Quarry School

Trigonometry / Sum and difference formulas

Sum and difference formulas

Subject: Mathematics

All 7 lessons, in order.

The unit at a glance

  1. Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b

    Picture a Ferris wheel whose seats sit 1 unit from the center, with your seat starting at the far right.

  2. The cosine of a difference, from a distance on the circle

    Picture two seats on a Ferris wheel with a rope pulled tight from one to the other.

  3. The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

    The previous lesson built one formula, the one for cos(a − b).

  4. Exact values of angles such as 15 degrees and 75 degrees

    Your calculator says sin 15° is about 0.2588.

  5. The tangent of a sum or a difference

    The tangent of an angle measures steepness.

  6. Using the formulas from one value of each angle

    Every sine or cosine sum formula and difference formula is a recipe with four ingredients: the sine and the cosine of the first angle, and the sine and the cosine of the second.

  7. Reading a formula backwards

    In the earlier lessons each sum formula and difference formula worked forwards: one thing, sin(x − y), came apart into four pieces.

Rules (7)
  • Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b

    cos(a + b) ≠ cos a + cos b in general: for example, cos(π4 + π4) = cos π2 = 0, while cos π4 + cos π4 = 2. Sine behaves the same way: sin(a + b) ≠ sin a + sin b in general.

  • The cosine of a difference, from a distance on the circle

    For every pair of angles a and b, in degrees or in radians: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.

  • The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

    For every pair of angles a and b:
    cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b
    sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b
    sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b

  • Exact values of angles such as 15 degrees and 75 degrees

    If θ = a + b or θ = a − b, where a and b are special angles, the sum formula or the difference formula gives sin θ and cos θ exactly:
    sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b and sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b
    cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b and cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b

  • The tangent of a sum or a difference

    tan(a + b) = tana+tanb1−tanatanb and tan(a − b) = tana−tanb1+tanatanb
    Both need tan a and tan b to exist. When the bottom is 0, the tangent of the sum or difference is undefined.

  • Using the formulas from one value of each angle

    One value and the quadrant fix the other value of the same angle: cos a = ±1−sin2a and sin b = ±1−cos2b, each sign chosen by that angle's quadrant. Then sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b and cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.

  • Reading a formula backwards

    sin x cos y − cos x sin y = sin(x − y), for every pair of angles x and y. Every other sum formula and difference formula can be read from right to left in the same way, the tangent ones wherever they are defined; the table lists all six.

Recipes (7)
  • Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b
    1. Read the parentheses as an instruction: cos(a + b) means add the angles first, then take one cosine of the total.
    2. To test a claim such as cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, pick angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle: 0, π6, π4, π3, π2 or π.
    3. Work the left side: add the angles, find where the total turn lands on the unit circle, and read the x of that point.
    4. Work the right side: read the x for each angle on its own, then add the two numbers.
    5. Compare the two sides. If they differ, the claim is false and your pair is a counterexample. If they agree, nothing is proved yet: try another pair.
    6. Finish with a size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1, so a side outside that range cannot be a single cosine.
  • The cosine of a difference, from a distance on the circle
    1. Read what is asked: cos(a − b) is the cosine of one angle, the gap a − b. It is not two cosines with a minus between them.
    2. Name the angles: a is the angle before the minus sign and b is the angle after it.
    3. Write the four values cos a, sin a, cos b and sin b from the unit circle or the special triangles, each with the sign its quadrant gives it.
    4. Multiply the two cosines: cos a · cos b.
    5. Multiply the two sines: sin a · sin b.
    6. Add the two products. The sign between them is plus, even though the angle has a minus.
    7. Check: when the gap a − b is an angle whose cosine you know, the result must equal that cosine.
  • The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas
    1. Say what the question asks: is it a sine or a cosine, and are the two angles added or subtracted? Call the first angle a and the second b.
    2. Write the matching formula in letters, sign included, before any number goes in. Cosine matches like with like and switches the sign; sine mixes and keeps it.
    3. Find the four values cos a, sin a, cos b and sin b from the special triangles or the unit circle.
    4. Put each value in its place and do the two multiplications: top times top, bottom times bottom.
    5. Add or subtract the two results as the formula says, and simplify to an exact value: fractions and roots, no rounding.
    6. Check: if the whole angle a + b or a − b is one whose value you already know, find that value directly and compare.
  • Exact values of angles such as 15 degrees and 75 degrees
    1. Write the angle as a sum or a difference of two special angles, in the order that gives the angle itself (75° = 45° + 30°, 15° = 45° − 30°, −15° = 30° − 45°).
    2. Pick the formula that matches the question: sine or cosine, sum or difference.
    3. Write down sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b from the special-angle triangles, each with the sign of its quadrant.
    4. Substitute the four values into the formula, keeping the sign in the middle.
    5. Multiply each pair: tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms, and two roots join under one root.
    6. Combine the two products over their common bottom 4, leaving different roots apart.
    7. Check: compare the decimal of your answer with a calculator in the right mode, and ask whether the size and sign fit the picture.
  • The tangent of a sum or a difference
    1. Say what is asked: the tangent of a sum or difference of two angles, either an exact value for one angle or a value from two tangents you are given.
    2. If you start from one angle, write it as a sum or difference of two angles whose tangents you know. Leave out 90° and 270°, which have no tangent.
    3. Choose by the sign between the angles: the sum formula for a + b, the difference formula for a − b.
    4. Put each tangent in its place, and wrap a negative one in parentheses.
    5. Work out the bottom first. If it is 0, stop: the tangent of the sum or difference is undefined.
    6. Work out the top, divide the top by the bottom, and clear any square root from the bottom.
    7. Check: the sign must match the quadrant where the angle lands, and a calculator decimal must match your answer.
  • Using the formulas from one value of each angle
    1. Say in plain words what is given (one value of each angle and its quadrant) and what is asked (for example sin(a + b) and cos(a − b)).
    2. Write the four-slot list sin a, cos a, sin b, cos b, and copy in the two given values.
    3. Turn each given value into a right triangle: sine is yr and cosine is xr, with any minus sign on x or y and r always positive.
    4. Find the missing leg with x2 + y2 = r2, then give it the sign its quadrant demands.
    5. Write each missing value as that leg over r, so all four slots are full.
    6. Substitute the four values, each in parentheses, into the sum formula or difference formula, multiply, and combine over the common bottom.
    7. Check that each answer lies between −1 and 1 and that estimates of the angles give the same sign and size.
  • Reading a formula backwards
    1. Name the two functions in each product. A sine times a cosine in both products points to a sine formula. A cosine times a cosine in one product and a sine times a sine in the other point to a cosine formula. A fraction of tangents points to a tangent formula.
    2. Check that the same two angles appear in both products, that each angle switches function from one product to the other, and that no number multiplies only one product. If any check fails, stop: no formula packs it.
    3. Choose between x + y and x − y with Sine Same, Cosine Changes: a sine pattern keeps the sign between the products as the sign between the angles, a cosine pattern switches it, and a tangent fraction keeps it on top and switches it on the bottom.
    4. For a difference, put first the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine the order does not matter.
    5. Work out the one angle, giving fractions with π a common bottom, then evaluate its sine, cosine or tangent, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
    6. Check the answer a second way: a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or a test angle put into both the start and the answer.
Traps (7)
  • Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b

    Splitting the cosine over the plus sign: writing cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, or its twin cos(2a) = 2 cos a. Avoid it by adding the angles first and taking one cosine of the total, then checking that the answer lies from −1 to 1.

  • The cosine of a difference, from a distance on the circle

    Copying the minus sign. The angle inside is a − b, so a minus between the two products feels natural, but the formula has a plus: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b. Catch it with a = b: the gap is 0° and cos 0° = 1, and only the plus gives cos2a + sin2a = 1.

  • The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

    The sign in the cosine formulas. The cosine of a sum has a minus in the middle, and the cosine of a difference has a plus: cosine switches the sign you see inside, while sine keeps it. With a plus, cos(90° + 90°) would come out 0 · 0 + 1 · 1 = 1, but the point at 180° is (−1, 0), so the true value is −1. Write the formula in letters, sign included, before any number goes in, and say cosine switches, sine stays as you write it.

  • Exact values of angles such as 15 degrees and 75 degrees

    Getting the sign wrong in the cosine formula. cos 15° = cos(45° − 30°) has a plus in the middle: cos 30° cos 45° + sin 30° sin 45° = 6+24 ≈ 0.9659. Copying the minus from the angles gives 6−24 ≈ 0.2588, which is cos 75°, not cos 15°. Catch it with a size check: a small angle such as 15° has a cosine close to 1, so its cosine must be the larger of the two numbers.

  • The tangent of a sum or a difference

    Putting the same sign on the bottom as on top, for example 1 + tan a tan b in the sum formula. The bottom always takes the other sign. Test it with 45° + 45° = 90°, where tangent does not exist: the bottom must come out 0, and only 1 − 1 · 1 does.

  • Using the formulas from one value of each angle

    Dropping the sign of the missing value. The square root gives only the size, as in 225 = 15. Writing cos a = 1517 for an angle in Quadrant II turns the main example's sin(a + b) = 7785 into −1385. Choose the sign from the quadrant in the same step where you take the root, before the value goes anywhere near a formula.

  • Reading a formula backwards

    Taking the angles in the order they are printed. In a sine difference, the first angle is the one whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, wherever that sine is written. So cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65° is sin(65° − 20°) = 22, not sin(20° − 65°). The wrong order gives the negative of the right answer, because sin(−45°) = −sin 45°. Before you subtract, find the sine in the product before the minus sign and put its angle first.

Lesson 1 of 7

Why cos(a + b) is not cos a + cos b

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Sine and cosine on the unit circleLeans on: Radians and degreesLeans on: Inside the parentheses firstLeans on: Adding fractions with πLeans on: Adding like radicalsLeans on: The special valuesLeans on: Negative anglesOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Picture a Ferris wheel whose seats sit 1 unit from the center, with your seat starting at the far right. The cosine of a turn tells how far right of the center your seat ends up. Turn 45° upward: your seat is about 0.7 to the right. Turn 45° more: you are at the very top, 0 to the right. Now try the tempting shortcut and add the two single-turn answers: 0.7 + 0.7 = 1.4. That would put your seat 1.4 to the right, farther out than any seat on the wheel can go. Two turns in a row do not add their cosines, because the wheel is round. Turn first, then read the cosine of the whole turn.

2 Picture it

a = 45°b = 45°sum = 90°
Turn a = 45°, then b = 45° more from where you stopped.

Reminder

Reminder: Sine and cosine on the unit circle, Radians and degrees, Inside the parentheses first, Adding fractions with π, Adding like radicals, The special values, Negative angles
  • Sine and cosine on the unit circle. A turn of θ from the positive x-axis lands at a point (x, y) on the circle of radius 1; cos θ = x and sin θ = y. Example: π2 lands at (0, 1), so cos π2 = 0 and sin π2 = 1.
  • Radians and degrees. π = 180°, so π6 = 30°, π4 = 45°, π3 = 60° and π2 = 90°.
  • Inside the parentheses first. As in 2 × (3 + 4) = 2 × 7 = 14, the parentheses in cos(a + b) say to add the angles before taking the cosine.
  • Adding fractions with π. Same bottoms: add the tops, then reduce, so π4 + π4 = 2π4 = π2. Different bottoms: rewrite first, so π3 + π6 = 2π6 + π6 = 3π6 = π2.
  • Adding like radicals. Count the roots like apples: 22 + 22 = 222 = 2, since one 2 plus one 2 is two 2, and 22 = 1.
  • The special values. cos 0 = 1, cos π6 = 32 ≈ 0.866, cos π4 = sin π4 = 22 ≈ 0.7071, cos π3 = 12, cos π2 = 0 and cos π = −1 (decimals rounded).
  • Negative angles. A negative angle turns clockwise. −π3 = −60° lands at (12, −32), so cos(−π3) = 12, the same x as for π3.

3 Why

Every cosine is an x coordinate on the unit circle, so no cosine is bigger than 1. Yet cos a + cos b reaches 1 + 1 = 2 when a = b = 0, so the two sides cannot always agree. Sharper still, keep any a and put b = 0. Turning by 0 changes nothing, so the left side is cos a, while the right side is cos a + cos 0 = cos a + 1. No number equals itself plus 1. One failing case, called a counterexample, is enough to throw a rule out.

4 The rule

cos(a+b)≠cosa+cosb in general: for example, cos(π4+π4)=cosπ2=0, while cosπ4+cosπ4=2.

Sine behaves the same way: sin(a+b)≠sina+sinb in general.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

the cosine of the quantity a plus b is, in general, not the cosine of a plus the cosine of b.

Write it

Taking the cosine of the whole turn a + b usually gives a different number from taking the cosine of each turn and adding the two.

In math
  • cos(a + b) ≠ cos a + cos b, in general
  • cos(π4 + π4) = 0, but cos π4 + cos π4 = 2
  • cos(2a) ≠ 2 cos a, in general (the case a = b)
  • sin(a + b) ≠ sin a + sin b, in general
  • Graph words: on the graph of y = cos x, the height at x = a + b is, in general, not the height at x = a plus the height at x = b
Like

A taxi charges a $3 flat fee plus $2 a mile. One 10-mile ride costs $23, but two 5-mile rides cost $26, because splitting the trip pays the flat fee twice.

See it
(0, 1)
Turning π4 and then π4 more ends at the top point (0, 1), so the cosine of the whole turn is the x there: 0.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Start at (1, 0) on the unit circle. Turn a = 45°: the point lands at (22, 22), about (0.7071, 0.7071). Turn b = 45° more, starting where you stopped: the point lands at the top, (0, 1). The x, which is the cosine, went from 1 to about 0.7071 to 0. The first turn moved it left by about 0.29, the second by about 0.71, because the circle curves. Adding the two single-turn cosines, 0.7071 + 0.7071 = 1.4142, would put the point past the circle's right edge at x = 1.

b = 45°terminal sideinitial side
The second turn b starts where the first turn a stopped, at 45°, and ends pointing straight up, at 90°.
As a story

A taxi charges a $3 flat fee plus $2 a mile. One 10-mile ride costs 3 + 2 × 10 = $23. Two 5-mile rides cost 3 + 2 × 5 = $13 each, so $26 in all, because the flat fee is paid twice. The fare for a whole trip is not the fare for its first half plus the fare for its second half. Cosine has a flat fee of its own: a turn of 0 still has cosine 1. Turning by a and then by 0 is the same as turning by a, yet the shortcut cos a + cos 0 adds that 1 on top.

A rule of thumb

Most functions do not split over a plus sign, and you have met this before. (3 + 4)2 = 72 = 49, but 32 + 42 = 9 + 16 = 25. 9+16 = 25 = 5, but 9 + 16 = 3 + 4 = 7. Cosine joins the list. One kind of splitting that does work is multiplying by a number: 3(2 + 5) = 3 · 7 = 21, and 3 · 2 + 3 · 5 = 6 + 15 = 21. The cos in cos(a + b) is not a number being multiplied; it is the name of a function. Work out the inside first, then apply the function once.

(3 + 4)2 = 49, but 32 + 42 = 25

9+16 = 5, but 9 + 16 = 7

cos(π4 + π4) = 0, but cos π4 + cos π4 = 2

Inside first, then the function once

Why it must be true

Suppose cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b were true for every pair of angles, and put b = 0. Turning by a and then by 0 is the same as turning by a, so the left side is cos a. The right side is cos a + cos 0 = cos a + 1, because a turn of 0 leaves the point at (1, 0), whose x is 1. The rule would then say cos a = cos a + 1: a number equal to itself plus 1. No number is, so the rule breaks for every angle a as soon as b = 0.

(1, 0)
A turn of 0 leaves the point at (1, 0), so cos 0 = 1: the shortcut adds this 1 for nothing.
With small numbers

Try three small pairs, each with a = b. With a = b = 0, the left side is cos 0 = 1 and the right side is 1 + 1 = 2. With a = b = π2, the left side is cos π = −1 and the right side is 0 + 0 = 0. With a = b = π4, the left side is cos π2 = 0 and the right side is 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded). Three pairs, three mismatches: the shortcut is wrong, not unlucky.

(−1, 0)
Two quarter turns end at (−1, 0), so cos π = −1, while each quarter turn alone has cosine 0.
aba + bcos(a + b)cos a + cos bEqual?
00011 + 1 = 2no
π6π6π31232+32=3≈1.732no
π4π4π2022+22=2≈1.414no
π3π6π2012+32=1+32≈1.366no
π2π2π−10 + 0 = 0no
π3−π30112+12=1yes, by luck

5 How

  1. Read the parentheses as an instruction: cos(a + b) means add the angles first, then take one cosine of the total.
  2. To test a claim such as cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, pick angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle: 0, π6, π4, π3, π2 or π.
  3. Work the left side: add the angles, find where the total turn lands on the unit circle, and read the x of that point.
  4. Work the right side: read the x for each angle on its own, then add the two numbers.
  5. Compare the two sides. If they differ, the claim is false and your pair is a counterexample. If they agree, nothing is proved yet: try another pair.
  6. Finish with a size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1, so a side outside that range cannot be a single cosine.

Testing a claimed rule with numbers

1
Is the claim about cosine?
YesTry b = 0 first. The left side is cos a and the right side is cos a + 1, so the claim fails at once.
NoSkip 0 for sine: sin 0 = 0 makes both sides match and hides the mistake. Use a = b = π4 instead.
↓
2
Do the two sides give different numbers for your pair?
YesThe claim is false. Write the pair down as your counterexample; you are done.
NoNothing is proved. Pick a different pair, such as a = b = π4, and test again.
↓
3
Does the right side come out bigger than 1 or smaller than −1?
YesIt cannot equal the left side, which is one cosine and always lies from −1 to 1, so the claim is false.
NoThe size check passes, but compare the numbers anyway: −1 and 0 both pass it and are still different.
  1. Write the claim with its two sides apart: the left side cos(a + b) and the right side cos a + cos b.
  2. Choose angles whose exact values you know from the unit circle. For a cosine claim, b = 0 is the fastest choice; for a sine claim, avoid 0 and use π4 or π2.
  3. Work out each side on its own, inside the parentheses first.
  4. Compare. Different numbers: the claim is false, and your pair is a counterexample. Equal numbers: try another pair, because one match proves nothing.

6 Worked example

Worked example

The counterexample a = b = π4

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = π4 and b = π4.

