rounded). It is positive, it is between −1 and 1, and it is neither 0 nor 1.sin t is a height on a circle of radius 1, so only values from −1 to 1 can happen; a value strictly between 0 and 1 gives two points, one in quadrant I and one in quadrant II.
  3. Picture the unit circle with a level line at height 32, high up, a little below the top point.The solutions are the angles of the points of the circle that sit at that height.
  4. The line meets the circle twice: once right of the vertical axis, in quadrant I, and once left of it, in quadrant II.Sine is positive above the horizontal axis, in quadrants I and II, and the two crossings are mirror images across the vertical axis.
  5. The quadrant I point is (12,32), at the special angle t=π3.The special angles refresher gives sin π3 = 32, so this point is at the right height.
  6. Its mirror image across the vertical axis is (−12,32), which the special angles refresher lists at t=2π3.The mirror flips the sign of the x coordinate and keeps the height, so sin 2π3 = 32 too.
  7. Answer for one turn: t=π3 and t=2π3.No other point of the circle is at that height, and each point has exactly one angle in 0 ≤ t < 2π.
  8. Next turn: add 2π, written as 6π3, to each. π3+6π3=7π3 and 2π3+6π3=8π3.A full turn brings each point back to the same spot, so its height, the sine, is unchanged; writing 2π as 6π3 gives the fractions the same bottom.
  9. Make sure both are in the next turn: 2π=6π3 and 4π=12π3, and 7π3 and 8π3 lie between them.The question asked for 2π ≤ t < 4π only, and 6 ≤ 7 < 12 and 6 ≤ 8 < 12.
Answer
  • One turn: t = π3 and t = 2π3
  • Next turn: t = 7π3 and t = 8π3
Double-check Put each answer back: sin π3 = 32 and sin 2π3 = 32 from the special angles, and 7π3 − 2π = π3 and 8π3 − 2π = 2π3, the same two points. Second way, by the mirror: twins above the horizontal axis sit equally far on either side of the top point π2. π2 − π3 = 3π6 − 2π6 = π6, and 2π3 − π2 = 4π6 − 3π6 = π6. The distances match, so the pair is right.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

Rung 1: test one angle

Is t = π4 a solution of sin t = 22?

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θπ/4
The point at π4 sits halfway between the axes, with two equal legs of length 22.
  1. Say what it asks: the input is π4; work out sinπ4 and see whether it equals 22.A solution is an angle that makes the equation true, so testing one angle means working out the left side and comparing it with the right side.
  2. Find the point at π4 on the unit circle: (22,22).π4 is one of the special angles, so its point is in the special angles refresher.
  3. Read its height: sinπ4=22.sin t is the y coordinate, the height, of the point.
  4. Compare the two sides: 22 on the left, 22 on the right.They are equal, so the equation is true at this angle.
Answer
Yes: t = π4 is a solution.
Double-check Second way: π4 is halfway between the horizontal axis and the vertical axis, so the point's two legs are equal. The legs and the radius 1 make a right triangle, so the squares of the legs add up to 12 = 1 (the Pythagorean theorem), and each square is 12. Since (22)2 = 24 = 12, each leg, and so the height, is 22.

Rung 2 of 6

Rung 2: some angles work, some do not

Which of t = π6, t = 5π6 and t = 7π6 solve sin t = −12?

Show the steps and the answer
input toutput sin tπ/61/25π/61/27π/6−1/2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
Only the cell under 7π6 holds −12 in the output row, so only that input is a solution.
  1. Say what it asks: for each of the three inputs, find the sine, and keep only the inputs whose output is −12.The equation is true at some angles and false at others; testing each one sorts them.
  2. t=π6: the point is (32,12), so sinπ6=12.The height is 12, above the horizontal axis, not −12, so π6 is not a solution.
  3. t=5π6: the point is (−32,12), the mirror image of the first, so sin5π6=12.The height is again 12, so 5π6 is not a solution either.
  4. t=7π6: the point is (−32,−12), in quadrant III, so sin7π6=−12.This height matches −12, so 7π6 is a solution.
  5. Look at the output row in the picture: only the cell under 7π6 holds −12.The up arrow in the picture runs from that cell to its input, the one solution in the list.
Answer
Only t = 7π6.
Double-check Second way, by the signs: −12 is negative, so a solution must sit below the horizontal axis, in quadrant III or IV. π6 is in quadrant I and 5π6 is in quadrant II, both above it, so they fail; 7π6 is in quadrant III. Same single answer. Its twin in quadrant IV, 11π6, also solves the equation but was not on the list.

Rung 3 of 6

Rung 3: both solutions on one turn

Solve sin t = 22 on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ3π/4
The twin of the π4 point, on the left, at the same height 22.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle t with 0≤t<2π whose point on the unit circle is at height 22.The solutions on one turn are all the angles in that stretch that make the equation true.
  2. Size up the value: 22≈0.71 (rounded) is positive and strictly between 0 and 1.So the level line crosses the circle twice, in quadrants I and II, where sine is positive.
  3. Quadrant I: t=π4, the angle tested in rung 1.sinπ4=22.
  4. Quadrant II: the mirror image of (22,22) across the vertical axis is (−22,22), which the special angles list at t=3π4.The mirror flips the sign of x and keeps the height 22.
  5. Stop at two.A straight line meets a circle at most twice, so there is no third point at that height.
Answer
t = π4 and t = 3π4
Double-check Put back: sin 3π4 = 22 in the special angles, and sin π4 = 22 from rung 1. Second way: twins above the horizontal axis sit equally far on either side of the top point π2, so they add up to 2 × π2 = π. Here π4 + 3π4 = 4π4 = π.

Rung 4 of 6

Rung 4: a negative value

Solve sin t = −32 on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ4π/3
The point at 4π3 hangs 32 below the horizontal axis, in quadrant III.
x = cos θy = sin θ5π/3
Its twin at 5π3 hangs at the same depth, in quadrant IV.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle t with 0≤t<2π whose point is at height −32, below the horizontal axis.The meaning is the same as before; only the sign of the height has changed.
  2. Size up the value: −32≈−0.87 (rounded) is negative and strictly between −1 and 0.So there are two solutions, both below the horizontal axis, in quadrants III and IV, where sine is negative.
  3. Quadrant IV: flip the π3 point (12,32) across the horizontal axis to get (12,−32), which the special angles list at t=5π3.Flipping across the horizontal axis keeps x and changes the sign of the height.
  4. Quadrant III: the mirror image of that point across the vertical axis is (−12,−32), listed at t=4π3.The mirror across the vertical axis keeps the height −32.
  5. Write them in turning order: 4π3, then 5π3.Turning counterclockwise from 0, you pass quadrant III before quadrant IV.
Answer
t = 4π3 and t = 5π3
Double-check Put back: sin 4π3 = −32 and sin 5π3 = −32 in the special angles. Second way: twins below the horizontal axis sit equally far on either side of the bottom point 3π2, so they add up to 2 × 3π2 = 3π. Here 4π3 + 5π3 = 9π3 = 3π.

Rung 5 of 6

Rung 5: the same answers turn after turn

List every solution of sin t = −32 with 0 ≤ t < 6π, three full turns. Then give the two solutions in the turn before 0, −2π ≤ t < 0.

Show the steps and the answer
4π/35π/310π/311π/316π/317π/3π2π3π4π5π6π−11
On each of the three turns the wave crosses the line y = −32 twice, near its lowest point.
  1. Say what it asks: the equation from rung 4, but now every solution in three full turns, and then the two in the turn before 0.Each extra turn holds its own copy of the two solutions.
  2. First turn: t=4π3 and t=5π3, from rung 4.Every later solution is one of these two points, reached again.
  3. Second turn: add 2π, written 6π3. 4π3+6π3=10π3 and 5π3+6π3=11π3.A full turn brings each point back, so the sine stays −32; writing 2π as 6π3 gives the fractions the same bottom.
  4. Third turn: add 6π3 again. 10π3+6π3=16π3 and 11π3+6π3=17π3.The same reason, one more turn.
  5. Stop: the next pair would be 22π3 and 23π3, but the stretch ends at 6π=18π3.The question asks for t < 6π, and 22 and 23 are both more than 18.
  6. Turn before 0: take 6π3 away from the first pair. 4π3−6π3=−2π3 and 5π3−6π3=−π3.A full turn backward, clockwise, also lands on the same two points.
Answer
  • Three turns: t = 4π3, 5π3, 10π3, 11π3, 16π3 and 17π3
  • Turn before 0: t = −2π3 and t = −π3
Double-check Count: two solutions per turn for three turns makes 6, and the list has 6. Second way for the negative pair: −π3 turns clockwise from the right end of the circle by π3, down to the point (12, −32); −2π3 turns farther, to (−12, −32). Both points are at height −32: they are the 5π3 and 4π3 points again.

Rung 6 of 6

Rung 6: the edge cases at the right, the middle and outside

How many solutions does each equation have on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π, and what are they: cos t = 1, cos t = 0 and cos t = −54?

Show the steps and the answer
0π/23π/2π/2π3π/22π−2−112
The line y = 1 touches the wave only at its highest point on the turn, t = 0; y = 0 crosses it at π2 and 3π2.
  1. Say what it asks: three separate equations; for each one, count the points of the unit circle at that x position and name their angles.Cosine is the x coordinate of the point, so the count of solutions on one turn is the count of points at that x.
  2. cost=1: the vertical line x=1 touches the circle only at the right point (1, 0), at t=0.1 is the largest x on the circle; the right point sits on the horizontal axis, so it is its own mirror image and has no twin. The angle 2π gives the same point and is left out of the turn.
  3. cost=0: the line x=0 is the vertical axis itself, which meets the circle at (0, 1) and (0,−1), at t=π2 and t=3π2.Those are the two points with x = 0: the top and the bottom of the circle.
  4. cost=−54: the line x=−54 lies to the left of the whole circle and never meets it.No point of a circle of radius 1 is farther left than −1, so no angle has cosine −54.
Answer
  • cos t = 1: one solution, t = 0
  • cos t = 0: two solutions, t = π2 and t = 3π2
  • cos t = −54: no solution
Double-check Put back: cos 0 = 1, cos π2 = 0 and cos 3π2 = 0. Second way, on the wave in the picture: y = cos t starts at its highest point, 1, at t = 0 and reaches 1 again only at 2π, the start of the next turn; it crosses height 0 at π2 and 3π2; and it never drops below −1, so the counts are 1, 2 and 0 again.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Treat sin t = 12 as true at every angle, like a rule about sine.
That describes an identity, such as sin2 t + cos2 t = 1, which holds at every angle. sin t = 12 fails at most angles: at t = 0, sin 0 = 0, not 12.
✓ Instead: Solving finds the angles where it holds: π6 and 5π6 on one turn, and those plus or minus full turns.
✗ Not this: Divide both sides of sin t = 12 by sin to get t = 12sin.
sin is not a number multiplying t. It names a rule that takes an angle in and gives a height out, the way 'the height of the seat at' names a rule. You cannot divide by the name of a rule.
✓ Instead: Ask which angles the rule sends to 12, and read them off the circle: t = π6 and t = 5π6 on one turn.
✗ Not this: sin t = 12 has one solution on one turn, t = π6, the first angle that comes to mind.
π6 is the quadrant I point, but the level line at height 12 crosses the circle twice. Stopping at π6 throws away the point on the left.
✓ Instead: Two solutions on one turn: t = π6 and t = 5π6.
✗ Not this: π6 solves sin t = 12, so π6 + π = 7π6 solves it too.
Half a turn carries the point to the opposite side of the circle, where the height has the other sign: sin 7π6 = −12. A whole turn brings the point back to where it started, so the height is the same again.
✓ Instead: Add 2π: π6 + 2π = 13π6, and sin 13π6 = 12.
✗ Not this: Every sine equation has two solutions on one turn, so sin t = 1 has two.
The level line y = 1 touches the circle only at the top point (0, 1). That point is on the vertical axis, so it is its own mirror image and has no twin. A line above the circle, such as y = 2, touches nothing at all.
✓ Instead: sin t = 1 has one solution on one turn, t = π2; sin t = −1 has one, t = 3π2; sin t = 2 has none.
✗ Not this: sin t = 0 on [0, 2π) has three solutions: t = 0, t = π and t = 2π.
2π is the same point as 0, one full turn later. The round bracket in [0, 2π) leaves 2π out so that each point of the circle is counted once.
✓ Instead: Two solutions: t = 0 and t = π.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory cue, the Ferris wheel: every height strictly between the top and the bottom is passed twice per ride, once going up and once coming down. Two solutions per turn.
  • Found only one angle? If c is strictly between −1 and 1 and is not 0, look across the vertical axis for its twin: same height, other side.
  • Pair check: two solutions above the horizontal axis add up to π, and two below it add up to 3π, because twins sit evenly around the top point π2 or the bottom point 3π2. For π6 and 5π6: π6 + 5π6 = 6π6 = π.
  • Putting an answer back is the final word: if the sine of your angle is not c, it is not a solution, however you found it.
  • Read the interval before you answer: [0, 2π) wants one turn's solutions only; a longer stretch wants each one repeated every 2π inside it.

7 The trap

Stopping at the first angle you find. When −1 < c < 1 and c ≠ 0, sin t = c has a second solution on one turn, the mirror image across the vertical axis, and every solution comes back after each full turn. Before you finish, ask two questions: did I find both points, and does the question want one turn or more?

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Does t = π make sin t = −12 true?
  • No.
  • At t = π the wheel has made half a turn, so your seat is level with the hub, on the left: sin π = 0.
  • A solution must make the equation true, and 0 ≠ −12.
Why does sin t = 25 have exactly two solutions on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π?
  • Your seat's height above the hub is sin t, and a level line at height 25 crosses the circle your seat rides on at exactly two points.
  • One is on the right, in quadrant I, as your seat climbs.
  • The other is its mirror image across the vertical axis, on the left, in quadrant II, as your seat sinks.
  • You can count the two solutions without knowing the angles.
In which quadrants are the two solutions of sin t = −12 on one turn?
  • Quadrants III and IV, the two quadrants where sine is negative.
  • A height of −12 puts your seat below the hub: once sinking on the left, in quadrant III, and once climbing on the right, in quadrant IV.
The angle t = 5π4 solves sin t = −22. Which solutions does that give one turn forward and one turn back?
  • One turn forward: 5π4 + 2π = 5π4 + 8π4 = 13π4.
  • One turn back: 5π4 − 2π = 5π4 − 8π4 = −3π4.
  • A full turn puts your seat back at the same height, so the sine is still −22.

Lesson 2 of 8

Solving sin t = c, cos t = c and tan t = c on one turn

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Reference angleLeans on: Signs by quadrantLeans on: Sine and cosine as coordinatesLeans on: Tangent from sine and cosineLeans on: One number, two formsLeans on: Fractions with πLeans on: Solving a linear equationLeans on: One turnOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Until now you went forward, from an angle to its sine. Now you go backward. You are given the sine, a number c such as −12, and you want every angle on one turn that has it. Picture a Ferris wheel seat and its height above the hub, where below the hub counts as negative. On one ride round, the seat passes each height twice, once going up and once coming down; only the top and the bottom are passed once. Two moves find both spots. The size of c, with its sign dropped, points to a small first quadrant angle called the reference angle. The sign of c picks the two quadrants. Then you place the reference angle in each of them.

2 Picture it

QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
When the equation has answers and none sits on an axis, find the sign of c for your function.

Reminder

Reminder: Reference angle, Signs by quadrant, Sine and cosine as coordinates, Tangent from sine and cosine, One number, two forms, Fractions with π, Solving a linear equation, One turn
  • Reference angle. The acute angle between the terminal side and the x-axis. For 5π6 it is π − 5π6 = π6; for 7π4 it is 2π − 7π4 = π4.
  • Signs by quadrant. All Students Take Calculus: in Quadrant I all three are positive, in II sine, in III tangent, in IV cosine. At 4π3, in Quadrant III, tangent is positive while sine and cosine are negative.
  • Sine and cosine as coordinates. On the unit circle the point at angle t is (cos t, sin t). At 5π6 the point is (−32, 12), so cos 5π6 = −32 and sin 5π6 = 12.
  • Tangent from sine and cosine. tan t = sintcost. At π3: 32 ÷ 12 = 32 × 21 = 3, because dividing by a fraction means multiplying by its flip.
  • One number, two forms. 13 = 33: multiply the top and bottom by 3, and the bottom becomes 3 × 3 = 3.
  • Fractions with π. Give π or 2π the same bottom as α, then combine the tops: 2π − π3 = 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.
  • Solving a linear equation. Undo adding or subtracting first, then multiplying, doing the same to both sides: 2 sin t − 1 = 0 becomes 2 sin t = 1, then sin t = 12.
  • One turn. 0 ≤ t < 2π includes 0 and stops short of 2π, because 2π is the same point as 0. So sin t = 0 has the answers 0 and π on the turn, and 2π is not counted.

3 Why

On the unit circle, the points with reference angle α form a family of four, one in each quadrant. Each is a mirror image of the Quadrant I point: flipped across the y-axis, across the x-axis, or across both. A mirror never changes a distance, so all four points have coordinates of the same sizes, and so the same size of sine, cosine and tangent. Only the signs differ. That is why the size of c fixes α and the sign of c picks the quadrants. Each sign shows up in exactly two quadrants, so most values of c give exactly two answers.

4 The rule

For 0 ≤ t < 2π, when c is not an axis value and the function can reach it: the size of c gives the reference angle α, the table angle whose sine, cosine or tangent has that size; the sign of c gives the two quadrants where that function has that sign; the answers are α in I, π − α in II, π + α in III and 2π − α in IV.

The axis values, 0, 1 and −1 for sine and cosine and 0 for tangent, put the answers on the axes instead, and sine and cosine have no answer when c is above 1 or below −1.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Sine of t equals c, for t from zero up to but not including two pi: find every such t.

Write it

A solution on one turn of sin t = c is an angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π whose sine equals c. When c lies strictly between −1 and 1 and is not 0, the size of c gives the reference angle and the sign of c gives the two quadrants.

In math
  • sint=c,0≤t<2π
  • t in [0, 2π)
  • {t|sint=c,0≤t<2π}
  • sin t = −12 on one turn: t = 7π6 or t = 11π6
  • in degrees: sin t = −12, 0° ≤ t < 360°: t = 210° or t = 330°
  • graph words: the t values where the line y = c meets one turn of the sine wave
Like

Like asking at which moments of one Ferris wheel ride your seat is at a given height: once on the way up, once on the way down.

See it
7π/611π/6π/2π3π/22π−11
The wave is the height sin t as t runs over one turn; the line y = −12 crosses it twice.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Draw the unit circle and a horizontal line at height c. Each place the line meets the circle is a point whose sine is c, so its angle is an answer. A horizontal line at a height strictly between −1 and 1 meets the circle at two points, one on each side of the y-axis, mirror images of each other. For cos t = c, use a vertical line at x = c instead: for c strictly between −1 and 1, two points, one above and one below the x-axis. A line touching the circle at its very top or bottom, or at its far left or right, meets it once, and a line beyond the circle misses it.

x = cos θy = sin θP
Start at 210°, then pick 330°. Sin reads −12 both times, while the point moves from the left half of the circle to the right half.
As a story

You ride a Ferris wheel. Your seat starts level with the hub, on the right, 1 unit from it. As the wheel turns, the seat's height above the hub is the sine of the angle turned; below the hub counts as negative. You want a photo when you are 12 unit below the hub. On one ride round you reach that height twice: once sinking on the left side, once rising on the right side. The first time you are π6 past the half turn, at 7π6. The second time you are π6 short of the full turn, at 11π6. One small angle, π6, places both photos.

As a rule of thumb

Size picks the angle, sign picks the quadrants. First check two things: c is not an axis value (0 for all three, 1 or −1 for sine and cosine), and for sine and cosine c lies between −1 and 1. Then find the size of c in the table to get α. Use the sign of c with All Students Take Calculus to get two quadrants. Write the angle for each of those quadrants, then put both answers back into the equation.

Size picks the angle: find the size of c in the table, read α.

Sign picks the quadrants: All Students Take Calculus.

Quadrant I: t = α

Quadrant II: t = π − α

Quadrant III: t = π + α

Quadrant IV: t = 2π − α

Put each answer back into the equation.

Why it must be true

Take the Quadrant I point at angle α, at (x, y). Flip it across the y-axis to get (−x, y), the point at π − α. Flip it across the x-axis to get (x, −y), the point at 2π − α. Flip it both ways to get (−x, −y), the point at π + α. All four have coordinates of the same sizes, so their sines, cosines and tangents have the same sizes; only the signs change. No other point on the circle has coordinates of those sizes, so every answer off the axes comes from this family, and the sign of c says which two members. Answers on the axes, for c = 0, or c = 1 or −1 with sine and cosine, sit in no quadrant and are read straight off the circle.

With numbers

The picture lists the four angles with reference angle π6 and the sine of each. Every output has size 12; only the sign changes. Solving sin t = −12 means starting in the output row: the two cells holding −12 sit under 7π6 and 11π6, the Quadrant III and Quadrant IV angles. Those are the answers, and sin t = 12 gets the other two, π6 and 5π6.

input toutput sin tπ/61/25π/61/27π/6−1/211π/6−1/2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
Solving reads the table upward: the two −12 cells in the output row point up to 7π6 and 11π6.
reference angle αin degreessin αcos αtan α
π630°123233, also written 13
π445°22221
π360°32123

Part 1: Sine: sin t = c asks for a height

Sine is the height of the point on the unit circle: positive above the x-axis, negative below it. So sin t = c asks for every point at height c. Above the axis that means Quadrants I and II; below it, Quadrants III and IV. Draw a horizontal line at height c across the circle. When c is strictly between −1 and 1, it meets the circle at two points, one on each side of the y-axis, like two riders at the same height on opposite sides of a Ferris wheel. At c = 1 or c = −1 it touches the circle once, at the top or the bottom, and past those values it misses the circle.

  • Sine is the y coordinate: the height of the point.
  • 0 < c < 1: Quadrants I and II, so t = α and t = π − α.
  • −1 < c < 0: Quadrants III and IV, so t = π + α and t = 2π − α.
  • Axis values: sin t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π; sin t = 1 gives only t = π2; sin t = −1 gives only t = 3π2.
  • No solution when c > 1 or c < −1: no point on the unit circle is that high or that low.
  • Pair check: the two answers add to π when 0 < c < 1 and to 3π when −1 < c < 0.
5π/47π/4π/2π3π/22π−11
The wave is the height sin t as t runs over one turn; the line at height −22 crosses it twice.

Worked example

Sin t = −22 on one turn

Solve sin t = −22 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn put the point at height −22, below the x-axis?Sine is the height, so we know the output and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. −22 is about −0.71: between −1 and 1, and not 0, 1 or −1.So there are answers, and they do not sit on the axes.
  3. Drop the sign: 22 sits in the π4 row of the sinα column, so α=π4.The size of c names the reference angle; the sign is handled next.
  4. c is negative, and sine is negative in Quadrants III and IV.Below the x-axis every height is negative.
  5. Quadrant III: t=π+π4=4π4+π4=5π4.A Quadrant III angle goes past a half turn by α; writing π as 4π4 gives matching bottoms, so the tops add: 4 + 1 = 5.
  6. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π4=8π4−π4=7π4.A Quadrant IV angle stops short of a full turn by α; 2π is 8π4, and 8 − 1 = 7.
Answer
  • t=5π4
  • t=7π4
Double-check Put each answer back. 5π4 is in Quadrant III with reference angle π4, and sine is negative there, so sin 5π4 = −22. 7π4 is in Quadrant IV with reference angle π4, sine negative again, so sin 7π4 = −22. Second way: 5π4 + 7π4 = 12π4 = 3π, the sum two sine answers below the x-axis always have.
Tips and tricks
  • Sine answers sit at the same height, one left and one right of the y-axis; if your two answers are not mirror images like that, recheck the quadrants.

Part 2: Cosine: cos t = c asks for a left or right position

Cosine is the x coordinate of the point: how far right of the center it sits, with left of the center counting as negative. So cos t = c asks for every point at that sideways position. Right of the y-axis means Quadrants I and IV; left of it means II and III. Draw a vertical line at x = c. When c is strictly between −1 and 1, it meets the circle at two points, one above and one below the x-axis, like the tip of a lamp post and its reflection in a still lake. At c = 1 or c = −1 it touches the circle once, at the far right or the far left, and past those values it misses the circle.

  • Cosine is the x coordinate: right of center is positive, left is negative.
  • 0 < c < 1: Quadrants I and IV, so t = α and t = 2π − α.
  • −1 < c < 0: Quadrants II and III, so t = π − α and t = π + α.
  • Axis values: cos t = 0 gives t = π2 and t = 3π2; cos t = 1 gives only t = 0; cos t = −1 gives only t = π.
  • No solution when c > 1 or c < −1: no point on the unit circle is that far right or left.
  • Pair check: for c strictly between −1 and 1, the two answers add to 2π.
  • Gotcha: cos t = 1 does not give 2π, because the turn stops short of 2π.
x = cos θy = sin θπ/3
The point at π3 sits 12 to the right of center, so cos π3 = 12.

Worked example

Cos t = 12 on one turn

Solve cos t = 12 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn put the point 12 to the right of center?Cosine is the x coordinate, so we know the output and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. 12 is between −1 and 1 and is not 0, 1 or −1.So there are answers, and they do not sit on the axes.
  3. In the cosα column of the table, 12 sits in the π3 row, so α=π3.Read the cosine column, not the sine column: sin π6 is also 12, but that belongs to the other function.
  4. c is positive, and cosine is positive in Quadrants I and IV.All Students Take Calculus: All in I, Cosine in IV. Both sit right of the y-axis.
  5. Quadrant I: t=α=π3.In Quadrant I the angle is the reference angle itself.
  6. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π3=6π3−π3=5π3.A Quadrant IV angle stops short of a full turn by α; 2π is 6π3, and 6 − 1 = 5.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=5π3
Double-check Put each answer back. cos π3 = 12 from the table. 5π3 is in Quadrant IV with reference angle π3, and cosine is positive there, so cos 5π3 = 12. Second way: π3 + 5π3 = 6π3 = 2π, the sum two cosine answers always have.
Tips and tricks
  • Cosine answers sit at the same left or right position, one above and one below the x-axis.

