Rewriting with an identity first
Quick review (2 minutes)
Picture a wallet with dollars and euros, and a bill to pay in dollars.
t + t = 1 at every angle, so t = 1 − t and t = 1 − t: replace the squared function and keep the lonely one.
Where cos t ≠ 0, = tan t, so sin t = cos t becomes tan t = 1, and a·sin t = b·cos t (a ≠ 0) becomes tan t = . First test t = and t = in the original, because a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions.
Say what the equation asks: every solution on one turn, each t in [0, 2π) that makes the two sides equal.
Rewrite with an identity until one trigonometric function of t is left; the strategy in this lesson says which identity. Write each swap inside parentheses.
If you divide by cos t, first put t = and t = into the original equation and keep any that work.
Get a 0 on one side. If the equation is a quadratic in the function or has a common factor, factor it, treating the function as a single unknown.
Solve each piece with the reference angle and the quadrants. Throw out any value of sine or cosine outside [−1, 1].
Put every answer into the original equation, not the rewritten one.
Circle every trigonometric function in the equation and note its power: squared, like t, or alone, like sin t.
If the same function is a factor of every term, do not divide by it: move every term to one side and factor it out.
If one function is squared and the other is alone, keep the lonely one and swap the squared one with the identity, in parentheses.
If both are squared and neither is alone, swap either one.
If one sin t term faces one cos t term, test t = and t = in the original, then divide by cos t to reach tan t.
Solve the one-function equation with the earlier methods, then check every answer in the original.
Solve 2 t + 5 cos t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π).
t =
t =
Dividing both sides by cos t, or by sin t, without testing where it is zero. Division by zero is not allowed, so every solution with cos t = 0, at t = or t = , disappears without any warning; for sin t the angles are t = 0 and t = π. In 2 sin t cos t = cos t, a division loses and . Test those angles in the original equation before dividing, and when the function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.
trigonometric equation
An equation with sine, cosine or tangent of an unknown angle, such as 2 cos t = 1. Most are true at some angles and false at the others; solving one means finding every angle that makes it true. One that is true at every angle is called an identity, and one such as sin t = 2 is true at none.
solution on one turn
A solution inside one trip around the circle, the interval [0, 2π). The start, 0, is included; the end, 2π, is left out because it is the same spot as 0.
general solution
One formula naming every solution: the solutions on one turn plus any whole number of periods, as in t = a + 2kπ, where k is any integer, negative, zero or positive.
period
How far you go along before a function's pattern starts over. Sine and cosine repeat every 2π, one full turn; tangent repeats every π, half a turn.
reference angle
The angle between an angle's ending ray, its terminal side, and the nearest part of the x-axis, from 0 to . Angles sharing one have the same sine and cosine except for sign.
1 In plain words
Picture a wallet with dollars and euros, and a bill to pay in dollars. You cannot pay with the money as it is. First you change the euros into dollars at a fixed rate, and now there is one kind of money to count. A trigonometric equation with both sin t and cos t is that wallet. Your methods so far handle one trigonometric function at a time. So you convert first, with an identity: a fact true at every angle, like a rate that never changes. The identity t + t = 1 trades t for 1 − t. When one sin t faces one cos t, dividing by cos t turns the pair into tan t, as long as cos t is not 0.
2 Picture it
Keep the lonely one, swap the squared one.
tan t = where cos t ≠ 0
Before dividing by cos t, test where cos t = 0: and on one turn.
Same function in every term: factor, do not divide.
Check every answer in the original.
Reminder
Reminder: What t means, Why t + t = 1, Tangent is sine over cosine, Dividing by a fraction, Doing the same to both sides, No dividing by zero, Distributing, Factoring out a common factor, The zero-product rule, Sine and cosine stay in [−1, 1], Angles from a reference angle
- What t means. t is (sin t: find the sine, then square it. At t = , sin t = −, so t = .