Show the steps and the answer
a = 45°terminal sideinitial side
First turn: a = π4 = 45°, measured from the positive x-axis.
b = 45°terminal sideinitial side
Second turn: b = 45° more, starting where the first turn stopped, so the two together end straight up at 90°.
(0, 1)
The whole turn π2 ends at the top point (0, 1), so cos(a + b) is its x, 0.
x = cos θy = sin θP
One 45° turn lands at (22, 22), so each leg is about 0.7071 and two of them add to more than the radius 1.
  1. Say what the question asks: work out the left side and the right side with a=π4 and b=π4, then see whether the two numbers match.A rule has to give equal sides for every pair of angles, so one pair where the sides differ shows the claim is false.
  2. Left side, inside first: a+b=π4+π4=2π4=π2.The parentheses say to add the angles before taking any cosine. Both bottoms are 4, so add the tops, π + π = 2π, then divide the top and bottom of 2π4 by 2.
  3. Picture the two turns one after the other: 45° from the positive x-axis, then 45° more from where the first turn stopped. Together they make 90°, which ends at the top of the unit circle, the point (0, 1).π = 180°, so π4 = 45° and π2 = 90°, and a 90° turn from the positive x-axis points straight up.
  4. So cos(a+b)=cosπ2=0.The cosine of an angle is the x of the point where the turn lands, and the point (0, 1) has x = 0.
  5. Right side: cosπ4=22, an exact value.A 45° turn lands at (22, 22) on the unit circle, from the 45-45-90 triangle with hypotenuse 1, and the cosine is the x of that point.
  6. Add the two cosines: 22+22=222=2.The bottoms match, so add the tops: one 2 plus one 2 is two 2. Then 22 = 1 leaves 2.
  7. Compare: the left side is 0 and the right side is 2≈1.414 (rounded). They are different numbers.2 is a positive number, about 1.414, so it is not 0.
  8. Conclude: the claim is false, and the pair a=b=π4 is a counterexample.A counterexample is one case where a claimed rule gives the wrong answer, and one is enough to throw the rule out.
Answer
  • cos(π4+π4)=cosπ2=0
  • cos π4 + cos π4 = 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
  • The sides differ, so cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b is false.
Double-check Second way, with decimals: 22 ≈ 0.7071 (rounded), so the right side is about 0.7071 + 0.7071 = 1.4142, which matches 2 ≈ 1.4142. No cosine can be more than 1, because it is the x of a point on a circle of radius 1, so 2 cannot be the cosine of π2 or of any angle, while the left side, 0, is the x of the top point (0, 1).

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 5

No turn at all

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = 0 and b = 0.

Show the steps and the answer
(1, 0)
With no turn the point stays at (1, 0), so cos 0 = 1.
  1. Say what it asks: work out each side with a=0 and b=0, then compare.If the two sides differ for even one pair of angles, the claim is false.
  2. Left side: a+b=0+0=0, so cos(a+b)=cos0=1.Inside the parentheses first. A turn of 0 leaves the point at (1, 0), and the cosine is its x, 1.
  3. Right side: cos0+cos0=1+1=2.Each cos 0 is 1, for the same reason as on the left.
  4. Compare: 1≠2, so the claim fails.The two sides give different numbers for this pair, so a = b = 0 is a counterexample.
Answer
  • cos(0 + 0) = 1
  • cos 0 + cos 0 = 2
  • The claim fails.
Double-check Second way, a size check: a cosine is the x of a point on a circle of radius 1, so it is never more than 1. The right side, 2, is too big to be the cosine of any angle, so it cannot equal cos(0 + 0).

Rung 2 of 5

Two quarter turns

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = π2 and b = π2.

Show the steps and the answer
(−1, 0)
Two quarter turns make a half turn that ends at (−1, 0), so cos π = −1.
  1. Say what it asks: work out each side with a=b=π2, then compare.One pair where the sides differ is enough to show the claim is false.
  2. Left side, inside first: π2+π2=2π2=π.The bottoms match, so add the tops, then divide the top and bottom of 2π2 by 2.
  3. cosπ=−1.π = 180°, a half turn, which ends at the far left of the unit circle, (−1, 0), and the cosine is its x.
  4. Right side: cosπ2+cosπ2=0+0=0.A quarter turn, 90°, ends at the top, (0, 1), whose x is 0.
  5. Compare: −1≠0, so the claim fails again.The two sides give different numbers.
Answer
  • cos(π2+π2)=−1
  • cosπ2+cosπ2=0
  • The claim fails.
Double-check Second way, with a calculator set to degrees: cos 180° = −1 for the left side, and cos 90° = 0 twice for the right side, so 0 + 0 = 0. Both sides lie from −1 to 1 here, so the size check alone would not catch this one; comparing the numbers does.

Rung 3 of 5

Two different special angles

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = π3 and b = π6.

Show the steps and the answer
a = 60°b = 30°sum = 90°
A 60° turn and then a 30° turn make one 90° turn, which ends at the top of the circle where the cosine is 0.
  1. Say what it asks: work out each side with a=π3, which is 60°, and b=π6, which is 30°, then compare.One pair where the sides differ is enough to show the claim is false.
  2. Left side, inside first: π3+π6=2π6+π6=3π6=π2.The bottoms differ, so rewrite π3 with bottom 6 by multiplying its top and bottom by 2. Then add the tops, and divide the top and bottom of 3π6 by 3.
  3. cosπ2=0.60° + 30° = 90°, a quarter turn to the top point (0, 1), whose x is 0.
  4. Right side: cosπ3+cosπ6=12+32=1+32.60° lands at (12, 32) and 30° at (32, 12), from the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 1, so the cosines are 12 and 32. The bottoms match, so the tops go over one bottom. 1 and 3 are different kinds of number, so 1 + 3 stays as it is; it is not 4.
  5. Compare: 1+32≈1+1.7322=2.7322=1.366 (rounded), which is not 0. The claim fails.3 ≈ 1.732 (rounded), and a positive number divided by 2 is still positive, so it cannot be 0.
Answer
  • cos(π3+π6)=0
  • cos π3 + cos π6 = 1+32 ≈ 1.366 (rounded)
  • The claim fails.
Double-check Second way, a size check: 1+32 ≈ 1.366 is more than 1, and no cosine is more than 1, so the right side cannot be cos π2 or the cosine of any angle.

Rung 4 of 5

Sine has the same problem

Test the sine version, sin(a + b) = sin a + sin b, with a = π4 and b = π4.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 45° the y leg, sin π4, is about 0.7071, and two of them make about 1.414, taller than the whole radius 1.
  1. Say what it asks: this is the same test with sine in place of cosine, so work out each side and compare.Sine is the y of the point where a turn lands, so it can fail for the same reason cosine does.
  2. Left side: π4+π4=π2, so sin(a+b)=sinπ2=1.Two 45° turns end at the top point (0, 1), and the sine is its y, 1.
  3. Right side: sinπ4+sinπ4=22+22=2.A 45° turn lands at (22, 22), so each sine is 22, and two halves of 2 make one 2.
  4. Compare: 1≠2≈1.414 (rounded), so the sine claim fails too.The two sides give different numbers.
  5. Gotcha: do not test sine with b=0. Then sin(a+0)=sina and sina+sin0=sina+0=sina, which match for every a.sin 0 = 0, so adding it changes nothing; a test pair is useful only if it can show a difference.
Answer
  • sin(π4+π4)=1
  • sin π4 + sin π4 = 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded)
  • The sine claim fails too.
Double-check Second way, a size check: a sine is the y of a point on a circle of radius 1, so it is never more than 1. 2 ≈ 1.414 is more than 1, so the right side cannot be sin π2 or the sine of any angle.

Rung 5 of 5

A lucky match proves nothing

Test the claim cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b with a = π3 and b = −π3. Does the result rescue the claim?

Show the steps and the answer
b = −60°terminal sideinitial side
The second turn, b = −60°, swings clockwise back to where the first turn began, so the whole turn is 0.
  1. Say what it asks: work out each side with a=60° and b=−60°, compare, then decide whether one match can make the claim true.A rule must hold for every pair of angles, so one pair that agrees and one pair that disagrees carry very different weight.
  2. Left side, inside first: π3+(−π3)=0, so cos(a+b)=cos0=1.A number plus its negative is 0. Turning 60° one way and 60° back leaves the point where it started, at (1, 0).
  3. Right side: cosπ3+cos(−π3)=12+12=1.60° lands at (12, 32). A negative angle turns clockwise, so −60° lands at (12, −32), the mirror point below the x-axis with the same x, 12.
  4. Compare: 1=1. The two sides agree for this pair.Both sides came out to the same number.
  5. Decide: the claim is still false, because the pair a=b=π4 already breaks it, with 0 on the left and 2 on the right.A pair that disagrees disproves a claim; a pair that agrees shows only that the claim happens to work there.
Answer
  • cos(π3+(−π3))=1
  • cosπ3+cos(−π3)=1
  • The sides agree here by luck; the claim is still false.
Double-check Second way, with a calculator set to degrees: cos 0° = 1, and cos 60° = 0.5 and cos(−60°) = 0.5 add to 1, so the match is real. Now change b to −30°: the left side becomes cos 30° ≈ 0.866 while the right side is 0.5 + 0.866 = 1.366 (both rounded), so the match does not survive a small change.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Distribute the cos the way you distribute a 3: since 3(a + b) = 3a + 3b, write cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b.
In 3(a + b) the 3 is a number being multiplied, and multiplying does distribute: 3(2 + 5) = 3 · 7 = 21, and 3 · 2 + 3 · 5 = 6 + 15 = 21. In cos(a + b) the cos is not a number at all; it is the name of a function, an instruction to turn by a + b and read the x.
✓ Instead: Read cos(a + b) as an instruction: add the angles, then take one cosine of the total.
✗ Not this: cos(π4+π4)=cosπ4+cosπ4=2
2 ≈ 1.414 is more than 1, and a cosine, the x of a point on a circle of radius 1, is never more than 1.
✓ Instead: Add the angles first: cos(π4 + π4) = cos π2 = 0.
✗ Not this: cos(2a) = 2 cos a, for example cos(2 · π4) = 2 cos π4
cos(2a) is the cosine of the single angle a + a, so this is the same split in disguise. With a = π4: cos(2 · π4) = cos π2 = 0, but 2 cos π4 = 2 · 22 = 2.
✓ Instead: Double the angle first, then take one cosine: cos(2 · π4) = cos π2 = 0.
✗ Not this: sin(a + b) = sin a + sin b, since only cosine was shown to fail.
Sine fails the same way: sin(π4 + π4) = sin π2 = 1, but sin π4 + sin π4 = 2 ≈ 1.414 (rounded).
✓ Instead: Add the angles first for sine too: sin(π4 + π4) = sin π2 = 1.
✗ Not this: The sides matched for a = π3 and b = −π3, so cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b must be true.
That match is luck: cos 0 = 1 and 12 + 12 = 1. A rule must work for every pair, and a = b = π4 gives 0 against 2.
✓ Instead: One counterexample disproves a rule; one agreeing example proves nothing.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: turn first, cosine last. Add the angles inside the parentheses, then take one cosine of the whole turn.
  • Size check: one sine or one cosine always lies from −1 to 1. If a cosine comes out as 2 or 2 ≈ 1.414, something was split that should not have been.
  • The size check does not catch every mistake: with a = b = π2 the two sides are −1 and 0, both inside the range and still different. Compare the numbers as well.
  • Fastest test for a cosine claim: put b = 0. The left side stays cos a, but the right side becomes cos a + 1, one too big. For sine, 0 hides the mistake because sin 0 = 0, so test with a = b = π4 instead.
  • Write the parentheses. cos a + b means find cos a, then add the angle b; only cos(a + b) is the cosine of the whole turn.
  • The same warning holds for tangent: tan(π4 + π4) = tan π2 does not exist, since the top point (0, 1) would need 1 ÷ 0, while tan π4 + tan π4 = 1 + 1 = 2. The correct sum formula for each function is built in the lessons that follow.
  • In this lesson's table, a decimal after ≈ is rounded to three places.

7 The trap

Splitting the cosine over the plus sign: writing cos(a + b) = cos a + cos b, or its twin cos(2a) = 2 cos a. Avoid it by adding the angles first and taking one cosine of the total, then checking that the answer lies from −1 to 1.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Work out cos(a + b) and cos a + cos b for a = π6 and b = π3. Do they match?
  • cos(a + b) = cos π2 = 0, since π6 + π3 = π6 + 2π6 = 3π6 = π2.
  • cos a + cos b = 32 + 12 = 3+12 ≈ 1.37 (rounded).
  • They do not match. No seat on the Ferris wheel sits 1.37 to the right of the center, so 1.37 cannot be one cosine.
Someone writes sin(π2 + π2) = sin π2 + sin π2 = 2. What went wrong?
  • They split the sine over the plus sign.
  • Angles first: π2 + π2 = π, a half turn that leaves your Ferris wheel seat at the far left, level with the center, so sin π = 0.
  • Size check: sine is the seat's height above the center, never more than 1, so 2 cannot be one sine.
Does cos(2a) equal 2 cos a? Try a = π3.
  • No.
  • Angle doubled first: 2 · π3 = 2π3, and cos 2π3 = −12.
  • Cosine doubled: 2 · cos π3 = 2 · 12 = 1.
  • Twice the turn puts your Ferris wheel seat 12 to the left of the center, not 1 to the right.
For a = π3 and b = π, cos(a + b) and cos a + cos b agree. Are they equal for every a and b?
  • No.
  • Angles first: π3 + π = π3 + 3π3 = 4π3, and cos 4π3 = −12.
  • Cosines added: cos π3 + cos π = 12 + (−1) = −12, so this pair agrees by chance.
  • An agreeing pair proves nothing yet; one failing pair, a counterexample such as a = b = π4, throws the claim out.

Lesson 2 of 7

The cosine of a difference, from a distance on the circle

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: A point on the unit circleLeans on: The distance formulaLeans on: Squaring a differenceLeans on: Squaring a sumLeans on: What cos²t meansLeans on: The Pythagorean identityLeans on: Multiplying fractions with rootsLeans on: Signs when multiplyingLeans on: Special anglesLeans on: Signs by quadrantLeans on: Subtracting a negativeLeans on: Taking out a common factorLeans on: Keeping an equation balancedLeans on: Subtracting fractions of πOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Picture two seats on a Ferris wheel with a rope pulled tight from one to the other. A straight line joining two points of a circle is called a chord. When the wheel turns, both seats move together, so the rope keeps its length: it depends only on the gap between the seats, not on where the wheel stopped. If one seat sits at angle a and the other at angle b, the gap is a − b. You can measure that chord twice: once where the seats are, and once after turning the wheel until one seat reaches the 3 o'clock spot. The two lengths must agree, and writing that down gives the difference formula: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.

2 Picture it

a − b
The gap from the point at angle b to the point at angle a is a − b, and the chord between the two points…

Reminder

Reminder: A point on the unit circle, The distance formula, Squaring a difference, Squaring a sum, What cos2t means, The Pythagorean identity, Multiplying fractions with roots, Signs when multiplying, Special angles, Signs by quadrant, Subtracting a negative, Taking out a common factor, Keeping an equation balanced, Subtracting fractions of π
  • A point on the unit circle. The point at angle t is (cos t, sin t): x is the cosine, y is the sine. At 0° it is (1, 0); at 90° it is (0, 1).
  • The distance formula. d = (x2−x1)2+(y2−y1)2, so d2 = (x2 − x1)2 + (y2 − y1)2. From (1, 0) to (0, 1): d2 = (0 − 1)2 + (1 − 0)2 = 2, so d = 2.
  • Squaring a difference. (x − y)2 = x2 − 2xy + y2, three terms. Test: (5 − 2)2 = 9, and 25 − 20 + 4 = 9.
  • Squaring a sum. (x + y)2 = x2 + 2xy + y2. Test: (1 + 2)2 = 9, and 1 + 4 + 4 = 9.
  • What cos2t means. cos2t means (cos t)2: find the cosine, then square it. cos260° = (12)2 = 14.
  • The Pythagorean identity. cos2t + sin2t = 1 for every angle t, with the same t in both places. At 30°: 34 + 14 = 1.
  • Multiplying fractions with roots. Multiply top by top and bottom by bottom, using 3 · 3 = 3: 32 · 32 = 34, and 12 · 32 = 34.
  • Signs when multiplying. Negative times negative is positive, negative times positive is negative: (−12)(−32) = 34, and (−2)2 = 2.
  • Special angles. cos30°=32,sin30°=12;cos45°=sin45°=22;cos60°=12,sin60°=32.
  • Signs by quadrant. Quadrant II: cosine negative, sine positive. Quadrant III: both negative. Quadrant IV: cosine positive, sine negative. So cos 210° = −32, since 210° is 30° past 180° and lies in quadrant III.
  • Subtracting a negative. Taking away a negative adds: −32 − (−12) = −32 + 12 = 1−32.
  • Taking out a common factor. −2X − 2Y = −2(X + Y). Test with X = 3 and Y = 4: −6 − 8 = −14, and −2 · 7 = −14.
  • Keeping an equation balanced. Subtract the same number from both sides, or divide both sides by the same number that is not 0, and they stay equal: 2 − 2c = 2 − 2d becomes −2c = −2d, then c = d.
  • Subtracting fractions of π. Give them a common bottom first: π2 − π6 = 3π6 − π6 = 2π6 = π3.

3 Why

Take the chord between the points at angles a and b, (cos a, sin a) and (cos b, sin b). The distance formula, after expanding and using cos2t + sin2t = 1 twice, gives its squared length as 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b). Turn the circle back by b: the point at b lands on (1, 0), the point at a lands at angle a − b, and the squared length reads 2 − 2 cos(a − b). Turning cannot stretch a chord, so the results are equal, which forces cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.

4 The rule

For every pair of angles a and b, in degrees or in radians: cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

the cosine of a minus b equals cosine a times cosine b, plus sine a times sine b

Write it

The cosine of the gap between two angles equals the product of their cosines plus the product of their sines.

In math
  • cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb
  • cos(a−b)=cos(a)·cos(b)+sin(a)·sin(b)
  • cos(α−β)=cosαcosβ+sinαsinβ
  • cos(a − b) = x1x2 + y1y2, for the point (x1, y1) at angle a and the point (x2, y2) at angle b on the unit circle
  • chord picture: PQ2 = 2 − 2 cos(a − b), for the chord PQ between those two points
Like

Like the rope between two Ferris wheel seats: its length depends only on the gap between the seats, so you may measure it wherever the wheel happens to stop.

See it
a − b1
A slice with two radii of length 1 and the gap a − b between them.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Draw the unit circle with P at angle a, Q at angle b, and the straight chord PQ between them. Draw it a second time after turning the whole circle back by b: Q now sits at 3 o'clock, the point (1, 0), and P sits at angle a − b. The two drawings show one chord, moved but not stretched. Measure it in each drawing with the distance formula and set the two answers equal.