Part 3: Tangent: tan t = c asks for a steepness

Tangent is the sine divided by the cosine: y divided by x. Think of it as the steepness of the spoke from the center to the point, like the slope of a ramp. It is positive where x and y have the same sign, Quadrants I and III, and negative where they differ, Quadrants II and IV. Unlike sine and cosine, tangent is not kept between −1 and 1: a spoke can be as steep as you like, so tan t = 3 has answers. At π2 and 3π2 the x coordinate is 0, and tangent does not exist.

  • Tangent is sintcost, the y coordinate divided by the x coordinate.
  • Its special values come from that division, for example tan π3 = 32 ÷ 12 = 3; all three are in the table.
  • c > 0: Quadrants I and III, so t = α and t = π + α.
  • c < 0: Quadrants II and IV, so t = π − α and t = 2π − α.
  • Axis value: tan t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π. tan t = 1 and tan t = −1 are not axis values: their reference angle is π4.
  • Never an answer: π2 and 3π2, where cos t = 0 and tangent does not exist.
3π/47π/4π/2π3π/22π−4−224
On one turn the line y = −1 meets the tangent graph twice, at 3π4 and 7π4.

Worked example

Tan t = −3 on one turn

Solve tan t = −3 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn have a tangent, y divided by x, equal to −3?We know the output of tangent and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. −3 is not 0, so it is not an axis value for tangent, and there is no size limit to check.Only tan t = 0 sits on the axes, and a division can give any number.
  3. Drop the sign: 3 sits in the π3 row of the tanα column, so α=π3.At π3 the point has x = 12 and y = 32, and 32 ÷ 12 = 3.
  4. c is negative, and tangent is negative in Quadrants II and IV.There x and y have opposite signs, and dividing numbers of opposite signs gives a negative.
  5. Quadrant II: t=π−π3=3π3−π3=2π3.A Quadrant II angle stops short of a half turn by α; π is 3π3, and 3 − 1 = 2.
  6. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π3=6π3−π3=5π3.A Quadrant IV angle stops short of a full turn by α; 2π is 6π3, and 6 − 1 = 5.
Answer
  • t=2π3
  • t=5π3
Double-check Divide y by x at each point. At 2π3 the point is (−12, 32), and 32 ÷ (−12) = −3. At 5π3 the point is (12, −32), and (−32) ÷ 12 = −3. Both give −3.
Tips and tricks
  • Check a tangent answer by dividing the point's y by its x: the signs of the two coordinates decide the sign of the result.

5 How

  1. Get the function alone on one side: sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c.
  2. Say what the question asks: every angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π whose sine (or cosine, or tangent) equals c.
  3. Rule out the special cases. For sine or cosine, c > 1 or c < −1 has no solution. If c is 0, or 1 or −1 for sine and cosine, the answers sit on the axes: read them off the circle, check them and stop.
  4. Drop the sign of c and find that size in your function's column of the table. The angle at the start of that row is the reference angle α.
  5. Use the sign of c and All Students Take Calculus to pick the two quadrants where your function has that sign.
  6. Place α in each of those quadrants: α in I, π − α in II, π + α in III, 2π − α in IV. Rewrite π or 2π with the same bottom as α, then combine the tops.
  7. Check: put each answer back into the original equation. Name its quadrant and reference angle, read the size from the table, attach that quadrant's sign, and confirm you get c.

Solving a basic trigonometric equation on one turn

1
Is sin t, cos t or tan t alone on one side?
YesGo on.
NoUndo any adding or subtracting first, then any multiplying, until it stands alone.
↓
2
Is it sine or cosine, with c > 1 or c < −1?
YesStop: there is no solution, because every point on the unit circle has coordinates from −1 to 1.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Is c equal to 0, or is it sine or cosine with c = 1 or c = −1?
YesThe answers sit on the axes: read them off the circle (for example, cos t = −1 gives only t = π), check them and stop.
NoGo on.
↓
4
With its sign dropped, is c in your function's column of the table?
YesThe angle in that row is the reference angle α.
NoThe answers are not special angles; a calculator method later in this unit finishes such equations.
↓
5
Is c positive?
YesSine: Quadrants I and II. Cosine: I and IV. Tangent: I and III.
NoSine: Quadrants III and IV. Cosine: II and III. Tangent: II and IV.
  1. Get sin t, cos t or tan t alone on one side.
  2. Check the special cases: no solution, or an axis value read off the circle.
  3. The size of c gives the reference angle α from the table.
  4. The sign of c gives the two quadrants, by All Students Take Calculus.
  5. Write the answers: α in I, π − α in II, π + α in III, 2π − α in IV.
  6. Put each answer back into the original equation.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Worked example: cos t = −32 on one turn

Solve cos t = −32 for 0 ≤ t < 2π. Give exact answers.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The chain for cos 150°, which is 5π6: Quadrant II, reference angle 30°, a negative sign, value −32.
x = cos θy = sin θP
The chain for cos 210°, which is 7π6: Quadrant III, reference angle 30°, a negative sign, value −32.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t, from 0 up to but not including 2π, put the point of the unit circle at x=−32, a little less than 1 unit left of the center?Cosine is the x coordinate. We know the output, so we are looking for every input angle that produces it.
  2. Check the special cases: −32 is about −0.87, between −1 and 1, and it is not 0, 1 or −1.Outside −1 to 1 there would be no solution, and 0, 1 or −1 would put the answers on the axes. Neither happens, so the main method applies.
  3. Drop the sign: the size is 32. In the cosα column of the table, 32 sits in the π6 row, so the reference angle is α=π6.All four mirror points with reference angle π6 have a cosine of size 32; the table names the Quadrant I one.
  4. c is negative, and cosine is negative in Quadrants II and III.All Students Take Calculus: cosine is positive only in I (All) and IV (Calculus), so it is negative in II and III, left of the y-axis.
  5. Quadrant II: t=π−π6=6π6−π6=5π6, which is 150°.A Quadrant II angle stops short of a half turn by α. Writing π as 6π6 gives one bottom, so the tops subtract: 6 − 1 = 5.
  6. Quadrant III: t=π+π6=6π6+π6=7π6, which is 210°.A Quadrant III angle goes past a half turn by α: 6 + 1 = 7.
  7. Both answers lie between 0 and 2π=12π6, so both are solutions on one turn.The question asks only for angles on this turn, and 5 and 7 are both less than 12.
Answer
  • t=5π6
  • t=7π6
Double-check Put each answer back. 5π6 is in Quadrant II with reference angle π6, and cosine is negative there, so cos 5π6 = −32. 7π6 is in Quadrant III with reference angle π6, cosine negative again, so cos 7π6 = −32. A second way: the points are (−32, 12) and (−32, −12), mirror images across the x-axis, and both x coordinates are −32.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

An axis value

Solve cos t = −1 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
π
The left point of the circle is at x = −1, and one turn reaches it only once.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn put the point of the unit circle at x=−1?Cosine is the x coordinate of the point, so we know the output and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. −1 is an axis value: it is the farthest left the circle reaches, and only the left point (−1,0) has it.The circle has radius 1, so nothing sits farther left than −1, and a vertical line at that x touches the circle at one point only.
  3. The left point is half a turn from the start: t=π, which is 180°.A half turn is π.
Answer
t = π
Double-check Put it back: the point at π is (−1, 0), so cos π = −1. There is no second answer: the left point is its own mirror image across the x-axis, so the usual pair shrinks to one.

Rung 2 of 6

A positive value

Solve sin t = 32 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn put the point at height 32?We know the output, a height, and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. 32 is about 0.87: between −1 and 1, and not 0, 1 or −1.So there are answers, and they do not sit on the axes.
  3. In the sinα column of the table, 32 sits in the π3 row, so α=π3.The size of c names the reference angle.
  4. c is positive, and sine is positive in Quadrants I and II.Above the x-axis every height is positive.
  5. Quadrant I: t=π3. Quadrant II: t=π−π3=3π3−π3=2π3.A Quadrant II angle stops short of a half turn by α; writing π as 3π3 gives matching bottoms, and 3 − 1 = 2.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=2π3
Double-check sin π3 = 32 from the table. 2π3 is in Quadrant II with reference angle π3, where sine is positive, so sin 2π3 = 32. Second way: π3 + 2π3 = 3π3 = π, the sum two sine answers above the x-axis always have.

Rung 3 of 6

A negative value, and a tempting negative angle

Solve sin t = −12 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
-30°330°same terminal side
−30° and 330° end on the same side: −π6 and 11π6 name one point, but only 11π6 is on the turn.
11 of 12 wedges, each π/6
A full turn is twelve wedges of π6; take one away and eleven are left, so 2π − π6 = 11π6.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn put the point at height −12, half a unit below the center?Sine is the height, and a negative height is below the x-axis.
  2. Drop the sign: 12 sits in the π6 row of the sinα column, so α=π6.The table gives only sizes; the sign is the next step.
  3. c is negative, and sine is negative in Quadrants III and IV.Below the x-axis every height is negative.
  4. Quadrant III: t=π+π6=6π6+π6=7π6.A Quadrant III angle goes past a half turn by α; π is 6π6, and 6 + 1 = 7.
  5. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π6=12π6−π6=11π6.Gotcha: turning back π6 from 0 gives −π6, which ends at the same point but is not between 0 and 2π. A full turn minus π6 reaches that point and stays on the turn.
Answer
  • t=7π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check 7π6 is in Quadrant III with reference angle π6, and sine is negative there, so sin 7π6 = −12. 11π6 is in Quadrant IV with reference angle π6, and sine is negative there too, so sin 11π6 = −12. Second way: 7π6 + 11π6 = 18π6 = 3π, the sum two sine answers below the x-axis always have.

Rung 4 of 6

Tangent, with its own pair of quadrants

Solve tan t = 3 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ4π/3
At 4π3 both legs point the negative way, so y divided by x is positive: the tangent is 3, the same as at π3.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn have a tangent, y divided by x, equal to 3?We know the output of tangent and look for every input angle that gives it.
  2. 3 is about 1.73, more than 1. That is allowed for tangent.Tangent is a division, and a division can give any number; only sine and cosine, which are coordinates, stay between −1 and 1.
  3. In the tanα column, 3 sits in the π3 row, so α=π3.tanπ3=32÷12=3.
  4. c is positive, and tangent is positive in Quadrants I and III.All Students Take Calculus: All in I, Tangent in III. In III both coordinates are negative, and a negative divided by a negative is positive.
  5. Quadrant I: t=π3. Quadrant III: t=π+π3=3π3+π3=4π3.A Quadrant III angle goes past a half turn by α; π is 3π3, and 3 + 1 = 4.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=4π3
Double-check Divide y by x at each point. At π3 the point is (12, 32), and 32 ÷ 12 = 3. At 4π3 the point is (−12, −32), and (−32) ÷ (−12) = 3. Both give 3.

Rung 5 of 6

Get the cosine alone first

Solve 2 cos t + 2 = 0 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
=2 cos t +√20do the same thing to both sides
Keep the scale level: take 2 off both sides, then halve both sides.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn make 2cost+2 equal 0? The cosine is not alone yet, so first find the value cos t must have.The table can be read only once we know the value of cos t.
  2. Subtract 2 from both sides: 2cost=−2.Undo the adding first; doing the same to both sides keeps them equal.
  3. Divide both sides by 2: cost=−22.Undo the multiplying next. This step finds the one value of cos t that makes the left side 0.
  4. Drop the sign: 22 sits in the π4 row of the cosα column, so α=π4.The size of c names the reference angle.
  5. c is negative, and cosine is negative in Quadrants II and III.Left of the y-axis every x coordinate is negative.
  6. Quadrant II: t=π−π4=4π4−π4=3π4. Quadrant III: t=π+π4=4π4+π4=5π4.Quadrant II stops short of a half turn by α and Quadrant III goes past it by α; π is 4π4.
Answer
  • t=3π4
  • t=5π4
Double-check Put each answer into the original equation. 3π4 is in Quadrant II with reference angle π4, so cos 3π4 = −22, and 2 × (−22) + 2 = −2 + 2 = 0. 5π4 is in Quadrant III with the same reference angle, and cosine is negative there too, so the same sum gives 0. Both work.

Rung 6 of 6

Genuinely hard, a tangent value in disguise

Solve 3 tan t + 3 = 0 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
Follow the chain for tan 150°, the same angle as 5π6. Quadrant II, reference angle 30°, a negative sign, and the value −33.
  1. Say what it asks: which angles t on one turn make 3tant+3 equal 0? First find the value tan t must have.The table can be read only with tan t alone.
  2. Subtract 3 from both sides: 3tant=−3. Divide both sides by 3: tant=−33.Undo the adding, then the multiplying. This finds the one value of tan t that makes the left side 0.
  3. Drop the sign: 33 sits in the π6 row of the tanα column, so α=π6.Gotcha: some tables write this value as 13. It is the same number: multiplying the top and bottom of 13 by 3 gives 33, since 3 × 3 = 3.
  4. c is negative, and tangent is negative in Quadrants II and IV.There x and y have opposite signs, so y divided by x is negative.
  5. Quadrant II: t=π−π6=6π6−π6=5π6. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π6=12π6−π6=11π6.Quadrant II stops short of a half turn by α, and Quadrant IV stops short of a full turn by α.
Answer
  • t=5π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check At 5π6 the point is (−32, 12), so tan 5π6 = 12 ÷ (−32) = −13 = −33, and 3 × (−33) + 3 = −3 + 3 = 0. At 11π6 the point is (32, −12), so tan 11π6 = −12 ÷ 32 = −33 as well, and the sum is 0 again. Both work.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin t = −32, and sin π3 = 32, so t = π3.
The table gives sizes only. At π3 the point is above the x-axis, so sin π3 = +32, not −32.
✓ Instead: Use π3 as the reference angle and place it where sine is negative, Quadrants III and IV: t = 4π3 and t = 5π3.
✗ Not this: cos t = 12, so t = π6 and t = 5π6.
That reads the sine column (sin π6 = 12) and uses sine's quadrants. Put π6 back: cos π6 = 32, not 12.
✓ Instead: In the cosine column 12 sits in the π3 row, and cosine is positive in I and IV: t = π3 and t = 5π3.
✗ Not this: Every basic equation has two answers on one turn, so cos t = −1 needs a second answer besides π.
−1 is the far left of the circle. The vertical line x = −1 only touches the circle, at one point, and that point is its own mirror image across the x-axis.
✓ Instead: cos t = −1 has one answer, t = π. So do sin t = 1 (t = π2), sin t = −1 (t = 3π2) and cos t = 1 (t = 0).
✗ Not this: cos t = 1, so t = 0 and t = 2π.
0 and 2π name the same point. The turn 0 ≤ t < 2π stops short of 2π so that each point is counted once.
✓ Instead: On one turn, cos t = 1 has the single answer t = 0.
✗ Not this: sin t = −12: turning back π6 from 0 gives t = −π6.
−π6 ends at a correct point, but it is a negative angle, outside 0 ≤ t < 2π.
✓ Instead: Name the same point going forward: 2π − π6 = 11π6. Together with 7π6, that is the whole answer.
✗ Not this: tan t = −1 is negative, so use sine's negative quadrants III and IV: t = 5π4 and t = 7π4.
Tangent has its own sign pattern. At 5π4 both coordinates are −22, and (−22) ÷ (−22) = 1, not −1.
✓ Instead: Tangent is negative in II and IV: t = 3π4 and t = 7π4.
✗ Not this: sin t = 3: the table shows 3 in the π3 row, so t = π3.
That 3 is in the tangent column. As a sine, 3 (about 1.73) is higher than any point on the unit circle, whose heights run from −1 to 1.
✓ Instead: sin t = 3 has no solution. tan t = 3 is the equation with answers π3 and 4π3.

Tips and tricks

  • Size from the table, sign from the quadrants. The table never tells you the sign; that is always its own step.
  • Quadrant shortcut: for c > 0 the answers are in Quadrant I and in your function's own quadrant from All Students Take Calculus (Sine II, Tangent III, Cosine IV); for c < 0 they are in the other two quadrants.
  • Bottoms match: written in lowest terms, answers built from π6 have 6 on the bottom (5π6, 7π6, 11π6), from π4 a 4, from π3 a 3. A different bottom on a fraction in lowest terms means an arithmetic slip.
  • Pair check: two sine answers add to π when c > 0, since α + (π − α) = π, and to 3π when c < 0, since (π + α) + (2π − α) = 3π; two cosine answers always add to 2π.
  • Always put each answer back: name its quadrant and reference angle, read the size, attach the sign. If you do not get c back, redo the quadrant step.
  • Sketch both answers on a circle: sine answers sit at the same height, cosine answers at the same left or right position.
  • Every answer must obey 0 ≤ t < 2π: no negative angles, and never 2π itself.
  • You may think in degrees (30°, 150°, 210°, 330°) and convert at the end: multiply by π180, so 210° becomes 210π180 = 7π6.

7 The trap

Stopping at the table. The table gives only the size of c, so answering t = π6 to sin t = −12 loses the sign: sin π6 is +12. After the table, always pick the two quadrants from the sign of c, write an angle in each, and put both answers back into the equation.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

When you solve sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c, what does the size of c tell you, and what does its sign tell you?
  • The size of c, with its sign dropped, points to the reference angle α in the table.
  • The sign of c picks the two quadrants where your function has that sign.
  • Axis values are the exception: when sin t or cos t is 0, 1 or −1, or tan t is 0, the answers sit on the axes and are read straight from the circle. For example, cos t = 1 only at t = 0.
Why is t = π4 a wrong answer to cos t = −22?
  • It has the wrong sign: cos π4 = +22. The table gives only the size of c.
  • Cosine is negative in II and III, so place α = π4 there.
  • II: t = π − π4 = 3π4
  • III: t = π + π4 = 5π4
Solve tan t = −3 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.
  • The size 3 gives α = π3.
  • All Students Take Calculus: tangent is positive in I and III, so it is negative in II and IV.
  • II: t = π − π3 = 3π3 − π3 = 2π3
  • IV: t = 2π − π3 = 6π3 − π3 = 5π3
How many solutions does sin t = 32 have for 0 ≤ t < 2π?
  • None.
  • Sine is never more than 1 or less than −1, the way a Ferris wheel seat never goes above the top of the wheel or below the bottom.
  • Do not mistake 32, which is 1.5, for the table value 32, which is less than 1.

Lesson 3 of 8

Writing every solution with the period

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Turns in radiansLeans on: Adding whole π's to a fraction of πLeans on: IntegersLeans on: The trig values at a pointLeans on: Dividing by a fractionLeans on: Dividing two negativesLeans on: Negative anglesLeans on: Solving on one turnLeans on: SlopeLeans on: Solving for one letterOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Picture a Ferris wheel that takes 10 minutes to go around once. Your seat is at the top at minute 2. When else is it at the top? At minutes 12, 22 and 32, and also at minute −8, before you started watching. Nobody lists them all. You say: 2, plus or minus any whole number of 10s. A trigonometric equation works the same way. The point on the unit circle comes back to the same spot after every full turn, 2π. So once you know each solution on one turn, every other solution is one of them plus or minus a whole number of full turns. Writing them all that way is the general solution. Tangent is special: it repeats after only half a turn.

2 Picture it

−11π/6−7π/6π/65π/613π/617π/6one period−2π−ππ2π3π−11−11π/6−7π/6π/65π/613π/617π/6one period−2π−ππ2π3π−11
The line y = 12 meets the sine wave twice in each full turn, a stretch of 2π that counts its start and not…

Reminder

Reminder: Turns in radians, Adding whole π's to a fraction of π, Integers, The trig values at a point, Dividing by a fraction, Dividing two negatives, Negative angles, Solving on one turn, Slope, Solving for one letter
  • Turns in radians. A full turn is 2π (360°) and half a turn is π (180°): half a turn past π6 is π6 + π = 7π6.
  • Adding whole π's to a fraction of π. Write the whole π's over the same bottom first: 3π4 + 2π = 3π4 + 8π4 = 11π4.
  • Integers. An integer is a whole number that is positive, negative or zero: ..., −2, −1, 0, 1, 2, ... So −5 is an integer and 12 is not.
  • The trig values at a point. At the point (x, y) of angle t on the unit circle, cos t = x, sin t = y and tan t = yx: at π4 the point is (22, 22), so tan π4 = 1.
  • Dividing by a fraction. Dividing by 12 is multiplying by 2: 32 ÷ 12 = 32 × 2 = 3.
  • Dividing two negatives. A negative divided by a negative is positive: (−6) ÷ (−3) = 2, the same as 6 ÷ 3.
  • Negative angles. A negative angle turns clockwise from the positive x-axis: −π2 is a quarter turn clockwise and ends at the bottom of the circle, (0, −1).
  • Solving on one turn. Reference angle first, then the quadrants with the right sign: sin t = 12 has reference angle π6 and sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so t = π6 or t = π − π6 = 5π6.
  • Slope. Slope is rise over run: from (0, 0) to (2, 6) the rise is 6 and the run is 2, so the slope is 6 ÷ 2 = 3.
  • Solving for one letter. Undo the adding, then the multiplying: from 5π6 + 2kπ = −13π6, take 5π6 from both sides to get 2kπ = −3π, then divide both sides by 2π to get k = −32.

3 Why

A full turn, 2π, brings the point back to the same spot, so x and y do not change: sine and cosine repeat. That is why each solution on one turn brings a whole family, a + 2kπ: the angle moved by any whole number of turns, either way. Half a turn, π, sends the point (x, y) through the center to the opposite point (−x, −y). Sine and cosine flip sign there, so they need the full turn. Tangent is yx, and −y−x = yx because the two minus signs cancel. So tangent's period, its shortest repeat, is π, and its family is a + kπ.

4 The rule

If t=a solves sint=c or cost=c, so does t=a+2kπ for every integer k; if t=a solves tant=c, so does t=a+kπ.

The general solution: each solution on one turn +2kπ for sine and cosine, the one solution in [0,π)+kπ for tangent, where k is any integer.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

t equals pi over 6 plus 2 k pi, where k is any integer. In everyday words: pi over 6, plus or minus any whole number of full turns.

Write it

The family t = π6 + 2kπ holds π6 and every angle you reach from it by adding or taking away whole turns. It is one of the two families that solve sin t = 12; the other starts at 5π6.

In math
  • t = π6 + 2kπ, where k is any integer
  • t=π6+2πk,k=...,−2,−1,0,1,2,...
  • {t | t = π6 + 2kπ, k an integer}
  • t is one of ..., −11π6, π6, 13π6, 25π6, ...
  • in degrees: t = 30° + 360°k
  • on a graph: every x where the line y = 12 meets the sine wave on its way up
  • the pattern: t = a + 2kπ for sine and cosine, t = a + kπ for tangent
Like

Trash pickup is every Tuesday: this Tuesday, plus or minus any whole number of weeks. Nobody lists every Tuesday of every year; one rule names them all, past and future.

See it
30°390°same terminal side
π6 (30°) and 13π6 (390°) end on the same side: one full turn apart, the same point, the same sine.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Picture the sine wave cut by the flat line y = 12: the line crosses it twice in each full turn, so the crossings form two rows, each spaced a full turn apart. Two rows, two families. Now look at this picture, the tangent graph cut by the line y = 1: it crosses once on every branch, and a new branch starts every π. One row, spaced half a turn apart, one family. Count the rows to count the families; measure the spacing to find the step.

−3π/4π/45π/49π/4−ππ2π−4−224
The line y = 1 meets the tangent graph once on every branch, and a new branch starts every π.
As a story

Your Ferris wheel seat is at the top once per ride, so its top times are one time plus any number of full rides. Sine and cosine behave like the seat: the point itself must come all the way around before x and y repeat. Now picture a seesaw plank laid through the axle. After half a turn the plank lies on exactly the same slant, with its ends swapped. Tangent measures only that slant, the steepness of the line through the center, so tangent repeats after half a ride.

1 of 2 wedges, each π
A full turn is two half turns of π: tangent repeats after one of them, sine and cosine need both.
Why it must be true

A full turn, 2π, brings the point back to where it started, so x and y are unchanged, and so is yx wherever x is not 0. Half a turn, π, moves the point along a diameter to the far end. The center is the middle of that diameter, so the far point is (−x, −y). At π6 the point is (32, 12); at 7π6 it is (−32, −12). The height changed sign, so sine did not repeat, and neither did cosine. But −y−x = yx, so tangent did.

x = cos θy = sin θP
Half a turn past π6, at 7π6, the point is (−32, −12).
With numbers

Look at the table. The columns under −11π6, π6 and 13π6 all hold 12: those inputs are whole turns apart. The column under 7π6, only half a turn past π6, holds −12: half a turn is not enough for sine. For tangent it is enough: tan π4 = 1, and at 5π4 the point is (−22, −22), so tan 5π4 = (−22) ÷ (−22) = 1.

input toutput sin t−11π/61/2π/61/27π/6−1/213π/61/2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
Inputs a whole turn apart share the output 12; the input half a turn away gives −12.
A rule of thumb

Before you add anything, ask one question: is this tangent? Yes: the step is half a turn, kπ, and one family covers everything. No: the step is a full turn, 2kπ, and every solution on one turn gets its own family. Then end with: where k is any integer.

sin t = c: each one-turn answer + 2kπ

cos t = c: each one-turn answer + 2kπ

tan t = c: the answer in [0, π) + kπ

k is any integer: ..., −2, −1, 0, 1, 2, ...

EquationPeriodSolutions on one turnGeneral solution
sin t = c2π, a full turn2 when −1 < c < 1; 1 when c = 1 or c = −1; none otherwiseeach one-turn answer + 2kπ
cos t = c2π, a full turn2 when −1 < c < 1; 1 when c = 1 or c = −1; none otherwiseeach one-turn answer + 2kπ
tan t = cπ, half a turnalways 2, exactly π apartthe one answer in [0, π), + kπ

Part 1: Sine: each one-turn answer + 2kπ

Sine is the height of the point on the unit circle, like the height of your seat on a Ferris wheel. In one ride around, your seat passes a given height twice, once on the way up and once on the way down; the very top and the very bottom it reaches only once. Those are the solutions on one turn. The next ride repeats them exactly. So each solution on one turn of sin t = c starts its own family, stepping by a full turn, 2π.