- Why t + t = 1. The point (cos t, sin t) is on the circle of radius 1, so the Pythagorean theorem gives t + t = 1. At t = : + = 1.
- Tangent is sine over cosine. tan t = . At t = : ÷ = .
- Dividing by a fraction. Multiply by its flip: ÷ = × = , the same number as .
- Doing the same to both sides. An equation stays balanced when both sides get the same move: subtract 3 from both sides of x + 3 = 5 to get x = 2, or multiply both sides of −2 + u = 0 by −1 to get 2 − u = 0. The one move never allowed is dividing by 0.
- No dividing by zero. 6 ÷ 0 has no answer. cos t = 0 at t = and t = ; sin t = 0 at t = 0 and t = π.
- Distributing. A number in front of parentheses multiplies every term inside: 2(1 − t) = 2 − 2 t.
- Factoring out a common factor. Pull out what every term shares: 2 − u = u(2u − 1). Multiply back to check: u·2u − u·1 = 2 − u.
- The zero-product rule. If A·B = 0, then A = 0 or B = 0, and it needs a zero on one side: (2u − 1)(u − 2) = 0 gives u = or u = 2.
- Sine and cosine stay in [−1, 1]. Both are coordinates of a point that sits on the unit circle, whose radius is 1, so no angle has cos t = 2: throw it out.
- Angles from a reference angle. Quadrant I: α; II: π − α; III: π + α; IV: 2π − α. Sine is positive in I and II, cosine in I and IV, tangent in I and III (All Students Take Calculus). With α = : , , , .
3 Why
Your earlier methods work because one trigonometric function can act as a single unknown, like u. With sin t and cos t together there are two unknowns. The identity removes one without changing the answers: the point (cos t, sin t) sits on a circle of radius 1, so the Pythagorean theorem makes t + t = 1 at every angle, and trading t for 1 − t cannot change whether the equation is true. Dividing by cos t is safe except where cos t = 0, since nothing can be divided by zero, so t = and t = are tested by hand.
4 The rule
at every angle, so and : replace the squared function and keep the lonely one.
Where , so becomes , and () becomes . First test and in the original, because a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions.
The same idea, five ways
Rewrite first: trade the squared function using sine squared plus cosine squared equals one, or divide sine by cosine to get tangent, so only one trig function is left.
Before solving a trigonometric equation that contains both sin t and cos t, rewrite it with an identity so that only one trigonometric function of t remains, then solve that equation.
- tan t = where cos t ≠ 0
- a·sin t = b·cos t becomes tan t = (a ≠ 0)
- sin t = cos t becomes tan t = 1 (no solution has cos t = 0), so t = or t = on [0, 2π)
Like a recipe that lists flour in cups and in tablespoons: change the tablespoons into cups (16 tablespoons make 1 cup) before you add, and the amount of flour stays the same.
The same idea, other ways
Put the point P for the angle t on the unit circle and drop a line from P straight to the x-axis. Away from the axes you get a right triangle: the flat leg has length |cos t|, the upright leg has length |sin t|, and the slanted side is the radius, 1. The Pythagorean theorem says le + le = slanted sid, and a square is the same with or without the sign, so t + t = 1. On an axis the triangle flattens, and the identity still holds there: one of cos t and sin t is 0 and the other is 1 or −1. That is why knowing cos t pins down t: the two squares share the 1 between them.
tan t = is the height of P divided by its x coordinate: rise over run, the steepness of the radius. sin t = cos t says P is exactly as high as it is far to the right, like a ramp that climbs 1 foot for every foot forward. That ramp has slope 1, so tan t = 1. On the circle this happens at 45°, which is , and on the opposite side at 225°, which is , where both coordinates are negative and their quotient is again 1. Where cos t = 0 the radius stands straight up or down, a ramp with no run and no slope at all, and that is the angle a division by cos t cannot handle.