Before the turn: P = (cos a, sin a), Q = (cos b, sin b)

After turning back by b: P = (cos(a − b), sin(a − b)), Q = (1, 0)

One chord, so the two values of PQ2 are equal

As a story

Two friends ride a Ferris wheel in seats joined by a tight rope. You can measure the rope right now, wherever the seats happen to be. Or you can wait until the wheel carries one friend to the 3 o'clock spot and measure it then. The rope has not changed, so both measurements give the same number. The first measurement comes out in terms of cos a, cos b, sin a and sin b; the second in terms of cos(a − b). Saying the two are equal is the formula.

With small numbers

Take a = 180° and b = 90°. Where they sit, P = (−1, 0) and Q = (0, 1), so PQ2 = (−1 − 0)2 + (0 − 1)2 = 1 + 1 = 2. Turned back by 90°, P moves to 90°, the point (0, 1), and Q moves to (1, 0), so PQ2 = (0 − 1)2 + (1 − 0)2 = 2 again. The formula agrees: cos 180° cos 90° + sin 180° sin 90° = (−1)(0) + (0)(1) = 0, and cos(180° − 90°) = cos 90° = 0.

where they sit: P = (−1, 0), Q = (0, 1), PQ2 = 1 + 1 = 2

turned back by 90°: P = (0, 1), Q = (1, 0), PQ2 = 1 + 1 = 2

formula: (−1)(0) + (0)(1) = 0 = cos 90°

Why it must be true

Work out the squared chord with letters and it always comes out as 2 minus 2 times something. Measured where the points sit, the something is cos a cos b + sin a sin b. Measured after the turn, the something is cos(a − b). One chord cannot have two lengths, so 2 − 2 × (the first something) equals 2 − 2 × (the second something), and that can only happen when the two somethings are equal.

where it sits: PQ2 = 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b)

after the turn: PQ2 = 2 − 2 cos(a − b)

one chord, one length: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b

As a rule of thumb

Multiply matching coordinates and add. With P = (cos a, sin a) and Q = (cos b, sin b), x times x plus y times y is cos(a − b). It measures how well the two points line up: 1 when they are the same point, 0 when they are a quarter turn apart, −1 when they sit opposite each other. Try (1, 0) and (0, 1): 1 · 0 + 0 · 1 = 0 = cos 90°.

x = cos θy = sin θ(cos a, sin a)
Each point on the unit circle carries its cosine as x and its sine as y, so the formula multiplies x by x and…
aba−bcos a cos bsin a sin btheir sumcos(a−b)
60°60°0°143411
90°30°60°0121212
135°45°90°−121200
210°120°90°34−3400
300°60°240°14−34−12−12
30°90°−60°0121212

5 How

  1. Read what is asked: cos(a − b) is the cosine of one angle, the gap a − b. It is not two cosines with a minus between them.
  2. Name the angles: a is the angle before the minus sign and b is the angle after it.
  3. Write the four values cos a, sin a, cos b and sin b from the unit circle or the special triangles, each with the sign its quadrant gives it.
  4. Multiply the two cosines: cos a · cos b.
  5. Multiply the two sines: sin a · sin b.
  6. Add the two products. The sign between them is plus, even though the angle has a minus.
  7. Check: when the gap a − b is an angle whose cosine you know, the result must equal that cosine.

Deriving the difference formula: one chord, measured two ways

1
Is each point written as (cos of its angle, sin of its angle)?
YesGo on to the distance formula.
NoRewrite it first: on the unit circle the point at angle t is (cos t, sin t), and the point at 0° is (1, 0).
↓
2
Did each squared bracket expand into three terms, including a middle term?
YesGo on to pairing.
NoExpand again with (x − y)2 = x2 − 2xy + y2; only two terms means the middle one was lost.
↓
3
Is every cos2 paired with the sin2 of the same angle?
YesReplace each pair by 1.
NoPair them again: cos2a + sin2b is not 1 in general.
↓
4
Do both measurements have the shape 2 − 2 × (something)?
YesSet them equal, subtract 2 from both sides, divide both sides by −2.
NoAn expansion went wrong; redo that measurement before setting anything equal.
  1. Draw the unit circle with P at angle a and Q at angle b, and write them as P = (cos a, sin a) and Q = (cos b, sin b).
  2. First measurement: put P and Q into the squared distance formula, PQ2 = (cos a − cos b)2 + (sin a − sin b)2.
  3. Expand both squares, pair cos2a with sin2a and cos2b with sin2b, replace each pair by 1, and take out −2: PQ2 = 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b).
  4. Turn the circle back by b, so every angle loses b. Q lands on (1, 0) and P lands on (cos(a − b), sin(a − b)); the chord moves with them and keeps its length.
  5. Second measurement: PQ2 = (cos(a − b) − 1)2 + sin2(a − b) = 2 − 2 cos(a − b), after expanding and using cos2(a − b) + sin2(a − b) = 1.
  6. Equate the two expressions for the squared distance, take 2 away from each side, and divide each side by −2: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.

6 Worked example

Worked example

One chord, two ways: the points at 90° and 30°

On the unit circle, P is the point at 90° and Q is the point at 30°. Find the length of the chord PQ where it sits, and again after turning the circle back (clockwise) by 30°. Then test the difference formula with a = 90° and b = 30°. In plain words: measure one straight line in two pictures, check that the two lengths agree, and check that cos 90° cos 30° + sin 90° sin 30° equals cos(90° − 30°).

90° − 30° = 60°
Where the points sit: Q at 30°, P at 90°, a 60° gap between them.
60°
After turning back by 30°: Q at 3 o'clock and P at 60°, the same 60° gap.
Show the steps and the answer
30°60°√31245°45°11√2
The 30-60-90 triangle.
  1. Write the points where they sit: P=(cos90°,sin90°)=(0,1) and Q=(cos30°,sin30°)=(32,12).On the unit circle the point at angle t is (cos t, sin t). 90° points straight up, and the 30° values come from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  2. First way: PQ2=(0−32)2+(1−12)2.The distance formula subtracts the x's and the y's, squares each difference and adds. Working with PQ2 leaves the square root for the very end.
  3. Work out each square: (−32)2=34, and 1−12=12, so (12)2=14.To square a fraction, square its top and its bottom; 3 · 3 = 3, and a negative number times itself is positive.
  4. Add: PQ2=34+14=44=1.The bottoms match, so add the tops.
  5. Turn the circle back by 30°: Q moves to 30°−30°=0°, the point (1, 0), and P moves to 90°−30°=60°, the point (12,32).Turning back by 30° takes 30° off every angle. Both points move together, so the chord between them keeps its length.
  6. Second way: PQ2=(12−1)2+(32−0)2=(−12)2+34=14+34=1.The same distance formula on the turned points; 12 − 1 = −12, whose square is 14.
  7. Both ways give PQ2=1, so PQ =1=1.A length is never negative, so PQ is the positive square root of PQ2.
  8. Formula side: cos90°cos30°+sin90°sin30°=0·32+1·12=12.From P = (0, 1), cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1; anything times 0 is 0.
  9. Gap side: cos(90°−30°)=cos60°=12. The two sides match.After the turn, P sat at 60°, and its x coordinate is cos 60° = 12.
Answer
  • PQ = 1 both ways.
  • cos90°cos30°+sin90°sin30°=12=cos(90°−30°).
Double-check Look at the triangle made by the center O and the points P and Q. Its sides OP and OQ are radii, both 1 long, with the 60° gap between them. A triangle with two equal sides is a mirror image of itself across its middle, so its other two angles are equal; together they make 180° − 60° = 120°, so each is 120° ÷ 2 = 60°. A triangle whose three angles are all 60° has three equal sides (it is the triangle that the 30-60-90 triangle is half of), so PQ = OP = 1, as both measurements found.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 7

Rung 1: the same point twice

Use the difference formula with a = 60° and b = 60°, and compare the result with cos(60° − 60°). In plain words: when both angles are the same, does the formula give the cosine of a 0° gap?

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θa = b = 60°
Both angles name the same point, so the chord from it to itself has length 0.
  1. Find the gap and its cosine: 60°−60°=0°, and cos0°=1.The point at 0° on the unit circle is (1, 0), and the cosine is its x coordinate.
  2. Write the values: cos60°=12 and sin60°=32.The 30-60-90 triangle, shrunk to hypotenuse 1, has 12 next to the 60° angle and 32 across from it.
  3. Fill in the formula: cos60°·cos60°+sin60°·sin60°=12·12+32·32=14+34.Multiply top by top and bottom by bottom; 3 · 3 = 3.
  4. Add: 14+34=44=1.The bottoms match, so add the tops.
Answer
Both sides equal 1.
Double-check With a = b, the formula's right side is cos260° + sin260°, and cos2t + sin2t = 1 holds for every angle t, so it had to come out 1.

Rung 2 of 7

Rung 2: a level chord, 135° and 45°

P is the point at 135° and Q is the point at 45° on the unit circle. Find PQ2 where the points sit and again after turning the circle back by 45°, then compare cos 135° cos 45° + sin 135° sin 45° with cos(135° − 45°). In plain words: measure one chord in two places, then test the formula on these two angles.

Show the steps and the answer
135° − 45° = 90°
The gap from 45° to 135° is a quarter turn.
  1. Write the points: P=(−22,22) and Q=(22,22).135° is 45° short of 180°, in quadrant II, where cosine is negative and sine is positive; at 45° both values are 22.
  2. First way: PQ2=(−22−22)2+(22−22)2=(−2)2+02=2.Two halves of 2 make one 2, here with a minus; equal heights subtract to 0; and (−2)2 = 2.
  3. Turn the circle back by 45°: Q moves to 0°, the point (1, 0), and P moves to 135°−45°=90°, the point (0, 1).Turning back by 45° takes 45° off both angles, and the chord moves with them unchanged.
  4. Second way: PQ2=(0−1)2+(1−0)2=1+1=2.The distance formula on the turned points.
  5. Formula side: (−22)·22+22·22=−24+24=0.2 · 2 = 2; a negative times a positive is negative, so the two products cancel.
  6. Gap side: cos(135°−45°)=cos90°=0. The two sides match.The point at 90° is (0, 1), whose x coordinate is 0.
Answer
  • PQ2 = 2 both ways, so PQ = 2.
  • The formula gives 0 = cos 90°.
Double-check Both points sit at the same height, 22, so the chord is level and its length is the distance between the x's: 22 − (−22) = 2, and (2)2 = 2.

Rung 3 of 7

Rung 3: negatives and roots, 210° and 120°

P is the point at 210° and Q is the point at 120° on the unit circle. Find PQ2 where the points sit and after turning the circle back by 120°, then test the difference formula with a = 210° and b = 120°. In plain words: the same two measurements, with coordinates that are negative and contain roots.

Show the steps and the answer
210° − 120° = 90°
Another quarter turn of gap, this time reaching from quadrant II into quadrant III.
  1. Write the points: P=(−32,−12) and Q=(−12,32).210° is 30° past 180°, in quadrant III, where cosine and sine are both negative; 120° is 60° short of 180°, in quadrant II, where cosine is negative and sine positive.
  2. Find the differences. x: −32−(−12)=1−32. y: −12−32=−1+32.Taking away a negative adds; both fractions have bottom 2, so the tops combine.
  3. Square them: (1−32)2=1−23+34=4−234, and (−1+32)2=1+23+34=4+234.(x − y)2 = x2 − 2xy + y2 and (x + y)2 = x2 + 2xy + y2, with x = 1 and y = 3; the bottom 2 squares to 4, and a negative squared is positive.
  4. Add: PQ2=4−23+4+234=84=2.The −23 and the +23 cancel.
  5. Turn the circle back by 120°: Q moves to 0°, the point (1, 0), and P moves to 210°−120°=90°, the point (0, 1). Then PQ2=(0−1)2+(1−0)2=2.Both points turn together, so the chord is the same; the turned points have whole-number coordinates.
  6. Formula side: (−32)·(−12)+(−12)·32=34−34=0.A negative times a negative is positive; a negative times a positive is negative.
  7. Gap side: cos(210°−120°)=cos90°=0. The two sides match.The point at 90° is (0, 1).
Answer
  • PQ2 = 2 both ways, so PQ = 2.
  • The formula gives 0 = cos 90°.
Double-check In decimals, with 3 ≈ 1.732, the differences are about −0.366 and −1.366, whose squares are about 0.134 and 1.866, adding to about 2.000 (rounded). Rung 2 also had a 90° gap and also gave PQ2 = 2: equal gaps, equal chords, which is the idea this lesson rests on.

Rung 4 of 7

Rung 4: a gap past half a turn, 300° and 60°

P is the point at 300° and Q is the point at 60° on the unit circle. Find PQ2 both ways and test the difference formula with a = 300° and b = 60°. In plain words: the gap 300° − 60° = 240° is more than half a turn; does the method still work, and does the formula give a negative cosine correctly?

Show the steps and the answer
300° − 60° = 240°
The gap runs more than half a turn.
  1. Write the points: P=(12,−32) and Q=(12,32).300° is 60° short of 360°, in quadrant IV, where cosine is positive and sine negative; 60° gives (12, 32).
  2. First way: PQ2=(12−12)2+(−32−32)2=02+(−3)2=3.The x's are equal; two halves of 3, with a minus, make −3; and (−3)2 = 3.
  3. Turn the circle back by 60°: Q moves to 0°, the point (1, 0), and P moves to 300°−60°=240°, the point (−12,−32).240° is 60° past 180°, in quadrant III, where both coordinates are negative.
  4. Second way: PQ2=(−12−1)2+(−32−0)2=(−32)2+34=94+34=124=3.−12 − 1 = −32, whose square is 94; a negative squared is positive.
  5. Formula side: 12·12+(−32)·32=14−34=−24=−12.3 · 3 = 3, a negative times a positive is negative, and 24 reduces to 12.
  6. Gap side: cos(300°−60°)=cos240°=−12. The two sides match.The turned point P = (−12, −32) sits at 240°, and its x coordinate is −12.
Answer
  • PQ2 = 3 both ways, so PQ = 3.
  • The formula gives −12 = cos 240°.
Double-check P and Q share the x coordinate 12, so the chord stands upright and its length is the distance between the heights: 32 − (−32) = 3, whose square is 3.

Rung 5 of 7

Rung 5: the first way, with letters

For any angles a and b, let P = (cos a, sin a) and Q = (cos b, sin b). Show that PQ2 = 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b). In plain words: do the first measurement once with letters, so it covers every pair of angles at the same time.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ(cos a, sin a)
Each end of the chord is written with its own angle.
  1. PQ2=(cosa−cosb)2+(sina−sinb)2.The squared distance formula, with x's cos a and cos b and y's sin a and sin b.
  2. First square: (cosa−cosb)2=cos2a−2cosacosb+cos2b.(x − y)2 = x2 − 2xy + y2, with x = cos a and y = cos b.
  3. Second square: (sina−sinb)2=sin2a−2sinasinb+sin2b.The same pattern, with x = sin a and y = sin b.
  4. Regroup: PQ2=(cos2a+sin2a)+(cos2b+sin2b)−2cosacosb−2sinasinb.Terms joined by adding may be put in any order; this sets each angle's own cos2 and sin2 side by side.
  5. Replace each pair by 1: PQ2=1+1−2cosacosb−2sinasinb=2−2cosacosb−2sinasinb.cos2t + sin2t = 1 for every angle t, used once with t = a and once with t = b.
  6. Take out −2: PQ2=2−2(cosacosb+sinasinb).−2X − 2Y = −2(X + Y), with X = cos a cos b and Y = sin a sin b; multiplying the bracket back out returns the two terms.
Answer
PQ2 = 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b)
Double-check Put in a = 90° and b = 30°: 2 − 2(0 · 32 + 1 · 12) = 2 − 2 · 12 = 1, the same PQ2 = 1 that the worked example found with numbers.

Rung 6 of 7

Rung 6: the second way, with letters

Show that the chord from the point (cos t, sin t) to the point (1, 0) has squared length 2 − 2 cos t. In plain words: when one end of the chord sits at 3 o'clock, its squared length depends on one cosine only.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ(cos t, sin t)
One end of the chord is (cos t, sin t); the other end is (1, 0), where the circle crosses the positive x-axis.
  1. PQ2=(cost−1)2+(sint−0)2.The squared distance formula, with (1, 0) as the second point.
  2. First square: (cost−1)2=cos2t−2cost+1.(x − y)2 = x2 − 2xy + y2, with x = cos t and y = 1: 2 · cos t · 1 = 2 cos t and 12 = 1.
  3. Second square: (sint−0)2=sin2t.Taking away 0 changes nothing.
  4. Add and regroup: PQ2=(cos2t+sin2t)−2cost+1=1−2cost+1=2−2cost.cos2t + sin2t = 1, and 1 + 1 = 2.
Answer
PQ2 = 2 − 2 cos t
Double-check Take t = 180°: the point is (−1, 0), and the chord runs straight through the center from one side of the circle to the other, so its length is 2 and PQ2 = 4. The formula gives 2 − 2 cos 180° = 2 − 2(−1) = 4.