  • Period: 2π, one full turn.
  • Family: t = a + 2kπ for each solution on one turn, a.
  • Two answers, with reference angle r: 0 < c < 1 gives r and π − r; −1 < c < 0 gives π + r and 2π − r.
  • One answer: sin t = 1 gives t = π2 + 2kπ; sin t = −1 gives t = 3π2 + 2kπ.
  • Joining: sin t = 0 gives 0 + 2kπ and π + 2kπ, which join into t = kπ because 0 and π are half a turn apart.
−5π/3−4π/3π/32π/37π/38π/3one period−2π−ππ2π3π−11
The line y = 32 meets the sine wave at π3 and 2π3 on one turn, and again one full turn later or earlier.

Worked example

Every solution of sin t = 32

Write every solution of sin t = 32.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t, on every turn and in both directions, whose point on the unit circle has height 32.sin t is the y coordinate, the height, of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π3.The special-angle table gives sin π3 = 32.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π3 and t=π−π3=2π3.The height is positive above the x-axis, in quadrants I and II. In quadrant II the angle is π minus the reference angle, and with π = 3π3: 3π3 − π3 = 2π3.
  4. Add 2kπ to each: t=π3+2kπ and t=2π3+2kπ, where k is any integer.Sine repeats only after a full turn. The two answers are 2π3 − π3 = π3 apart, not π, so they stay two families.
Answer
  • t=π3+2kπ
  • t=2π3+2kπ
  • where k is any integer
Double-check k = −1 in the first family gives π3 − 6π3 = −5π3, a 300° turn clockwise. Turning 300° clockwise ends where turning 60° counterclockwise ends, because 300° + 60° = 360°, a full turn. That is the point at π3, with height 32. k = 1 in the second family gives 2π3 + 6π3 = 8π3, which is 480°; 480° − 360° = 120°, in quadrant II, where sin 120° = 32.
Tips and tricks
  • The two one-turn answers of sin t = c are mirror images across the y-axis, so they add up to π when c > 0 and to 3π when c < 0: π3 + 2π3 = π. Use that to check them.

Part 2: Cosine: each one-turn answer + 2kπ

Cosine is the point's left-right position: positive to the right of the center, negative to the left. On the Ferris wheel, it is how far your seat is to the right or left of the axle. In one ride, the seat passes a given left-right position twice, once in the top half and once in the bottom half; the far right and the far left it reaches only once. Half a ride puts it on the other side, so cosine also needs the full turn, 2π. Each solution on one turn starts its own family.

  • Period: 2π, one full turn.
  • Family: t = a + 2kπ for each solution on one turn, a.
  • Two answers, with reference angle r: 0 < c < 1 gives r and 2π − r; −1 < c < 0 gives π − r and π + r.
  • Short form: the two answers are mirror images across the x-axis, so they can also be written a + 2kπ and −a + 2kπ.
  • One answer: cos t = 1 gives t = 2kπ; cos t = −1 gives t = π + 2kπ.
  • Joining: cos t = 0 gives π2 + 2kπ and 3π2 + 2kπ, which join into t = π2 + kπ.
−11π/6−π/6π/611π/613π/6one period−2π−ππ2π−11
The line y = 32 meets the cosine wave at π6 and 11π6 on one turn.

Worked example

Every solution of cos t = 32

Write every solution of cos t = 32.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point on the unit circle has x=32.cos t is the x coordinate of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π6.The special-angle table gives cos π6 = 32.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.x is positive on the right half of the circle, in quadrants I and IV. In quadrant IV the angle is 2π minus the reference angle, and with 2π = 12π6: 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
  4. Add 2kπ to each: t=π6+2kπ and t=11π6+2kπ, where k is any integer.Cosine repeats only after a full turn, and the answers are 11π6 − π6 = 10π6 = 5π3 apart, not π.
Answer
  • t=π6+2kπ
  • t=11π6+2kπ
  • where k is any integer
Double-check k = −1 in the second family gives 11π6 − 12π6 = −π6, a 30° turn clockwise. It ends at the mirror image, across the x-axis, of the point at π6, and a mirror across the x-axis keeps x the same, so cos(−π6) = 32. This is also why the answer can be written t = π6 + 2kπ and t = −π6 + 2kπ.
Tips and tricks
  • The two one-turn answers of cos t = c always add up to 2π: π6 + 11π6 = 12π6 = 2π. Use that to check them.

Part 3: Tangent: one answer + kπ

Tangent is the steepness of the line from the center of the circle out to the point: rise over run, yx. Picture a seesaw plank laid through the center along that line. Turn the plank half a turn and it lies on exactly the same slant, only with its ends swapped. Tangent sees only the slant, so it repeats every half turn, π. That is why one family, a + kπ, catches both solutions on one turn.

  • Period: π, half a turn.
  • Family: t = a + kπ, where a is the one solution in [0, π).
  • The second solution on one turn is a + π, the family's k = 1 member, so no second family is needed.
  • Every number c has exactly one answer in [0, π): in quadrant I when c > 0, t = 0 when c = 0, in quadrant II when c < 0.
  • Writing a + 2kπ and (a + π) + 2kπ is also correct, only longer: they are the even k and the odd k of a + kπ.
  • Never a solution: π2 + kπ, where x = 0 and tangent is not defined.
−5π/4−π/43π/47π/411π/4−ππ2π−4−224
The line y = −1 meets every branch of tangent once, π apart.

Worked example

Every solution of tan t = −3

Write every solution of tan t = −3.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point (x, y) on the unit circle has yx=−3.tan t = yx at the point of angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π3.At π3 the point is (12, 32), and 32 ÷ 12 = 3.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π−π3=2π3 and t=2π−π3=5π3.yx is negative when x and y have opposite signs: in quadrant II (x negative) and quadrant IV (y negative).
  4. Measure the gap: 5π3−2π3=3π3=π.The two one-turn answers are half a turn apart: the half-turn repeat of tangent showing up.
  5. Keep the answer in [0,π), which is 2π3, and write t=2π3+kπ, where k is any integer.k = 0 gives 2π3 and k = 1 gives 5π3, so this one family holds both one-turn answers and every turn after.
Answer
t = 2π3 + kπ, where k is any integer
Double-check k = −1 gives 2π3 − π = −π3, a 60° turn clockwise, ending at (12, −32). There yx = −32 ÷ 12 = −3, as required. Compare cos t = −12: its one-turn answers 2π3 and 4π3 are 2π3 apart, not half a turn, so cosine keeps two families.
Tips and tricks
  • Check a tangent family: its k = 1 member must be your second one-turn answer. If it is not, one of the answers is wrong.

5 How

  1. Find every solution on one turn, [0, 2π), with the reference angle and quadrant method from the lesson before.
  2. Sine or cosine: write each one-turn answer + 2kπ. Each such list is a family: one starting angle plus every whole number of full turns, forward or back.
  3. Tangent: keep the one answer in [0, π) and write it + kπ. The other one-turn answer is that one + π, so the family already holds it.
  4. Finish with the words: where k is any integer.
  5. Check: put k = 1 and k = −1 into each family and confirm that each angle lands on a point with the right value.

Writing the general solution

1
Is the equation tan t = c?
YesFind the one answer in [0, π) and write it + kπ. That one family is the whole answer.
NoIt is sin t = c or cos t = c. Go on.
↓
2
Is c greater than 1 or less than −1?
YesNo solution at all: the point's x and y never leave the range from −1 to 1, so there is nothing to repeat.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Did one turn give only one answer? (This happens when c = 1 or c = −1.)
YesWrite that answer + 2kπ. That one family is the whole answer.
NoYou have two answers. Go on.
↓
4
Are the two answers exactly π apart? (This happens only when c = 0.)
YesWrite each + 2kπ, or join them into one family: the smaller answer + kπ.
NoWrite each + 2kπ: two families.
  1. Solve on one turn, [0, 2π), with the reference angle and quadrant method, and list every solution on one turn.
  2. Sine or cosine: write each one-turn answer + 2kπ, one family per answer.
  3. Tangent: take the one answer in [0, π) and write it + kπ; the second one-turn answer is that one + π, so it is already inside.
  4. Finish with: where k is any integer.
  5. Check k = 1 and k = −1 in each family: each must land on a point with the right value.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Every solution of a cosine equation

Write every solution of cos t = −22.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
cos 495°. Drop the full turn to reach 135°, in quadrant II with reference angle 45°, so the value is −22, the same as at 3π4.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle t, on every turn and in both directions, whose point on the unit circle has x=−22.cos t is the x coordinate of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π4.The reference angle comes from the value without its sign, and the special-angle table gives cos π4 = 22.
  3. Pick the quadrants: II and III.x is negative on the left half of the circle, so cosine is negative in quadrants II and III.
  4. Build the one-turn answers: t=π−π4=3π4 and t=π+π4=5π4.In quadrant II the angle is π minus the reference angle, in quadrant III it is π plus it. With π = 4π4: 4π4 − π4 = 3π4 and 4π4 + π4 = 5π4.
  5. Add 2kπ to each: t=3π4+2kπ and t=5π4+2kπ.Cosine repeats only after a full turn. The two answers are 5π4 − 3π4 = 2π4 = π2 apart, not π, so they stay two families.
  6. Say what k may be: any integer.k = 0 gives the one-turn answers, positive k adds full turns forward, negative k turns back.
Answer
  • t=3π4+2kπ
  • t=5π4+2kπ
  • where k is any integer
Double-check A second way, with degrees and a clockwise turn. k = 1 in the first family gives 3π4 + 8π4 = 11π4, which is 495°. Drop the full turn: 495° − 360° = 135°, in quadrant II with reference angle 45°, so cos 495° = −22. k = −1 in the second family gives 5π4 − 8π4 = −3π4, a 135° turn clockwise, which ends in quadrant III at (−22, −22). Both land where x = −22.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

Sin t = 1

Write every solution of sin t = 1.

Show the steps and the answer
90°450°same terminal side
90° and 450° end on the same side, at the top of the circle: π2 and 5π2 are one full turn apart.
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point on the unit circle has height 1.sin t is the y coordinate, the height, of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the solutions on one turn: only t=π2.The circle has radius 1, so height 1 is reached at one point only, the very top, (0, 1), a quarter turn from the start.
  3. Add full turns: t=π2+2kπ, where k is any integer.Every full turn brings the point back to the top. There is no second answer on one turn, so there is no second family.
Answer
t = π2 + 2kπ, where k is any integer
Double-check k = 1 gives π2 + 2π = 5π2, which is 450°; 450° − 360° = 90°, the top again, height 1. k = −1 gives π2 − 2π = −3π2, a 270° turn clockwise: a quarter turn clockwise reaches the bottom, half a turn the left side, three quarters the top. Height 1 again.

Rung 2 of 6

Two families, sin t = −12

Write every solution of sin t = −12.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 330°, the same point as −π6, the point is (32, −12): its height is −12.
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point has height −12, a little below the x-axis.sin t is the height of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π6.Drop the sign: sin π6 = 12 in the special-angle table.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π+π6=7π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.The height is negative below the x-axis, in quadrants III and IV. With π = 6π6 and 2π = 12π6: 6π6 + π6 = 7π6 and 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
  4. Add 2kπ to each: t=7π6+2kπ and t=11π6+2kπ, where k is any integer.Sine repeats only after a full turn, and the answers are 11π6 − 7π6 = 4π6 = 2π3 apart, not π.
Answer
  • t=7π6+2kπ
  • t=11π6+2kπ
  • where k is any integer
Double-check k = −1 in the second family gives 11π6 − 12π6 = −π6, a 30° turn clockwise, ending below the x-axis at (32, −12): height −12. k = −1 in the first family gives 7π6 − 12π6 = −5π6, a 150° turn clockwise, which ends in quadrant III at (−32, −12): height −12 again.

Rung 3 of 6

Tangent steps by half a turn, tan t = 1

Write every solution of tan t = 1.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 225°, which is 5π4, x and y are both −22: equal, so their ratio is 1.
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point (x, y) has yx=1, which means y and x are equal.tan t = yx, and a number divided by itself is 1.
  2. Find the reference angle: π4.At π4 the point is (22, 22): x and y are equal.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π4 and t=π+π4=5π4.yx is positive when x and y have the same sign: both positive in quadrant I, both negative in quadrant III.
  4. Measure the gap: 5π4−π4=4π4=π.The answers are half a turn apart: tangent's period showing up.
  5. Keep the answer in [0,π),π4, and write t=π4+kπ, where k is any integer.k = 1 gives 5π4, so one family holds both one-turn answers. A second family would list the same angles again.
Answer
t = π4 + kπ, where k is any integer
Double-check k = 1 gives 5π4, the point (−22, −22), and (−22) ÷ (−22) = 1. k = 2 gives π4 + 2π = 9π4, one full turn past π4, the same point, so the tangent is 1 again.

Rung 4 of 6

Two families that join, cos t = 0

Write every solution of cos t = 0.

Show the steps and the answer
−3π/2−π/2π/23π/25π/2−ππ2π−11
The cosine wave crosses zero every half turn, π apart, so one family, π2 + kπ, holds every crossing.
  1. Say what it asks: every angle t whose point has x=0, so it sits on the y-axis.cos t is the x coordinate of the point at angle t.
  2. Find the solutions on one turn: t=π2 (the top, (0, 1)) and t=3π2 (the bottom, (0,−1)).The circle meets the y-axis at only two points, its top and its bottom.
  3. Write the two families: t=π2+2kπ and t=3π2+2kπ.Cosine repeats every full turn. This answer is already correct and complete.
  4. Notice the gap: 3π2−π2=2π2=π. In order, the solutions are ..., −π2,π2,3π2,5π2, ... each π after the last.The top and the bottom are half a turn apart, and both have x = 0, so the two families take turns.
  5. Join them into one family: t=π2+kπ, where k is any integer.Even k lands on the top and odd k on the bottom, so a step of π visits every solution. This join works only because the two one-turn answers are exactly π apart.
Answer
  • t = π2 + kπ, where k is any integer
  • (the same angles as t = π2 + 2kπ and t = 3π2 + 2kπ)
Double-check k = 2 gives π2 + 2π = 5π2, a full turn past the top: x = 0. k = −1 gives π2 − π = −π2, a quarter turn clockwise, ending at the bottom, (0, −1): x = 0. k = 3 gives π2 + 3π = 7π2, which is 3π2 + 2π, the bottom again.

Rung 5 of 6

Two ways to write the same answer, tan t = −3

Write every solution of tan t = −3. Then decide whether t = −π3 + kπ names the same angles.

Show the steps and the answer
−4π/3−π/32π/35π/3−ππ2π−4−224
The line y = −3 meets tangent once per branch, every π: −π3 and 2π3 are neighbors in the same row.
  1. Say what it asks: first, every angle t whose point has yx=−3; second, whether a different-looking family is the same list.tan t = yx at the point of angle t.
  2. Find the reference angle: π3.At π3 the point is (12, 32), and 32 ÷ 12 = 32 × 2 = 3.
  3. Pick the quadrants and build the one-turn answers: t=π−π3=2π3 and t=2π−π3=5π3.yx is negative when x and y have opposite signs, in quadrants II and IV. 3π3 − π3 = 2π3 and 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.
  4. Measure the gap, 5π3−2π3=3π3=π, keep the answer in [0,π), and write t=2π3+kπ.Tangent repeats every half turn, so k = 1 already gives 5π3.
  5. Test the other family: −π3+kπ gives −π3 at k=0,2π3 at k=1 and 5π3 at k=2.Adding π = 3π3 each time: −π3 + 3π3 = 2π3, then 2π3 + 3π3 = 5π3.
  6. Conclude: the two families are the same list, numbered differently.Both step by π and both contain 2π3, so from there they march together in both directions; the member called k = 1 in one is called k = 0 in the other.
Answer
  • t = 2π3 + kπ, where k is any integer
  • Yes: −π3 + kπ names the same angles
Double-check Put −π3 straight into the equation: a 60° turn clockwise ends at (12, −32), and −32 ÷ 12 = −3. So −π3 is a solution, and our family reaches it at k = −1: 2π3 − 3π3 = −π3.

Rung 6 of 6

Rung 6 (hard): is a far-away angle a solution?

Is t = −21π4 a solution of sin t = −22?

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: does the angle −21π4 belong to one of the families of sint=−22? Put another way: is the height of its point −22?Every solution of the equation lies in one of its families, and nothing else does.
  2. Write the general solution: t=5π4+2kπ and t=7π4+2kπ.Reference angle π4; sine is negative in quadrants III and IV, giving π + π4 = 5π4 and 2π − π4 = 7π4; sine repeats every 2π.
  3. Bring −21π4 onto one turn by adding full turns of 2π=8π4: −21π4+8π4=−13π4, still negative, so add another: −13π4+8π4=−5π4, still negative, so add a third: −5π4+8π4=3π4.Adding a full turn ends on the same point, so the sine does not change. We stop once the angle lies in [0, 2π).
  4. Compare: 3π4 is neither 5π4 nor 7π4.Every member of a family ends on the same point as its one-turn answer, and the point at 3π4 is a different point.
  5. Read the sine there: 3π4 is in quadrant II with reference angle π4, so sin(−21π4)=sin3π4=22.Quadrant II is above the x-axis, so the height is positive.
Answer
No: sin(−21π4) = 22, not −22
Double-check A second way: solve for k to see whether a whole number would reach −21π4. First family: 5π4 + 2kπ = −21π4 gives 2kπ = −26π4 = −13π2, so k = −134. Second family: 7π4 + 2kπ = −21π4 gives 2kπ = −28π4 = −7π, so k = −72. Plug back to test the arithmetic: 7π4 + 2 · (−72) · π = 7π4 − 28π4 = −21π4. The arithmetic holds, but neither k is an integer, so −21π4 is in neither family.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin t = 12, so t = π6 + kπ.
k = 1 gives 7π6, half a turn past π6. The point there is (−32, −12), so sin 7π6 = −12, not 12. Half a turn flips the sign of sine.
✓ Instead: t = π6 + 2kπ and t = 5π6 + 2kπ, where k is any integer.
✗ Not this: tan t = 1, so t = π4 + 2kπ.
Every angle in this family ends at the point of π4, so the family never reaches 5π4. But at 5π4 the point is (−22, −22), and tan 5π4 = 1 too: half the solutions are missing.
✓ Instead: t = π4 + kπ, where k is any integer.
✗ Not this: sin t = 22, so t = π4 + 2kπ.
This family misses 3π4 and every angle a full turn from it. Sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so one turn has two answers, and each needs its own family.
✓ Instead: t = π4 + 2kπ and t = 3π4 + 2kπ, where k is any integer.
✗ Not this: For sin t = 12: t = π6 + 2kπ and t = 5π6 + 2kπ, for k = 1, 2, 3, ...
Leaving out k = 0 drops π6 and 5π6 themselves, and leaving out negative k drops angles such as −11π6 (k = −1 in the first family), which is π6 turned back one full turn.
✓ Instead: The same two families, where k is any integer: ..., −2, −1, 0, 1, 2, ...

Tips and tricks

  • Memory cue: sine and cosine go all the way around, + 2kπ; tangent needs only half the trip, + kπ. Picture a seesaw plank through the center: half a turn puts it back on the same slant, and the slant is all tangent measures.
  • Fast check for any family: k = 0 must give your one-turn answer, and k = 1 and k = −1 must land on points with the same value. For tangent, k = 1 must give your second one-turn answer.
  • Always finish with the words where k is any integer. Without them, the answer does not say which numbers k may be.
  • Answers that look different can be the same list: 2π3 + kπ and −π3 + kπ name the same angles, because −π3 + π = 2π3. To compare two answers, list a few members of each.
  • In degrees the same rules read t = a + 360°k for sine and cosine and t = a + 180°k for tangent.

7 The trap

Mixing up the two steps. A family of sine or cosine solutions steps by a full turn, + 2kπ; a family of tangent solutions steps by a half turn, + kπ. For cos t = −22, writing 3π4 + kπ would make 7π4 (k = 1) a solution, but cos 7π4 = 22, the wrong sign. Before you write + kπ, ask: is this tangent? The one other case is sin t = 0 or cos t = 0, whose two families sit half a turn apart and may be joined into one with + kπ.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Why does adding 2kπ to a solution of sin t = c or cos t = c give another solution?
A full turn, 2π, brings the point on the unit circle back to the same spot, so sine and cosine do not change. Adding 2kπ, with k any integer, moves the angle any whole number of full turns, forward or back.
Why does tangent repeat after only half a turn, π?
Half a turn sends the point (x, y) to (−x, −y). Tangent is yx, and −y−x = yx because the two minus signs cancel. Sine and cosine flip sign there, so they need the full turn, 2π.
The solutions of sin t = −22 on one turn are 5π4 and 7π4. Write the general solution.
  • t=5π4+2kπ
  • t=7π4+2kπ
  • where k is any integer
  • Each needs its own family: whole turns from 5π4 never land on 7π4.
The solutions of tan t = 1 on one turn are π4 and 5π4. Write the general solution.
  • t = π4 + kπ, where k is any integer
  • One family holds both: k = 1 gives π4 + π = 5π4.

Lesson 4 of 8

Equations with a multiple of the angle

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Multiplying an inequality by a positive numberLeans on: Adding a full turn to a fraction of πLeans on: Dividing a fraction by a whole numberLeans on: Comparing with the end of the stretchLeans on: The method for one turnLeans on: Getting one unknown aloneLeans on: The general solutionOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Picture two runners on a round track, starting side by side. While the slow runner does one lap, the fast runner, going twice as fast, does two. In sin 2t, the sine of 2 times t, the angle t is the slow runner and the doubled angle 2t is the fast one: while t goes once around the circle, from 0 to 2π, 2t goes around twice, from 0 to 4π. The fast runner passes each spot twice as often, so sin 2t = 12 has twice as many answers on one turn as sin t = 12: four instead of two. The method follows the fast runner: find every value of 2t that works, on both laps, then divide each by 2.

2 Picture it

π/125π/1213π/1217π/12π/2π3π/22π−11π/125π/1213π/1217π/12π/2π3π/22π−11
On one turn the dashed y = sin t meets the line y = 12 twice.

Reminder

Reminder: Multiplying an inequality by a positive number, Adding a full turn to a fraction of π, Dividing a fraction by a whole number, Comparing with the end of the stretch, The method for one turn, Getting one unknown alone, The general solution
  • Multiplying an inequality by a positive number. The signs stay as they are: multiply each part of 0 ≤ t < 2π by 2 to get 0 ≤ 2t < 4π. Only a negative number would flip them.
  • Adding a full turn to a fraction of π. Write 2π with the same bottom first, then add the tops: π6 + 2π = π6 + 12π6 = 13π6.
  • Dividing a fraction by a whole number. Multiply the bottom by that number: 13π6 ÷ 2 = 13π12. Then simplify if top and bottom share a factor: 4π6 = 2π3.
  • Comparing with the end of the stretch. Give both the same bottom: is 17π6 less than 4π? 4π = 24π6, and 17 < 24, so yes.
  • The method for one turn. sin u = 12: the reference angle is π6; sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so u = π6 and π − π6 = 5π6.
  • Getting one unknown alone. Undo the adding, then the multiplying: 2x + 2 = 0 gives 2x = −2, then x = −22. The same moves free cos 2t.
  • The general solution. Every solution of sin u = c or cos u = c repeats each full turn: u = a + 2kπ for any whole number k, positive, negative or zero. For tangent the step is π: u = a + kπ.

3 Why

Take one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π, and multiply every part by 2. Multiplying by a positive number keeps the inequality signs, so 0 ≤ 2t < 4π: the angle inside the sine covers two full turns. Sine repeats every full turn, so each solution on the first turn has a partner on the second, 2π later. Two turns, twice as many solutions; with 3t, three turns and three times as many. If you searched 2t only from 0 to 2π, dividing by 2 would give only values of t from 0 to π, losing every answer in the second half of the turn.

4 The rule

To solve a trigonometric equation such as sin(nt) =c, cos(nt) =c or tan(nt) =c for 0≤t<2π: the inside angle u= nt runs over 0≤u<2nπ, which is n full turns.

Find every u on that stretch, then divide each one by n. For a positive whole number n, that gives n times as many solutions as the plain equation, such as sint=c, has on one turn.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Say it out loud as: sine of two t equals c. The 2 belongs to the angle: double t first, then take the sine.

Write it

The sine of twice the angle t equals c, and the job is to find every angle t on one turn that makes it true.

In math
  • sin 2t = c
  • sin(2t) = c
  • u = 2t, so sin u = c
  • 0 ≤ t < 2π gives 0 ≤ 2t < 4π
  • t in [0, 2π) gives 2t in [0, 4π)
Like

Two runners on one track: while the slow one runs one lap, the fast one runs two and passes every flag twice.

See it
04πlap 12πlap 2
The doubled angle 2t runs from 0 up to 4π, with 4π left out: two laps of the circle, each 2π long.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Picture the arrow that draws an angle from the center of the unit circle. While the arrow for t sweeps one full turn, the arrow for 2t sweeps two, ending at 4π, which is 720°. The spots where sine is 12 sit at π6 and 5π6, and the 2t arrow passes each spot once on every lap: two spots, two laps, four passes, four solutions.

2t: two turnsterminal sideinitial side
When t makes one full turn, 2t makes two: 720°, which is 4π.
As a story

In twelve hours the hour hand of a clock goes around once, while the minute hand, twelve times as fast, goes around twelve times. How often does the minute hand point straight up in those twelve hours? Twelve times, once per lap. A faster hand meets every spot more often. In sin 2t the angle 2t moves twice as fast as t, so during one turn of t it meets each solution spot twice.