Try the swap at t = : t = ( = , and 1 − t = 1 − = . Same number, so putting one in place of the other cannot change whether an equation is true. Now try dividing at t = : sin t = 1 and cos t = 0, and 1 ÷ 0 has no answer. Tangent does not exist there, so a solution sitting at or would vanish in a division. That is why those two angles are tested first.
Keep the lonely one, swap the squared one. If an equation has t and a lone sin t, it will end up in sine; if it has t and a lone cos t, it ends up in cosine. If one sin t faces one cos t, knock on the doors at and , then divide to get tan t. If the same function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.
5 How
- Say what the equation asks: every solution on one turn, each t in [0, 2π) that makes the two sides equal.
- Rewrite with an identity until one trigonometric function of t is left; the strategy in this lesson says which identity. Write each swap inside parentheses.
- If you divide by cos t, first put t = and t = into the original equation and keep any that work.
- Get a 0 on one side. If the equation is a quadratic in the function or has a common factor, factor it, treating the function as a single unknown.
- Solve each piece with the reference angle and the quadrants. Throw out any value of sine or cosine outside [−1, 1].
- Put every answer into the original equation, not the rewritten one.
Choosing the identity that leaves one function
- Circle every trigonometric function in the equation and note its power: squared, like t, or alone, like sin t.
- If the same function is a factor of every term, do not divide by it: move every term to one side and factor it out.
- If one function is squared and the other is alone, keep the lonely one and swap the squared one with the identity, in parentheses.
- If both are squared and neither is alone, swap either one.
- If one sin t term faces one cos t term, test t = and t = in the original, then divide by cos t to reach tan t.
- Solve the one-function equation with the earlier methods, then check every answer in the original.
6 Worked example
Worked example
Swap the squared sine, then factor
Solve 2 t + 5 cos t = 4 for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle t on one turn, from 0 up to but not including , that makes 2 equal to 4.Solving a trigonometric equation on one turn means finding all such angles, not only one.
- Spot the two functions: is squared, and cos t stands alone.The methods you have need one function. The lonely one, cosine, is the one to keep, so the squared sine is the one to trade.
- Replace with (): .Subtracting t from both sides of t + t = 1 gives t = 1 − t at every angle, so the swap changes no answer. The parentheses keep the 2 on both pieces.
- Multiply out: .The 2 multiplies both the 1 and the −t.
- Subtract 4 from both sides: .The zero-product rule needs a zero on one side, and 2 − 4 = −2.
- Multiply both sides by : 2 .Every sign flips and 0 stays 0, so the solutions do not change, and a positive first term is friendlier to factor.
- Write u for cos t: . Factor it: .This is a quadratic in cos t, like the ones in the last lesson. Multiply back to check: 2 − 4u − u + 2 = 2 − 5u + 2.
- Set each factor to 0: gives , and gives .This finds the values of cos t that make a bracket zero, which makes the whole product zero. Plug back in: 2· − 1 = 0 and 2 − 2 = 0.
- So or . Throw out .Cosine is the x coordinate of a point on a circle of radius 1, so it is never larger than 1. No angle has cos t = 2.
- Solve : the reference angle is , and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so and .cos = . In quadrant IV the angle is a full turn minus the reference angle: − = .
Ladder: from easy to exam-hard
Try each rung before you open its steps.
Rung 1 of 6
Rung 1: one sine against one cosine
Solve sin t = cos t for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where sin t, the height of the point, equals times cos t, its x coordinate.On the unit circle, cos t and sin t are the two coordinates of the point for the angle t.
- Test where . At the left side is 1 and the right side is . At the left side is and the right side is 0. Neither works.We are about to divide by cos t, which is not allowed where cos t = 0, so those two angles are checked by hand. At the top and bottom of the circle sin t is 1 or −1, never 0, so dividing loses nothing.
- Divide both sides by cos t: , that is, .tan t means , so now only one function is left.