Rung 7 of 7

Rung 7: the two ways together

Use rungs 5 and 6 to show that cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b for every pair of angles a and b. In plain words: measure one chord in two places with letters, set the two answers equal, and solve for cos(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer

where it sits: PQ2 = 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b)

after the turn: PQ2 = 2 − 2 cos(a − b)

subtract 2: −2 cos(a − b) = −2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b)

divide by −2: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b

  1. Put P at angle a and Q at angle b. By rung 5, PQ2=2−2(cosacosb+sinasinb).This is the first measurement, made where the points sit.
  2. Turn the circle back by b: Q moves to angle b−b=0, the point (1, 0), and P moves to angle a−b, the point (cos(a−b),sin(a−b)).Turning back by b takes b off every angle, and the point at any angle t is (cos t, sin t).
  3. By rung 6 with t=a−b, the turned chord has PQ2=2−2cos(a−b).A turn moves the chord without stretching it, like the rope between two Ferris wheel seats, so this is the same chord measured again.
  4. Set the two equal: 2−2cos(a−b)=2−2(cosacosb+sinasinb).They are two measurements of one length.
  5. Subtract 2 from both sides: −2cos(a−b)=−2(cosacosb+sinasinb).This removes the 2 that both sides share; taking the same amount from both sides keeps them equal.
  6. Divide both sides by −2: cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb.This frees cos(a − b); dividing both sides by the same number that is not 0 keeps them equal.
Answer
cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, for every pair of angles a and b.
Double-check Test it on a case where a is smaller than b, so the gap is negative: a = 30° and b = 90°. The formula gives 32 · 0 + 12 · 1 = 12. The gap is 30° − 90° = −60°, the point reached by turning 60° clockwise from 3 o'clock, which is (12, −32), so cos(−60°) = 12. The two match.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: cos(a−b)=cosa−cosb
Cosine does not split across a minus sign, any more than it splits across a plus. Take a = b = 50°: the left side is cos 0° = 1, but the right side is cos 50° − cos 50° = 0.
✓ Instead: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b. With a = b = 50° it gives cos250° + sin250° = 1, which matches cos 0° = 1.
✗ Not this: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b, with the minus sign copied into the middle
Take a = b = 90°: this version gives 0 · 0 − 1 · 1 = −1, but cos(90° − 90°) = cos 0° = 1. The version with a minus in the middle belongs to a different angle, taken up in the next lesson.
✓ Instead: A plus in the middle: cos 90° cos 90° + sin 90° sin 90° = 0 · 0 + 1 · 1 = 1 = cos 0°.
✗ Not this: (cos a − cos b)2 = cos2a − cos2b, dropping the middle term
Squaring a difference gives three terms, not two. With numbers, (5 − 2)2 = 9, but 52 − 22 = 21. The dropped term, −2 cos a cos b, is the very piece that grows into the formula.
✓ Instead: (cosa−cosb)2=cos2a−2cosacosb+cos2b.
✗ Not this: Replacing cos2a + sin2b by 1
The identity cos2t + sin2t = 1 needs the same angle in both places. With a = 0° and b = 90°: cos20° + sin290° = 1 + 1 = 2, not 1.
✓ Instead: Pair cos2a with sin2a, and cos2b with sin2b. Each pair is 1, so the two pairs make 2.
✗ Not this: Taking the chord to be the curved arc between the two points
The arc bends along the circle, while the chord cuts straight across, and the distance formula measures straight lines. For a 60° gap on the unit circle the arc is π3 ≈ 1.047 long (rounded), but the chord is 1.
✓ Instead: The chord is the straight segment PQ, and its length comes from the distance formula.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: minus inside, plus outside. In the formula, like pairs with like: cos a with cos b, sin a with sin b.
  • Sign check: put a = b. The gap is 0° and cos 0° = 1. The plus version gives cos2a + sin2a = 1; a minus version fails, for example cos290° − sin290° = 0 − 1 = −1.
  • Zero check: put b = 0°. The formula gives cos a · 1 + sin a · 0 = cos a, as it must, since a − 0° = a.
  • Order does not matter: swapping a and b leaves cos a cos b + sin a sin b unchanged, so cos(30° − 90°) = cos(90° − 30°) = 12. The chord does not care which end you name first.
  • Radians work the same way: cos(π2 − π6) = 0 · 32 + 1 · 12 = 12, and π2 − π6 = π3, whose cosine is 12.
  • Compare PQ2, not PQ. Equal lengths have equal squares, and the squared form never needs a square root.
  • Know the formula cold: the next lessons build on it. The derivation you do not need to memorize; rebuild it from the picture of one chord in two places.

7 The trap

Copying the minus sign. The angle inside is a − b, so a minus between the two products feels natural, but the formula has a plus: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b. Catch it with a = b: the gap is 0° and cos 0° = 1, and only the plus gives cos2a + sin2a = 1.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Complete the difference formula: cos(a − b) = ?
  • cos a cos b + sin a sin b
  • Cosines pair with cosines, sines pair with sines. Minus in the angle, plus in the answer.
The angle in cos(a − b) has a minus, but the difference formula has a plus. How does choosing a = b confirm the plus?
  • With a = b the gap is 0°, and cos 0° = 1.
  • The plus gives cos a cos a + sin a sin a = cos2a + sin2a = 1, a match.
  • A minus would give cos2a − sin2a, which is 0 − 1 = −1 at a = 90°, so it cannot be right.
Why must 2 − 2 cos(a − b) equal 2 − 2(cos a cos b + sin a sin b)?
  • Both are the squared length of the same chord, the one joining the points at angles a and b.
  • The right side measures it where the points sit. The left side measures it after the circle turns back by b, moving the point at b to (1, 0) at 3 o'clock and the point at a to angle a − b.
  • Turning cannot stretch a chord, any more than a turning Ferris wheel stretches a rope between two seats, so the two must agree. Setting them equal gives the difference formula.
Find cos(90° − 30°) with the difference formula, and say why cos 90° − cos 30° is the wrong move.
  • cos90°cos30°+sin90°sin30°=0·32+1·12=12
  • Check: the gap is 60°, and cos 60° = 12.
  • cos 90° − cos 30° = 0 − 32 = −32, a different number: cos(a − b) is the cosine of one angle, the gap, not two cosines with a minus between them.

Lesson 3 of 7

The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Taking away and adding negativesLeans on: Turning by a negative angleLeans on: CofunctionsLeans on: A minus sign in front of bracketsLeans on: Radians to degreesLeans on: The special valuesLeans on: Multiplying fractions and rootsLeans on: Signs when multiplyingLeans on: Adding fractions with the same bottomOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 1

1 In plain words

The previous lesson built one formula, the one for cos(a − b). Think of it as a machine with two slots. Drop any two angles in, and it hands back the cosine of their difference. This lesson gets three more formulas out of that one machine. You change only what you drop in. Drop in −b where b goes: undoing a step backward is the same as taking a step forward, so out comes cos(a + b), the cosine of a sum. For the sine formulas, first trade the sine for a cosine: the sine of an angle is the cosine of what is left of a right angle. Then that cosine goes into the same machine.

2 Picture it

cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb

put −b in place of b:

cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb

write sin t as cos(π2 − t):

sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b

put −b in place of b:

sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb

Reminder

Reminder: Taking away and adding negatives, Turning by a negative angle, Cofunctions, A minus sign in front of brackets, Radians to degrees, The special values, Multiplying fractions and roots, Signs when multiplying, Adding fractions with the same bottom
  • Taking away and adding negatives. Taking away a negative is adding: 5 − (−3) = 5 + 3 = 8, so a − (−b) = a + b. Adding a negative is taking away: 7 + (−2) = 7 − 2 = 5, so a + (−b) = a − b.
  • Turning by a negative angle. A negative angle turns clockwise and lands at the mirror image across the x-axis: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b. For example cos(−30°) = 32 and sin(−30°) = −12.
  • Cofunctions. The sine of an angle is the cosine of what is left of a right angle, and the other way around: sin t = cos(π2 − t) and cos t = sin(π2 − t). For example sin 30° = cos 60° = 12.
  • A minus sign in front of brackets. A minus in front of brackets changes the sign of everything inside: 10 − (3 + 2) = 10 − 3 − 2 = 5.
  • Radians to degrees. π is 180°, so π6 = 30°, π4 = 45°, π3 = 60°, π2 = 90° and 2π3 = 120°.
  • The special values. sin 30° = 12, cos 30° = 32, sin 45° = cos 45° = 22, sin 60° = 32 and cos 60° = 12. At 0° the point on the unit circle is (1, 0) and at 90° it is (0, 1), so cos 0° = 1, sin 0° = 0, cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1.
  • Multiplying fractions and roots. Top times top, bottom times bottom: 12 · 32 = 34. A square root times itself gives the number inside: 3 · 3 = 3 and 2 · 2 = 2.
  • Signs when multiplying. A negative times a positive is negative: (−12) · 12 = −14. A negative times a negative is positive: (−2) · (−3) = 6.
  • Adding fractions with the same bottom. Add or subtract the tops and keep the bottom: 34 − 14 = 24, and dividing top and bottom by 2 gives 12.

3 Why

The formula for cos(a − b) holds for any two angles, so −b or π2 − a may go into its slots. Two facts finish the work. Turning by −b mirrors turning by b across the x-axis: the point keeps its x and flips its y, so cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b. And sin t = cos(π2 − t) holds for every angle, not only in a triangle: since the point at π2 is (0, 1), the same formula gives cos(π2 − t) = 0 · cos t + 1 · sin t = sin t.

4 The rule

For every pair of angles a and b:cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinbsin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinbsin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb

The same idea, five ways

Say it

the cosine of a plus b is cos a cos b minus sin a sin b. The sine of a plus b is sin a cos b plus cos a sin b. The sine of a minus b is sin a cos b minus cos a sin b.

Write it

The cosine of a sum of two angles equals their cosines multiplied together, minus their sines multiplied together. The sine of a sum equals the sine of the first angle times the cosine of the second, plus the cosine of the first times the sine of the second; for the sine of a difference, that plus becomes a minus.

In math
  • cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb
  • sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b
  • sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb
  • sin(a ± b) = sin a cos b ± cos a sin b, reading all the top signs together, then all the bottom signs together
  • cos(a ± b) = cos a cos b ∓ sin a sin b, where ∓ is the opposite of the sign inside: a plus inside gives a minus
Like

Like a machine with two slots that only serves the cosine of a difference: drop −b into the second slot, or the leftover angle π2 − a into the first, and the same machine serves sums and sines.

See it
x = cos θy = sin θa + b
Turn a, then b more, and the point lands at the angle a + b.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Put the point for an angle b on the unit circle, then the point for −b. Turning backward by b lands on the mirror image across the x-axis: the same x, and the same height on the other side of the axis. So cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b. That mirror is the whole reason the sum formula for cosine differs from the difference formula in one sign: trading b for −b leaves every cos b alone and flips every sin b, so only the sin a sin b part changes sign.

x = cos θy = sin θ−b
With b = 40°, the point for −40° sits below the x-axis.
As a story

A traveler with one plug carries adapters instead of new plugs. Your plug is the difference formula for cosine. Adapter one is a + b = a − (−b): it lets a sum fit the difference slot. Adapter two is the cofunction fact (the sine of an angle is the cosine of what is left of a right angle): it lets a sine fit the cosine plug. Every formula in this lesson is the old plug with one or two adapters on it, and the mirror facts tidy up what comes out.

With small numbers

Take a = 90° and b = 90°, where every value is 0 or 1: cos 90° = 0 and sin 90° = 1. The sum formula for cosine gives cos 180° = 0 · 0 − 1 · 1 = −1, and the point at 180° is (−1, 0), so it is right. With a plus you would get 0 · 0 + 1 · 1 = 1, which is cos 0°, the cosine of the difference 90° − 90°. The sine of a sum gives sin 180° = 1 · 0 + 0 · 1 = 0, the y of (−1, 0). The sine of a difference gives sin 0° = 1 · 0 − 0 · 1 = 0, also right.

x = cos θy = sin θa + b
At 180° the point is (−1, 0): cos 180° = −1 and sin 180° = 0, the values the formulas give for 90° + 90°.
As a rule of thumb

Sine mixes, cosine matches. Sine mixes the two functions, sin cos then cos sin, and keeps the sign you see inside: a plus stays a plus. Cosine matches like with like, cos cos then sin sin, and switches the sign: a plus inside becomes a minus in the middle. In the sine formulas the first angle's sine leads: sin a cos b, then cos a sin b.

Sine mixes and keeps the sign:

sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b

sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb

Cosine matches and switches the sign:

cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb

cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb

Why it must be true

Each formula is the difference formula with a clever input, so none of them is a guess. cos(a + b) = cos(a − (−b)) = cos a cos(−b) + sin a sin(−b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b. sin(a + b) = cos((π2 − a) − b) = cos(π2 − a) cos b + sin(π2 − a) sin b = sin a cos b + cos a sin b. sin(a − b) = sin(a + (−b)) = sin a cos(−b) + cos a sin(−b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b. The cofunction facts used here hold for every angle: cos(π2 − t) = 0 · cos t + 1 · sin t = sin t, and putting π2 − a in place of t gives cos a = sin(π2 − a).

FormulaWhat is multipliedSign in the middle
cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinbcos with cos, sin with sinplus, the opposite of the minus inside
cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinbcos with cos, sin with sinminus, the opposite of the plus inside
sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin bsin with cos, cos with sinplus, the same as inside
sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinbsin with cos, cos with sinminus, the same as inside

Part 1: The cosine of a sum

To get cos(a + b) you do not need a new picture or a new chord. Adding b is the same as taking away −b, the way walking 3 steps forward is the same as undoing 3 steps backward. So cos(a + b) is cos(a − (−b)), a cosine of a difference, and the formula you already have takes it with −b in the second slot. Then the mirror facts tidy up: cos b stays as it is, sin b flips its sign, and the plus in the middle turns into a minus.

  • Start: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, for any two angles.
  • Rewrite: a + b = a − (−b).
  • Mirror facts: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b.
  • Result: cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b.
a, and −b in place of bcos(first − second)= cos(first)cos(second) +sin(first)inputoutputcos a cos b − sin a sin b, which is cos(a + b)
The difference machine.

Worked example

Building cos(a + b)

Start from the difference formula cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b and build a formula for cos(a + b).

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: you have a formula for the cosine of a difference and want one for the cosine of a sum.So the first move is to write the sum a + b as a difference.
  2. Write a+b=a−(−b).Taking away a negative is adding: 5 − (−3) = 5 + 3 = 8.
  3. cos(a+b)=cos(a−(−b))=cosacos(−b)+sinasin(−b).The difference formula holds for any two angles, so a goes in the first slot and −b in the second.
  4. Replace cos(−b) with cos b and sin(−b) with −sinb.The point for −b is the mirror image of the point for b across the x-axis: the same x, the opposite y.
  5. cosacosb+sina·(−sinb)=cosacosb−sinasinb.Adding a negative amount is taking it away.
Answer
cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb
Double-check Test it with a = b = π4, which is 45°: cos π4 cos π4 − sin π4 sin π4 = 22 · 22 − 22 · 22 = 24 − 24 = 0. Directly, π4 + π4 = 2π4 = π2, which is 90°, and the point at 90° on the unit circle is (0, 1), so cos π2 = 0. Same answer, and not the 2 that adding the cosines gives.
Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Flipping both signs when b becomes −b: cos(a + b) = −cos a cos b − sin a sin b.
Only the sine flips; the cosine of −b is cos b. Test with a = b = 0°: the wrong formula gives −1 · 1 − 0 · 0 = −1, but cos(0° + 0°) = cos 0° = 1.
✓ Instead: cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b, which gives 1 · 1 − 0 · 0 = 1 at a = b = 0°.
Tips and tricks
  • Only the sin a sin b part feels the change from b to −b, so the cosine of a sum is the cosine of a difference with its middle sign switched and nothing else.

Part 2: The sine of a sum

There is no sine formula yet, so rename the sine as a cosine. In a right triangle the two small angles add up to a right angle, and the sine of one is the cosine of the other. So sin(a + b) is the cosine of what is left of a right angle after a + b, which is cos(π2 − (a + b)). Group the inside as (π2 − a) − b and it is a difference, which the old formula takes. Two more trades between sine and cosine finish the job.

  • Cofunction facts: sin t = cos(π2 − t) and cos t = sin(π2 − t), for every angle t, not only angles in a triangle.
  • Rename: sin(a + b) = cos(π2 − (a + b)) = cos((π2 − a) − b).
  • Difference formula: cos((π2 − a) − b) = cos(π2 − a) cos b + sin(π2 − a) sin b.
  • Trade back: cos(π2 − a) = sin a and sin(π2 − a) = cos a.
  • Result: sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b.
a + bπ/2 − (a + b)sum = 90°
A right angle cut into a + b and what is left of it.

Worked example

Building sin(a + b)

Use the difference formula for cosine and the cofunction facts to build a formula for sin(a + b).

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: you have a formula for the cosine of a difference and want one for the sine of a sum.So the first move is to rewrite the sine as a cosine.
  2. sin(a+b)=cos(π2−(a+b)).The cofunction fact sin t = cos(π2 − t) holds for every angle t; here t is a + b.
  3. π2−(a+b)=π2−a−b=(π2−a)−b.The minus in front of the brackets reaches both a and b, so −(a + b) is −a − b; grouping π2 with −a makes the inside a difference of the two angles π2 − a and b.
  4. cos((π2−a)−b)=cos(π2−a)cosb+sin(π2−a)sinb.This is the difference formula for cosine with π2 − a in the first slot and b in the second.
  5. Replace cos(π2−a) with sin a and sin(π2−a) with cos a, so sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb.These are the two cofunction facts: the cosine of the leftover angle is the sine of the angle, and the sine of the leftover is the cosine.
Answer
sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b
Double-check Test it with a = π3 and b = π6, which are 60° and 30°: sin π3 cos π6 + cos π3 sin π6 = 32 · 32 + 12 · 12 = 34 + 14 = 1. Directly, π3 + π6 = 2π6 + π6 = 3π6 = π2, which is 90°, and sin 90° = 1. Same answer.
Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Rewriting π2 − (a + b) as π2 − a + b.
The minus in front of the brackets reaches both a and b. With a = b = 30°: 90° − (30° + 30°) = 30°, but 90° − 30° + 30° = 90°.
✓ Instead: π2 − (a + b) = π2 − a − b = (π2 − a) − b, a difference the formula can take.
Tips and tricks
  • If the sine of a sum slips your mind, rebuild it in three moves: sine to the cosine of the leftover angle, the difference formula, then trade back.

Part 3: The sine of a difference

With the sine of a sum in hand, the sine of a difference costs one more move. Taking away b is the same as adding −b, so sin(a − b) = sin(a + (−b)). Put −b into the sine of a sum and let the mirror facts tidy up: cos(−b) is cos b, sin(−b) is −sin b, and the plus in the middle becomes a minus. For sine, the sign you see inside is the sign you write in the middle. Keep the angles in order: a, the angle written first, gives the first sine.

  • Rewrite: a − b = a + (−b).
  • Sine of a sum with −b: sin(a + (−b)) = sin a cos(−b) + cos a sin(−b).
  • Mirror facts: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b.
  • Result: sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b.
  • Second route, through the cofunction fact: sin(a − b) = cos((π2 − a) + b) = cos(π2 − a) cos b − sin(π2 − a) sin b = sin a cos b − cos a sin b.
  • Order matters: the first angle's sine comes first.
−bterminal sideinitial side
Taking away b is turning by −b, clockwise: the turn ends below the x-axis, the mirror image of a turn by b.

Worked example

Building sin(a − b)

Use the sum formula for sine to build a formula for sin(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: you have the sine of a sum and want the sine of a difference.So the first move is to write a − b as a sum.
  2. Write a−b=a+(−b).Taking away a number is adding its negative: 7 − 2 = 7 + (−2) = 5.
  3. sin(a−b)=sin(a+(−b))=sinacos(−b)+cosasin(−b).The sum formula for sine holds for any two angles, so −b can go in the second slot.
  4. Replace cos(−b) with cos b and sin(−b) with −sinb.The point for −b has the same x as the point for b and the opposite y.
  5. sinacosb+cosa·(−sinb)=sinacosb−cosasinb.Adding a negative amount is taking it away.
Answer
sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb
Double-check Test it with a = 60° and b = 30°: sin 60° cos 30° − cos 60° sin 30° = 32 · 32 − 12 · 12 = 34 − 14 = 24 = 12. Directly, 60° − 30° = 30°, and sin 30° = 12. Same answer.
Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: Swapping the order: sin(a − b) = sin b cos a − cos b sin a.
That is sin(b − a), the turn the other way, and it has the opposite sign. Test with a = 90° and b = 0°: it gives 0 · 0 − 1 · 1 = −1, but sin(90° − 0°) = sin 90° = 1.
✓ Instead: sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b, which gives 1 · 1 − 0 · 0 = 1.
Tips and tricks
  • To test the order, use a = 90° and b = 0°: the answer must be sin 90° = 1, and only the correct order gives it.