With small numbers

In the table, the top row holds the four answers t and the bottom row holds their doubles 2t. Look at the last two columns: 13π12 is more than π, in the second half of the turn, and its double 13π6 is more than 2π. Take away one full turn: 13π6 − 12π6 = π6, so sin 2t = sin π6 = 12: a real solution. A search of 2t that stopped at 2π would reach only the first two columns.

input toutput 2tπ/12π/65π/125π/613π/1213π/617π/1217π/6
Each answer t on top, its double 2t below: the last two doubles are past 2π, on the second lap.
Why it must be true

Two facts settle it. First, multiplying 0 ≤ t < 2π by 2 gives 0 ≤ 2t < 4π, so the inside angle covers two turns. Second, adding π to t adds 2π to 2t, because 2(t + π) = 2t + 2π, and a full turn lands on the same spot: sin(2t + 2π) = sin 2t. So every answer t between 0 and π has a twin t + π between π and 2π, and the count doubles.

0 ≤ t < 2π

times 2: 0 ≤ 2t < 4π

2(t + π) = 2t + 2π

sin(2t + 2π) = sin 2t

every answer t below π has a twin t + π

EquationThe inside angle runs overTurns of the inside angleSolutions on one turn of t, when the plain equation has 2
sin t = c[0, 2π)12
sin 2t = c[0, 4π)24
sin 3t = c[0, 6π)36
sin 4t = c[0, 8π)48
sin(t2)=c[0, π)half of one0, 1 or 2: list them and check each

5 How

  1. Say what is asked: every solution on one turn, that is, every angle t with 0 ≤ t < 2π that makes the equation true.
  2. Get the sine, cosine or tangent alone on one side, the way you would solve for x.
  3. Give the inside angle, the angle the function acts on, a nickname: u = 2t (or u = 3t, and so on).
  4. Stretch the interval: multiply both ends of 0 ≤ t < 2π by the number in front of t. For 2t that gives 0 ≤ u < 4π, two turns.
  5. Solve for u on the first turn with the reference angle and the quadrant signs.
  6. Add 2π to each of those answers, again and again, keeping every result that is below the new end.
  7. Divide each u by the number in front of t, and simplify the fraction.
  8. Check: the count should be the number of turns times the count on one turn; then put each t back into the original equation.

Solving an equation with a multiple of the angle

1
Is the sine, cosine or tangent alone on one side?
YesGo on.
NoGet it alone first: undo the adding, then the multiplying, as you would for 2x + 1 = 0.
↓
2
Is the angle inside a multiple of t, such as 2t, 3t or t2?
YesCall that angle u and go on.
NoIt is a basic equation: solve it on one turn with the reference angle and the quadrants.
↓
3
Is the number n in front of t a whole number?
Yesu runs over 0 ≤ u < 2nπ, n full turns: find the answers on the first turn, then add 2π to each, n − 1 times.
NoMultiply the ends by it anyway and keep only the values of u inside that stretch. For t2, u runs over 0 ≤ u < π, half a turn, and t = 2u at the end.
↓
4
Did a value of u land exactly on the end of the stretch, such as 4π?
YesDrop it: the end of the stretch is left out, because it comes from t = 2π, which is not in the turn.
NoKeep every value below the end.
↓
5
For a whole number n, is the count n times the count for one turn?
YesDivide every u by n and put each t back in.
NoLook for a lap you skipped or a value past the end, then count again.
  1. Get it alone: put sin, cos or tan of the multiple angle by itself on one side.
  2. Rename: call the inside angle u, so sin 2t = c becomes sin u = c.
  3. Stretch: multiply both ends of 0 ≤ t < 2π by the number in front of t. That is the stretch u covers.
  4. Solve: find u on the first turn with the reference angle and the quadrant signs.
  5. Add turns: add 2π to each of those answers, again and again, keeping only values below the end of the stretch.
  6. Shrink: divide every u by the number in front of t.
  7. Check: count the answers, check the spacing between partners, and put each t back in.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Sin 2t = 12 on one turn: four answers

Solve sin 2t = 12 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
30°390°same terminal side
π6 (30°) and 13π6 (390°) end on the same side, so both have sine 12.
  1. Say what the question asks: find every angle t on one turn whose double, 2t, has sine 12.Naming the target reminds you that the answer is a list of every such t, not a single angle.
  2. Call the inside angle u, so u=2t and the equation reads sinu=12. Multiply each part of 0≤t<2π by 2: 0≤u<4π.u is a nickname for 2t, which turns the problem into the basic kind you already solve. Multiplying by the positive number 2 keeps the inequality signs, and the stretch from 0 to 4π is two full turns, so both must be searched.
  3. Solve sinu=12 on the first turn. The reference angle is π6, because sinπ6=12. Sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so u=π6 and u=π−π6=5π6.This is the method for one turn: the special value gives the reference angle, and the sign of 12 picks the quadrants.
  4. Add one full turn, 2π=12π6, to each: u=π6+12π6=13π6 and u=5π6+12π6=17π6.On the second lap the angle passes the same two spots again: adding 2π brings the point back to where it was. Both values are less than 4π = 24π6, so both stay.
  5. Try one more turn: 13π6+12π6=25π6 and 17π6+12π6=29π6.Both are more than 24π6 = 4π, past the end of the stretch, so the search stops with four values of u: π6, 5π6, 13π6, 17π6.
  6. Divide each u by 2: t=π12,5π12,13π12,17π12.u = 2t, so t is half of u. Halving a fraction doubles its bottom: 13π6 ÷ 2 = 13π12.
  7. Put each one back. 2·π12=π6 and 2·5π12=5π6: both have sine 12. 2·13π12=13π6, which is π6 plus a full turn, and 2·17π12=17π6, which is 5π6 plus a full turn: sine 12 again.Every answer must make the original equation true, and adding a full turn never changes a sine.
Answer
  • t=π12
  • t=5π12
  • t=13π12
  • t=17π12
Double-check Second way, with the general solution: every solution of sin u = 12 is u = π6 + 2kπ or u = 5π6 + 2kπ. Halve them: t = π12 + kπ or t = 5π12 + kπ. k = 0 gives π12 and 5π12; k = 1 gives 13π12 and 17π12; k = 2 gives 25π12 and 29π12, both past 2π = 24π12. The same four answers, and the count matches: two per turn times two turns.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 7

Sin 2t = 1

Solve sin 2t = 1 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
π/2
Sine is 1 only at the top of the circle, at π2: one spot per lap.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose double, 2t, has sine 1.The answer is a list of every such t; naming it keeps you from stopping at the first.
  2. Let u=2t. Multiply each part of 0≤t<2π by 2: 0≤u<4π.The inside angle covers two full turns, so both must be searched.
  3. On the first turn, sin u = 1 only at the top of the unit circle: u=π2.Sine is the height of the point on the unit circle, and only the very top point has height 1. So each turn holds one answer here, not two.
  4. Add one full turn, 2π=4π2: u=π2+4π2=5π2. One more turn would give 9π2.5π2 is less than 4π = 8π2, so it stays; 9π2 is more, so the search stops.
  5. Divide each u by 2: t=π4 and t=5π4.t is half of u, and halving a fraction doubles its bottom.
Answer
  • t=π4
  • t=5π4
Double-check Put back: 2 · π4 = π2, and sin π2 = 1; 2 · 5π4 = 5π2, which is π2 plus a full turn, so its sine is 1 too. Second way: adding π to t adds a full turn to 2t, so the answers should sit π apart, and 5π4 − π4 = 4π4 = π. One answer per turn, two turns, two answers.

Rung 2 of 7

The usual four, cos 2t = 12

Solve cos 2t = 12 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose double, 2t, has cosine 12.The same kind of question as the worked example, with cosine in place of sine.
  2. Let u=2t, so 0≤u<4π.Doubling every part of one turn gives two turns.
  3. First turn: the reference angle is π3, because cosπ3=12. Cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so u=π3 and u=2π−π3=5π3.Cosine is the x coordinate, and it is positive on the right half of the circle: quadrants I and IV. Gotcha: these are not the sine quadrants, I and II.
  4. Add 2π=6π3 to each: u=7π3 and u=11π3.Both are less than 4π = 12π3, so both stay. One more 2π gives 13π3 and 17π3, past the end.
  5. Divide each u by 2: t=π6,5π6,7π6,11π6.t is half of u, and halving doubles the bottom.
Answer
  • t=π6
  • t=5π6
  • t=7π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check Second way, with the general solution: u = π3 + 2kπ or u = 5π3 + 2kπ, so t = π6 + kπ or t = 5π6 + kπ. k = 0 gives π6 and 5π6; k = 1 gives 7π6 and 11π6; k = 2 gives 13π6 and 17π6, past 2π = 12π6. The same four. Put one back: 2 · 11π6 = 11π3, which is 5π3 plus a full turn, and cos 5π3 = 12.

Rung 3 of 7

The open end, sin 2t = 0

Solve sin 2t = 0 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
04ππ2π3π
u = 0, π, 2π and 3π lie inside [0, 4π); 4π is the open end, so it is not an answer.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose double, 2t, has sine 0.The answer is the full list of such t.
  2. Let u=2t, so 0≤u<4π.Two turns for the doubled angle. Notice the end: 4π is left out, in the same way that 2π is left out of one turn.
  3. First turn: sinu=0 where the height is 0, at the two points on the horizontal axis: u=0 and u=π.Sine is the height of the point on the unit circle, and the height is 0 at the right end (angle 0) and the left end (angle π).
  4. Add 2π: u=2π and u=3π. One more turn: u=4π and u=5π.2π and 3π are less than 4π, so they stay. Gotcha: 4π is the end itself, which is left out, and 5π is past it.
  5. Divide each u by 2: t=0,π2,π,3π2.t is half of u: 0 ÷ 2 = 0, π ÷ 2 = π2, 2π ÷ 2 = π and 3π ÷ 2 = 3π2.
Answer
  • t = 0
  • t=π2
  • t = π
  • t=3π2
Double-check Put back: the doubles are 0, π, 2π and 3π, all points on the horizontal axis, so each has sine 0. Second way: adding π to t adds a full turn to 2t, so the answers pair up π apart, and they do: 0 with π, π2 with 3π2. The dropped u = 4π would give t = 2π, the same spot as t = 0, which is already on the list.

Rung 4 of 7

Get it alone first, 2 cos 2t + 2 = 0

Solve 2 cos 2t + 2 = 0 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
Cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so cos u = −22 has one answer in each on every turn.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn that makes 2cos2t+2 equal to 0.The cosine is not alone yet, so the first job is to free it.
  2. Subtract 2 from both sides: 2cos2t=−2. Divide both sides by 2: cos2t=−22.This finds the one value the cosine must have, the same way 2x + 2 = 0 gives x = −22. Plug it back to see: 2 · (−22) + 2 = −2 + 2 = 0.
  3. Let u=2t, so 0≤u<4π.Two turns for the doubled angle.
  4. First turn: the reference angle is π4, because cosπ4=22. Cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so u=π−π4=3π4 and u=π+π4=5π4.Cosine is the x coordinate, negative on the left half of the circle: quadrants II and III.
  5. Add 2π=8π4 to each: u=11π4 and u=13π4.Both are less than 4π = 16π4, so both stay; one more 2π gives 19π4 and 21π4, past the end.
  6. Divide each u by 2: t=3π8,5π8,11π8,13π8.Halving doubles the bottom. Gotcha: these are not special angles, and that is fine; only the inside angle 2t has to be one.
Answer
  • t=3π8
  • t=5π8
  • t=11π8
  • t=13π8
Double-check Second way, with the general solution: u = 3π4 + 2kπ or u = 5π4 + 2kπ, so t = 3π8 + kπ or t = 5π8 + kπ. k = 0 gives 3π8 and 5π8; k = 1 gives 3π8 + 8π8 = 11π8 and 5π8 + 8π8 = 13π8; k = 2 is past 2π. Put one back: 2 · 11π8 = 11π4, which is 3π4 plus a full turn, so 2 cos 2t + 2 = 2 · (−22) + 2 = 0.

Rung 5 of 7

Tangent, tan 2t = 3

Solve tan 2t = 3 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
π/62π/37π/65π/3π/2π3π/22π−4−224
y = tan 2t repeats every π2, so the line y = 3 meets it four times on one turn, π2 apart.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose double, 2t, has tangent 3.Same method; only the function and its quadrants change.
  2. Let u=2t, so 0≤u<4π.Two turns for the doubled angle.
  3. First turn: the reference angle is π3, because tanπ3=32÷12=3 (dividing by 12 is the same as multiplying by 2). Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III, so u=π3 and u=π+π3=4π3.Tangent is sine divided by cosine, so it is positive where the two share a sign: quadrant I (both positive) and quadrant III (both negative). Gotcha: quadrant III means π + π3, not π − π3.
  4. Add 2π=6π3 to each: u=7π3 and u=10π3.Both are less than 4π = 12π3, so both stay; one more 2π gives 13π3 and 16π3, past the end.
  5. Divide each u by 2: t=π6,4π6=2π3,7π6,10π6=5π3.Halving doubles the bottom; then 4π6 and 10π6 simplify by dividing top and bottom by 2.
Answer
  • t=π6
  • t=2π3
  • t=7π6
  • t=5π3
Double-check Second way, with the period of tangent, π: every solution is u = π3 + kπ, so t = π6 + k · π2. k = 0, 1, 2, 3 give π6, 4π6 = 2π3, 7π6, 10π6 = 5π3; k = 4 gives 13π6, past 2π. The same four, each π2 after the one before.

Rung 6 of 7

Three turns, sin 3t = 22

Solve sin 3t = 22 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
π/12π/43π/411π/1217π/1219π/12π/2π3π/22π−11
y = sin 3t makes three waves on one turn, and each wave crosses the line y = 22 twice: six solutions.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose triple, 3t, has sine 22.The number in front of t is now 3, not 2.
  2. Let u=3t. Multiply each part of 0≤t<2π by 3: 0≤u<6π.Three full turns, so expect three times as many answers: 2 × 3 = 6.
  3. First turn: the reference angle is π4, because sinπ4=22. Sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so u=π4 and u=π−π4=3π4.The method for one turn: reference angle, then the quadrants where sine is positive.
  4. Add 2π=8π4 twice: first u=9π4 and 11π4, then u=17π4 and 19π4.The second and third laps pass the same two spots. All are less than 6π = 24π4; one more 2π gives 25π4, past the end.
  5. Divide each u by 3: t=π12,3π12=π4,9π12=3π4,11π12,17π12,19π12.t is a third of u, and dividing a fraction by 3 multiplies its bottom by 3. Gotcha: divide by 3 here, not by 2. Then simplify where top and bottom share a 3.
Answer
  • t=π12
  • t=π4
  • t=3π4
  • t=11π12
  • t=17π12
  • t=19π12
Double-check Count: 2 per turn times 3 turns is 6. Spacing: adding 2π3 = 8π12 to t adds 2π to 3t, so partners sit 8π12 apart, and they do: π12, 9π12, 17π12 and 3π12, 11π12, 19π12. Put one back: 3 · 19π12 = 19π4, which is 3π4 plus 4π, two full turns, so its sine is 22.

Rung 7 of 7

Genuinely hard, half the angle, cos(t2) = −12

Solve cos(t2) = −12 for 0 ≤ t < 2π.

Show the steps and the answer
4π/3π/2π3π/22π−11
On one turn of t, y = cos(t2) makes only half a wave, so it meets the line y = −12 once.
  1. Say what it asks: every t on one turn whose half, t2, has cosine −12.This time the number in front of t is 12, so the inside angle moves slower than t.
  2. Let u=t2. Divide each part of 0≤t<2π by 2: 0≤u<π.Dividing by the positive number 2 keeps the inequality signs. Gotcha: the stretch shrinks; the inside angle covers only half a turn, the top half of the circle.
  3. Solve cosu=−12 on a full first turn: the reference angle is π3, and cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so u=π−π3=2π3 or u=π+π3=4π3.The method for one turn lists every candidate; the next step keeps only the ones inside the stretch.
  4. Keep only u less than π: 2π3 is less than 3π3=π, so it stays; 4π3 is more, so it goes. No turns are added.u never reaches π, so it never gets to quadrant III, let alone a second lap.
  5. Undo the halving: t=2u=2·2π3=4π3.u = t2, so t is twice u.
Answer
t=4π3
Double-check Put it back: 4π3 ÷ 2 = 4π6 = 2π3, and cos 2π3 = −12. The dropped value u = 4π3 would need t = 8π3, more than 2π = 6π3, so it really is outside. Second way, the picture: as t goes from 0 to 2π, y = cos(t2) falls steadily from 1 toward −1, half a wave, so it crosses the height −12 exactly once.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: For sin 2t = 12, find 2t = π6 and 5π6 on one turn, divide by 2, and stop at t = π12 and 5π12.
2t runs from 0 to 4π, two turns, and this searched only the first, so every answer with t from π to 2π is missing. t = 13π12 works: 2 · 13π12 = 13π6, a full turn past π6, and its sine is 12.
✓ Instead: Search 0 ≤ 2t < 4π: 2t = π6, 5π6, 13π6, 17π6, so t = π12, 5π12, 13π12, 17π12.
✗ Not this: Divide the 2 away as if it multiplied the sine: sin 2t = 1, so sin t = 12, so t = π6 or 5π6.
The 2 sits inside the sine, on the angle, so sin 2t is not 2 sin t. At t = π4: sin 2t = sin π2 = 1, but 2 sin π4 = 2 · 22 = 2 ≈ 1.41 (rounded). And t = π6 fails the original: sin(2 · π6) = sin π3 = 32, not 1.
✓ Instead: Solve for the whole angle first: 2t = π2 or 5π2 on the two turns, then divide: t = π4 or 5π4.
✗ Not this: Divide first, then add the full turn to t: from t = π12 add 2π to get 25π12, which is past 2π, and decide there is nothing more.
Adding 2π to t adds 4π to 2t: two laps at once, which jumps over the answer in between. One full turn of 2t is only half a turn of t.
✓ Instead: Add 2π to 2t before dividing, or add π to t afterward: π12 + π = π12 + 12π12 = 13π12, a solution.
✗ Not this: For sin 2t = 0, count 2t = 4π as an answer, giving t = 2π.
One turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π, leaves out 2π because it is the same spot as 0, which is already counted. So the stretch 0 ≤ 2t < 4π leaves out 4π.
✓ Instead: 2t = 0, π, 2π, 3π, so t = 0, π2, π, 3π2: four answers.
✗ Not this: Expect two answers for cos(t2) = −12 and keep both u = 2π3 and u = 4π3.
The number in front of t is 12, so the inside angle covers 0 ≤ t2 < π, only half a turn. u = 4π3 is past π: it would need t = 8π3, more than 2π.
✓ Instead: Keep u = 2π3 only, so t = 2 · 2π3 = 4π3: one answer.

Tips and tricks

  • Count before you solve: the number in front of t tells how many turns the inside angle makes. For sin 2t = 12 expect 2 turns × 2 answers = 4. Any other count means a lap was skipped or a value past the end slipped in.
  • Twin check: for sin 2t and cos 2t the answers come in pairs exactly π apart, like π12 and 13π12, because adding π to t adds a full turn to 2t. For 3t the step between partners is 2π3; for tan 2t it is π2.
  • Memory cue: stretch, solve, shrink. Stretch the interval by the number in front of t, solve on the long stretch, then shrink every answer by dividing by that number.
  • Do all the adding of 2π on the inside angle, and divide only at the very end.
  • Answers like 3π8 or π12 are fine. Only the inside angle has to be a special angle; t itself can be any fraction of π.
  • When the number in front of t is between 0 and 1, as in t2, the inside angle covers less than one turn, so expect the same number of answers or fewer, never more. Check each candidate against the end of the stretch.

7 The trap

Solving for 2t only on the usual one turn, 0 ≤ 2t < 2π, and then dividing by 2. That finds only the answers with t less than π and quietly loses the rest: for sin 2t = 12 it gives t = π12 and 5π12 and misses 13π12 and 17π12. Stretch the interval before you solve, 0 ≤ 2t < 4π, and do all the adding of 2π on 2t before you divide.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Picture two runners on a round track. In sin 2t, which angle is the fast runner, and how many laps does it run while t runs one?
  • The doubled angle 2t.
  • Two laps: while t goes from 0 to 2π, 2t goes from 0 to 4π.
On one turn, cos t = −22 has two solutions. How many does cos 3t = −22 have for 0 ≤ t < 2π?
  • Six.
  • Multiply both ends of 0 ≤ t < 2π by 3: the inside angle covers 0 ≤ 3t < 6π, three full turns.
  • Each turn gives two solutions, and 3 × 2 = 6.
One solution of sin 2t = 12 is t = π12. Why is adding 2π to t the wrong way to look for more?
  • It lands on 25π12, past the end of the turn 0 ≤ t < 2π.
  • Sine repeats when its inside angle grows by 2π, and the inside angle is 2t = π6. Add 2π there, then divide by 2: π6 + 2π = 13π6, so t = 13π12.
You solve cos 4t = c with 4t only on one turn, 0 ≤ 4t < 2π, and then divide by 4. Which part of the turn do your values of t come from?
  • Only 0 ≤ t < π2, the first quarter of the turn.
  • Every solution with t from π2 up to 2π is lost. Stretch first: 0 ≤ 4t < 8π, four full turns.

Lesson 5 of 8

Equations that factor like a quadratic

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: The zero-product ruleLeans on: Factoring by splitting the middle termLeans on: Pulling out a common factorLeans on: Moving a term across the equals signLeans on: Solving 2u + 1 = 0Leans on: What sin² t meansLeans on: Sine and cosine stay from −1 to 1Leans on: A basic equation on one turnLeans on: Adding and subtracting fractions of πOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

A trigonometric equation such as 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0 looks crowded. (sin2 t means sin t times itself.) The trick: cover every sin t with a sticky note marked u. What is left, 2u2 − 7u − 4 = 0, is a quadratic you already know how to factor. So you solve in two stages, like finding a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1: first the height (the value of sin t), then the spots on the wheel at that height (the angles). No seat is ever more than 1 above or below the center, so if the algebra hands you a height of 4, nothing matches. You cross it out.

2 Picture it

7π/611π/6π/2π3π/22π247π/611π/6π/2π3π/22π−11234
In the worked example, 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t = 4, the quadratic gives sin t = 4 or sin t = −12.

Reminder

Reminder: The zero-product rule, Factoring by splitting the middle term, Pulling out a common factor, Moving a term across the equals sign, Solving 2u + 1 = 0, What sin2 t means, Sine and cosine stay from −1 to 1, A basic equation on one turn, Adding and subtracting fractions of π
  • The zero-product rule. If a product is 0, one of its factors is 0: (u − 3)(u + 4) = 0 means u = 3 or u = −4. It works only when the other side is 0.
  • Factoring by splitting the middle term. For au2 + bu + c, find two numbers that multiply to a·c and add to b, split the middle term with them, and group. For 2u2 + 5u + 3: a·c = 6, and 2 + 3 = 5, so 2u2 + 2u + 3u + 3 = 2u(u + 1) + 3(u + 1) = (2u + 3)(u + 1).
  • Pulling out a common factor. When every term has a u, take it out front: 2u2 + u = u(2u + 1). Multiply back to check: u·2u + u·1 = 2u2 + u.
  • Moving a term across the equals sign. Do the same thing to both sides: from u2 = 4u − 3, subtract 4u and add 3 to get u2 − 4u + 3 = 0.
  • Solving 2u + 1 = 0. Undo the steps in reverse order: subtract 1 to get 2u = −1, then divide by 2 to get u = −12.
  • What sin2 t means. sin2 t is (sin t)2: find the sine first, then square it. sin2(π6) = (12)2 = 14, and (−12)2 = 14 as well, because a negative times a negative is positive.
  • Sine and cosine stay from −1 to 1. On the unit circle, cos t is the x and sin t is the y of a point on a circle of radius 1, so −1 ≤ sin t ≤ 1 and −1 ≤ cos t ≤ 1. Tangent has no such limit.
  • A basic equation on one turn. For sin t = −12: the reference angle is π6, and sine is negative in quadrants III and IV, so t = π + π6 = 7π6 and t = 2π − π6 = 11π6.
  • Adding and subtracting fractions of π. Rewrite π and 2π with the same bottom first: π + π6 = 6π6 + π6 = 7π6, and 2π − π3 = 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.

3 Why

The equation looks at t only through sin t. So if an angle t makes it true, the number sin t, put in for u, makes 2u2 − 7u − 4 = 0 true: sin t must be one of the quadratic's answers, −12 or 4. And any angle whose sine is one of those answers makes the equation true. So the solutions are exactly those angles. The throw-out step comes from the unit circle: its radius is 1, and sin t is the height of a point on it, so sin t is never below −1 or above 1. The algebra cannot know that; the circle does.

4 The rule

An equation a·sin2t+b·sint+c=0, with a≠0, is a quadratic in sin t: writing u=sint gives au2+ bu +c=0.

Its solutions are the angles t with sint=u, for each answer u of the quadratic with −1≤u≤1; an answer outside [−1,1] gives no angle. Cosine works the same way. For tangent, keep every real answer, since tangent takes every real value.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

a quadratic in sine t. It means sine t plays the part that x plays in an ordinary quadratic. Read sin2 t aloud as sine squared of t.

Write it

An equation is a quadratic in sin t when, after you write one letter u for sin t, it has the form au2 + bu + c = 0 with a not equal to 0.

In math
  • a·sin2 t + b·sin t + c = 0, with a ≠ 0
  • u = sin t turns it into au2 + bu + c = 0
  • 2 sin2 t − sin t − 1 = 0 is 2u2 − u − 1 = 0
  • keep an answer u only when −1 ≤ u ≤ 1 (sine and cosine)
Like

Like a box with a label: put sin t in a box marked u, do the algebra with the box, and open it only at the end to find the angles.

See it

2sin2t−sint−1=0

write u for sin t

2u2−u−1=0

a quadratic in u

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Picture the graph of y = sin t over one turn: a wave that rises to 1 and falls to −1. Each answer the quadratic gives for sin t is a flat line across that picture, and each place where the wave crosses the line is an angle. A line at 1 touches the top of the wave once. A line at 12 crosses it twice. A line at −2 passes below the whole wave and crosses nothing: that miss is the throw-out step.