- Find the reference angle: , so it is .Dividing by is multiplying by 2, and × 2 = .
- Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III: and .In quadrant III both coordinates are negative, and a negative divided by a negative is positive. π + = + = .
Rung 2 of 6
Rung 2: move a term first, and the tangent comes out negative
Solve sin t + cos t = 0 for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn that makes equal to 0.Solving means finding all the angles that make the equation true.
- Subtract cos t from both sides: .Now one sine term faces one cosine term, the shape that turns into tangent.
- Test where . At : , not 0. At : , not 0.These are the only angles a division by cos t could lose. Neither is a solution, so dividing is safe.
- Divide both sides by : .On the left, sin t ÷ ( cos t) leaves , which is tan t. On the right, −cos t ÷ ( cos t) leaves −.
- Find the reference angle: , so it is .Dividing by is multiplying by , and the 2s cancel. is the same number as , the form your table may show.
- Tangent is negative in quadrants II and IV: and .There sine and cosine have opposite signs, so their quotient is negative. − = and − = .
Rung 3 of 6
Rung 3: the swap, then a common factor
Solve 2 t + sin t = 2 for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn that makes 2 equal to 2.Every such angle is a solution on one turn, and we want them all.
- is squared and sin t is alone, so keep sine and replace with (): .Subtracting t from both sides of t + t = 1 gives t = 1 − t at every angle, so the answers do not change.
- Multiply out: .The 2 multiplies both pieces inside the parentheses.
- Subtract 2 from both sides: . Multiply by : 2 .The zero-product rule needs a zero on one side, and multiplying by −1 keeps the same solutions.
- Pull out the common factor sin t: sin t .Both terms contain sin t. Multiply back to check: sin t·2 sin t − sin t·1 = 2 t − sin t.
- Set each factor to 0: , or , which gives .This finds the values of sine that make one factor zero. For the second, add 1 and divide by 2; plug back in: 2· − 1 = 0.
- at and .The height is 0 at the right and left ends of the circle. 2π is the same point as 0 and is not in [0, 2π).
- : the reference angle is , and sine is positive in quadrants I and II, so and .sin = , and the quadrant II angle is half a turn minus the reference angle.
- t = 0
- t = π
Rung 4 of 6
Rung 4: the same function in every term, so factor instead of dividing
Solve 2 sin t cos t = sin t for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where 2 sin t cos t equals .Each such angle is a solution, and a division could hide some of them.
- Notice that sin t is a factor of both sides, and test where . At : and . At : and . Both are solutions.Dividing by sin t is not allowed where sin t = 0, and here those angles are solutions, so a division would lose them. Factor instead.
- Subtract from both sides: .A zero on one side lets the zero-product rule work.
- Pull out sin t: sin t .Both terms contain sin t. Multiply back to check: sin t·2 cos t − sin t· = 2 sin t cos t − sin t.
- First factor: at and .These are the two angles found in the test, now found by the method.
- Second factor: gives .This finds the value of cosine that makes the second factor zero: add , then divide by 2. Plug back in: 2· − = 0.
- : the reference angle is , and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so and .cos = , and − = .
- t = 0
- t = π
Rung 5 of 6
Rung 5: the swap gives a full quadratic with three answers
Solve 2 t = 3 sin t + 3 for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where 2 equals .All such angles are the solutions on one turn.
- Keep the lonely sine and replace with (): .t = 1 − t at every angle, so no answer changes, and afterward sine is the only function left.
- Multiply out: .The 2 multiplies both pieces inside the parentheses.
- Add 2 to both sides and subtract 2 from both sides: .Moving every term to the right leaves a zero on the left and keeps the squared term positive; 3 − 2 = 1.
- Write u for sin t and factor: .Multiply back to check: 2u·u + 2u·1 + 1·u + 1·1 = 2 + 3u + 1.