5 How

  1. Say what the question asks: is it a sine or a cosine, and are the two angles added or subtracted? Call the first angle a and the second b.
  2. Write the matching formula in letters, sign included, before any number goes in. Cosine matches like with like and switches the sign; sine mixes and keeps it.
  3. Find the four values cos a, sin a, cos b and sin b from the special triangles or the unit circle.
  4. Put each value in its place and do the two multiplications: top times top, bottom times bottom.
  5. Add or subtract the two results as the formula says, and simplify to an exact value: fractions and roots, no rounding.
  6. Check: if the whole angle a + b or a − b is one whose value you already know, find that value directly and compare.

Rebuilding a sum or difference formula from cos(a − b)

1
Is it the cosine of a difference, cos(a − b)?
YesUse cos a cos b + sin a sin b as it stands.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is it the cosine of a sum, cos(a + b)?
YesWrite a + b as a − (−b), use the difference formula with −b, then cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b. You get cos a cos b − sin a sin b.
NoGo on: it is a sine.
↓
3
Is it the sine of a sum, sin(a + b)?
YesWrite it as cos((π2 − a) − b), use the difference formula, then cos(π2 − a) = sin a and sin(π2 − a) = cos a. You get sin a cos b + cos a sin b.
NoGo on.
↓
4
Is it the sine of a difference, sin(a − b)?
YesWrite a − b as a + (−b), use the sine of a sum with −b, then the mirror facts. You get sin a cos b − cos a sin b.
NoThere is no sum or difference of two angles inside one sine or cosine, so these formulas do not apply.
  1. Write the one formula you trust: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b. It holds for any two angles.
  2. For the cosine of a sum, write a + b as a − (−b) and use the formula with −b in the second slot.
  3. Tidy up with the mirror facts cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b: only the sine part changes sign.
  4. For a sine, rewrite it as a cosine with sin t = cos(π2 − t), then group the inside as (π2 − a) − b so it is a difference.
  5. Use the difference formula on (π2 − a) − b, then trade cos(π2 − a) for sin a and sin(π2 − a) for cos a.
  6. For the sine of a difference, write a − b as a + (−b), use the sine of a sum with −b, and tidy up with the mirror facts.
  7. Test what you built with b = 0°: cos(a + 0°) must come out cos a, and sin(a + 0°) must come out sin a.

6 Worked example

Worked example

The cosine of 60° + 60°

Find cos(60° + 60°) with the sum formula for cosine, and check the answer.

Show the steps and the answer
30°60°√31245°45°11√2
In the 30-60-90 triangle the side next to 60° is 1 and the side across from it is 3, over the hypotenuse 2.
x = cos θy = sin θ120°
The point at 120° sits left of the y-axis, so its x, which is cos 120°, is negative: −12.
  1. Say what it asks: the angle is made of two pieces, a=60° and b=60°. Find the cosine of the whole angle from the sines and cosines of the pieces.The formula is written in a and b, so name them first.
  2. Write the formula with its sign: cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb.Cosine matches like with like, cos with cos and sin with sin, and switches the sign: a plus inside, a minus in the middle.
  3. Read the values: cos60°=12 and sin60°=32.In the 30-60-90 triangle with sides 1, 3 and 2, the side next to 60° is 1 and the side across from it is 3, each over the hypotenuse 2.
  4. Multiply each pair: cos60°·cos60°=12·12=14, and sin60°·sin60°=32·32=34.Top times top and bottom times bottom; 3 · 3 = 3.
  5. Subtract: 14−34=1−34=−24=−12.The bottoms match, so subtract the tops; then divide top and bottom by 2.
Answer
cos(60°+60°)=−12
Double-check 60° + 60° = 120°. On the unit circle, 120° is in the second quadrant (between 90° and 180°) and 60° short of 180°, so its point is the 60° point mirrored across the y-axis: the x turns negative, and cos 120° = −cos 60° = −12. Same answer. Adding the cosines instead gives 12 + 12 = 1, which is the cosine of 0°, not of 120°.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

Rung 1: an angle plus 0°

Find sin(45° + 0°) with the sum formula for sine.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: a=45° and b=0°; find the sine of the whole angle.Naming a and b tells you which value goes where in the formula.
  2. Write sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb.Sine mixes, sin cos then cos sin, and keeps the plus.
  3. sin45°=22,cos45°=22,cos0°=1 and sin0°=0.The 45° values come from the 45-45-90 triangle; at 0° the point on the unit circle is (1, 0), so its x is 1 and its y is 0.
  4. 22·1+22·0=22+0=22.Times 1 leaves a number as it is, and times 0 gives 0.
Answer
sin(45°+0°)=22
Double-check 45° + 0° = 45°, and sin 45° = 22. Adding no angle changes nothing, and the formula agrees.

Rung 2 of 6

Rung 2: a difference that starts at 90°

Find sin(90° − 60°) with the difference formula for sine.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: a=90° comes first and b=60° is taken away; find the sine of what is left.In a difference the order matters, so a must be the angle written first.
  2. Write sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb.Sine mixes and keeps the minus you see inside.
  3. sin90°=1,cos90°=0,cos60°=12 and sin60°=32.At 90° the point on the unit circle is (0, 1); the 60° values come from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  4. 1·12−0·32=12−0=12.Times 0 gives 0, so only the first multiplication is left.
Answer
sin(90°−60°)=12
Double-check 90° − 60° = 30°, and sin 30° = 12. The cofunction fact agrees too: sin(90° − 60°) = cos 60° = 12.

Rung 3 of 6

Rung 3: radians and two multiplications

Find cos(π6 + π6) with the sum formula for cosine.

Show the steps and the answer
30°60°√31245°45°11√2
The 30-60-90 triangle gives cos 30° = 32, sin 30° = 12 and the check value cos 60° = 12.
  1. Say what it asks: a=b=π6, which is 30° because π is 180° and 180°÷6=30°; find the cosine of the whole angle.In degrees you can read the values from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  2. Write cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb.Cosine matches like with like and switches the sign.
  3. cos30°=32 and sin30°=12.In the 30-60-90 triangle the side next to 30° is 3 and the side across from it is 1, each over the hypotenuse 2.
  4. cosacosb=32·32=34 and sinasinb=12·12=14.Top times top, bottom times bottom; 3 · 3 = 3.
  5. 34−14=24=12.The bottoms match, so subtract the tops; then divide top and bottom by 2.
Answer
cos(π6+π6)=12
Double-check π6 + π6 = 2π6 = π3, which is 60°, and cos 60° = 12. Same answer. The gotcha: when adding π6 + π6, add only the tops; adding the bottoms too gives 2π12 = π6, which is wrong.

Rung 4 of 6

Rung 4: a difference in the other order

Find sin(30° − 60°) with the difference formula for sine.

Show the steps and the answer
  1. Say what it asks: a=30° comes first and b=60° is taken away; find the sine of the result.The angle written first is a; swapping a and b would change the answer.
  2. Write sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb.Sine mixes and keeps the minus you see inside.
  3. sin30°=12,cos60°=12,cos30°=32 and sin60°=32.All four come from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  4. sinacosb=12·12=14 and cosasinb=32·32=34.Top times top, bottom times bottom; 3 · 3 = 3.
  5. 14−34=1−34=−24=−12.The bottoms match, so subtract the tops; then divide top and bottom by 2.
Answer
sin(30°−60°)=−12
Double-check 30° − 60° = −30°, a turn of 30° clockwise. By the mirror facts, sin(−30°) = −sin 30° = −12. Same answer. The gotcha: starting with sin 60° cos 30° gives 34 − 14 = 12, the sine of 60° − 30°, the wrong order.

Rung 5 of 6

Rung 5: values from the second quadrant

Find cos(2π3 + π3) with the sum formula for cosine.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
Step through cos 120°: second quadrant, 60° from the x-axis, table value 12, sign negative, so −12.
  1. Say what it asks: a=2π3 and b=π3; find the cosine of the whole angle.Naming a and b first keeps each value in its place.
  2. In degrees, a=120° and b=60°.π is 180°, so π3 = 180° ÷ 3 = 60° and 2π3 = 2 · 60° = 120°.
  3. Write cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb.Cosine matches like with like and switches the sign.
  4. cos120°=−12 and sin120°=32.120° is in the second quadrant, 60° short of 180°: its point is the 60° point mirrored across the y-axis, so the x turns negative and the y stays positive.
  5. cos60°=12 and sin60°=32.These come from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  6. cosacosb=(−12)·12=−14 and sinasinb=32·32=34.A negative times a positive is negative; 3 · 3 = 3.
  7. −14−34=−1−34=−44=−1.The bottoms match, so combine the tops: starting at −1 and taking away 3 more goes down to −4; and 4 over 4 is 1.
Answer
cos(2π3+π3)=−1
Double-check 2π3 + π3 = 3π3 = π, which is 180°. The point at 180° on the unit circle is (−1, 0), so cos π = −1. Same answer.

Rung 6 of 6

Rung 6: taking away a negative

Find sin(150° − 30°) with the difference formula for sine.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
Step through cos 150°: second quadrant, 30° from the x-axis, table value 32, sign negative.
x = cos θy = sin θP
Step through sin 120° for the check: second quadrant, 60° from the x-axis, sign positive, so 32.
  1. Say what it asks: a=150° comes first and b=30° is taken away; find the sine of the result.Naming a and b in order keeps each value in its place.
  2. Write sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb.Sine mixes and keeps the minus you see inside.
  3. sin150°=12 and cos150°=−32.150° is in the second quadrant, 30° short of 180°: its point is the 30° point mirrored across the y-axis, so the x turns negative and the y stays positive.
  4. cos30°=32 and sin30°=12.These come from the 30-60-90 triangle.
  5. sinacosb=12·32=34 and cosasinb=(−32)·12=−34.Top times top, bottom times bottom; a negative times a positive is negative.
  6. 34−(−34)=34+34=234=32.Taking away a negative is adding, the same move as a − (−b) = a + b; then add the tops over the shared bottom and divide top and bottom by 2.
Answer
sin(150°−30°)=32
Double-check 150° − 30° = 120°, in the second quadrant, where the y of a point is positive, and 60° short of 180°, so sin 120° = sin 60° = 32. Same answer. The gotcha: dropping the minus sign of cos 150° gives 34 − 34 = 0, which is wrong.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: cos(a + b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, keeping the plus from the difference formula.
That is the formula for cos(a − b). With a = 60° and b = 30° it gives 12 · 32 + 32 · 12 = 34 + 34 = 32, which is cos 30°, the cosine of the difference. But 60° + 30° = 90°, and cos 90° = 0.
✓ Instead: cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b, which gives 34 − 34 = 0 = cos 90°.
✗ Not this: sin(a + b) = sin a + sin b.
With a = 30° and b = 60° it gives 12 + 32 = 1+32 ≈ 1.37 (rounded), and no sine is ever bigger than 1, because a sine is the height of a point on a circle of radius 1. The true value is sin 90° = 1.
✓ Instead: sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb:12·12+32·32=14+34=1.
✗ Not this: cos(−b) = −cos b, flipping the cosine as well as the sine.
The point for −b is the mirror image of the point for b across the x-axis, so only its y flips. The point for −60° sits straight below the point for 60°, and its x is still 12.
✓ Instead: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b: cos(−60°) = 12 and sin(−60°) = −32.
✗ Not this: sin(a + b) = sin a sin b + cos a cos b, matching like with like the way cosine does.
Put b = 0°, where cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0: this gives cos a, but sin(a + 0°) must be sin a. With a = 90° it gives 0, while sin 90° = 1.
✓ Instead: Sine mixes: sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b. With a = 90° and b = 0°: 1 · 1 + 0 · 0 = 1.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: sine mixes, cosine matches. Sine mixes the two functions (sin cos, then cos sin) and keeps the sign you see inside. Cosine matches like with like (cos cos, then sin sin) and switches the sign.
  • Test any formula you rebuilt with b = 0°. Since cos 0° = 1 and sin 0° = 0, a correct formula collapses to cos(a + 0°) = cos a and sin(a + 0°) = sin a; a formula with the wrong pairs fails.
  • Know cold: the difference formula for cosine and the memory device. Rebuild when needed: the other three, each one move away (−b in place of b, or a sine written as the cosine of the leftover angle). Put all four on the cheat sheet; there is no need to memorize them as four separate facts.
  • In the sine of a difference the order matters: the first angle's sine comes first. sin(60° − 30°) = 12, but sin(30° − 60°) = −12.
  • A quick number check: 60° and 30° add to 90°, whose cosine is 0 and sine is 1. Any formula for a sum must give those for a = 60° and b = 30°.
  • Write the formula in letters, sign included, before a single number goes in. Most wrong answers come from deciding the sign halfway through the arithmetic.

7 The trap

The sign in the cosine formulas. The cosine of a sum has a minus in the middle, and the cosine of a difference has a plus: cosine switches the sign you see inside, while sine keeps it. With a plus, cos(90° + 90°) would come out 0 · 0 + 1 · 1 = 1, but the point at 180° is (−1, 0), so the true value is −1. Write the formula in letters, sign included, before any number goes in, and say cosine switches, sine stays as you write it.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Starting from cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, how do you get the formula for cos(a + b)?
  • Drop −b into the slot for b, because a − (−b) = a + b.
  • Turning by −b instead of b keeps the cosine and flips the sign of the sine: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b.
  • So the sin a sin b part changes sign:
  • cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb
Why is cos(π + t) = −cos t true for every angle t?
  • Put π in the a slot and t in the b slot of the cos(a + b) formula. The point at π is (−1, 0), so cos π = −1 and sin π = 0.
  • cos(π+t)=(−1)·cost−0·sint=−cost
  • The cos(a + b) formula works for every pair of angles, so this works for every t.
What are the formulas for sin(a + b) and sin(a − b)?
  • sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b
  • sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb
  • Sine mixes (sine times cosine, then cosine times sine) and keeps the sign you see inside: cosine switches, sine stays.
Write 195° as 135° + 60° and use the sum formula to find cos 195° exactly.
  • cos195°=cos135°cos60°−sin135°sin60°
  • =(−22)·12−22·32
  • =−24−64
  • =−2+64
  • The angles are added, so the cosine formula has a minus in the middle. The answer is negative, as it must be: 195° ends in quadrant III, where every cosine is negative.

Lesson 4 of 7

Exact values of angles such as 15 degrees and 75 degrees

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: The special-angle valuesLeans on: The four formulasLeans on: Multiplying fractions with square rootsLeans on: Adding fractions with the same bottomLeans on: Multiplying signed numbersLeans on: Signs from the quadrantLeans on: Subtracting fractions with πLeans on: Degrees to radiansOpen this lesson
Leans on 1Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Your calculator says sin 15° is about 0.2588. That decimal is rounded: its digits never end. An exact value is the true number, written with fractions and square roots, like 32. The special-angle table has exact values at 0°, 30°, 45°, 60°, 90° and their partners around the circle, but no row for 15°. So you build the angle from angles you know, the way you pay with the coins in your pocket. To pay 75 cents, you hand over a half dollar and a quarter: 50 + 25. To pay 15 cents with a quarter, you hand it over and get a dime back: 25 − 10. Angles work the same way: 75° = 45° + 30°, and 15° = 45° − 30°.

2 Picture it

45°30°sum = 75°
A 75° angle is a 45° wedge and a 30° wedge side by side, so sin 75° is sin(45° + 30°).

Reminder

Reminder: The special-angle values, The four formulas, Multiplying fractions with square roots, Adding fractions with the same bottom, Multiplying signed numbers, Signs from the quadrant, Subtracting fractions with π, Degrees to radians
  • The special-angle values. From the 30-60-90 and 45-45-90 triangles: sin 30° = 12, cos 30° = 32, sin 45° = cos 45° = 22, sin 60° = 32, cos 60° = 12.
  • The four formulas. From the last lesson: sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b, sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b, cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b, cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b.
  • Multiplying fractions with square roots. Tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms, and two roots join under one root: 22 · 32 = 64. A root times itself gives back the number inside: 3 · 3 = 3.
  • Adding fractions with the same bottom. Add the tops and keep the bottom: 64 + 24 = 6+24. Different roots do not merge, the way 3 apples and 2 pears are not 5 apples.
  • Multiplying signed numbers. A negative times a positive is negative: (−12) · 22 = −24. Keep a negative value in parentheses while you substitute.
  • Signs from the quadrant. Past 90°, take the value at the reference angle and give it the sign of its quadrant: 120° is in quadrant II, where x is negative, so cos 120° = −cos 60° = −12, while sin 120° = sin 60° = 32.
  • Subtracting fractions with π. Put both over a common bottom, then subtract the tops: π3 − π4 = 4π12 − 3π12 = π12.
  • Degrees to radians. Multiply by π180 and reduce: 15° = 15π180 = π12, and 75° = 75π180 = 5π12.

3 Why

The sum formula and the difference formula build the sine or cosine of a + b or a − b out of four numbers: sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b. When a and b are special angles, all four are known exactly, such as 12 and 22. The formula only multiplies them in pairs and adds or subtracts the products, and none of that rounds anything, so the answer is exact too. A rounded decimal would carry a small error into every later step; 6−24 is the true number. The decimal still has a job: it is the quickest check.

4 The rule

If θ=a+b or θ=a−b, where a and b are special angles, the sum formula or the difference formula gives sinθ and cosθ exactly:sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb and sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinbcos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb and cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb

The same idea, five ways

Say it

the sine of fifteen degrees is root six minus root two, all over four, because fifteen degrees is forty-five degrees minus thirty degrees.

Write it

The exact value of sin 15° comes from writing 15° as the difference of the special angles 45° and 30° and using the difference formula for sine.

In math
  • 15°=45°−30°=60°−45°
  • sin15°=sin(45°−30°)=6−24
  • π12 = π3 − π4, so sin π12 = 6−24
  • 75° = 45° + 30°, so cos 75° = 6−24
  • sin 15° ≈ 0.2588 (a rounded decimal, not the exact value)
Like

Paying 15 cents with a quarter: you hand over 25 cents and get a dime back, so 25 − 10 = 15. You never needed a 15-cent coin.

See it
45° − 30°terminal sideinitial side
A 15° turn, labeled with its build: a 45° turn with 30° taken back.