π/2π/65π/6π/2π3π/22π−2−11
Three flat lines, three outcomes.
As a story

A Ferris wheel has radius 1, and heights are measured from its center. A friend works out on paper that your seat must be at height 4 or at height −12. You look up: the top seat is at height 1, so height 4 is empty sky far above the wheel. Cross it out. Height −12 is below the center, and a seat passes it twice on every turn, once on the way down and once on the way back up. Those two moments are the two angles.

x = cos θy = sin θseat
A seat at angle 7π6 is half a unit below the center of a wheel of radius 1.
With small numbers

Take cos2 t − cos t − 2 = 0. Write u for cos t: u2 − u − 2 = 0. Two numbers that multiply to −2 and add to −1 are −2 and 1, so (u − 2)(u + 1) = 0, and u = 2 or u = −1. Put cosine back: cos t = 2 has no angle, since cosine never goes above 1; cos t = −1 is the leftmost point of the circle: t = π on one turn, and t = π + 2kπ for every integer k in general. Check: (−1)2 − (−1) − 2 = 1 + 1 − 2 = 0.

x = cos θy = sin θπ
cos t = −1 happens only at the leftmost point of the circle, once per turn, at π.
Why it must be true

The equation looks at t only through the number sin t. Two angles with the same sine, like π6 and 5π6, look identical to it. So the question splits in two: which numbers u make 2u2 − 7u − 4 = 0, a plain algebra question, and which angles have those numbers as their sine, a unit circle question. Splitting it this way loses nothing and adds nothing.

x = cos θy = sin θ5π/6
5π6 sits at the same height, 12, as π6: an equation that sees only sin t cannot tell them apart.
Rule of thumb

Algebra first, circle second, check last. The algebra does not know that sine and cosine stop at 1, so every number it hands you must pass the circle's test, from −1 to 1, before it turns into angles.

1. algebra: find the values of sin t

2. filter: keep −1 ≤ value ≤ 1

3. circle: turn each kept value into angles

4. check each angle in the original

value from the factoringsin t = value: angles in [0, 2π)cos t = value: angles in [0, 2π)
1π2 (one angle)0 (one angle)
12π6,5π6π3,5π3
00, ππ2,3π2
−127π6,11π62π3,4π3
−13π2 (one angle)π (one angle)
below −1 or above 1, such as 4, −3 or −32none: throw it outnone: throw it out

5 How

  1. Get 0 on one side: add or subtract on both sides until every term sits on the left and the right side is 0.
  2. Make sure only one trig function appears (all sin t, or all cos t, or all tan t), with its square in one term.
  3. Write u for that function, so sin2 t becomes u2 and sin t becomes u.
  4. Factor the quadratic in u: pull out a common factor when there is no plain number term; otherwise split the middle term and group. Multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored, such as (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0, skips this step.
  5. Set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u (the zero-product rule). Plug each u back into the factored form to see the product is 0.
  6. Put the function back: each value of u becomes a basic equation such as sin t = −12.
  7. Throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1: no angle has it. Keep every value of tangent.
  8. Solve each remaining basic equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants. For sine or cosine, the values 1 and −1 give one angle each; the other values give two.
  9. List all the angles in order and put each one back into the original equation.

Solving a trig equation that factors like a quadratic

1
Is the right side something other than 0?
YesAdd or subtract on both sides until one side is 0.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Does the equation come already factored, as in (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0?
YesSkip the factoring: set each factor equal to 0, solve for the value of the function, and go to the question about values below −1 or above 1.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Does only one trig function appear (sin t, or cos t, or tan t), with its square in one term?
YesWrite u for it and go on.
NoThis method does not fit the equation as it stands. Equations that mix sin t and cos t are first rewritten into one function, a step taught later in this unit.
↓
4
Is the plain number term missing, as in 2u2 + u = 0?
YesPull out the common factor u. Do not divide by u: that deletes the answers where u = 0.
NoLook for two whole numbers, positive or negative, that multiply to a·c and add to b.
↓
5
Did you find two such numbers?
YesSplit the middle term with them, group, and multiply back to check.
NoRecheck the signs and that every term moved to one side. Every equation in this lesson that does not come already factored factors this way.
↓
6
Is an answer for sin t or cos t below −1 or above 1?
YesThrow that answer out: it gives no angle.
NoKeep it. Answers for tan t are always kept.
↓
7
Is a kept value of sin t or cos t equal to 1 or −1?
YesIt gives one angle on one turn: the top, bottom, right or left point of the unit circle.
NoIt gives two angles on one turn. Every kept value of tan t also gives two.
  1. Zero: move every term to one side so the other side is 0.
  2. Rename: write u for the one trig function in the equation.
  3. Factor the quadratic in u and multiply back to check. An equation that comes already factored skips this step.
  4. Zero-product: set each factor equal to 0 and solve for u.
  5. Return: turn each u into a basic equation, such as sin t = −12.
  6. Filter: throw out any value of sine or cosine below −1 or above 1.
  7. Angles: solve each kept equation on [0, 2π) with the reference angle and the quadrants.
  8. Check: put every angle back into the original equation.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Two values of sine, one thrown out

Solve 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side equal 4.

Show the steps and the answer
2u²−8u2uu−4+1u−4
The four parts add to 2u2 − 8u + u − 4 = 2u2 − 7u − 4, so (2u + 1)(u − 4) is the right factoring.
x = cos θy = sin θ7π/6
At 7π6, in quadrant III, the point sits half a unit below the center: sin t = −12.
x = cos θy = sin θ11π/6
At 11π6, in quadrant IV, the point is again half a unit below the center: the second angle with sin t = −12.
  1. Subtract 4 from both sides: 2 sin2t−7sint−4=0.The zero-product rule, used in a moment, needs a 0 on one side. Subtracting the same number from both sides keeps them equal.
  2. Write u for sin t: 2u2−7u−4=0.sin2 t means (sin t)2, which is u2. Every t in the equation sits inside a sin t, so with this one letter the trigonometric equation becomes a plain quadratic.
  3. Find two numbers that multiply to a·c=2·(−4)=−8 and add to b=−7. They are −8 and 1.(−8)·1 = −8 and −8 + 1 = −7. These two numbers show how to split the middle term so the four pieces group in pairs.
  4. Split and group: 2u2−8u+u−4=2u(u−4)+1(u−4)=(2u+1)(u−4). So (2u+1)(u−4)=0.Both pairs contain (u − 4), so it comes out as a common factor. Multiply back to check: 2u2 − 8u + u − 4 = 2u2 − 7u − 4, the quadratic you started with.
  5. Set each factor equal to 0: 2u+1=0 gives u=−12; u−4=0 gives u=4.This finds the values of u that make the product 0 (the zero-product rule). For 2u + 1 = 0, subtract 1, then divide by 2. Plug back in: u = −12 gives (0)(−92) = 0, and u = 4 gives (9)(0) = 0.
  6. Put sine back: sint=−12 or sint=4.u was only a stand-in for sin t. These are values of sine, not angles yet.
  7. Throw out sint=4.sin t is the height of a point on the unit circle, whose radius is 1, so −1 ≤ sin t ≤ 1. Height 4 is far above the whole circle: no angle has sine 4.
  8. Solve sint=−12. The reference angle is π6, since sinπ6=12. Sine is negative in quadrants III and IV.This is a basic equation, solved by the reference angle and quadrant method: the reference angle gives the size, and the sign of sine picks the quadrants.
  9. Quadrant III: t=π+π6=7π6. Quadrant IV: t=2π−π6=11π6.In quadrant III you go half a turn, then the reference angle more; in quadrant IV you stop the reference angle short of a full turn. In sixths: 6π6 + π6 = 7π6 and 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
Answer
  • t=7π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check Put each angle into the original equation 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t = 4. At t = 7π6, sin t = −12, so the left side is 2·14 − 7·(−12) = 12 + 72 = 82 = 4, the right side. At t = 11π6, sin t is also −12, so the same arithmetic gives 4. A second way, by picture: on the unit circle the only points at height −12 are the two at 7π6 (quadrant III) and 11π6 (quadrant IV), and no point is at height 4.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 7

Already factored

Solve (sin t − 1)(sin t + 2) = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the product on the left equal 0.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θπ/2
Height 1 is the top of the circle, reached once per turn, at π2.
  1. Set each factor equal to 0: sint−1=0 or sint+2=0.This finds what sin t must be for the product to be 0. A product is 0 only when one of its factors is 0 (the zero-product rule), and the right side here is already 0.
  2. Solve each one for sin t: sint=1 or sint=−2.Add 1 to both sides of the first; subtract 2 from both sides of the second. Plug back in: with sin t = 1 the product is (0)(3) = 0, and with sin t = −2 it is (−3)(0) = 0.
  3. Throw out sint=−2.sin t is the height of a point on the unit circle, so it is never below −1. No angle has sine −2.
  4. Solve sint=1: height 1 is the top of the unit circle, the point (0, 1), a quarter turn from the start, so t=π2.Only one point of the circle sits at height 1, so this value gives one angle on one turn, not two.
Answer
t=π2
Double-check Put t = π2 back in: sin π2 = 1, so the left side is (1 − 1)(1 + 2) = 0·3 = 0. A second way: on the unit circle the only point at height 1 is the top, at π2, and no point is as low as −2, so no other angle can work.

Rung 2 of 7

A plain trinomial, one value thrown out

Solve cos2 t + 2 cos t − 3 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ0
The rightmost point, (1, 0), is the only point with x-coordinate 1, so cos t = 1 once per turn, at t = 0.
  1. Write u for cos t: u2+2u−3=0.cos2 t means (cos t)2, which is u2. The right side is already 0, so nothing has to move.
  2. Find two numbers that multiply to −3 and add to 2: they are 3 and −1. So u2+2u−3=(u+3)(u−1).3·(−1) = −3 and 3 + (−1) = 2. When u2 has no number in front, those two numbers go straight into the brackets. Multiply back to check: u2 − u + 3u − 3 = u2 + 2u − 3.
  3. Set each factor equal to 0: u+3=0 gives u=−3; u−1=0 gives u=1.This finds the values of u that make the product 0. Plug back in: (−3 + 3)(−3 − 1) = 0·(−4) = 0 and (1 + 3)(1 − 1) = 4·0 = 0.
  4. Put cosine back: cost=−3 or cost=1. Throw out cost=−3.cos t is the x-coordinate of a point on the unit circle, and no point of that circle lies left of −1.
  5. Solve cost=1: x-coordinate 1 belongs to the rightmost point of the circle, (1, 0), so t=0.Only one point is that far right. A full turn, 2π, lands on the same point, but [0, 2π) leaves 2π out, so 0 is the only answer on this turn.
Answer
t = 0
Double-check Put t = 0 back in: cos 0 = 1, so the left side is 12 + 2·1 − 3 = 1 + 2 − 3 = 0. A second way: on the unit circle only the rightmost point, (1, 0), has x-coordinate 1, and no point has x-coordinate −3, so t = 0 is the only angle. The thrown-out value does solve the quadratic, (−3)2 + 2·(−3) − 3 = 9 − 6 − 3 = 0; it is out only because of the circle.

Rung 3 of 7

No number term, so pull out a common factor

Solve 2 cos2 t + cos t = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.

Show the steps and the answer
π/22π/34π/33π/2π/2π3π/22π−11
The lines y = 0 and y = −12 each cross the graph of y = cos t twice on one turn: four answers in all.
  1. Write u for cos t: 2u2+u=0.Renaming shows the quadratic. There is no plain number term, so both terms contain u.
  2. Pull out the common factor u: u(2u+1)=0.Multiply back to check: u·2u + u·1 = 2u2 + u. Do not divide both sides by u instead: dividing by a number that might be 0 deletes the answers where it is 0.
  3. Set each factor equal to 0: u=0 or 2u+1=0, so u=0 or u=−12.This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u + 1 = 0, subtract 1 and divide by 2. Plug back in: u = 0 gives 0·(2·0 + 1) = 0·1 = 0, and u = −12 gives 2u + 1 = −1 + 1 = 0, so the product is 0.
  4. Put cosine back: cost=0 or cost=−12. Both lie from −1 to 1, so both stay.Neither value is below −1 or above 1.
  5. Solve cost=0: x-coordinate 0 means the top or the bottom of the circle, so t=π2 and t=3π2.The two points of the unit circle on the vertical axis are (0, 1) and (0, −1).
  6. Solve cost=−12: the reference angle is π3, since cosπ3=12. Cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so t=π−π3=2π3 and t=π+π3=4π3.The reference angle gives the size; the sign of cosine picks the quadrants. In thirds: 3π3 − π3 = 2π3 and 3π3 + π3 = 4π3.
  7. List the angles in order: π2,2π3,4π3,3π2.Both factors give angles, and the answer is all of them.
Answer
  • t=π2
  • t=2π3
  • t=4π3
  • t=3π2
Double-check At t = 2π3 and t = 4π3, cos t = −12, so 2·14 + (−12) = 12 − 12 = 0. At t = π2 and t = 3π2, cos t = 0, so 2·0 + 0 = 0. A second way, by picture: the line y = 0 and the line y = −12 each cross the graph of y = cos t twice on one turn, so four answers is the right count. Dividing by cos t at the start would have found only 2π3 and 4π3.

Rung 4 of 7

Move the terms first, with a 2 in front

Solve 2 sin2 t + 1 = 3 sin t for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes both sides equal.

Show the steps and the answer
π/6π/25π/6π/2π3π/22π−11
The line y = 12 crosses the graph of y = sin t twice and the line y = 1 touches it once: three answers.
  1. Subtract 3 sin t from both sides: 2 sin2t−3sint+1=0.The zero-product rule needs 0 on one side. Write the terms from the square down, the way a quadratic is written.
  2. Write u for sin t: 2u2−3u+1=0.Renaming shows the quadratic.
  3. Find two numbers that multiply to a·c=2·1=2 and add to −3: they are −2 and −1. Split the middle term: 2u2−2u−u+1.(−2)·(−1) = 2 and −2 + (−1) = −3. Splitting makes two pairs that share a factor.
  4. Group: 2u(u−1)−1(u−1)=(2u−1)(u−1).Both pairs contain (u − 1). Multiply back to check: 2u2 − 2u − u + 1 = 2u2 − 3u + 1.
  5. Set each factor equal to 0: 2u−1=0 gives u=12; u−1=0 gives u=1.This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u − 1 = 0, add 1 and divide by 2. Plug back in: u = 12 gives (2·12 − 1)(12 − 1) = 0·(−12) = 0, and u = 1 gives (2 − 1)(1 − 1) = 1·0 = 0.
  6. Put sine back: sint=12 or sint=1. Both lie from −1 to 1, so both stay.Nothing to throw out this time.
  7. Solve sint=12: the reference angle is π6; sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so t=π6 and t=π−π6=5π6.Two quadrants share a positive sine. In sixths: 6π6 − π6 = 5π6.
  8. Solve sint=1: only the top of the circle, t=π2.Height 1 is a single point of the circle.
  9. List in order: π6,π2,5π6.The answer is every angle from both factors.
Answer
  • t=π6
  • t=π2
  • t=5π6
Double-check Use the original equation, before anything moved. At t = π6, sin t = 12: left 2·14 + 1 = 32, right 3·12 = 32. At t = 5π6, sin t is also 12, so the sides match again. At t = π2, sin t = 1: left 2·1 + 1 = 3, right 3·1 = 3.

Rung 5 of 7

Tangent, where nothing is thrown out

Solve (tan t − 3)(tan t + 1) = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the product on the left equal 0.

Show the steps and the answer
π/33π/44π/37π/4π/2π3π/22π−22
The graph of y = tan t climbs to every height.
  1. Set each factor equal to 0: tant−3=0 or tant+1=0, so tant=3 or tant=−1.This finds what tan t must be for the product to be 0 (the zero-product rule). Plug back in: (3 − 3)(3 + 1) = 0 and (−1 − 3)(−1 + 1) = 0.
  2. Keep both values, even though 3≈1.73 is bigger than 1.The limit from −1 to 1 belongs to sine and cosine, the coordinates of a point on a circle of radius 1. Tangent is sin t ÷ cos t, and a quotient can be any number.
  3. Solve tant=3: the reference angle is π3, since tanπ3=32÷12=3. Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III, so t=π3 and t=π+π3=4π3.Dividing by 12 is the same as multiplying by 2. Tangent is positive where sine and cosine have the same sign.
  4. Solve tant=−1: the reference angle is π4, since tanπ4=1. Tangent is negative in quadrants II and IV, so t=π−π4=3π4 and t=2π−π4=7π4.Tangent is negative where sine and cosine have opposite signs. In fourths: 4π4 − π4 = 3π4 and 8π4 − π4 = 7π4.
  5. List in order: π3,3π4,4π3,7π4.The answer is every angle from both factors.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=3π4
  • t=4π3
  • t=7π4
Double-check At 4π3 the point is (−12, −32), so tan t = (−32) ÷ (−12) = 3 and the first factor is 0. At 7π4 the point is (22, −22), so tan t = −1 and the second factor is 0. A second way: the two answers for each value are exactly π apart, 4π3 − π3 = π and 7π4 − 3π4 = π, as tangent's period of π says they must be.

Rung 6 of 7

A 4 in front, and a fraction out of range

Solve 4 cos2 t + 4 cos t − 3 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle on one turn that makes the left side 0.

Show the steps and the answer
π/35π/3π/2π3π/22π−2−11
The line y = −32 runs below the whole graph of y = cos t, so only y = 12 gives angles.
  1. Write u for cos t: 4u2+4u−3=0.Renaming shows the quadratic; the right side is already 0.
  2. Find two numbers that multiply to a·c=4·(−3)=−12 and add to 4: they are 6 and −2. Split the middle term: 4u2+6u−2u−3.The pairs that multiply to −12 are 1 and −12, 2 and −6, 3 and −4, 4 and −3, 6 and −2, 12 and −1. Only 6 and −2 add to 4.
  3. Group: 2u(2u+3)−1(2u+3)=(2u−1)(2u+3).Both pairs contain (2u + 3). Multiply back to check: 4u2 + 6u − 2u − 3 = 4u2 + 4u − 3.
  4. Set each factor equal to 0: 2u−1=0 gives u=12; 2u+3=0 gives u=−32.This finds the values of u that make the product 0. For 2u + 3 = 0, subtract 3, then divide by 2. Plug back in: when u = 12, 2u = 1 and the product is (1 − 1)(1 + 3) = 0; when u = −32, 2u = −3 and it is (−3 − 1)(−3 + 3) = 0.
  5. Put cosine back: cost=12 or cost=−32. Throw out cost=−32.−32 is −1.5, and −1.5 < −1. A fraction can still be out of range: no point of the unit circle is that far left.
  6. Solve cost=12: the reference angle is π3; cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t=π3 and t=2π−π3=5π3.Two quadrants share a positive cosine. In thirds: 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=5π3
Double-check At t = π3, cos t = 12: 4·14 + 4·12 − 3 = 1 + 2 − 3 = 0. At t = 5π3, cos t is also 12, so the same arithmetic gives 0. A second way, by picture: the line y = 12 crosses the graph of y = cos t exactly twice on one turn, and the line y = −32 runs below the whole graph. The thrown-out value does solve the quadratic, 4·94 + 4·(−32) − 3 = 9 − 6 − 3 = 0; it is out only because no angle has cosine −1.5.

Rung 7 of 7

A doubled angle inside the quadratic

Solve 2 cos2 2t − 5 cos 2t + 2 = 0 for every t in [0, 2π). In plain words: find every angle t on one turn that makes the left side 0, where each cosine is taken of the doubled angle 2t.

Show the steps and the answer
π/65π/67π/611π/6π/2π3π/22π−112
y = cos 2t makes two full waves while t makes one turn.
  1. Write u for cos 2t: 2u2−5u+2=0.The same cos 2t appears in both places, so one letter can stand for it. cos2 2t means (cos 2t)2.
  2. Find two numbers that multiply to a·c=2·2=4 and add to −5: they are −4 and −1. Split and group: 2u2−4u−u+2=2u(u−2)−1(u−2)=(2u−1)(u−2).(−4)·(−1) = 4 and −4 + (−1) = −5. Multiply back to check: 2u2 − 4u − u + 2 = 2u2 − 5u + 2.
  3. Set each factor equal to 0: 2u−1=0 gives u=12; u−2=0 gives u=2.This finds the values of u that make the product 0. Plug back in: u = 12 gives (2·12 − 1)(12 − 2) = 0·(−32) = 0, and u = 2 gives (4 − 1)(2 − 2) = 3·0 = 0.
  4. Put cosine back: cos2t=12 or cos2t=2. Throw out cos2t=2.A cosine is never above 1, whatever angle sits inside it.
  5. Widen the interval: as t runs over [0,2π), 2t runs over [0,4π), two full turns.Doubling every t doubles both ends of the interval, as in the lesson on multiple angles.
  6. Solve cos2t=12 for 2t on [0,4π): the first turn gives 2t=π3 and 2t=5π3; adding a full turn, 2π=6π3, gives 2t=7π3 and 2t=11π3.The reference angle is π3, cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, and cosine repeats every full turn.
  7. Divide each by 2: t=π6,5π6,7π6,11π6.Dividing a fraction by 2 doubles its bottom: 7π3 ÷ 2 = 7π6. All four are less than 2π = 12π6, so all four lie on one turn.
Answer
  • t=π6
  • t=5π6
  • t=7π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check At t = 7π6, 2t = 7π3, one full turn plus π3, so cos 2t = 12 and 2·14 − 5·12 + 2 = 12 − 52 + 2 = 0. A second way, by counting: one kept value gives two angles per turn, and 2t makes two turns, so there must be 2·2 = 4 answers, which matches the list.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Keeping sin t = 4 from 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0 and looking for an angle whose sine is 4.
u = 4 does make the quadratic 0 (2·16 − 7·4 − 4 = 32 − 28 − 4 = 0), but sin t is the height of a point on a circle of radius 1. No point on that circle is at height 4, so no angle has sine 4.
✓ Instead: Write 'no angle' beside sin t = 4 and solve only sin t = −12, which gives t = 7π6 and t = 11π6.
✗ Not this: Factoring 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t = 4 as sin t (2 sin t − 7) = 4 and setting each factor equal to 4.
The zero-product rule works only for 0. Two numbers can multiply to 4 without either one being 4: 8 × 12 = 4. Here the wrong move gives sin t = 4 or sin t = 112, both impossible, and the false verdict that nothing solves the equation.
✓ Instead: Subtract 4 first: 2 sin2 t − 7 sin t − 4 = 0, which factors as (2 sin t + 1)(sin t − 4) = 0 and gives the real answers 7π6 and 11π6.
✗ Not this: Solving 2 sin2 t = sin t by dividing both sides by sin t, which leaves 2 sin t = 1, so sin t = 12 and t = π6 or 5π6.
Dividing by sin t is not allowed when sin t = 0, and those are exactly angles that work: at t = 0 and t = π, sin t = 0, so the left side is 2·02 = 0 and the right side is 0. Dividing throws them away without a trace.
✓ Instead: Move everything to one side and pull out the common factor: 2 sin2 t − sin t = 0, so sin t (2 sin t − 1) = 0. Then sin t = 0 gives 0 and π, and sin t = 12 gives π6 and 5π6: four answers, 0, π6, 5π6 and π.
✗ Not this: Throwing out tan t = 3 because 3 ≈ 1.73 is bigger than 1.
The limit from −1 to 1 comes from the unit circle and belongs to sine and cosine only. Tangent is sin t ÷ cos t, and a quotient can be any number: at π3 it is 32 ÷ 12 = 3.
✓ Instead: Keep every value of tan t. tan t = 3 gives t = π3 and t = 4π3 on one turn.
✗ Not this: Keeping cos t = −32 because a fraction looks small.
−32 is −1.5, and −1.5 < −1. No point of the unit circle is farther left than −1, so no angle has cosine −32.
✓ Instead: Compare each value with −1 and 1, as a decimal if that helps: −32 = −1.5 is out, 12 = 0.5 is in. In 4 cos2 t + 4 cos t − 3 = 0 only cos t = 12 survives, giving π3 and 5π3.
✗ Not this: Reading sin2 t as sin(t2), the sine of the angle squared.
The small 2 after sin squares the sine's output, not the angle. sin2(π6) = (12)2 = 14, which is not the sine of the angle (π6)2.
✓ Instead: Read sin2 t as (sin t)2. That is exactly why writing u for sin t turns sin2 t into u2.

Tips and tricks

  • Write u = sin t at the top of your work. The letter u is a nickname: when the algebra ends, put sin t back, because the answers must be angles.
  • Check the factoring before you go on: multiply the brackets back out and compare with the quadratic term by term.
  • Draw a box around each value of sine or cosine that lies from −1 to 1. Only boxed values go on to the unit circle. Turn a fraction into a decimal if that helps: −32 = −1.5 is out.
  • Count before you finish: on one turn each kept value of sine or cosine gives two angles, except 1 and −1, which give one each. Every kept value of tangent gives two.
  • Memory cue: find the sine, then the angle. The quadratic answers the first question; the unit circle answers the second.
  • Do not divide both sides by sin t, cos t or tan t to make an equation smaller: the division drops every angle where that function is 0. Pull it out as a common factor instead, so those answers stay in.
  • For the general solution of an equation in sin t, cos t or tan t, find each solution on one turn first, then add 2kπ to each one for sine and cosine (k any integer, such as −1, 0 or 2). For tangent, whose period is π, add kπ to each solution between 0 and π.