- Set each factor to 0: gives , and gives .This finds the values of sine that make each factor zero. Plug back in: 2·(−) + 1 = 0 and −1 + 1 = 0. Both values lie in [−1, 1], so both stay.
- at .The height is −1 only at the bottom of the circle.
- : the reference angle is , and sine is negative in quadrants III and IV, so and .Below the x-axis the height is negative. + = and − = .
Rung 6 of 6
Rung 6, genuinely hard: both functions squared, solved two ways
Solve t = 3 t for every t in [0, 2π).
Show the steps and the answer
- Say what it asks: find every angle on one turn where the square of the sine is 3 times the square of the cosine.Solving means finding all such angles.
- Both functions are squared, so either one can be swapped. Replace with (): .t = 1 − t at every angle, and after the swap only cosine is left.
- Add to both sides: . Then subtract 1 from both sides and turn the equation around: 4 .This gathers the t terms on one side and leaves a zero on the other.
- Write u for cos t and factor: .Multiply back to check: 4 + 2u − 2u − 1 = 4 − 1, since the middle terms cancel.
- Set each factor to 0: gives , and gives .This finds the values of cosine that make each factor zero. Plug back in: 2· − 1 = 0 and 2·(−) + 1 = 0.
- : the reference angle is , and cosine is positive in quadrants I and IV, so and .cos = , and − = .
- : the reference angle is again , and cosine is negative in quadrants II and III, so and .Left of the y-axis the x coordinate is negative. − = and + = .
Counterexamples
What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.
Tips and tricks
- Memory device: keep the lonely one, swap the squared one. The function that appears without a square is the one the equation will end up in.
- Test a swap at one angle: the old form and the new form must give the same number. If you kept cosine, use t = 0, where cos t = 1; if you kept sine, use t = , where sin t = 1. For 2 t + 5 cos t at t = 0, the old form gives 0 + 5 = 5 and the new form 2 − 2 t + 5 cos t gives 2 − 2 + 5 = 5.
- Before you divide by cos t, knock on two doors: put t = and t = into the original equation. Any that works stays in the answer list. Dividing by sin t has the same two doors at t = 0 and t = π.
- Tangent's answers on one turn come in pairs exactly π apart, because its period is half a turn: and . The general solution of tan t = is t = + kπ for any integer k.
- Check in the original equation, not the rewritten one. The original is the question you were asked, and checking there also catches a slip made while rewriting.
7 The trap
Dividing both sides by cos t, or by sin t, without testing where it is zero. Division by zero is not allowed, so every solution with cos t = 0, at t = or t = , disappears without any warning; for sin t the angles are t = 0 and t = π. In 2 sin t cos t = cos t, a division loses and . Test those angles in the original equation before dividing, and when the function sits in every term, factor it out instead of dividing.
Flash cards
Say the answer out loud, then flip.
Why rewrite an equation that has both sin t and cos t with an identity before you solve it?
In 2 t + 3 cos t = 3, which function do you replace, and with what?
- Replace t with (1 − t) and keep the lonely cos t, because the identity t + t = 1 trades a square for a square.
- The parentheses make the 2 multiply both terms: 2(1 − t) + 3 cos t = 3, and cosine is the only function left.
How do you solve sin t = cos t on [0, 2π)?
- First test t = and t = , where cos t = 0, since a division by cos t would lose them if they were solutions. There sin t is 1 or −1 while cos t is 0, so neither works.
- Then divide both sides by cos t: tan t = .
- The reference angle is , and tangent is positive in quadrants I and III.
In 2 sin t cos t = sin t on [0, 2π), why factor out sin t instead of dividing both sides by it?
- Nothing can be divided by zero, so dividing by sin t throws away t = 0 and t = π, where sin t = 0, and both are solutions. Factoring keeps them:
- 2 sin t cos t − sin t = 0, so sin t (2 cos t − 1) = 0
- sin t = 0 gives t = 0 and t = π
- cos t = gives t = and t =