The same idea, other ways

As a story

A door swings open 45°, then the wind pushes it back 30°. It now stands 15° open. You know exactly where a door at 45° points and exactly where a door at 30° points. The difference formula uses those two known positions to find exactly where the 15° door points, without ever measuring it.

As a picture

Draw a 45° wedge. Lay a 30° wedge inside it, along the same starting side. The sliver left over is 15°. For 75°, put the two wedges side by side instead. Every angle in this lesson is two familiar wedges, either side by side (a sum) or one inside the other (a difference).

30°15°sum = 45°
Take a 30° wedge out of 45° and a 15° sliver is left, so 15° = 45° − 30°.
As a rule of thumb

For a multiple of 15° between 0° and 360° that is not special, take 45° away. What is left is a multiple of 30°, and those are all special: 75° − 45° = 30°, 105° − 45° = 60°, 165° − 45° = 120°. So 75° = 45° + 30°, 105° = 60° + 45° and 165° = 120° + 45°. The one exception is 15° itself, where taking 45° away drops below 0°; write it the other way round, 15° = 45° − 30°.

Why the answer stays exact

Each special value is an exact number such as 12 or 32. The formula multiplies two pairs of them and adds or subtracts the products. Multiplying and adding exact numbers keeps them exact, the way 12 + 13 is exactly 56 with nothing rounded. Rounding enters only when an exact value is swapped for a decimal, as a calculator does, which is why the calculator is the check and not the method.

AngleRadiansBuilt fromsincos
15°π1245°−30°6−246+24
75°5π1245° + 30°6+246−24
105°7π1260° + 45°6+242−64
165°11π12120° + 45°6−24−6+24

5 How

  1. Write the angle as a sum or a difference of two special angles, in the order that gives the angle itself (75° = 45° + 30°, 15° = 45° − 30°, −15° = 30° − 45°).
  2. Pick the formula that matches the question: sine or cosine, sum or difference.
  3. Write down sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b from the special-angle triangles, each with the sign of its quadrant.
  4. Substitute the four values into the formula, keeping the sign in the middle.
  5. Multiply each pair: tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms, and two roots join under one root.
  6. Combine the two products over their common bottom 4, leaving different roots apart.
  7. Check: compare the decimal of your answer with a calculator in the right mode, and ask whether the size and sign fit the picture.

Finding an exact value at a multiple of 15°

1
Is the angle already special, or a partner of one around the circle (such as 120°, 135° or 210°)?
YesRead it from the table with its quadrant sign. No formula is needed.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is the angle a multiple of 15° (in radians, a whole number times π12)?
YesGo on, after adding or subtracting 360° until the angle lies from 0° to 360°; a full turn changes no sine or cosine.
NoNo two special angles add or subtract to it, so this method cannot reach it. Use a calculator decimal.
↓
3
Does taking 45° away leave a special angle above 0°?
YesWrite the angle as that special angle plus 45° and use a sum formula, for example 75° = 45° + 30°.
NoWrite it as a difference with the larger angle first, for example 15° = 45° − 30°, and use a difference formula.
↓
4
Does the question ask for a sine?
YesSine mixes and keeps: sin a cos b, then the same sign as between the angles, then cos a sin b.
NoCosine matches and flips: cos a cos b, then the opposite sign, then sin a sin b.
↓
5
Is either special angle below 0° or past 90°?
YesGive its sine and cosine their quadrant signs before you substitute, for example cos 120° = −12 and sin(−30°) = −12.
NoBoth angles lie from 0° to 90°, so none of the four values is negative.
↓
6
Does the decimal of your answer match the calculator?
YesDone.
NoLook for a flipped sign in the cosine formula, a missing quadrant sign, or a calculator in the wrong mode.
  1. Add or subtract 360° until the angle lies from 0° to 360°; a full turn changes no sine or cosine. Then look it up: if it is special (0°, 30°, 45°, 60°, 90° or a partner such as 120°, 135° or 210°), read its value with the quadrant sign and stop.
  2. Otherwise split it into two special angles. Take 45° away: if a special angle above 0° is left, the angle is that angle plus 45°. For 15°, use the difference 45° − 30°, larger angle first.
  3. Choose the formula: sine or cosine, sum or difference.
  4. List sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b, each with the sign of its quadrant.
  5. Substitute, multiply each pair, and combine the two products over the bottom 4.
  6. Check the size and sign against the picture, then the decimal against a calculator in the right mode.

6 Worked example

Worked example

The exact value of sin 15°

Find the exact value of sin 15°, then check it with a decimal. In plain words: write sin 15° as a number made of fractions and square roots, with nothing rounded, then make sure it agrees with the calculator's rounded value.

Show the steps and the answer
30°60°√31245°45°11√2
Every value used here comes from these two triangles: 30° and 60° from the first, 45° from the second.
x = cos θy = sin θP
The point at 15° sits low on the circle, so its height, sin 15°, is a small number, about 0.26.
  1. Write 15°=45°−30°.15° is not in the special-angle table, but 45° and 30° are, and 45 − 30 = 15. The larger angle goes first, so the difference is 15° and not −15°.
  2. Choose sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb, with a=45° and b=30°: sin15°=sin45°cos30°−cos45°sin30°.The question asks for a sine, and the angle is a difference. Sine mixes the pairs (a sine with a cosine) and keeps the minus sign that sits between the angles.
  3. Write the four values: sin45°=22,cos30°=32,cos45°=22,sin30°=12.They come from the 45-45-90 and 30-60-90 triangles in the first picture. Both angles are in quadrant I, so all four values are positive.
  4. Substitute: sin15°=22·32−22·12.Each name in the formula is replaced by its number, and the minus sign between the two products stays.
  5. Multiply each pair: 22·32=64 and 22·12=24.To multiply fractions, multiply the tops and multiply the bottoms. Two square roots multiply under one root: 2 · 3 = 6. Each bottom is 2 · 2 = 4.
  6. Subtract: 64−24=6−24.Both fractions have the bottom 4, so subtract the tops and keep the 4. 6 and 2 are different roots, so 6 − 2 stays as it is.
Answer
  • sin 15° = 6−24 (exact)
  • sin 15° ≈ 0.2588 (rounded)
Double-check Decimal: 6 ≈ 2.4495 and 2 ≈ 1.4142, so the top is about 1.0353, and 1.0353 ÷ 4 ≈ 0.2588. A calculator in degree mode gives sin 15° ≈ 0.2588, so the two agree.
Second build: 15° is also 60° − 45°, and sin 60° cos 45° − cos 60° sin 45° = 32 · 22 − 12 · 22 = 64 − 24, the same exact value.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 7

Rung 1: the formula on a sum you already know

Use the sum formula for sine on 60° + 30° and compare the result with sin 90°. In plain words: 60° + 30° is 90°, whose sine you already know is 1; the question asks whether the formula also gives 1.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θ(0, 1)
At 90° the point is at the top of the circle, so its height, sin 90°, is 1.
  1. Write the formula with a=60° and b=30°: sin(60°+30°)=sin60°cos30°+cos60°sin30°.It is the sine of a sum, so the pairs are mixed (a sine with a cosine) and the plus sign stays.
  2. Put in the values: 32·32+12·12.From the 30-60-90 triangle, sin 60° = cos 30° = 32 and cos 60° = sin 30° = 12.
  3. Multiply: 32·32=34 and 12·12=14.A square root times itself gives back the number inside: 3 · 3 = 3. The bottoms multiply to 2 · 2 = 4.
  4. Add: 34+14=44=1.The bottoms match, so add the tops: 3 + 1 = 4, and four quarters make one whole.
Answer
sin(60° + 30°) = 1, the known value of sin 90°
Double-check On the unit circle, 90° points straight up to the point (0, 1), and sine is the height of that point, so sin 90° = 1. The formula and the picture agree, which is a reason to trust the formula at 75°, where no picture gives the value directly.

Rung 2 of 7

Rung 2: a sum, for sine: sin 75°

Find the exact value of sin 75°. In plain words: write sin 75° with fractions and square roots, no rounding.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The point at 75° sits high on the circle, so its height, sin 75°, is close to 1.
  1. Write 75°=45°+30°.Take 45° away from 75° and 30° is left; 45° and 30° are both special.
  2. Use sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb with a=45° and b=30°: sin75°=sin45°cos30°+cos45°sin30°.It is the sine of a sum: sine mixes the pairs and keeps the plus sign.
  3. Put in the values: 22·32+22·12.sin 45° = cos 45° = 22, cos 30° = 32 and sin 30° = 12; both angles are in quadrant I, so all four are positive.
  4. Multiply: 64+24.Tops times tops and bottoms times bottoms: 2 · 3 = 6, 2 · 1 = 2, and 2 · 2 = 4.
  5. Add: 6+24.The bottoms are both 4, so add the tops and keep the 4. The roots are different, so the top stays as two terms.
Answer
  • sin 75° = 6+24 (exact)
  • sin 75° ≈ 0.9659 (rounded)
Double-check Decimal: (2.4495 + 1.4142) ÷ 4 = 3.8637 ÷ 4 ≈ 0.9659, and a calculator in degree mode gives sin 75° ≈ 0.9659. Size check: 75° is close to 90°, so its sine should be close to 1, and it is.

Rung 3 of 7

Rung 3: a sum, for cosine, where the sign flips: cos 75°

Find the exact value of cos 75°. In plain words: the same angle as in rung 2, but now its cosine, written exactly.

Show the steps and the answer
75°15°sum = 90°
75° and 15° fill a right angle, so the cosine of one is the sine of the other.

Sine mixes and keeps:

sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b

sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb

Cosine matches and flips:

cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb

cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb

  1. Write 75°=45°+30°.The same build as for sin 75°: the build depends on the angle, not on which function you want.
  2. Use cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb: cos75°=cos45°cos30°−sin45°sin30°.Cosine matches the pairs (cosine with cosine, sine with sine) and flips the sign: the angles are added, so the formula subtracts.
  3. Put in the values: 22·32−22·12.The same four special values as in rung 2, all positive.
  4. Multiply: 64−24.2 · 3 = 6 and 2 · 1 = 2 on top; 2 · 2 = 4 on the bottom.
  5. Subtract: 6−24.Same bottom, so subtract the tops; different roots stay apart.
Answer
  • cos 75° = 6−24 (exact)
  • cos 75° ≈ 0.2588 (rounded)
Double-check Decimal: (2.4495 − 1.4142) ÷ 4 = 1.0353 ÷ 4 ≈ 0.2588, and a calculator in degree mode gives cos 75° ≈ 0.2588. Cofunction check: 75° and 15° add up to 90°, so cos 75° = sin 15°, and the worked example found sin 15° = 6−24: the same number.

Rung 4 of 7

Rung 4: the same idea in radians: cos π12

Find the exact value of cos π12. In plain words: the angle is given in radians; write its cosine with fractions and square roots.

Show the steps and the answer

π3=4π12(60°)

π4=3π12(45°)

4π12−3π12=π12(15°)

  1. Write π12 as a difference of special angles: π3−π4=4π12−3π12=π12.π3 (60°) and π4 (45°) are special. To subtract the fractions, put both over the common bottom 12: π3 = 4π12 and π4 = 3π12, and 4 − 3 = 1.
  2. Use cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb with a=π3 and b=π4: cosπ12=cosπ3cosπ4+sinπ3sinπ4.It is the cosine of a difference: matched pairs, and the minus between the angles flips to a plus.
  3. Put in the values: 12·22+32·22.cos π3 = 12 and sin π3 = 32 (the 60° values); cos π4 = sin π4 = 22 (the 45° values).
  4. Multiply: 24+64.1 · 2 = 2 and 3 · 2 = 6 on top; 2 · 2 = 4 on the bottom.
  5. Add: 2+64, the same as 6+24.Same bottom, so add the tops; the order of the two terms in a sum does not matter.
Answer
  • cos π12 = 6+24 (exact)
  • cos π12 ≈ 0.9659 (rounded)
Double-check A calculator in radian mode gives cos(π ÷ 12) ≈ 0.9659, and (2.4495 + 1.4142) ÷ 4 ≈ 0.9659.
A second build: π12 is 180°12 = 15°, and 15° = 45° − 30° gives cos 45° cos 30° + sin 45° sin 30° = 64 + 24, the same exact value.

Rung 5 of 7

Rung 5: positive pieces, negative answer: cos 105°

Find the exact value of cos 105°. In plain words: write the cosine of 105° exactly, and watch its sign.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The point at 105° is a little left of the vertical axis, so its x coordinate.
  1. Write 105°=60°+45°.Take 45° away from 105° and 60° is left, which is special.
  2. Use cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb: cos105°=cos60°cos45°−sin60°sin45°.The cosine of a sum: matched pairs, and the sign flips to minus.
  3. Put in the values: 12·22−32·22.cos 60° = 12, sin 60° = 32 and cos 45° = sin 45° = 22; all positive, since 60° and 45° are in quadrant I.
  4. Multiply: 24−64.1 · 2 = 2 and 3 · 2 = 6 on top; 2 · 2 = 4 on the bottom.
  5. Subtract: 2−64.Same bottom, so subtract the tops. 6 is bigger than 2, so the top is below zero and the answer is negative, even though all four values were positive.
Answer
  • cos 105° = 2−64 (exact)
  • cos 105° ≈ −0.2588 (rounded)
Double-check Sign check: 105° is past 90°, in quadrant II, where cosine (the x coordinate) is negative, so a negative answer is right.
Decimal: (1.4142 − 2.4495) ÷ 4 = −1.0353 ÷ 4 ≈ −0.2588, and a calculator in degree mode gives cos 105° ≈ −0.2588.

Rung 6 of 7

Rung 6: a piece past 90°: cos 165°

Find the exact value of cos 165°. In plain words: write the cosine of 165° exactly; one of the two special angles it needs lies past 90°.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The chain for cos 120°. Quadrant II, reference angle 60°, table value 12, and a minus sign because x is negative there.
  1. Write 165°=120°+45°.Take 45° away from 165° and 120° is left. 120° is special: it is in quadrant II with reference angle 60°.
  2. Find the values at 120°: cos120°=−12 and sin120°=32.The reference angle 60° gives the sizes 12 and 32. In quadrant II, x is negative and y is positive, so the cosine takes a minus sign and the sine stays positive.
  3. Use cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb: cos165°=cos120°cos45°−sin120°sin45°.The cosine of a sum: matched pairs, and the sign flips to minus.
  4. Put in the values: (−12)·22−32·22.The negative value goes in parentheses so its sign is not lost.
  5. Multiply: −24−64.A negative times a positive is negative, so the first product is −24. The second product is 64, and the minus sign in front of it stays.
  6. Combine: −24−64=−6+24.Both parts are negative with bottom 4, so their sizes add, 2 + 6, and the minus sign goes in front of the whole fraction.
Answer
  • cos 165° = −6+24 (exact)
  • cos 165° ≈ −0.9659 (rounded)
Double-check Picture check: 165° is close to 180°, where the point on the unit circle is near (−1, 0), so the cosine should be close to −1.
Reference-angle check: 165° is in quadrant II with reference angle 15°, so cos 165° = −cos 15° = −6+24 (rung 4 found cos 15°), matching the answer. A calculator in degree mode gives cos 165° ≈ −0.9659.

Rung 7 of 7

Rung 7: genuinely hard: radians and quadrant IV together: sin 23π12

Find the exact value of sin 23π12. In plain words: the angle is in radians and is nearly a full turn; write its sine exactly.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
The chain for sin 300°. Quadrant IV, reference angle 60°, table value 32, and a minus sign because y is negative there.
  1. Take π4 away: 23π12−3π12=20π12=5π3, so 23π12=5π3+π4.π4 is 3π12 over the bottom 12. What is left, 5π3, is 300°, a special angle, so the build uses two special angles.
  2. Find the values at 5π3: sin5π3=−32 and cos5π3=12.300° is in quadrant IV with reference angle 60°. There x is positive and y is negative, so the sine takes a minus sign and the cosine stays positive.
  3. Use sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb: sin23π12=sin5π3cosπ4+cos5π3sinπ4.The sine of a sum: mixed pairs, and the plus sign stays.
  4. Put in the values: (−32)·22+12·22.cos π4 = sin π4 = 22; the negative value goes in parentheses.
  5. Multiply: −64+24.A negative times a positive is negative, and 3 · 2 = 6; the second product is 24.
  6. Combine: 2−64.Same bottom 4: the tops give −6 + 2, which is 2 − 6 written with the positive term first.
Answer
  • sin 23π12 = 2−64 (exact)
  • sin 23π12 ≈ −0.2588 (rounded)
Double-check In degrees, 23π12 is 23·180°12 = 345°, in quadrant IV with reference angle 15°. Sine is negative there, so sin 345° = −sin 15° = −6−24 = 2−64, the same answer.
A calculator in radian mode gives sin(23π ÷ 12) ≈ −0.2588.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin15°=sin45°−sin30°=22−12=2−12≈0.2071
Sine does not split across a minus sign, the same way the first lesson of this unit showed that cosine does not split across a plus. The decimal check exposes it: a calculator gives sin 15° ≈ 0.2588, not 0.2071.
✓ Instead: Use the difference formula: sin 15° = sin 45° cos 30° − cos 45° sin 30° = 6−24 ≈ 0.2588.
✗ Not this: 15° is half of 30°, so sin 15° is half of sin 30°: 12 · 12 = 14 = 0.25.
Halving an angle does not halve its sine. The guess lands close (0.25 against 0.2588), which is what makes it tempting; the decimal check at the third decimal place shows it is off.
✓ Instead: Build 15° by subtraction, not by halving: 15° = 45° − 30°, so sin 15° = 6−24 ≈ 0.2588.
✗ Not this: 15° = 30° − 45°, so sin 15° = sin 30° cos 45° − cos 30° sin 45° = 2−64.
30° − 45° is −15°, not 15°, so this computes sin(−15°). The answer comes out negative, about −0.2588, but a 15° angle ends in quadrant I, where sine is positive.
✓ Instead: Put the larger angle first: 15° = 45° − 30°, which gives 6−24 ≈ 0.2588.
✗ Not this: 10° = 40° − 30°, so the difference formula gives sin 10° exactly.
The method needs both pieces to be special, and 40° is not: sin 40° and cos 40° are not in the table, so one unknown has become two. No other pair works either: every special angle is a multiple of 15°, so every sum or difference of special angles is too, and 10° is not.
✓ Instead: These formulas reach the multiples of 15° that are not already special, such as 15°, 75°, 105° and 165°. For 10°, use a calculator decimal: sin 10° ≈ 0.1736 (rounded).
✗ Not this: 6−24=44=24=12
Square roots do not subtract under one root sign: 6 − 2 ≈ 2.4495 − 1.4142 = 1.0353, while 4 = 2. The result 12 is sin 30°, and 15° cannot have the same sine as 30°, because its point sits lower on the circle.
✓ Instead: Leave the top as 6 − 2. The value 6−24 is already in simplest form.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory cue for the four formulas: sine mixes and keeps, cosine matches and flips. Sine pairs a sine with a cosine and keeps the sign between the angles; cosine pairs cosine with cosine and sine with sine, and flips the sign.
  • Size check before any calculator: a small angle such as 15° has a small sine and a cosine close to 1. Of the two numbers 6−24 ≈ 0.2588 and 6+24 ≈ 0.9659, the one with the minus sign is the small one.
  • Cofunction check: 15° and 75° add up to 90°, so sin 75° = cos 15° and cos 75° = sin 15°. The same two numbers trade places, which checks a pair of answers at once.
  • Calculator check: use degree mode for 15°. If sin 15 shows 0.6503, the calculator is reading 15 as radians; in radian mode, type sin(π ÷ 12) to get 0.2588.
  • Two builds, one answer: 15° = 45° − 30° and 15° = 60° − 45° give the same exact value. If two builds disagree, a slip is hiding in one of them.
  • Do not memorize the table of 15° values; each entry rebuilds in about a minute. Remember the pattern instead: every answer is 6+24 or 6−24, with a sign from the quadrant.