7 The trap

Stopping at the values of sin t. Factoring hands you numbers such as sin t = −12 and sin t = 4, not angles. Each number still needs two more steps: throw it out if it is below −1 or above 1, and otherwise turn it into every angle on one turn with that sine (one angle for 1 and −1, two for the others). Only those angles are the answers.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Factoring 2 cos2 t + cos t − 1 = 0 gives cos t = 12 or cos t = −1. Are you done?
  • No. Those are values of cos t, not angles. Both lie between −1 and 1, so each one still has to become angles on [0, 2π).
  • cos t = 12: reference angle π3, and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t = π3 and t = 5π3.
  • cos t = −1: the lowest value cosine reaches, so only one angle has it, t = π.
Solving the quadratic in u gives u = 3 or u = −1. What do you keep if u stands for sin t? If u stands for tan t?
  • For sin t: keep only sin t = −1, which gives t = 3π2. Throw out sin t = 3: sin t is the height of a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1, and no seat is ever more than 1 above the center.
  • For tan t: keep both. tan t = sintcost, and when cos t is close to 0 that fraction can be as large as you like, positive or negative. Only sine and cosine are stuck between −1 and 1.
Why does sin t = −12 give two angles on [0, 2π), but sin t = 1 only one?
  • sin t is the height of a seat on a Ferris wheel of radius 1. In one turn the seat passes every height between the bottom and the top twice, once on the left half and once on the right: height −12 comes at t = 7π6 and t = 11π6.
  • Height 1 is the very top seat, where the right and left halves meet, so it comes only once, at t = π2.
Solve 2 sin2 t = −sin t on [0, 2π).
  • Get 0 on one side, which the zero-product rule needs: 2 sin2 t + sin t = 0. Writing u for sin t gives 2u2 + u = 0.
  • There is no plain number term, so pull out the common factor: u(2u + 1) = 0. That gives sin t = 0 or sin t = −12.
  • sin t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π; sin t = −12 gives t = 7π6 and t = 11π6.

Lesson 6 of 8

Rewriting with an identity first

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: What sin²t meansLeans on: Why sin²t + cos²t = 1Leans on: Tangent is sine over cosineLeans on: Dividing by a fractionLeans on: Doing the same to both sidesLeans on: No dividing by zeroLeans on: DistributingLeans on: Factoring out a common factorLeans on: The zero-product ruleLeans on: Sine and cosine stay in [−1, 1]Leans on: Angles from a reference angleOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Picture a wallet with dollars and euros, and a bill to pay in dollars. You cannot pay with the money as it is. First you change the euros into dollars at a fixed rate, and now there is one kind of money to count. A trigonometric equation with both sin t and cos t is that wallet. Your methods so far handle one trigonometric function at a time. So you convert first, with an identity: a fact true at every angle, like a rate that never changes. The identity sin2t + cos2t = 1 trades cos2t for 1 − sin2t. When one sin t faces one cos t, dividing by cos t turns the pair into tan t, as long as cos t is not 0.

2 Picture it

sin2t+cos2t=1

sin2t=1−cos2t

cos2t=1−sin2t

Keep the lonely one, swap the squared one.

tan t = sintcost where cos t ≠ 0

Before dividing by cos t, test where cos t = 0: π2 and 3π2 on one turn.

Same function in every term: factor, do not divide.

Check every answer in the original.

Reminder

Reminder: What sin2t means, Why sin2t + cos2t = 1, Tangent is sine over cosine, Dividing by a fraction, Doing the same to both sides, No dividing by zero, Distributing, Factoring out a common factor, The zero-product rule, Sine and cosine stay in [−1, 1], Angles from a reference angle
  • What sin2t means. sin2t is (sin t)2: find the sine, then square it. At t = 7π6, sin t = −12, so sin2t = 14.
  • Why sin2t + cos2t = 1. The point (cos t, sin t) is on the circle of radius 1, so the Pythagorean theorem gives cos2t + sin2t = 1. At t = π3: 14 + 34 = 1.
  • Tangent is sine over cosine. tan t = sintcost. At t = π3: 32 ÷ 12 = 3.
  • Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: 12 ÷ 32 = 12 × 23 = 13, the same number as 33.
  • Doing the same to both sides. An equation stays balanced when both sides get the same move: subtract 3 from both sides of x + 3 = 5 to get x = 2, or multiply both sides of −2u2 + u = 0 by −1 to get 2u2 − u = 0. The one move never allowed is dividing by 0.
  • No dividing by zero. 6 ÷ 0 has no answer. cos t = 0 at t = π2 and t = 3π2; sin t = 0 at t = 0 and t = π.
  • Distributing. A number in front of parentheses multiplies every term inside: 2(1 − cos2t) = 2 − 2 cos2t.
  • Factoring out a common factor. Pull out what every term shares: 2u2 − u = u(2u − 1). Multiply back to check: u·2u − u·1 = 2u2 − u.
  • The zero-product rule. If A·B = 0, then A = 0 or B = 0, and it needs a zero on one side: (2u − 1)(u − 2) = 0 gives u = 12 or u = 2.
  • Sine and cosine stay in [−1, 1]. Both are coordinates of a point that sits on the unit circle, whose radius is 1, so no angle has cos t = 2: throw it out.
  • Angles from a reference angle. Quadrant I: α; II: π − α; III: π + α; IV: 2π − α. Sine is positive in I and II, cosine in I and IV, tangent in I and III (All Students Take Calculus). With α = π6: π6, 5π6, 7π6, 11π6.

3 Why

Your earlier methods work because one trigonometric function can act as a single unknown, like u. With sin t and cos t together there are two unknowns. The identity removes one without changing the answers: the point (cos t, sin t) sits on a circle of radius 1, so the Pythagorean theorem makes cos2t + sin2t = 1 at every angle, and trading cos2t for 1 − sin2t cannot change whether the equation is true. Dividing by cos t is safe except where cos t = 0, since nothing can be divided by zero, so t = π2 and t = 3π2 are tested by hand.

4 The rule

sin2t+cos2t=1 at every angle, so sin2t=1−cos2t and cos2t=1−sin2t: replace the squared function and keep the lonely one.

Where cost≠0,sintcost=tant, so sint=cost becomes tant=1, and a·sint=b·cost (a≠0) becomes tant=ba. First test t=π2 and t=3π2 in the original, because a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Rewrite first: trade the squared function using sine squared plus cosine squared equals one, or divide sine by cosine to get tangent, so only one trig function is left.

Write it

Before solving a trigonometric equation that contains both sin t and cos t, rewrite it with an identity so that only one trigonometric function of t remains, then solve that equation.

In math
  • sin2t+cos2t=1
  • sin2t=1−cos2t
  • cos2t=1−sin2t
  • tan t = sintcost where cos t ≠ 0
  • a·sin t = b·cos t becomes tan t = ba (a ≠ 0)
  • sin t = cos t becomes tan t = 1 (no solution has cos t = 0), so t = π4 or t = 5π4 on [0, 2π)
Like

Like a recipe that lists flour in cups and in tablespoons: change the tablespoons into cups (16 tablespoons make 1 cup) before you add, and the amount of flour stays the same.

See it
x = cos θy = sin θP
Even where cos t is negative, the legs squared add to 1: (−12)2 + (32)2 = 14 + 34 = 1.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Put the point P for the angle t on the unit circle and drop a line from P straight to the x-axis. Away from the axes you get a right triangle: the flat leg has length |cos t|, the upright leg has length |sin t|, and the slanted side is the radius, 1. The Pythagorean theorem says leg2 + leg2 = slanted side2, and a square is the same with or without the sign, so cos2t + sin2t = 1. On an axis the triangle flattens, and the identity still holds there: one of cos t and sin t is 0 and the other is 1 or −1. That is why knowing cos t pins down sin2t: the two squares share the 1 between them.

θcos tsin t1
For an angle t in quadrant I the legs are cos t and sin t, with slanted side 1.
As a slope

tan t = sintcost is the height of P divided by its x coordinate: rise over run, the steepness of the radius. sin t = cos t says P is exactly as high as it is far to the right, like a ramp that climbs 1 foot for every foot forward. That ramp has slope 1, so tan t = 1. On the circle this happens at 45°, which is π4, and on the opposite side at 225°, which is 5π4, where both coordinates are negative and their quotient is again 1. Where cos t = 0 the radius stands straight up or down, a ramp with no run and no slope at all, and that is the angle a division by cos t cannot handle.

x = cos θy = sin θP
At 45° the two legs are equal, so sin t = cos t there and the slope tan t is 1.
With small numbers

Try the swap at t = π6: cos2t = (32)2 = 34, and 1 − sin2t = 1 − 14 = 34. Same number, so putting one in place of the other cannot change whether an equation is true. Now try dividing at t = π2: sin t = 1 and cos t = 0, and 1 ÷ 0 has no answer. Tangent does not exist there, so a solution sitting at π2 or 3π2 would vanish in a division. That is why those two angles are tested first.

6 ÷ 3 = 26 ÷ 2 = 36 ÷ 1 = 66 ÷ 0 = ?0 groups: nowhere to put them, so no answer
Sharing 6 among 0 groups has no answer; dividing by cos t fails the same way where cos t = 0.
As a rule of thumb

Keep the lonely one, swap the squared one. If an equation has cos2t and a lone sin t, it will end up in sine; if it has sin2t and a lone cos t, it ends up in cosine. If one sin t faces one cos t, knock on the doors at π2 and 3π2, then divide to get tan t. If the same function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.

5 How

  1. Say what the equation asks: every solution on one turn, each t in [0, 2π) that makes the two sides equal.
  2. Rewrite with an identity until one trigonometric function of t is left; the strategy in this lesson says which identity. Write each swap inside parentheses.
  3. If you divide by cos t, first put t = π2 and t = 3π2 into the original equation and keep any that work.
  4. Get a 0 on one side. If the equation is a quadratic in the function or has a common factor, factor it, treating the function as a single unknown.
  5. Solve each piece with the reference angle and the quadrants. Throw out any value of sine or cosine outside [−1, 1].
  6. Put every answer into the original equation, not the rewritten one.

Choosing the identity that leaves one function

1
Is only one trigonometric function of t in the equation?
YesSolve it with the reference angle and the quadrants, factoring first if it is a quadratic.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is the same function a factor of every term, like cos t in 2 sin t cos t = cos t?
YesDo not divide. Move every term to one side, factor that function out, and solve each factor.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Is one function squared while the other appears alone?
YesSwap the squared one: sin2t = 1 − cos2t or cos2t = 1 − sin2t, in parentheses.
NoGo on.
↓
4
Are both functions squared, with neither appearing alone?
YesSwap either one; then every term uses the same function.
NoGo on.
↓
5
Is it one sine term against one cosine term, like a·sin t = b·cos t with neither a nor b equal to 0?
YesTest t = π2 and t = 3π2 in the original and keep any that work. Then divide both sides by a·cos t to get tan t = ba.
NoNeither move of this lesson fits. Do not force a swap on a lone sin t or cos t.
  1. Circle every trigonometric function in the equation and note its power: squared, like cos2t, or alone, like sin t.
  2. If the same function is a factor of every term, do not divide by it: move every term to one side and factor it out.
  3. If one function is squared and the other is alone, keep the lonely one and swap the squared one with the identity, in parentheses.
  4. If both are squared and neither is alone, swap either one.
  5. If one sin t term faces one cos t term, test t = π2 and t = 3π2 in the original, then divide by cos t to reach tan t.
  6. Solve the one-function equation with the earlier methods, then check every answer in the original.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Swap the squared sine, then factor

Solve 2 sin2t + 5 cos t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At π3, which is 60°, the point sits 12 to the right of center: cos t = 12.
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 5π3, which is 300°, the point is the mirror image below the x-axis, with the same cos t = 12.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle t on one turn, from 0 up to but not including 2π, that makes 2 sin2t+5cost equal to 4.Solving a trigonometric equation on one turn means finding all such angles, not only one.
  2. Spot the two functions: sin2t is squared, and cos t stands alone.The methods you have need one function. The lonely one, cosine, is the one to keep, so the squared sine is the one to trade.
  3. Replace sin2t with (1−cos2t): 2(1−cos2t)+5cost=4.Subtracting cos2t from both sides of sin2t + cos2t = 1 gives sin2t = 1 − cos2t at every angle, so the swap changes no answer. The parentheses keep the 2 on both pieces.
  4. Multiply out: 2−2cos2t+5cost=4.The 2 multiplies both the 1 and the −cos2t.
  5. Subtract 4 from both sides: −2cos2t+5cost−2=0.The zero-product rule needs a zero on one side, and 2 − 4 = −2.
  6. Multiply both sides by −1: 2 cos2t−5cost+2=0.Every sign flips and 0 stays 0, so the solutions do not change, and a positive first term is friendlier to factor.
  7. Write u for cos t: 2u2−5u+2=0. Factor it: (2u−1)(u−2)=0.This is a quadratic in cos t, like the ones in the last lesson. Multiply back to check: 2u2 − 4u − u + 2 = 2u2 − 5u + 2.
  8. Set each factor to 0: 2u−1=0 gives u=12, and u−2=0 gives u=2.This finds the values of cos t that make a bracket zero, which makes the whole product zero. Plug back in: 2·12 − 1 = 0 and 2 − 2 = 0.
  9. So cost=12 or cost=2. Throw out cost=2.Cosine is the x coordinate of a point on a circle of radius 1, so it is never larger than 1. No angle has cos t = 2.
  10. Solve cost=12: the reference angle is π3, and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t=π3 and t=2π−π3=5π3.cos π3 = 12. In quadrant IV the angle is a full turn minus the reference angle: 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=5π3
Double-check Put each answer into the original equation. At t = π3: sin t = 32, so sin2t = 34 and 2 sin2t = 32; cos t = 12, so 5 cos t = 52; and 32 + 52 = 82 = 4. At t = 5π3: sin t = −32, whose square is again 34, and cos t = 12 again, so the total is 4 again. Both work. An angle off the list fails: at t = π, 2·0 + 5·(−1) = −5, not 4.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

Rung 1: one sine against one cosine

Solve sin t = 3 cos t for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III, where sine and cosine have the same sign.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where sin t, the height of the point, equals 3 times cos t, its x coordinate.On the unit circle, cos t and sin t are the two coordinates of the point for the angle t.
  2. Test where cost=0. At t=π2 the left side is 1 and the right side is 3·0=0. At t=3π2 the left side is −1 and the right side is 0. Neither works.We are about to divide by cos t, which is not allowed where cos t = 0, so those two angles are checked by hand. At the top and bottom of the circle sin t is 1 or −1, never 0, so dividing loses nothing.
  3. Divide both sides by cos t: sintcost=3, that is, tant=3.tan t means sintcost, so now only one function is left.
  4. Find the reference angle: tanπ3=32÷12=3, so it is π3.Dividing by 12 is multiplying by 2, and 32 × 2 = 3.
  5. Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III: t=π3 and t=π+π3=4π3.In quadrant III both coordinates are negative, and a negative divided by a negative is positive. π + π3 = 3π3 + π3 = 4π3.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=4π3
Double-check At t = π3: sin t = 32 and 3 cos t = 3·12 = 32. At t = 4π3: sin t = −32 and 3 cos t = 3·(−12) = −32. The sides match both times. The two answers are also exactly π apart, as tangent's answers on one turn always are, because its period is half a turn.

Rung 2 of 6

Rung 2: move a term first, and the tangent comes out negative

Solve 3 sin t + cos t = 0 for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 150° the point is 12 up and 32 to the left, so 3·sin t and cos t cancel.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn that makes 3sint+cost equal to 0.Solving means finding all the angles that make the equation true.
  2. Subtract cos t from both sides: 3sint=−cost.Now one sine term faces one cosine term, the shape that turns into tangent.
  3. Test where cost=0. At t=π2: 3·1+0=3, not 0. At t=3π2: 3·(−1)+0=−3, not 0.These are the only angles a division by cos t could lose. Neither is a solution, so dividing is safe.
  4. Divide both sides by 3cost: tant=−13.On the left, 3 sin t ÷ (3 cos t) leaves sintcost, which is tan t. On the right, −cos t ÷ (3 cos t) leaves −13.
  5. Find the reference angle: tanπ6=12÷32=13, so it is π6.Dividing by 32 is multiplying by 23, and the 2s cancel. 13 is the same number as 33, the form your table may show.
  6. Tangent is negative in quadrants II and IV: t=π−π6=5π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.There sine and cosine have opposite signs, so their quotient is negative. 6π6 − π6 = 5π6 and 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
Answer
  • t=5π6
  • t=11π6
Double-check At t = 5π6: sin t = 12 and cos t = −32, so 3·12 − 32 = 0. At t = 11π6: sin t = −12 and cos t = 32, so −32 + 32 = 0. Both work, and they sit π apart, as tangent's answers should.

Rung 3 of 6

Rung 3: the swap, then a common factor

Solve 2 cos2t + sin t = 2 for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 30° the height is 12 and cos t = 32, so 2 cos2t + sin t = 2·34 + 12 = 2.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn that makes 2 cos2t+sint equal to 2.Every such angle is a solution on one turn, and we want them all.
  2. cos2t is squared and sin t is alone, so keep sine and replace cos2t with (1−sin2t): 2(1−sin2t)+sint=2.Subtracting sin2t from both sides of sin2t + cos2t = 1 gives cos2t = 1 − sin2t at every angle, so the answers do not change.
  3. Multiply out: 2−2sin2t+sint=2.The 2 multiplies both pieces inside the parentheses.
  4. Subtract 2 from both sides: −2sin2t+sint=0. Multiply by −1: 2 sin2t−sint=0.The zero-product rule needs a zero on one side, and multiplying by −1 keeps the same solutions.
  5. Pull out the common factor sin t: sin t (2sint−1)=0.Both terms contain sin t. Multiply back to check: sin t·2 sin t − sin t·1 = 2 sin2t − sin t.
  6. Set each factor to 0: sint=0, or 2sint−1=0, which gives sint=12.This finds the values of sine that make one factor zero. For the second, add 1 and divide by 2; plug back in: 2·12 − 1 = 0.
  7. sint=0 at t=0 and t=π.The height is 0 at the right and left ends of the circle. 2π is the same point as 0 and is not in [0, 2π).
  8. sint=12: the reference angle is π6, and sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so t=π6 and t=π−π6=5π6.sin π6 = 12, and the quadrant II angle is half a turn minus the reference angle.
Answer
  • t = 0
  • t=π6
  • t=5π6
  • t = π
Double-check At t = 0: cos t = 1, so 2·1 + 0 = 2. At t = π: cos t = −1 and cos2t = 1, so 2·1 + 0 = 2. At t = π6: cos2t = 34, so 2·34 + 12 = 32 + 12 = 2. At t = 5π6: cos t = −32, so cos2t is 34 again and the total is 2 again. All four work.

Rung 4 of 6

Rung 4: the same function in every term, so factor instead of dividing

Solve 2 sin t cos t = 3 sin t for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 180° the height sin t is 0, so every term with sin t in it is 0 and the two sides match.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where 2 sin t cos t equals 3sint.Each such angle is a solution, and a division could hide some of them.
  2. Notice that sin t is a factor of both sides, and test where sint=0. At t=0: 2·0·1=0 and 3·0=0. At t=π: 2·0·(−1)=0 and 3·0=0. Both are solutions.Dividing by sin t is not allowed where sin t = 0, and here those angles are solutions, so a division would lose them. Factor instead.
  3. Subtract 3sint from both sides: 2sintcost−3sint=0.A zero on one side lets the zero-product rule work.
  4. Pull out sin t: sin t (2cost−3)=0.Both terms contain sin t. Multiply back to check: sin t·2 cos t − sin t·3 = 2 sin t cos t − 3 sin t.
  5. First factor: sint=0 at t=0 and t=π.These are the two angles found in the test, now found by the method.
  6. Second factor: 2cost−3=0 gives cost=32.This finds the value of cosine that makes the second factor zero: add 3, then divide by 2. Plug back in: 2·32 − 3 = 0.
  7. cost=32: the reference angle is π6, and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t=π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.cos π6 = 32, and 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
Answer
  • t = 0
  • t=π6
  • t = π
  • t=11π6
Double-check At t = 0 and t = π, sin t = 0, so both sides are 0. At t = π6: 2·12·32 = 32 and 3·12 = 32. At t = 11π6: 2·(−12)·32 = −32 and 3·(−12) = −32. All four work. Dividing by sin t would have left 2 cos t = 3, which finds only π6 and 11π6 and misses 0 and π.

Rung 5 of 6

Rung 5: the swap gives a full quadratic with three answers

Solve 2 cos2t = 3 sin t + 3 for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 270° the point is at the bottom of the circle: sin t = −1 and cos t = 0.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where 2 cos2t equals 3sint+3.All such angles are the solutions on one turn.
  2. Keep the lonely sine and replace cos2t with (1−sin2t): 2(1−sin2t)=3sint+3.cos2t = 1 − sin2t at every angle, so no answer changes, and afterward sine is the only function left.
  3. Multiply out: 2−2sin2t=3sint+3.The 2 multiplies both pieces inside the parentheses.
  4. Add 2 sin2t to both sides and subtract 2 from both sides: 0=2sin2t+3sint+1.Moving every term to the right leaves a zero on the left and keeps the squared term positive; 3 − 2 = 1.
  5. Write u for sin t and factor: 2u2+3u+1=(2u+1)(u+1).Multiply back to check: 2u·u + 2u·1 + 1·u + 1·1 = 2u2 + 3u + 1.
  6. Set each factor to 0: 2u+1=0 gives sint=−12, and u+1=0 gives sint=−1.This finds the values of sine that make each factor zero. Plug back in: 2·(−12) + 1 = 0 and −1 + 1 = 0. Both values lie in [−1, 1], so both stay.
  7. sint=−1 at t=3π2.The height is −1 only at the bottom of the circle.
  8. sint=−12: the reference angle is π6, and sine is negative in quadrants III and IV, so t=π+π6=7π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.Below the x-axis the height is negative. 6π6 + π6 = 7π6 and 12π6 − π6 = 11π6.
Answer
  • t=7π6
  • t=3π2
  • t=11π6
Double-check At t = 3π2: cos t = 0, so the left side is 0, and the right side is 3·(−1) + 3 = 0. At t = 7π6: cos t = −32, so 2 cos2t = 2·34 = 32, and the right side is 3·(−12) + 3 = −32 + 3 = 32. At t = 11π6: cos2t is 34 and sin t is −12 again, so both sides are 32. All three work.

Rung 6 of 6

Rung 6, genuinely hard: both functions squared, solved two ways

Solve sin2t = 3 cos2t for every t in [0, 2π).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 240° the point is 12 to the left and 32 down: sin2t = 34 and 3 cos2t = 3·14 = 34.
  1. Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where the square of the sine is 3 times the square of the cosine.Solving means finding all such angles.
  2. Both functions are squared, so either one can be swapped. Replace sin2t with (1−cos2t): 1−cos2t=3cos2t.sin2t = 1 − cos2t at every angle, and after the swap only cosine is left.
  3. Add cos2t to both sides: 1=4cos2t. Then subtract 1 from both sides and turn the equation around: 4 cos2t−1=0.This gathers the cos2t terms on one side and leaves a zero on the other.
  4. Write u for cos t and factor: 4u2−1=(2u−1)(2u+1).Multiply back to check: 4u2 + 2u − 2u − 1 = 4u2 − 1, since the middle terms cancel.
  5. Set each factor to 0: 2u−1=0 gives cost=12, and 2u+1=0 gives cost=−12.This finds the values of cosine that make each factor zero. Plug back in: 2·12 − 1 = 0 and 2·(−12) + 1 = 0.
  6. cost=12: the reference angle is π3, and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so t=π3 and t=2π−π3=5π3.cos π3 = 12, and 6π3 − π3 = 5π3.
  7. cost=−12: the reference angle is again π3, and cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so t=π−π3=2π3 and t=π+π3=4π3.Left of the y-axis the x coordinate is negative. 3π3 − π3 = 2π3 and 3π3 + π3 = 4π3.
Answer
  • t=π3
  • t=2π3
  • t=4π3
  • t=5π3
Double-check Solve it the other way, with tangent. Where cos t = 0, at t = π2 and t = 3π2, sin2t = 1 but 3 cos2t = 0, so dividing by cos2t loses nothing. Dividing gives tan2t = 3, because sin2tcos2t is (sintcost)2. Then tan2t − 3 = (tan t − 3)(tan t + 3) = 0 (multiply back: tan2t + 3 tan t − 3 tan t − 3), so tan t = 3 gives π3 and 4π3, and tan t = −3 gives 2π3 and 5π3. The same four angles. A spot check at t = 2π3: sin2t = 34 and 3 cos2t = 3·14 = 34.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Solving 2 sin t cos t = cos t by dividing both sides by cos t: 2 sin t = 1, so sin t = 12, and the answers are π6 and 5π6.
Dividing by cos t is not allowed where cos t = 0. At t = π2 and t = 3π2, cos t = 0 and both sides equal 0, so those angles are solutions, and the division threw them away without any warning.
✓ Instead: Move every term to one side and factor: 2 sin t cos t − cos t = 0, so cos t (2 sin t − 1) = 0. Then cos t = 0 gives π2 and 3π2, and sin t = 12 gives π6 and 5π6: four solutions.
✗ Not this: Using the identity on a lone sine: replacing sin t with 1 − cos t.
The identity is about squares, and without the squares it is false. At t = π, sin t = 0 but 1 − cos t = 1 − (−1) = 2.
✓ Instead: Swap only a squared function: sin2t = 1 − cos2t or cos2t = 1 − sin2t. A lone sin t stays as it is; it tells you which function to keep.
✗ Not this: Writing 2 cos2t as 2 − sin2t.
The 2 multiplies all of cos2t, so it must multiply all of 1 − sin2t. At t = π2, 2 cos2t = 2·0 = 0, but 2 − sin2t = 2 − 1 = 1.
✓ Instead: Put the swap in parentheses first: 2 cos2t = 2(1 − sin2t) = 2 − 2 sin2t. At t = π2 this gives 2 − 2 = 0, which matches.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: keep the lonely one, swap the squared one. The function that appears without a square is the one the equation will end up in.
  • Test a swap at one angle: the old form and the new form must give the same number. If you kept cosine, use t = 0, where cos t = 1; if you kept sine, use t = π2, where sin t = 1. For 2 sin2t + 5 cos t at t = 0, the old form gives 0 + 5 = 5 and the new form 2 − 2 cos2t + 5 cos t gives 2 − 2 + 5 = 5.
  • Before you divide by cos t, knock on two doors: put t = π2 and t = 3π2 into the original equation. Any that works stays in the answer list. Dividing by sin t has the same two doors at t = 0 and t = π.
  • Tangent's answers on one turn come in pairs exactly π apart, because its period is half a turn: π3 and 4π3. The general solution of tan t = 3 is t = π3 + kπ for any integer k.
  • Check in the original equation, not the rewritten one. The original is the question you were asked, and checking there also catches a slip made while rewriting.