7 The trap

Getting the sign wrong in the cosine formula. cos 15° = cos(45° − 30°) has a plus in the middle: cos 30° cos 45° + sin 30° sin 45° = 6+24 ≈ 0.9659. Copying the minus from the angles gives 6−24 ≈ 0.2588, which is cos 75°, not cos 15°. Catch it with a size check: a small angle such as 15° has a cosine close to 1, so its cosine must be the larger of the two numbers.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Why is 6−24 the exact value of sin 15°, while 0.2588 is not?
  • 0.2588 is rounded: the digits of sin 15° never end, so a decimal can only come close.
  • 6−24 is the true number. It comes from the difference formula with 15° = 45° − 30°, which only multiplies and subtracts exact values such as 22 and 12. None of those steps rounds anything.
The special-angle table has no row for 15° or 75°. How do you build them from special angles?
  • 75° = 45° + 30°
  • 15° = 45° − 30°. Put the larger angle first: 30° − 45° is −15°, a different angle.
  • It works like paying with coins: a half dollar and a quarter make 75 cents, and handing over a quarter and getting a dime back pays 15 cents.
What is the exact value of sin 75°?
  • 75° = 45° + 30°, so use the sum formula:
  • sin 75° = sin 45° cos 30° + cos 45° sin 30°
  • =22·32+22·12=64+24
  • =6+24
  • Check: 6+24 ≈ 0.9659 (rounded), the same decimal a calculator set to degrees gives for sin 75°.
For cos 15° = cos(45° − 30°), is the sign in the middle of the formula a plus or a minus?
  • A plus: cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b. Sine keeps the sign between the angles; cosine flips it.
  • So cos 15° = cos 45° cos 30° + sin 45° sin 30° = 6+24 ≈ 0.9659 (rounded).
  • Size check: 15° is close to 0°, where the cosine is 1, so cos 15° must be close to 1. The minus version, 6−24 ≈ 0.2588 (rounded), is far too small: it is cos 75°.

From earlier

The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

Starting from cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, how do you get the formula for cos(a + b)?
Show answer
Drop −b into the slot for b, because a − (−b) = a + b.
Turning by −b instead of b keeps the cosine and flips the sign of the sine: cos(−b) = cos b and sin(−b) = −sin b.
So the sin a sin b part changes sign:
cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b

The cosine of a sum and the sine formulas

Why is cos(π + t) = −cos t true for every angle t?
Show answer
Put π in the a slot and t in the b slot of the cos(a + b) formula. The point at π is (−1, 0), so cos π = −1 and sin π = 0.
cos(π + t) = (−1) · cos t − 0 · sin t = −cos t
The cos(a + b) formula works for every pair of angles, so this works for every t.

Lesson 5 of 7

The tangent of a sum or a difference

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Tangent on the unit circleLeans on: Special tangentsLeans on: Reference angle and quadrant signLeans on: Sum formulas for sine and cosineLeans on: Adding a whole number to a fractionLeans on: Dividing two fractionsLeans on: Subtracting a negativeLeans on: Clearing a root from a bottom with two termsLeans on: Squaring a sum or a differenceLeans on: Dividing by zeroLeans on: Radians to degreesLeans on: Solving for one unknownOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

The tangent of an angle measures steepness. Picture a ramp leaning at that angle: its tangent is how far the ramp rises for each step across. A ramp at 45° rises 1 for every 1, so tan 45° = 1. Now you tilt the ramp further by a second angle. The new steepness is not the two steepnesses added together. The closer a ramp gets to straight up, the faster its steepness grows, and a ramp standing straight up has no steepness number at all. The sum formula for tangent gives the new steepness: add the two tangents on top; on the bottom, take 1 minus the two tangents multiplied together. When that bottom reaches 0, the ramp is standing straight up.

2 Picture it

tan(a+b)=tana+tanb1−tanatanb

tan(a−b)=tana−tanb1+tanatanb

Top: the same sign as between the angles

Bottom: 1, then the other sign

Bottom = 0: undefined, the angle is on the y-axis

No tan a or tan b: split another way, or use sin ÷ cos

Reminder

Reminder: Tangent on the unit circle, Special tangents, Reference angle and quadrant sign, Sum formulas for sine and cosine, Adding a whole number to a fraction, Dividing two fractions, Subtracting a negative, Clearing a root from a bottom with two terms, Squaring a sum or a difference, Dividing by zero, Radians to degrees, Solving for one unknown
  • Tangent on the unit circle. tan θ = sinθcosθ = y ÷ x at the angle's point. At 90° the point is (0, 1), so tan 90° = 10 does not exist.
  • Special tangents. From the table: tan 30° = 33, tan 45° = 1, tan 60° = 3. Also tan 0° = 0 and tan 180° = 0.
  • Reference angle and quadrant sign. Tangent is positive in quadrants I and III and negative in II and IV; the reference angle gives its size. 135° has reference angle 45°, so tan 135° = −1.
  • Sum formulas for sine and cosine. sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b and cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b; for a − b, flip the middle sign of each.
  • Adding a whole number to a fraction. Write the whole number over the same bottom: 1 + 33 = 33 + 33 = 3+33.
  • Dividing two fractions. Multiply by the flip of the second: 34 ÷ 78 = 34 × 87 = 2428 = 67. When the bottoms are equal, they cancel.
  • Subtracting a negative. Multiply before you subtract, and subtracting a negative adds: 1 − (−1) · 4 = 1 − (−4) = 5.
  • Clearing a root from a bottom with two terms. Multiply top and bottom by the bottom with its middle sign flipped: (3 − 3)(3 + 3) = 9 − 3 = 6, because (p − q)(p + q) = p2 − q2.
  • Squaring a sum or a difference. (p + q)2 = p2 + 2pq + q2, not p2 + q2: (3 + 3)2 = 9 + 63 + 3 = 12 + 63. With a minus, the middle term is −2pq.
  • Dividing by zero. 02 = 0, but 20 has no answer, because no number times 0 gives 2.
  • Radians to degrees. π radians is 180°, so π12 = 15° and 11π12 = 11 × 15° = 165°.
  • Solving for one unknown. Undo what was done to it: in 1 − tan x = 0, add tan x to both sides to get 1 = tan x.

3 Why

Tangent is sine over cosine, so tan(a + b) = sin(a+b)cos(a+b). Expand both by the sine and cosine sum formulas, then divide top and bottom by cos a cos b, allowed when neither cosine is 0. On top, each term becomes a sine over its own cosine: tan a + tan b. On the bottom, cos a cos b becomes 1 and sin a sin b becomes tan a tan b. That bottom is cos(a + b) ÷ (cos a cos b), so it is 0 exactly when tan(a + b) does not exist. For a − b, both middle signs flip.

4 The rule

tan(a+b)=tana+tanb1−tanatanb and tan(a−b)=tana−tanb1+tanatanbBoth need tan a and tan b to exist.

When the bottom is 0, the tangent of the sum or difference is undefined.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

the tangent of a plus b is tan a plus tan b, over 1 minus tan a times tan b. For a minus b: tan a minus tan b, over 1 plus tan a times tan b.

Write it

The tangent of a sum is the sum of the two tangents divided by 1 minus their product; the tangent of a difference is the difference of the two tangents divided by 1 plus their product; when that bottom is 0, the tangent is undefined.

In math
  • tan(a+b)=tana+tanb1−tanatanb
  • tan(a−b)=tana−tanb1+tanatanb
  • Both at once: tan(a ± b) = tana±tanb1∓tanatanb, reading the upper signs together and the lower signs together
  • Undefined: 1 − tan a tan b = 0 for a sum, 1 + tan a tan b = 0 for a difference
  • In radians, the same: tan(π3 + π4) = 3+11−3
  • The route that works even when tan a or tan b is missing: tan(a + b) = sin(a+b)cos(a+b)
Like

Like tilting a ramp twice: the second tilt adds more steepness the steeper the ramp already is, and a ramp standing straight up has no steepness number.

See it
π/2π3π/2−4−224
Tangent rises across each piece of its graph, without bound as x nears a dashed line from the left.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

On the unit circle, the tangent of an angle is y ÷ x at its point: how high the point is compared with how far right. At 75° the point is about (0.259, 0.966): tall and close to the y-axis, so tan 75° ≈ 0.966 ÷ 0.259 ≈ 3.73. Adding the tangents of 45° and 30° gives only 1 + 0.577 ≈ 1.58. As an angle climbs toward 90° from below, x shrinks toward 0 and y ÷ x grows without end; at 90°, x is 0, and so is the bottom of the formula.

x = cos θy = sin θP
At 75° the x leg is short and the y leg is long, so y ÷ x is large: about 3.73.
As a story

A drawbridge opens in two pushes. After the first push its deck climbs 1 foot for every 4 feet across: a steepness of 14. The second push turns it further by the angle whose steepness is 35. Adding the two says 1720, but the formula gives (14 + 35) ÷ (1 − 14 · 35) = 1720 ÷ 1720 = 1: the deck now climbs 1 foot for every foot across. Had the two steepnesses been 2 and 12, whose product is 1, the bottom would be 0, and the deck would stand straight up, with no steepness number.

Why it must look like this

Test the formula on turns you can see. With b = 0°: tana+01−tana·0 = tan a, and turning by 0° changes nothing. With b = 180°: tan 180° = 0, so you get tan a again, and a half turn leaves the side on the same line, as steep as before. With a = b = 45°: 1+11−1·1 = 20, undefined, and 45° + 45° = 90° points straight up. A bottom of 1 + tan a tan b would give 1 there, so the minus is forced.

As a rule of thumb

Same sign on top, the other sign on the bottom, and the bottom always starts with 1. Sum: plus on top, minus on the bottom. Difference: minus on top, plus on the bottom. The bottom is the warning light: when it comes out 0, stop, because the tangent is undefined.

PieceSum formula, a + bDifference formula, a − b
Toptan a + tan btana−tanb
Bottom1−tanatanb1 + tan a tan b
Bottom is 0 whentan a tan b = 1tanatanb=−1
An angle pair where that happens60° + 30° = 90°135°−45°=90°
Cannot start whena or b is on the y-axis (90°, 270°)a or b is on the y-axis (90°, 270°)

5 How

  1. Say what is asked: the tangent of a sum or difference of two angles, either an exact value for one angle or a value from two tangents you are given.
  2. If you start from one angle, write it as a sum or difference of two angles whose tangents you know. Leave out 90° and 270°, which have no tangent.
  3. Choose by the sign between the angles: the sum formula for a + b, the difference formula for a − b.
  4. Put each tangent in its place, and wrap a negative one in parentheses.
  5. Work out the bottom first. If it is 0, stop: the tangent of the sum or difference is undefined.
  6. Work out the top, divide the top by the bottom, and clear any square root from the bottom.
  7. Check: the sign must match the quadrant where the angle lands, and a calculator decimal must match your answer.

Finding the tangent of a sum or a difference

1
Is the angle itself on the table of special angles, or in another quadrant with a table angle as its reference angle (such as 120° or 225°)?
YesRead the value for the reference angle and give it the quadrant's sign; no formula is needed.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Can you write it as a sum or difference of two angles whose tangents you know, neither of them 90° or 270°?
YesUse the sum formula or the difference formula with that split.
NoUse tan = sin ÷ cos with the sum formulas for sine and cosine.
↓
3
Is the bottom (1 − tan a tan b for a sum, 1 + tan a tan b for a difference) equal to 0?
YesStop: the tangent is undefined, because the angle lies on the y-axis.
NoDivide the top by the bottom.
↓
4
Is a square root left in the bottom?
YesMultiply top and bottom by the bottom with its middle sign flipped, then simplify.
NoSimplify, then check the sign with the quadrant.
  1. Say what is asked, and change radians to degrees if that helps you see where the angle lands.
  2. Choose a split into angles whose tangents you know, leaving out 90° and 270°.
  3. Choose the sum formula or the difference formula by the sign between the two angles.
  4. Work out the bottom first; a 0 there means the answer is undefined.
  5. Work out the top, divide, and clear any square root from the bottom.
  6. Check the sign with the quadrant and the size with a calculator.

6 Worked example

Worked example

The exact value of tan 75°

Find the exact value of tan 75°.

Show the steps and the answer
45°30°sum = 75°
75° is a turn of 45° and then 30° more, two angles from the table.
input θoutput tan θ0°030°(√3)/345°160°√3↓ evaluate: input given, read the output below it
The special tangents: the highlighted columns under 30° and 45° hold the two values this example needs.
  1. Say what it asks: tan75° written with whole numbers and square roots, not a rounded decimal. 75° is not on the table of special angles, so build it from two angles that are.An exact value keeps every digit, and the sum formula needs angles whose tangents we already know exactly.
  2. Write 75°=45°+30°.45° and 30° are both on the table, they add to 75°, and neither is 90°, so both tangents exist.
  3. Read the two tangents from the table: the column under 45° holds 1, and the column under 30° holds 33.These are the special values, highlighted in the picture.
  4. Use the sum formula: tan75°=tan45°+tan30°1−tan45°tan30°.The angles are added, so the top gets a plus and the bottom gets 1 minus the product.
  5. Work out the bottom first: 1−1·33=33−33=3−33, about 0.42, so not 0.Multiplying by 1 changes nothing, and writing 1 as 33 lets us subtract over the same bottom. A bottom of 0 would mean 75° points straight up, and it does not.
  6. Work out the top: 1+33=33+33=3+33.The same move: write 1 with bottom 3, then add the tops.
  7. Divide the top by the bottom: 3+33÷3−33=3+33×33−3=3+33−3.To divide by a fraction, multiply by its flip; the 3 on the bottom of the first fraction cancels the 3 on top of the second.
  8. Clear the square root from the bottom: multiply top and bottom by 3+3. The bottom becomes (3−3)(3+3)=9−3=6.(p − q)(p + q) = p2 − q2, and (3)2 = 3, so the root disappears. Multiplying top and bottom by the same number keeps the value.
  9. The top becomes (3+3)2=9+63+3=12+63.(p + q)2 = p2 + 2pq + q2: here p2 = 9, 2pq = 2 · 3 · 3 = 63, and q2 = 3.
  10. Divide each part of the top by 6: 12+636=126+636=2+3.A top made of added parts splits into one fraction per part, all over the same bottom.
Answer
tan 75° = 2 + 3 (exact), about 3.732 (rounded)
Double-check Second way, with a calculator in degree mode: tan 75° ≈ 3.7321, and 2 + 3 ≈ 2 + 1.7321 = 3.7321. They match. Third way, as sine over cosine: sin 75° ≈ 0.9659 and cos 75° ≈ 0.2588, and 0.9659 ÷ 0.2588 ≈ 3.732.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 7

A half turn changes nothing

Use the sum formula to find tan 225°, writing 225° = 180° + 45°.

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 225° the point is down and to the left with legs of equal length.
  1. Say what it asks: find tan225° with the sum formula, as a half turn of 180° and then 45° more. The unit circle can also give this answer, which makes it a good first test of the formula.The sum formula needs two angles whose tangents we know.
  2. Find the two tangents: tan180°=0 and tan45°=1.At 180° the unit circle point is (−1, 0), so tan 180° = y ÷ x = 0 ÷ (−1) = 0; tan 45° = 1 is on the table.
  3. Bottom first: 1−tan180°·tan45°=1−0·1=1.Anything times 0 is 0. The bottom is 1, not 0, so the answer exists.
  4. Top: tan180°+tan45°=0+1=1.The sum formula adds the two tangents on top.
  5. Divide: 11=1.The tangent of the sum is the top divided by the bottom.
Answer
tan 225° = 1
Double-check Second way, on the unit circle: 225° lands at (−22, −22), so tan 225° = y ÷ x = 1, since a number divided by itself is 1. The same steps with any angle θ in place of 45° give tanθ+01−tanθ·0 = tan θ: adding 180° never changes a tangent.

Rung 2 of 7

Rung 2, two tangents as small fractions

Two angles a and b have tan a = 12 and tan b = 14. Find tan(a + b).

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = 2y = 1rP(2, 1)Ox = 2 (2 right) y = 1 (1 up) r = √5.0 ≈ 2.2the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
An angle whose tangent is 12: its side climbs 1 for every 2 across, because tan θ = y ÷ x.
  1. Say what it asks: we know the two tangents, not the angles, and want the tangent of the two angles added together.The sum formula is written only in tan a and tan b, so we never need a or b themselves.
  2. Bottom first: 1−12·14=1−18=88−18=78.Multiply fractions top times top and bottom times bottom; then write 1 as 88 to subtract. The bottom is not 0.
  3. Top: 12+14=24+14=34.To add fractions, rewrite both over a common bottom, here 4.
  4. Divide: 34÷78=34×87=2428=67.To divide by a fraction, multiply by its flip; then divide the top and bottom of 2428 by 4.
Answer
tan(a+b)=67
Double-check Second way, going back with the difference formula: a = (a + b) − b, so the difference formula with tan(a + b) = 67 and tan b = 14 must give tan a. Bottom: 1 + 67 · 14 = 1 + 628 = 3428. Top: 67 − 14 = 2428 − 728 = 1728. Then 1728 ÷ 3428 = 1734 = 12, which is tan a. Adding the tangents would have given 34, a different and wrong answer.

Rung 3 of 7

Rung 3, the difference formula with special angles

Find the exact value of tan 15°.