7 The trap

Dividing both sides by cos t, or by sin t, without testing where it is zero. Division by zero is not allowed, so every solution with cos t = 0, at t = π2 or t = 3π2, disappears without any warning; for sin t the angles are t = 0 and t = π. In 2 sin t cos t = cos t, a division loses π2 and 3π2. Test those angles in the original equation before dividing, and when the function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Why rewrite an equation that has both sin t and cos t with an identity before you solve it?
Your methods solve for one trigonometric function at a time, and sin t with cos t is two unknowns. An identity is true at every angle, so a swap with it removes one of the two and keeps the same solutions, like changing euros into dollars at a fixed rate so there is one kind of money to count.
In 2 sin2t + 3 cos t = 3, which function do you replace, and with what?
  • Replace sin2t with (1 − cos2t) and keep the lonely cos t, because the identity sin2t + cos2t = 1 trades a square for a square.
  • The parentheses make the 2 multiply both terms: 2(1 − cos2t) + 3 cos t = 3, and cosine is the only function left.
How do you solve sin t = 3 cos t on [0, 2π)?
  • First test t = π2 and t = 3π2, where cos t = 0, since a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions. There sin t is 1 or −1 while 3 cos t is 0, so neither works.
  • Then divide both sides by cos t: tan t = 3.
  • The reference angle is π3, and tangent is positive in quadrants I and III.
  • t=π3
  • t=4π3
In 2 sin t cos t = sin t on [0, 2π), why factor out sin t instead of dividing both sides by it?
  • Nothing can be divided by zero, so dividing by sin t throws away t = 0 and t = π, where sin t = 0, and both are solutions. Factoring keeps them:
  • 2 sin t cos t − sin t = 0, so sin t (2 cos t − 1) = 0
  • sin t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π
  • cos t = 12 gives t = π3 and t = 5π3

Lesson 7 of 8

Equations a calculator finishes

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Radians and degreesLeans on: Signs by quadrantLeans on: Principal valuesLeans on: One more full turnLeans on: Subtracting a negativeLeans on: Rounding to four decimal placesLeans on: Solving a linear equationLeans on: The periodOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Some trigonometric equations, like sin t = 0.4, do not land on a special angle, so no triangle or unit circle point you know gives the answer. A calculator helps, but it behaves like the operator of a Ferris wheel. Ask when your seat will be at a certain height, and the operator names one moment: the one on the way up. Your seat passes that same height again on the way down, and nobody mentions it. You work that moment out from the shape of the ride. In the same way, the calculator's inverse key hands you one angle, and the unit circle shows you where the second one hides. Last, you round the decimals once, at the very end.

2 Picture it

0.41152.7301π/2π3π/22π−110.41152.7301π/2π3π/22π−11
Plot the height sin t for one turn.

Reminder

Reminder: Radians and degrees, Signs by quadrant, Principal values, One more full turn, Subtracting a negative, Rounding to four decimal places, Solving a linear equation, The period
  • Radians and degrees. 180° = π radians, so one radian is about 57.3°: 0.4115 radians ≈ 23.58°.
  • Signs by quadrant. All Students Take Calculus: all three are positive in Quadrant I, sine in II, tangent in III, cosine in IV. So sin t = 0.4 needs Quadrants I and II.
  • Principal values. arcsin and arctan return an angle from −π2 to π2; arccos returns one from 0 to π. So arcsin(−0.25) ≈ −0.2527 is negative, but arccos(−0.8) ≈ 2.4981 is not.
  • One more full turn. Adding 2π to an angle lands on the same point of the circle: −0.2527 + 6.2832 = 6.0305.
  • Subtracting a negative. Taking away a negative adds: 3.1416 − (−0.2527) = 3.1416 + 0.2527 = 3.3943.
  • Rounding to four decimal places. Look at the fifth digit after the point: 5 or more rounds the fourth digit up. 2.730075 becomes 2.7301, and 0.411516 becomes 0.4115.
  • Solving a linear equation. Undo the adding, then the multiplying: 3 tan t + 6 = 0 becomes 3 tan t = −6, then tan t = −2.
  • The period. Sine and cosine repeat every 2π and tangent every π: if t ≈ 2.0344 solves tan t = −2, so does 2.0344 + kπ for every integer k.

3 Why

A key can show only one number, so the calculator's makers had to pick one angle for each value. For arcsin they picked angles from −π2 to π2, the right half of the circle, because every height from −1 to 1 shows up there exactly once. Call that angle α. The other angle with the same sine sits on the left half at the same height: the mirror image across the vertical axis, the angle π − α. Rounding waits for the end because every rounded number carries a small error, and arithmetic on rounded numbers piles those errors up.

4 The rule

To find each solution on one turn [0,2π) of sint=c,cost=c or tant=c when c is not a special value (and −1≤c≤1 for sine and cosine): in radian mode, the inverse key gives α= arcsin c, arccos c or arctan c.

The second solution is π−α for sine, 2π−α for cosine and α+π for tangent. Add 2π to any negative answer. Round only at the end, usually to four decimal places, and write ≈.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

t is about zero point four one one five radians: the arcsine of zero point four, read off the inverse key.

Write it

On one turn, sin t = 0.4 has two solutions: the arcsine of 0.4, which is about 0.4115, and π minus that, which is about 2.7301.

In math
  • t = arcsin 0.4 ≈ 0.4115
  • t = sin−1(0.4) ≈ 0.4115, in radian mode
  • t = π − arcsin 0.4 ≈ 2.7301
  • {t | sin t = 0.4, 0 ≤ t < 2π} ≈ {0.4115, 2.7301}
Like

Like asking a Ferris wheel operator when your seat reaches a height: you are told the moment on the way up, and you find the moment on the way down yourself.

See it
x = cos θy = sin θα ≈ 0.4115
The calculator's angle: the point on the right half of the circle at height 0.4.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Draw the unit circle and the flat line at height 0.4. It cuts the circle twice, once on the right half and once on the left half. The inverse key answers only with angles from −π2 to π2, the right half of the circle, so it gives the right point, at angle α ≈ 0.4115. The left point is the mirror image across the vertical axis, at angle π − α ≈ 2.7301.

x = cos θy = sin θπ − α ≈ 2.7301
The mirror point on the left half, at the same height 0.4: the solution the inverse key never gives.
With numbers

Type sin(0.4115), then sin(2.7301): both come out as 0.4000 to four decimal places. Now type sin−1(0.4): only 0.411516846 comes back. Two angles in one turn have sine 0.4, but a key can return one number, so the second angle is your job.

Why it must be true

The point at angle α is (cos α, sin α). Flip it across the vertical axis: x changes sign and the height stays. The new point, (−cos α, sin α), is α short of a half turn, so its angle is π − α. Same height means same sine, so sin(π − α) = sin α.

As a rule of thumb

Calculator first, then the mirror: sine mirrors left to right (π − α), cosine mirrors top to bottom (2π − α), tangent jumps half a turn (α + π). A negative α from the inverse key is never below −π2, so adding 2π once brings it into the turn.

EquationThe inverse key gives αSecond solution on [0, 2π)The mirror behind it
sin t = carcsin c, from −π2 to π2π − α (when c is 1 or −1 there is no second solution: π − α lands on the same point as α)across the vertical axis: same height
cos t = carccos c, from 0 to π2π − α (when c is 1 or −1 there is no second solution: 2π − α lands on the same point as α)across the horizontal axis: same x
tan t = carctan c, between −π2 and π2α + πhalf a turn: same ratio yx
any of the threea negative α (from arcsin or arctan)not another solution: write α + 2π in place of α, the same point named inside [0, 2π)a full turn: same point

5 How

  1. Get the trig function alone: sin t = c, cos t = c or tan t = c.
  2. Look at c. A special value is solved exactly, with no calculator. For sine or cosine, a c above 1 or below −1 means no solution: stop.
  3. Put the calculator in radian mode.
  4. Press the inverse key (sin−1, cos−1 or tan−1) on c. Call the result α and keep every digit.
  5. Find the second solution: π − α for sine, 2π − α for cosine, α + π for tangent.
  6. If an answer is negative, add 2π to it so it lands in [0, 2π).
  7. Round each answer to four decimal places, write ≈, and put each one back into the equation to check.

Finishing a trig equation with the calculator

1
Is c a special value? For sine and cosine: 0, 12, 22, 32, 1 or one of their negatives. For tangent: 0, 33, 1, 3 or one of their negatives.
YesSolve exactly with the reference angle and the quadrants. No calculator.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is it sine or cosine, with c above 1 or below −1?
YesStop: no solution. A point on the unit circle never goes past 1 or −1.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Is the calculator in radian mode (often shown as RAD on the screen)?
YesPress the inverse key on c and call the result α.
NoSwitch to radian mode first, or α comes out in degrees.
↓
4
Is the equation in sine?
YesSecond solution: π − α.
NoGo on.
↓
5
Is the equation in cosine?
YesSecond solution: 2π − α.
NoIt is tangent. Second solution: α + π.
↓
6
Is either answer negative?
YesAdd 2π to it.
NoRound to four decimal places and check.
  1. Get sin t, cos t or tan t alone, equal to a number c.
  2. Use the map below to decide whether the calculator is needed at all.
  3. In radian mode, press the inverse key on c. Call the result α and keep every digit.
  4. Find the second solution with the mirror for that function.
  5. Add 2π to any negative answer.
  6. Round to four decimal places at the end, write ≈, and put each answer back into the original equation.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Solving sin t = 0.4 with the inverse key

Solve sin t = 0.4 for 0 ≤ t < 2π, rounded to four decimal places. In plain words: the sine of the angle, the height of its point on the unit circle, is 0.4; find every angle in one turn with that height.

Show the steps and the answer

sin−1 0.4 ≈ 0.411516846 (Quadrant I)

π − 0.411516846 ≈ 2.730075808 (Quadrant II)

Round last: t ≈ 0.4115 and t ≈ 2.7301

Check: 0.4115 + 2.7301 = 3.1416 ≈ π

  1. Look at 0.4. The special sines are 0, 12,22≈0.7071,32≈0.8660, 1 and their negatives. 0.4 is none of them, and it lies between −1 and 1.A special value would be solved exactly, and a value outside [−1, 1] would have no solution. Neither happens, so answers exist and the calculator is needed.
  2. Sine is positive here, so expect two answers: one in Quadrant I and one in Quadrant II.All Students Take Calculus: sine is positive in Quadrants I and II only.
  3. In radian mode, press sin−1 0.4. The screen shows 0.411516846 (some calculators show more digits). Call it α and keep every digit.The inverse key returns the one angle from −π2 to π2 whose sine is 0.4. It is between 0 and 1.5708, so it is the Quadrant I answer.
  4. Second solution: π−α≈3.141592654−0.411516846=2.730075808.Mirroring the point across the vertical axis keeps its height at 0.4 and gives the angle π − α. The result is between 1.5708 and 3.1416, so it is in Quadrant II, as expected.
  5. Round both to four decimal places: 0.411516846 becomes 0.4115, and 2.730075808 becomes 2.7301.Rounding once, at the end, keeps the error in the last digit. The fifth digits after the point are 1 and 7, so the first stays and the second rounds up.
Answer
  • t ≈ 0.4115
  • t ≈ 2.7301
  • (both rounded to four decimal places)
Double-check Put each answer back: sin(0.4115) ≈ 0.39998 and sin(2.7301) ≈ 0.39998, both 0.4000 to four decimal places. Second way: the two points are mirror images across the vertical axis, so the first answer is as far past 0 as the second is short of π. The two must add to π, and 0.4115 + 2.7301 = 3.1416 ≈ π.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 5

A positive cosine, cos t = 0.6

Solve cos t = 0.6 for 0 ≤ t < 2π, to four decimal places. In plain words: the x of the angle's point on the unit circle is 0.6; find every angle in one turn with that x.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ2π − α ≈ 5.3559
Cosine's mirror point sits below the horizontal axis, with the same x = 0.6.
  1. 0.6 is not a special cosine and lies between −1 and 1. Cosine is positive, so expect answers in Quadrants I and IV.The special cosines are 0, 12, 22 ≈ 0.7071, 32 ≈ 0.8660, 1 and their negatives; cosine is positive in Quadrants I and IV (All Students Take Calculus).
  2. Radian mode: cos−10.6≈0.927295218. Call it α and keep every digit.arccos returns the angle from 0 to π with cosine 0.6. It is below 1.5708, so it is the Quadrant I answer.
  3. Second solution: 2π−α≈6.283185307−0.927295218=5.355890089.Mirroring across the horizontal axis keeps x = 0.6, and the result is between 4.7124 and 6.2832, in Quadrant IV.
  4. Round: 0.9273 and 5.3559.Four decimal places, once, at the end.
Answer
  • t ≈ 0.9273
  • t ≈ 5.3559
Double-check cos(0.9273) ≈ 0.6000 and cos(5.3559) ≈ 0.6000. Second way: the two points are mirror images across the horizontal axis, so the answers add to 2π: 0.9273 + 5.3559 = 6.2832 ≈ 2π.

Rung 2 of 5

A tangent, tan t = 2.5

Solve tan t = 2.5 for 0 ≤ t < 2π, to four decimal places. In plain words: the angle's point has y two and a half times its x; find every angle in one turn like that.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. 2.5 is not a special tangent. Tangent can be any number, so answers exist. Tangent is positive, so expect Quadrants I and III.The special tangents are 0, 33 ≈ 0.5774, 1, 3 ≈ 1.7321 and their negatives; unlike sine and cosine, tangent is not kept between −1 and 1.
  2. Radian mode: tan−12.5≈1.190289950. Call it α and keep every digit.arctan returns the angle between −π2 and π2 with tangent 2.5. It is below 1.5708, so it is the Quadrant I answer.
  3. Second solution: α+π≈1.190289950+3.141592654=4.331882604.Half a turn away, x and y both change sign, so the ratio yx is still 2.5. The result is between 3.1416 and 4.7124, in Quadrant III.
  4. Round: 1.1903 and 4.3319.Four decimal places at the end, and no earlier.
Answer
  • t ≈ 1.1903
  • t ≈ 4.3319
Double-check tan(1.1903) ≈ 2.5001 and tan(4.3319) ≈ 2.5001, both 2.500 when rounded to three decimal places; the tiny gap comes from rounding the angles. Second way: the two tangent answers differ by half a turn: 4.3319 − 1.1903 = 3.1416 ≈ π.

Rung 3 of 5

A negative sine, sin t = −0.25

Solve sin t = −0.25 for 0 ≤ t < 2π, to four decimal places. In plain words: the height of the angle's point is −0.25, a little below the center; find every angle in one turn at that height.

Show the steps and the answer
-14.48°345.52°same terminal side
The calculator's clockwise angle and the angle one full turn later end on the same side.
  1. −0.25 is between −1 and 1 and is not a special sine. Sine is negative, so expect answers in Quadrants III and IV.Sine is positive only in Quadrants I and II, so a negative sine lives in III and IV.
  2. Radian mode: sin−1(−0.25)≈−0.252680255. Call it α and keep every digit.arcsin returns an angle from −π2 to π2; a negative height gives a negative angle, a small clockwise turn into Quadrant IV.
  3. α is not in [0,2π), so add a full turn: α+2π≈−0.252680255+6.283185307=6.030505052.Adding 2π lands on the same point of the circle, now inside one counterclockwise turn. This is the Quadrant IV answer.
  4. Second solution: π−α≈3.141592654−(−0.252680255)=3.394272909.Sine's mirror is π − α even when α is negative. Subtracting a negative adds, and the result is between 3.1416 and 4.7124, in Quadrant III.
  5. Round and list from smallest to largest: 3.3943 and 6.0305.Four decimal places, once, at the end.
Answer
  • t ≈ 3.3943
  • t ≈ 6.0305
Double-check Second way, with the reference angle arcsin 0.25 ≈ 0.2527: Quadrant III gives π + 0.2527 ≈ 3.3943 and Quadrant IV gives 2π − 0.2527 ≈ 6.0305, the same two answers. Put back: sin(3.3943) ≈ −0.2500 and sin(6.0305) ≈ −0.2500.

Rung 4 of 5

A negative cosine, cos t = −0.8

Solve cos t = −0.8 for 0 ≤ t < 2π, to four decimal places. In plain words: the x of the angle's point is −0.8, on the left side; find every angle in one turn with that x.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. −0.8 is between −1 and 1 and is not a special cosine. Cosine is negative, so expect answers in Quadrants II and III.Cosine is positive only in Quadrants I and IV.
  2. Radian mode: cos−1(−0.8)≈2.498091545. Call it α and keep every digit.arccos returns an angle from 0 to π, never a negative one. For a negative cosine it lands between 1.5708 and 3.1416, in Quadrant II, so no 2π fix is needed.
  3. Second solution: 2π−α≈6.283185307−2.498091545=3.785093762.Cosine's mirror across the horizontal axis keeps x = −0.8. The result is between 3.1416 and 4.7124, in Quadrant III.
  4. Round: 2.4981 and 3.7851.Four decimal places, once, at the end.
Answer
  • t ≈ 2.4981
  • t ≈ 3.7851
Double-check The two cosine answers add to 2π: 2.4981 + 3.7851 = 6.2832 ≈ 2π. Second way, with the reference angle arccos 0.8 ≈ 0.6435: Quadrant II gives π − 0.6435 ≈ 2.4981 and Quadrant III gives π + 0.6435 ≈ 3.7851.

Rung 5 of 5

Rearrange first, then every solution, 3 tan t + 6 = 0

Solve 3 tan t + 6 = 0. Give each solution on one turn, 0 ≤ t < 2π, to four decimal places, then the general solution. In plain words: find the value tan t must have, then every angle with that tangent.

Show the steps and the answer
2.03445.1760π/2π3π/22π−4−224
Plot tan t for one turn: the flat line at −2 meets it twice, and the two meetings are π apart.
  1. Get tan t alone: subtract 6 from both sides, 3tant=−6, then divide by 3, tant=−2. Put it back: 3×(−2)+6=0.This finds the one value tan t must have, so the calculator method can start from tan t = c.
  2. −2 is not a special tangent. Tangent is negative, so expect answers in Quadrants II and IV.Tangent is positive in Quadrants I and III only.
  3. Radian mode: tan−1(−2)≈−1.107148718. Call it α and keep every digit.arctan returns an angle between −π2 and π2; a negative tangent gives a negative angle, in Quadrant IV.
  4. Second solution: α+π≈−1.107148718+3.141592654=2.034443936.Half a turn away, x and y both change sign and the ratio stays −2. The result is between 1.5708 and 3.1416, in Quadrant II.
  5. α is negative, so add 2π: α+2π≈−1.107148718+6.283185307=5.176036589.A full turn lands on the same point, now inside one turn, between 4.7124 and 6.2832 in Quadrant IV.
  6. The general solution, every solution at once: t≈2.0344+kπ, where k is any integer (0,1,−1,2,−2 and so on).Tangent repeats every half turn, so one answer plus whole multiples of π reaches all of them. k = 1 gives 2.0344 + 3.1416 = 5.1760, the other answer on one turn.
Answer
  • On one turn: t ≈ 2.0344 and t ≈ 5.1760
  • General solution: t ≈ 2.0344 + kπ, k any integer
Double-check The two answers on one turn differ by half a turn: 5.1760 − 2.0344 = 3.1416 ≈ π. Put back: tan(2.0344) ≈ −2.0002 and tan(5.1760) ≈ −2.0002, both −2.000 to three decimal places; the small gap comes from rounding the angles.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin t = 0.4 and the calculator says 0.4115, so the only answer is t ≈ 0.4115.
The key returns only the angle in its own range, the right half of the circle. Sine is also positive in Quadrant II, where a second angle has the same height.
✓ Instead: t ≈ 0.4115 and t ≈ π − 0.4115 ≈ 2.7301.
✗ Not this: In degree mode, sin−1 0.4 shows 23.5782, so the second solution is π − 23.5782 ≈ −20.4366.
23.5782 is in degrees and π is in radians. Subtracting one from the other mixes units, like subtracting inches from centimeters, and the negative result is not even on one turn.
✓ Instead: Switch to radian mode (0.4115 and 2.7301), or stay in degrees the whole way: 23.5782° and 180° − 23.5782° = 156.4218°.
✗ Not this: For cos t = 0.6, the second solution is π − 0.9273 ≈ 2.2143.
π − α is the mirror for sine. Cosine is positive in Quadrants I and IV, not II, and cos(2.2143) ≈ −0.6000 has the wrong sign.
✓ Instead: Mirror across the horizontal axis instead: 2π − 0.9273 ≈ 5.3559, and cos(5.3559) ≈ 0.6000.
✗ Not this: Round early: α ≈ 0.4, so π − 0.4 ≈ 2.7416. Or use 3.14 for π: 3.14 − 0.4115 = 2.7285.
Each shortcut throws digits away, and the lost amount moves into the answer: both miss the true 2.7301, one in the second decimal place and one in the third.
✓ Instead: Keep every digit and use the π key until the last step: π − 0.411516846 ≈ 2.7301.
✗ Not this: sin t = 0.5: the calculator gives 0.5236, so t ≈ 0.5236 and t ≈ 2.6180.
The decimals are correct, but 0.5 is a special value. Its exact answers need no rounding and show where the angles sit on the circle.
✓ Instead: t = π6 and t = 5π6, exactly (about 0.5236 and 2.6180).
✗ Not this: sin t = 1.3: the calculator shows an error, so switch modes and try again.
No angle has a sine above 1 in any mode, because the height of a point on the unit circle never passes 1. The error message is the answer.
✓ Instead: No solution.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device, key, mirror, fix, round: press the inverse key, find the mirror angle, fix a negative angle by adding 2π, and round last.
  • Mode check: in radian mode, sin−1 and tan−1 never give a number outside −1.5708 to 1.5708, and cos−1 never one outside 0 to 3.1416. A screen showing 23.5782 for sin−1 0.4 means degree mode.
  • Quadrant borders as decimals: π2 ≈ 1.5708, π ≈ 3.1416, 3π2 ≈ 4.7124 and 2π ≈ 6.2832. Compare a decimal answer with them to read its quadrant.
  • Built-in check: two sine answers add to π (or to 3π when α was negative), two cosine answers add to 2π, and two tangent answers differ by π.
  • A rounded angle put back into the equation returns c to about three decimal places, not exactly: tan(1.2490) ≈ 2.9995. For sine, cosine and a tangent value up to about 5 in size, the two numbers differ by less than 0.002, so a gap of 0.01 or more means a real mistake. Tangent climbs steeply near its asymptotes, so a large value forgives less: tan t = 500 gives t ≈ 1.5688, and tan(1.5688) ≈ 500.92, a right answer that still misses by almost 1.
  • sin−1 0.4 means the angle whose sine is 0.4, not 1sin0.4. On many calculators it sits above the sin key and is reached with a 2nd or SHIFT key.
  • Why four decimal places: 0.01 radian is more than half a degree (about 0.57°), so two places can be visibly off. Four places keep the error under 0.003°.

7 The trap

Stopping at the calculator's answer. The inverse key shows one angle, but sin t = 0.4 has two on one turn. After every key press, ask which other quadrant shares the sign, and find the second angle with π − α, 2π − α or α + π.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

In radian mode, sin−1(0.7) ≈ 0.7754. Why is that not the whole answer to sin t = 0.7 on [0, 2π)?
  • The point on the unit circle reaches height 0.7 twice per turn, like a Ferris wheel seat: once on the way up and once on the way down. The calculator names only the moment on the way up, α ≈ 0.7754.
  • The moment on the way down is π − α ≈ 2.3662 (rounded to four decimal places).
The inverse key gives α. How do you get both solutions on [0, 2π) for sine, for cosine and for tangent?
  • Sine: α and π − α
  • Cosine: α and 2π − α
  • Tangent: α and α + π
  • Then add 2π to any answer that came out negative.
  • One caution: when sin t or cos t is 1 or −1, one turn holds a single answer, read from the axes. There the two formulas name the same angle twice or land on 2π, which is not in [0, 2π).
What do you write for sin t = 1.3, and how can you tell before using the calculator?
  • No solution.
  • Sine is the height of a point on the unit circle, and that height never goes above 1 or below −1, the way a Ferris wheel seat never rises above the top of the wheel. A calculator would only show an error.
Why keep every digit of α and round only once, at the very end?
  • Every rounded number carries a small error, and arithmetic on rounded numbers piles the errors up.
  • For tan t = −2, keeping every digit gives α + π ≈ 2.0344, but rounding α to −1.1071 first gives −1.1071 + π ≈ 2.0345, off in the last decimal place.

Lesson 8 of 8

Checking for extra solutions after squaring

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Squaring a sum or a differenceLeans on: The Pythagorean identityLeans on: Moving a term acrossLeans on: DistributingLeans on: The zero-product ruleLeans on: FactoringLeans on: Sine and cosine where the circle meets the axesLeans on: The reference angle and quadrant methodLeans on: Fractions of πLeans on: Sign rulesLeans on: The square-root signLeans on: The general solutionOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Some trigonometric equations mix sine and cosine in a way none of the earlier methods can untangle, so you square both sides. Squaring is like fishing with a wide net: you catch every fish you wanted, plus a few you did not. After squaring, then, each answer you find is only a candidate, an answer that still has to pass a test. The test is the original equation, the one you started with. Put each candidate back into it. Keep the ones that make it true and throw the others back. A candidate that fails is an extraneous solution: extra, not real. Squaring sin t + cos t = 1, for example, hands you four candidates on one turn, and only two pass.

2 Picture it

keepkeepthrow outthrow outπ/2π3π/22π−2−112keepkeepthrow outthrow outπ/2π3π/22π−2−112
On one turn…

Reminder

Reminder: Squaring a sum or a difference, The Pythagorean identity, Moving a term across, Distributing, The zero-product rule, Factoring, Sine and cosine where the circle meets the axes, The reference angle and quadrant method, Fractions of π, Sign rules, The square-root sign, The general solution
  • Squaring a sum or a difference. (a + b)2 = a2 + 2ab + b2 and (a − b)2 = a2 − 2ab + b2: (x + 3)2 = x2 + 6x + 9, not x2 + 9.
  • The Pythagorean identity. sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 for every angle, so sin2 t = 1 − cos2 t: at t = π6, 14 + 34 = 1.
  • Moving a term across. Adding the same thing to both sides keeps an equation true: add cos t to both sides of sin t − cos t = 1 to get sin t = 1 + cos t.
  • Distributing. A number in front multiplies every piece in the brackets: 3(1 − c2) = 3 − 3c2.
  • The zero-product rule. If A · B = 0, then A = 0 or B = 0, and it works only with 0 alone on one side: 2 sin t cos t = 0 gives sin t = 0 or cos t = 0.
  • Factoring. Pull out a common factor, 2s2 + 2s = 2s(s + 1), or find two brackets, 2c2 + c − 1 = (2c − 1)(c + 1). Multiply back to check.
  • Sine and cosine where the circle meets the axes. cos t is the x-coordinate and sin t the y-coordinate: (1, 0) at t = 0, (0, 1) at π2, (−1, 0) at π, (0, −1) at 3π2.
  • The reference angle and quadrant method. sin t = 22: reference angle π4, sine positive in quadrants I and II, so t = π4 and t = π − π4 = 3π4.
  • Fractions of π. Write both over the same bottom before adding: π + π3 = 3π3 + π3 = 4π3.
  • Sign rules. A negative times a negative is positive, (−1)2 = (−1)(−1) = 1; subtracting a negative adds, 0 − (−1) = 0 + 1 = 1.
  • The square-root sign. x means the root that is not negative: 9 = 3, never −3.
  • The general solution. The period of sine and cosine is 2π, so a kept answer a gives t = a + 2kπ, k any integer (…, −1, 0, 1, …): t = π2 + 2kπ.

3 Why

Squaring works in one direction only. If two numbers are equal, their squares are equal, so no true answer is lost. Going back fails: 12 = 1 and (−1)2 = 1, so a squared equation cannot tell 1 from −1. Squaring sin t + cos t = 1 gives (sin t + cos t)2 = 1, which is true when the sum is 1 and also when the sum is −1. Every later step solves that wider equation, so the candidates include angles where the sum is −1, such as t = π. Only the original equation can tell the two kinds apart.

4 The rule

If a=b, then a2=b2, but a2=b2 only tells you that a=b or a=−b.

So squaring both sides never loses a solution and can add extraneous solutions: keep a candidate only if it makes the original equation true.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Say “π is an extraneous solution” (ek-STRAY-nee-us). It means π came out of the work but does not solve the original equation.

Write it

An extraneous solution is a candidate that the squared equation accepts and the original equation rejects.

In math
  • (sin π + cos π)2 = (−1)2 = 1: the squared equation accepts π
  • sin π + cos π = −1 ≠ 1: the original equation rejects π
  • on [0, 2π): candidates {0, π2, π, 3π2}; solutions {0, π2}; extraneous {π, 3π2}
  • a2 = b2 means a = b or a = −b
  • graph words: y = sin t + cos t meets the line y = −1 at t = π, not the line y = 1
Like

A fish that came up in your net but is the wrong kind: it was caught along with the rest, and you throw it back.

See it
−11−221234
The line at height 1 meets y = x2 twice, at x = −1 and at x = 1.

The same idea, other ways

With small numbers

Start with x = 3. It has one answer, 3. Square both sides: x2 = 9. Now two numbers work, 3 and −3, because (−3)2 = 9 as well. Put each one back into x = 3: 3 = 3 is true, −3 = 3 is false. Squaring turned one answer into two candidates, and the original equation threw one back. Trig equations do the same thing, with angles in place of 3 and −3.

x = 3: one answer

x2 = 9: candidates 3 and −3

back into x = 3: 3 passes, −3 fails

As a picture

On the unit circle, cos t is the x-coordinate and sin t is the y-coordinate, so sin t + cos t = 1 asks for a point whose two coordinates add to 1. Squaring gives four candidates, the points where the circle crosses the axes: (1, 0) at t = 0, (0, 1) at t = π2, (−1, 0) at t = π and (0, −1) at t = 3π2. Adding coordinates gives 1 + 0 = 1, 0 + 1 = 1, −1 + 0 = −1 and 0 + (−1) = −1. The last two sums have the right size and the wrong sign, and size is all that squaring can see.

x = cos θy = sin θ(−1, 0)
At t = π the point is (−1, 0), whose coordinates add to −1, so π passes the squared equation and fails sin t…
As a story

A friend tells you their apartment is one floor away from yours. That could be the floor above or the floor below: the message keeps the distance and loses the direction. Squaring does the same to a number. The square depends only on how far the number is from 0, not on which side of 0 it is on, so 1 and −1 both square to 1. You knock on both doors, the candidates, and only the original equation tells you which door is your friend's.

Why it must be true

Equal numbers have equal squares, so every true answer survives squaring. The reverse fails: a2 = b2 says only that a and b are the same distance from 0, so a = b or a = −b. Once you square sin t + cos t = 1, you are solving two equations at once, sin t + cos t = 1 or sin t + cos t = −1, and no algebra step on the squared equation can tell them apart; only a check in the original can. The card shows the whole chain: every line after the squaring accepts all four candidates, and only the last line, the check, sorts them.

(sint+cost)2=1

sin2t+2sintcost+cos2t=1

1 + 2 sin t cos t = 1

sin t cos t = 0

sin t = 0 or cos t = 0

candidates on [0, 2π): 0, π2, π, 3π2

check in sin t + cos t = 1: keep 0 and π2

Rule of thumb

Square it, then check it. Each time you square both sides, write CHECK in the margin, and do not write the answer until every candidate has gone back into the very first line of your work.

candidate tsin tcos tsin t + cos tkeep it?
0011yes
π2101yes
π0−1−1no, extraneous
3π2−10−1no, extraneous

5 How

  1. Write the original equation where you will see it at the end. It is the judge.
  2. Square both sides, the whole of each side at once, keeping the middle term: (a + b)2 = a2 + 2ab + b2.
  3. Use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1, get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
  4. Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π). Every answer you get is a candidate.
  5. Put each candidate into the original equation, not the squared one. Keep it only if the two sides match, sign included.
  6. Each kept solution on one turn, a, gives the general solution t = a + 2kπ, k any integer.

Solving by squaring, then checking

1
Can an earlier method finish the equation without squaring (one function after an identity, a quadratic that factors, or tan t = c)?
YesUse that method: it adds no fake answers. Check the answers anyway.
NoSquare both sides and go on.
↓
2
Did you square both sides anywhere in your work?
YesTreat every answer as a candidate and check each one in the original equation.
NoYour answers are solutions; a quick check still catches slips.
↓
3
At this candidate, do the two sides of the original equation match, sign included?
YesKeep it.
NoThrow it out: it is an extraneous solution.
↓
4
Does the question ask for every solution?
YesWrite the general solution t = a + 2kπ for each kept answer a.
NoList each kept solution on one turn.
  1. Write the original equation where you will see it at the end: it is the judge.
  2. Pick a shape: square both sides as they stand, or first move one term across so each side holds a single function.
  3. Square the whole of each side, keeping the middle term: (a − b)2 = a2 − 2ab + b2.
  4. Use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 to cancel the squares or to rewrite everything in one function.
  5. Get 0 alone on one side, factor, and set each factor equal to 0.
  6. Solve each small equation on one turn, [0, 2π): these are the candidates.
  7. Put each candidate into the original equation and keep it only if both sides match, sign included.
  8. For the general solution, add 2kπ to each kept answer.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Squaring a difference, then checking

Solve cos t − sin t = 1 on one turn, [0, 2π), then write the general solution. In plain words: find every angle where the cosine minus the sine comes out to exactly 1, then describe all such angles on every turn.

Show the steps and the answer
input toutput cos t − sin t01π/2−1π−13π/21↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
The two 1s in the output row point up to 0 and 3π2, the kept answers.
  1. Keep the original equation in view: cost−sint=1.It is the judge at the end. Every candidate goes back into this line, not into a later one.
  2. Square both sides: (cost−sint)2=12=1.Two different functions sit on the left, and none of the earlier methods joins them. Squaring will make cos2 t + sin2 t appear, which the identity turns into 1. Doing the same thing to both sides keeps them equal.
  3. Expand the left side: cos2t−2costsint+sin2t=1.(a − b)2 = a2 − 2ab + b2 with a = cos t and b = sin t. The middle term −2 cos t sin t must stay.
  4. Replace cos2t+sin2 t with 1: 1−2costsint=1.sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 for every angle, so the two squares together are worth 1.
  5. Subtract 1 from both sides, then divide both sides by −2: costsint=0.This puts 0 alone on one side, which the zero-product rule needs. Subtracting 1 leaves −2 cos t sin t = 0, and 0 ÷ (−2) = 0.
  6. Use the zero-product rule: cost=0 or sint=0.A product is 0 only when one of its factors is 0, so this step finds every angle that could make the product 0.
  7. Solve each on one turn. cost=0 at t=π2 and t=3π2; sint=0 at t=0 and t=π. The candidates are 0, π2,π and 3π2.cos t is the x-coordinate on the unit circle, 0 at the top (0, 1) and the bottom (0, −1); sin t is the y-coordinate, 0 at (1, 0) and (−1, 0). Plug one back in: at t = π2, cos t · sin t = 0 · 1 = 0.
  8. Check t=0 in the original: cos0−sin0=1−0=1. Keep it.The left side matches the right side, 1. In the table picture, this is the first 1 in the output row.
  9. Check t=π2: cosπ2−sinπ2=0−1=−1, not 1. Throw it out.The left side is −1. It passed the squared equation only because (−1)2 = 1, so it is an extraneous solution.
  10. Check t=π: cosπ−sinπ=−1−0=−1, not 1. Throw it out.Again the left side is −1, the sign that squaring hid.
  11. Check t=3π2: cos3π2−sin3π2=0−(−1)=1. Keep it.Subtracting −1 is the same as adding 1, so the left side is 1 and matches.
  12. Write the general solution: t=2kπ or t=3π2+2kπ, k any integer.The period of cosine and sine is 2π, so each kept answer comes back every full turn; 0 + 2kπ is written 2kπ.
Answer
  • On one turn: t = 0 and t = 3π2
  • General solution: t = 2kπ or t = 3π2 + 2kπ, k any integer
  • Extraneous: π2 and π
Double-check Second way: move sin t across first, cos t = 1 + sin t, and square: cos2 t = 1 + 2 sin t + sin2 t. Replace cos2 t with 1 − sin2 t and subtract 1 − sin2 t from both sides: 0 = 2 sin2 t + 2 sin t = 2 sin t (sin t + 1). So sin t = 0 (t = 0 or π) or sin t = −1 (t = 3π2), only three candidates this time. In cos t − sin t = 1: at 0, 1 − 0 = 1; at π, −1 − 0 = −1, out; at 3π2, 0 − (−1) = 1. The same two answers survive: 0 and 3π2.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 5

Rung 1: watch squaring add answers

Solve cos t = −32 on one turn by squaring both sides on purpose, then check. You could solve it directly; squaring here lets you watch what squaring does. In plain words: find the angles on one turn whose cosine is −32.

Show the steps and the answer
input toutput cos tπ/6(√3)/25π/6−(√3)/27π/6−(√3)/211π/6(√3)/2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
The two cells holding −32 point up to 5π6 and 7π6, the answers that survive the check.
  1. Square both sides: cos2t=34.(−32)2 = (−32) · (−32) = 34, since a negative times a negative is positive and 3 · 3 = 3.
  2. List every value of cos t whose square is 34: cost=32 or cost=−32.Both 32 and −32 square to 34. This is the moment the minus sign gets lost.
  3. Solve cost=32: t=π6 and t=2π−π6=11π6.cos π6 = 32, so the reference angle is π6; cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV.
  4. Solve cost=−32: t=π−π6=5π6 and t=π+π6=7π6.The same reference angle, placed in quadrants II and III, where cosine is negative.
  5. Check the four candidates in cost=−32: cosπ6=32, throw out; cos5π6=−32, keep; cos7π6=−32, keep; cos11π6=32, throw out.Only the original equation still knows the cosine must be negative. In the table picture, only the columns holding −32 are lit.
Answer
  • t = 5π6 and t = 7π6
  • Extraneous: π6 and 11π6
Double-check Second way: solve cos t = −32 directly, without squaring. The reference angle is π6 and cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so t = 5π6 and t = 7π6, the same pair. Squaring doubled the list from 2 to 4, and the check cut it back to 2.

Rung 2 of 5

Rung 2: square a whole sum

Solve sin t + cos t = −1 on one turn, then write the general solution. In plain words: find the angles where the sine plus the cosine comes out to exactly −1.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ(0, −1)
At t = 3π2 the point is (0, −1), and 0 + (−1) = −1, so 3π2 is a real answer of sin t + cos t = −1.
  1. Square both sides: (sint+cost)2=(−1)2=1.Doing the same thing to both sides keeps them equal, and squaring will make sin2 t + cos2 t appear.
  2. Expand the left side: sin2t+2sintcost+cos2t=1.(a + b)2 = a2 + 2ab + b2 with a = sin t and b = cos t; the middle term is 2 sin t cos t.
  3. Replace sin2t+cos2 t with 1, then subtract 1 from both sides: 2sintcost=0.The identity sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 gives 1 + 2 sin t cos t = 1, and subtracting 1 leaves 0 alone on the right.
  4. Use the zero-product rule: sint=0 or cost=0. The candidates are 0 and π (where sint=0) and π2 and 3π2 (where cost=0).2 is not 0, so one of sin t and cos t must be 0. Read both off the points where the unit circle meets the axes.
  5. Check in sint+cost=−1. At 0: 0+1=1, throw out. At π2: 1+0=1, throw out. At π: 0+(−1)=−1, keep. At 3π2: −1+0=−1, keep.The squared equation cannot see the sign and the original can. The two fakes are the angles where the sum is 1.
  6. Write the general solution: t=π+2kπ or t=3π2+2kπ, k any integer.The period of sine and cosine is 2π, so each kept answer comes back every full turn.
Answer
  • On one turn: t = π and t = 3π2
  • General solution: t = π + 2kπ or t = 3π2 + 2kπ, k any integer
  • Extraneous: 0 and π2
Double-check Second way: move cos t across first, sin t = −1 − cos t, and square: sin2 t = 1 + 2 cos t + cos2 t. Replace sin2 t with 1 − cos2 t and subtract 1 − cos2 t from both sides: 0 = 2 cos2 t + 2 cos t = 2 cos t (cos t + 1). So cos t = 0 (t = π2 or 3π2) or cos t = −1 (t = π). In sin t + cos t = −1: at π2, 1 + 0 = 1, out; at π, 0 + (−1) = −1; at 3π2, −1 + 0 = −1. The same pair survives: π and 3π2.

Rung 3 of 5

Rung 3: move a term first, then square

Solve sin t − cos t = 1 on one turn by first moving cos t to the right side. In plain words: find the angles where the sine minus the cosine is exactly 1.

Show the steps and the answer
input toutput sin t − cos tπ/21π13π/2−1↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
The two 1s in the output row point up to π2 and π, the kept answers; the −1 under 3π2 is the fake.
  1. Add cos t to both sides: sint=1+cost.With one function alone on the left, its square is the single term sin2 t, which the identity can replace.
  2. Square both sides: sin2t=1+2cost+cos2 t.(1 + cos t)2 = 12 + 2 · 1 · cos t + cos2 t, and squaring both sides keeps them equal.
  3. Replace sin2 t with 1−cos2 t: 1−cos2t=1+2cost+cos2 t.From sin2 t + cos2 t = 1. Now cos t is the only function left.
  4. Subtract 1−cos2 t from both sides: 0=2cos2t+2cost.This gets 0 alone on one side: 1 − 1 = 0, and cos2 t − (−cos2 t) = 2 cos2 t.
  5. Factor and use the zero-product rule: 0=2cost (cost+1), so cost=0 or cost=−1.2 cos t divides both terms. Plug one back in to see it work: with cos t = −1, 2(−1)(−1 + 1) = 2(−1)(0) = 0.
  6. List the candidates: cost=0 at π2 and 3π2; cost=−1 at π.On the unit circle x = 0 at the top and the bottom, and x = −1 at the far left. This route gives only three candidates.
  7. Check in sint−cost=1. At π2: 1−0=1, keep. At π: 0−(−1)=1, keep. At 3π2: −1−0=−1, throw out.Subtracting −1 adds 1. At 3π2 the moved equation sin t = 1 + cos t reads −1 = 1: equal size, opposite sign, which squaring cannot see. In the table picture, the −1 under 3π2 is the fake.
Answer
  • On one turn: t = π2 and t = π
  • General solution: t = π2 + 2kπ or t = π + 2kπ, k any integer
  • Extraneous: 3π2
Double-check Second way: square without moving anything. (sin t − cos t)2 = 1 becomes sin2 t − 2 sin t cos t + cos2 t = 1, so 1 − 2 sin t cos t = 1 and sin t cos t = 0. The candidates are now 0, π2, π and 3π2. In sin t − cos t = 1: at 0, 0 − 1 = −1; at π2, 1 − 0 = 1; at π, 0 − (−1) = 1; at 3π2, −1 − 0 = −1. The survivors are again π2 and π, though the candidate list was different.

Rung 4 of 5

Rung 4: a square root on one side

Solve 1−sint = cos t on one turn. In plain words: find the angles where the square root of 1 − sin t equals the cosine. The square-root sign always means the root that is not negative.

Show the steps and the answer

1−sint is never negative

cos π = −1 is negative

so t = π cannot be an answer

kept: t = 0 and t = π2

  1. Square both sides: 1−sint=cos2 t.Squaring undoes the root: (1−sint)2 = 1 − sin t. The inside is never negative, since sin t is at most 1, so the root always exists.
  2. Replace cos2 t with 1−sin2 t: 1−sint=1−sin2 t.From sin2 t + cos2 t = 1. Now sin t is the only function left.
  3. Subtract 1 from both sides, then add sin2 t to both sides: sin2t−sint=0.This gets 0 alone on one side: −sin t = −sin2 t becomes sin2 t − sin t = 0.
  4. Factor: sin t (sint−1)=0, so sint=0 or sint=1.sin t divides both terms, then the zero-product rule. Plug back: with sin t = 1, 1 · (1 − 1) = 0.
  5. List the candidates: sint=0 at 0 and π; sint=1 at π2.On the unit circle y = 0 at (1, 0) and (−1, 0), and y = 1 at the top, (0, 1).
  6. Check in 1−sint=cost. At 0: 1−0=1 and cos0=1, keep. At π2: 1−1=0 and cosπ2=0, keep. At π: 1−0=1 but cosπ=−1, throw out.A square root is never negative, so it can never equal −1. Squaring hid that, because 12 and (−1)2 are both 1.
Answer
  • On one turn: t = 0 and t = π2
  • General solution: t = 2kπ or t = π2 + 2kπ, k any integer
  • Extraneous: π
Double-check Second way, by signs: the left side is a square root, so it is never negative, and any answer needs cos t ≥ 0. Where both sides are 0 or more, equal squares do mean equal numbers, so there squaring adds no fakes. Of the candidates 0, π2 and π, the ones with cos t ≥ 0 are 0 (cos 0 = 1) and π2 (cos π2 = 0), while cos π = −1. The same pair: 0 and π2.

Rung 5 of 5

Rung 5: a number in front and two brackets to find

Solve 3 sin t + cos t = 1 on one turn. In plain words: find the angles where 3 times the sine, plus the cosine, is exactly 1.

Show the steps and the answer
input toutput √3 sin t + cos t012π/314π/3−2↑ solve: output given, read every input above it
Only the columns holding 1 survive, 0 and 2π3; at 4π3 the left side is −2.
  1. Subtract cos t from both sides: 3sint=1−cost.One function on each side keeps the squares short.
  2. Square both sides: 3 sin2t=1−2cost+cos2 t.(3 sin t)2 = (3)2 · sin2 t = 3 sin2 t, and (1 − cos t)2 = 1 − 2 cos t + cos2 t.
  3. Replace sin2 t with 1−cos2 t: 3−3cos2t=1−2cost+cos2 t.From sin2 t + cos2 t = 1; the 3 multiplies both pieces, 3(1 − cos2 t) = 3 − 3 cos2 t.
  4. Subtract 3 and add 3 cos2 t on both sides: 0=4cos2t−2cost−2.This gets 0 alone on one side: 1 − 3 = −2 and cos2 t + 3 cos2 t = 4 cos2 t.
  5. Divide both sides by 2: 0=2cos2t−cost−1.Smaller numbers factor with less work, and 0 ÷ 2 = 0.
  6. Factor: 0=(2cost+1)(cost−1).Multiply back to check: 2 cos2 t − 2 cos t + cos t − 1 = 2 cos2 t − cos t − 1.
  7. Set each bracket equal to 0: cost=−12 or cost=1.The zero-product rule finds the cosines that make the product 0. Plug back: with cos t = −12, 2(−12) + 1 = −1 + 1 = 0.
  8. List the candidates: cost=1 at t=0; cost=−12 at t=2π3 and t=4π3.Reference angle π3, with cosine negative in quadrants II and III: π − π3 = 2π3 and π + π3 = 4π3.
  9. Check t=0: 3·0+1=1. Keep it.sin 0 = 0 and cos 0 = 1.
  10. Check t=2π3: 3·32+(−12)=32−12=1. Keep it.sin 2π3 = 32 and cos 2π3 = −12, and 3 · 3 = 3.
  11. Check t=4π3: 3·(−32)+(−12)=−32−12=−2, not 1. Throw it out.In the moved equation 3 sin t = 1 − cos t, the two sides were −32 and 32: equal size, opposite sign, exactly what squaring cannot see. In the table picture, the −2 under 4π3 is the fake.
Answer
  • On one turn: t = 0 and t = 2π3
  • General solution: t = 2kπ or t = 2π3 + 2kπ, k any integer
  • Extraneous: 4π3
Double-check Second way: square the whole left side without moving anything. (3 sin t + cos t)2 = 1 gives 3 sin2 t + 23 sin t cos t + cos2 t = 1. Write 3 sin2 t as 2 sin2 t + sin2 t and use sin2 t + cos2 t = 1: 2 sin2 t + 23 sin t cos t = 0, so 2 sin t (sin t + 3 cos t) = 0. Either sin t = 0, giving t = 0 or π, or sin t = −3 cos t, which means tan t = −3 (cos t = 0 would force sin t = 0 too, and they are never 0 together), giving t = 2π3 or 5π3. In the original: at 0 and at 2π3 the left side is 1; at π it is 0 + (−1) = −1; at 5π3 it is −32 + 12 = −1. The same pair survives: 0 and 2π3.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Checking the candidates in the squared equation: at t = π, (sin π + cos π)2 = (0 + (−1))2 = 1 is true, so π looks like an answer.
The squared equation is the one that produced the candidates, so every candidate passes it. It cannot tell a sum of 1 from a sum of −1.
✓ Instead: Check in the original equation: sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1 ≠ 1, so π is an extraneous solution.
✗ Not this: Squaring each term on its own: sin t + cos t = 1 becomes sin2 t + cos2 t = 1.
(a + b)2 is not a2 + b2: the middle term 2ab goes missing. Worse, sin2 t + cos2 t = 1 is true for every angle, so it would say every t is a solution, yet t = π gives 0 + (−1) = −1.
✓ Instead: Square the whole side: (sin t + cos t)2 = sin2 t + 2 sin t cos t + cos2 t = 1 + 2 sin t cos t.
✗ Not this: Assuming squaring always adds fakes and throwing out some candidates without checking them.
Sometimes every candidate passes. 1+sint = 1 squares to 1 + sin t = 1, so sin t = 0 and t = 0 or π, and both pass: 1+0 = 1.
✓ Instead: Check every candidate, one at a time, and keep exactly the ones that pass, whether that is all, some or none.
✗ Not this: Adding 2kπ to all four candidates of sin t + cos t = 1 and calling that the general solution.
The fakes repeat every turn too: at t = π + 2π = 3π the sum is still 0 + (−1) = −1.
✓ Instead: Check on one turn first, then add 2kπ only to the survivors: t = 2kπ or t = π2 + 2kπ.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: “Square it, then check it.” Squaring opens the door to fakes, and the original equation is the bouncer who checks every ticket.
  • Check the sign before the size. At each candidate, ask whether the left side of the original equation is positive or negative; if the right side is 1 and the left side is negative, throw the candidate out at once.
  • The fakes follow a pattern: the fakes of sin t + cos t = 1, π and 3π2, are exactly the answers of sin t + cos t = −1, because both equations square to the same equation.
  • Two routes make a good second check. Squaring cos t − sin t = 1 as it stands gives four candidates, and moving sin t across first gives three, yet both end at 0 and 3π2.
  • Squaring can add answers, while dividing both sides by something that can be 0, such as cos t, can lose them. After either move, look back at the original equation.
  • When both sides can never be negative, as with a square root equal to a positive number, squaring adds no fakes: two numbers that are 0 or more with the same square are equal. Check anyway; it takes a minute.

7 The trap

Writing the candidates as the answer. After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, the list 0, π2, π, 3π2 looks finished, but at t = π the left side is sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, and 3π2 fails the same way. Put every candidate back into the original equation, never the squared one, before you write the answer.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

What is an extraneous solution?
A candidate you get after squaring that does not make the original equation true. It is like an unwanted fish in a wide net: throw it back.
What does squaring both sides do to the answers of an equation, and why?
  • It keeps every true answer, because if a = b, then a2 = b2.
  • It can add answers that fail the original equation, because a2 = b2 is also true when a = −b: 12 and (−1)2 are both 1.
After squaring sin t + cos t = 1, should you test the candidate t = π in the squared equation or in the original one?
  • In the original one.
  • The squared equation passes every candidate, π included: (sin π + cos π)2 = (−1)2 = 1.
  • The original catches it: sin π + cos π = 0 + (−1) = −1, not 1, so t = π is extraneous.
Squaring sin t − cos t = 1 and solving leads to four candidates on one turn: 0, π2, π and 3π2. Which ones make the original equation true?
  • π2 and π.
  • sin π2 − cos π2 = 1 − 0 = 1, and sin π − cos π = 0 − (−1) = 0 + 1 = 1.
  • At 0 and at 3π2 the left side is −1, not 1, so those two are extraneous.