Show the steps and the answer
15°30°sum = 45°
45° cut into 15° and 30°, so 15° = 45° − 30°.
  1. Say what it asks: tan15° with square roots, not decimals. 15° is not on the table.We will build it from table angles.
  2. Write 15°=45°−30°.Both are table angles, neither is 90°, and 45° − 30° = 15°.
  3. Use the difference formula: tan15°=tan45°−tan30°1+tan45°tan30°.The angles are subtracted, so the top gets a minus and the bottom gets 1 plus the product.
  4. Bottom first: 1+1·33=3+33, not 0. Top: 1−33=3−33.tan 45° = 1 and tan 30° = 33; writing 1 as 33 puts everything over the same bottom.
  5. Divide: 3−33÷3+33=3−33+3.Multiply by the flip; the two 3s cancel.
  6. Multiply top and bottom by 3−3. Bottom: (3+3)(3−3)=9−3=6. Top: (3−3)2=9−63+3=12−63.Flipping the middle sign of the bottom clears its root, and (p − q)2 = p2 − 2pq + q2.
  7. Simplify: 12−636=2−3.Divide each part of the top by 6.
Answer
tan 15° = 2 − 3 (exact), about 0.268 (rounded)
Double-check Second way, with a calculator in degree mode: tan 15° ≈ 0.2679, and 2 − 3 ≈ 2 − 1.7321 = 0.2679. They match. The answer is positive, as it must be for an angle in quadrant I.

Rung 4 of 7

Rung 4, a negative tangent goes in: radians and a double negative

Find the exact value of tan 11π12.

Show the steps and the answer
P
11π12 is 165°.
  1. Say what it asks: an exact tangent for the angle 11π12 radians. Since π radians is 180°,π12 is 15°, and 11π12 is 11×15°=165°, which is not on the table.Changing to degrees shows where the angle lands and which pieces can build it.
  2. Split it: 3π4=9π12 and π6=2π12, so 3π4+π6=11π12.To add fractions of π, give them the same bottom: 9 twelfths plus 2 twelfths is 11 twelfths. In degrees, 135° + 30° = 165°.
  3. The tangents: tan3π4=−1 and tanπ6=33.3π4 is 135°, in quadrant II with reference angle 45°, so its tangent is −1; π6 is 30°.
  4. Bottom first, with the negative in parentheses: 1−(−1)·33=1+33=3+33.(−1) times 33 is −33, and subtracting a negative adds it. The bottom is not 0.
  5. Top: −1+33=−3+33.Write −1 as −33 to add over the same bottom.
  6. Divide: −3+33÷3+33=−3+33+3.Multiply by the flip; the two 3s cancel.
  7. Multiply top and bottom by 3−3. Bottom: (3+3)(3−3)=9−3=6.Flipping the middle sign of the bottom clears its root.
  8. Top: −3+3 is −(3−3), so the top is −(3−3)2=−(9−63+3)=−12+63.Pulling out the minus sign turns the top into a square, and (p − q)2 = p2 − 2pq + q2.
  9. Simplify: −12+636=−2+3, which is 3−2.Divide each part of the top by 6.
Answer
tan 11π12 = 3 − 2 (exact), about −0.268 (rounded)
Double-check Second way, from rung 3: 165° = 180° − 15°, so its reference angle is 15°, and in quadrant II the tangent is negative: tan 165° = −tan 15° = −(2 − 3) = 3 − 2. It matches. A calculator in radian mode gives tan(11π ÷ 12) ≈ −0.2679, and 1.7321 − 2 = −0.2679.

Rung 5 of 7

Rung 5, the bottom comes out 0

Use the sum formula on tan(60° + 30°). What does it give, and why?

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θP
At 90° the point is (0, 1): its x is 0, so tan = y ÷ x has a zero bottom, the same zero the formula finds.
  1. Say what it asks: put tan60° and tan30° into the sum formula and read what comes out.This shows how the formula warns you that a tangent does not exist.
  2. The tangents: tan60°=3 and tan30°=33.Both are on the table.
  3. Bottom first: 1−3·33=1−33=1−1=0.3 · 3 = 3, so the two tangents multiply to exactly 1. Working out the bottom first tells us whether a division is possible at all.
  4. Top: 3+33=333+33=433, about 2.31.Write 3 as 333 to add over the same bottom.
  5. The formula asks for 433÷0, which has no answer.No number times 0 gives 433, so dividing by 0 is impossible.
  6. Plug the angle back in to see why: 60°+30°=90°, and the unit circle point at 90° is (0, 1), so tan90°=10.The zero bottom of the formula is the zero x of the point straight up.
Answer
tan(60° + 30°) is undefined: the bottom of the formula is 0, because 60° + 30° = 90° points straight up.
Double-check Second way: tan 90° = sin90°cos90° = 10, which has no answer. The formula and the unit circle agree.

Rung 6 of 7

Rung 6, a split that breaks the formula

Use a tangent formula to find tan 120°. A first try writes 120° = 90° + 30°.

Show the steps and the answer
120°60°sum = 180°
120° and 60° make 180°, so 120° = 180° − 60°: a split with no 90° in it.
  1. Say what it asks: the tangent of 120° by a formula, which means choosing a split the formula can use. The reference angle can also give the answer, which will be our check.Some splits feed the formula a tangent that does not exist.
  2. Try 120°=90°+30°: the sum formula needs tan90°, which is undefined. Stop: this split cannot be used.The formula was built by dividing by cos a cos b, and cos 90° = 0, so it never worked with a = 90°.
  3. Split again: 120°=180°−60°, and use the difference formula: tan120°=tan180°−tan60°1+tan180°tan60°.180° and 60° both have tangents, 0 and 3, and 180° − 60° = 120°.
  4. Bottom: 1+0·3=1. Top: 0−3=−3.Anything times 0 is 0, so the bottom is 1, not 0.
  5. Divide: −31=−3.Dividing by 1 changes nothing.
Answer
tan 120° = −3, about −1.732 (rounded)
Double-check Second way, keeping the 90° + 30° split but going through sine and cosine: sin(90° + 30°) = sin 90° cos 30° + cos 90° sin 30° = 1 · 32 + 0 · 12 = 32, and cos(90° + 30°) = cos 90° cos 30° − sin 90° sin 30° = 0 − 12 = −12. Their quotient is 32 ÷ (−12) = −3. It matches, and 120° is in quadrant II, where tangent is negative.

Rung 7 of 7

Rung 7, genuinely hard: the formula with a letter

Write tan(x + 45°) using only tan x. Then say where the new form fails for x in one full turn, from 0° up to but not including 360°, and what the true tangent is there.

Show the steps and the answer

tan(x+45°)=tanx+11−tanx

Bottom 0 at x = 45° and 225°: truly undefined

No tan x at x = 90° and 270°: the true value is −1

  1. Say what it asks: rewrite the tangent of a sum that contains a letter, then find the inputs where the rewritten form breaks.A form with a letter is a rule for many angles at once, so we must know where it stops working.
  2. Use the sum formula with a=x and b=45°: tan(x+45°)=tanx+tan45°1−tanx·tan45°=tanx+11−tanx.tan 45° = 1, and tan x times 1 is tan x.
  3. Set the bottom equal to 0: 1−tanx=0, so tanx=1. This finds the inputs that would make the bottom zero, so we can name them.Adding tan x to both sides of 1 − tan x = 0 gives 1 = tan x.
  4. tanx=1 at x=45° and at x=225°. Plug x=45° back in: 1+11−1=20, no answer, and 45°+45°=90° has no tangent. At x=225° the angle is 270°, which has no tangent either.tan 45° = 1 is on the table, and rung 1 showed tan 225° = 1. Here the form is right to fail.
  5. Find where the form cannot start: tan x itself does not exist at x=90° and x=270°.Tangent is undefined where cos x = 0, on the y-axis.
  6. Look at those angles directly: x+45° is 135° or 315°, and tan135°=−1 and tan315°=−1. The tangent exists there, but the new form cannot show it.135° is in quadrant II and 315° is in quadrant IV; both have reference angle 45°, and tangent is negative in both quadrants.
Answer
  • tan(x+45°)=tanx+11−tanx
  • It gives no answer at x = 45° and x = 225°, where tan(x + 45°) itself is undefined.
  • It cannot start at x = 90° and x = 270°, where tan(x + 45°) = −1 exists anyway.
Double-check Test the new form at angles you know. At x = 0°: 0+11−0 = 1, and tan 45° = 1. At x = 30°: it becomes (33 + 1) ÷ (1 − 33), the main example, which gave tan 75° = 2 + 3. Both match.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: tan75°=tan45°+tan30°=1+33≈1.577
Tangents do not add, for the same reason cosines do not: a calculator gives tan 75° ≈ 3.732, more than twice as much.
✓ Instead: Use the sum formula: tan 75° = tan45°+tan30°1−tan45°tan30° = 2 + 3 ≈ 3.732 (rounded).
✗ Not this: A plus on the bottom of the sum formula: tan(45° + 45°) = 1+11+1·1 = 1
45° + 45° = 90° points straight up, where tangent does not exist, so an answer of 1 cannot be right.
✓ Instead: The sum formula has 1 minus the product: 1+11−1·1 = 20, undefined, which matches tan 90°.
✗ Not this: The bottom came out 0, so the answer is 0.
A zero bottom does not make a zero answer: 02 = 0, but 20 has no answer, because no number times 0 gives 2.
✓ Instead: The formula gives 20, which is not a number: write undefined, matching tan 90°.
✗ Not this: tan135°=tan(90°+45°)=tan90°+11−tan90°·1
tan 90° is not a number, so nothing can go in its place; the formula was built by dividing by cos 90° = 0.
✓ Instead: Split another way: tan 135° = tan(180° − 45°) = 0−11+0·1 = −1.
✗ Not this: 3+33−3: cross out the 3s to get 3−3 = −1
You may cancel only a number that multiplies the whole top and the whole bottom. Here 3 is added, not multiplied, and the true value is about 3.73, not −1.
✓ Instead: Multiply top and bottom by 3 + 3: 12+636 = 2 + 3.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory cue: same on top, opposite on the bottom. The sign between the angles goes on top; the bottom starts with 1 and takes the other sign.
  • Sign test: run 45° + 45° through your formula. The bottom must come out 0, because 90° has no tangent; a bottom of 2 means the sign is wrong.
  • Work out the bottom before the top. If it is 0, write undefined and stop, with no more arithmetic to do.
  • Decide the sign before you simplify, from the quadrant where the angle lands: 165° is in quadrant II, so its tangent must be negative.
  • Decimal check: compare your exact answer with the calculator's tangent of the whole angle, in degree mode for degrees and radian mode for radians.
  • Never use 90° or 270° (π2 or 3π2) as a piece of a split. 0° and 180° are safe pieces, with tangent 0.
  • Cofunction check: 75° = 90° − 15°, so sin 75° = cos 15° and cos 75° = sin 15°, which makes tan 75° = 1 ÷ tan 15°. Indeed (2 + 3)(2 − 3) = 4 − 3 = 1.

7 The trap

Putting the same sign on the bottom as on top, for example 1 + tan a tan b in the sum formula. The bottom always takes the other sign. Test it with 45° + 45° = 90°, where tangent does not exist: the bottom must come out 0, and only 1 − 1 · 1 does.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

What are the sum formula and the difference formula for tangent, and how do you place the signs?
  • tan(a+b)=tana+tanb1−tanatanb
  • tan(a−b)=tana−tanb1+tanatanb
  • The top copies the sign between the angles. The bottom starts with 1 and takes the other sign.
In the sum formula for tangent, what does it mean when the bottom, 1 − tan a tan b, comes out 0?
  • tan(a + b) is undefined. The formula would divide by 0.
  • The bottom is 0 exactly when tan a · tan b = 1. Then the ramp at angle a + b stands straight up and has no steepness number.
  • Example: tan 45° · tan 45° = 1 · 1 = 1, and 45° + 45° = 90°, which has no tangent.
A ramp leans at angle a with tan a = 4, and you tilt it further by angle b with tan b = 12. What is tan(a + b)?
  • tan(a+b)=(4+12)÷(1−4·12)=92÷(−1)=−92
  • Check the sign: the product tan a tan b = 2 is more than 1, and for two angles between 0° and 90° that happens only when they add up to more than 90°. The ramp has tipped past straight up and leans back the other way, where the tangent is negative.
Find tan 15° exactly.
  • 15° = 60° − 45°, so use the difference formula with tan 60° = 3 and tan 45° = 1.
  • tan15°=3−11+3·1=3−11+3
  • Clear the square root from the bottom: multiply top and bottom by 3 − 1. Top: (3 − 1)2 = 4 − 23. Bottom: (1 + 3)(3 − 1) = 3 − 1 = 2.
  • tan 15° = 4−232 = 2 − 3 ≈ 0.268 (rounded), the same as a calculator gives.

Lesson 6 of 7

Using the formulas from one value of each angle

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: Sine and cosine from a pointLeans on: The Pythagorean theoremLeans on: Signs by quadrant (All Students Take Calculus)Leans on: Multiplying fractionsLeans on: Signs in a productLeans on: Adding fractions with the same bottomLeans on: Taking away a negativeLeans on: Multiplying and simplifying square rootsLeans on: The sum and difference formulasLeans on: Degree mode on a calculatorOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

Every sine or cosine sum formula and difference formula is a recipe with four ingredients: the sine and the cosine of the first angle, and the sine and the cosine of the second. A problem often hands you only one of each pair, plus the quadrant each angle points into. That is enough to rebuild the rest. Picture a friend on a round path 17 steps from a fountain who says they are 8 steps north of it. That leaves two spots: 15 steps east of the fountain or 15 steps west. When they add that they are on the west side, you know exactly where they stand. Here the right triangle gives the size of the missing value, and the quadrant gives its sign, plus or minus.

2 Picture it

QI (+, +)All positiveQII (−, +)Sine, csc positiveQIII (−, −)Tangent, cot positiveQIV (+, −)Cosine, sec positive
Read the sign of a missing value here.

Reminder

Reminder: Sine and cosine from a point, The Pythagorean theorem, Signs by quadrant (All Students Take Calculus), Multiplying fractions, Signs in a product, Adding fractions with the same bottom, Taking away a negative, Multiplying and simplifying square roots, The sum and difference formulas, Degree mode on a calculator
  • Sine and cosine from a point. For a point (x, y) on the angle's side at distance r from the center, sin θ = yr and cos θ = xr. Example: the point (−3, 4) has r = 5, so cos θ = −35 and sin θ = 45.
  • The Pythagorean theorem. x2 + y2 = r2. Example: y = 8 and r = 17 give x2 = 289 − 64 = 225, so x is 15 or −15.
  • Signs by quadrant (All Students Take Calculus). Quadrant I: All three positive; II: only Sine; III: only Tangent; IV: only Cosine. Example: a in Quadrant II means sin a > 0 and cos a < 0.
  • Multiplying fractions. Tops times tops, bottoms times bottoms: (817)(45) = 3285.
  • Signs in a product. Two negatives make a positive, one negative makes a negative: (−1517)(−35) = 4585 but (−1517)(45) = −6085.
  • Adding fractions with the same bottom. Add the tops and keep the bottom: 3285 + 4585 = 7785.
  • Taking away a negative. Subtracting a negative is adding: 120205 − (−36205) = 156205.
  • Multiplying and simplifying square roots. 5 · 15 = 75, and 75 = 25·3 = 53 because 25 is a perfect square.
  • The sum and difference formulas. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb;sin(a−b)=sinacosb−cosasinb;cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb;cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb.
  • Degree mode on a calculator. Set the calculator to degrees before typing sin 28°: it shows about 0.469. In radian mode the same keys give about 0.271, the sine of 28 radians.

3 Why

Between 0° and 360°, two angles have sine 817: one in Quadrant I and its mirror image across the y-axis in Quadrant II. Their points sit at the same height but on opposite sides of the y-axis, so their cosines are 1517 and −1517. The Pythagorean theorem, x2 + y2 = r2, can only report the size 15, because 152 and (−15)2 are both 225. The quadrant is the extra fact that picks one of the two mirror images. Once all four values are known, the sum formula and difference formula work exactly as before.

4 The rule

One value and the quadrant fix the other value of the same angle: cosa=±1−sin2a and sinb=±1−cos2b, each sign chosen by that angle's quadrant.

Then sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb and cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

from the sine of a and its quadrant, and the cosine of b and its quadrant, find all four values, then the sine of a plus b and the cosine of a minus b.

Write it

When a problem gives one trigonometric value of each angle and the quadrant it points into, rebuild each missing value, its size from the Pythagorean theorem and its sign from the quadrant, then put all four values into the sum formula or difference formula.

In math
  • sin a = 817 with π2 < a < π (Quadrant II), so cos a = −1−sin2a = −1517
  • cos b = 45 with 3π2 < b < 2π (Quadrant IV), so sin b = −1−cos2b = −35
  • sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=7785
  • cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=−8485
Like

Like finding a friend on a round path 17 steps from a fountain who says they are 8 steps north of it: two spots fit, 15 steps east or 15 steps west, and hearing that they are on the west side picks one.

See it
xyθx = −15y = 8rP(−15, 8)Ox = −15 (15 left) y = 8 (8 up) r = 17the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point is 8 up and 17 from the center.

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Put a's point on the unit circle. sin a = 817 puts the point a little under halfway up, and Quadrant II puts it in the upper left. Its left-right reach, which is cos a, lies to the left of the center, so cos a is negative. The triangle under the point supplies the size, 15 out of 17, and the picture supplies the minus.

x = cos θy = sin θa
a's point sits in the upper left: its height, sin a, is positive, and its reach, cos a, is negative.
As a story

A friend walking a round path 17 steps from a fountain calls to say they are 8 steps north of it. The path passes that height at two spots, 15 steps east of the fountain and 15 steps west, since 82 + 152 = 172. When they add that they are on the west side, only one spot is left. The sine is the north clue, the quadrant is the side clue, and you need both to find your friend.

As a rule of thumb

Size from the triangle, sign from the quadrant. Never write a missing value until you have both halves. Left of the y-axis, in Quadrants II and III, every cosine is negative; below the x-axis, in Quadrants III and IV, every sine is negative.

With algebra

The same step without a drawing: sin2a + cos2a = 1, so cos2a = 1 − (817)2 = 1 − 64289 = 225289. Two numbers have that square, 1517 and −1517, so cos a = ±1517. The equation cannot choose between them; the quadrant does. a is in Quadrant II, so cos a = −1517.

sin2a+cos2a=1

cos2a=1−64289=225289

cosa=±1517

Quadrant II: cos a = −1517

QuadrantWhere the angle pointsx and cosy and sin
Ibetween 0° and 90°++
IIbetween 90° and 180°−+
IIIbetween 180° and 270°−−
IVbetween 270° and 360°+−

5 How

  1. Say in plain words what is given (one value of each angle and its quadrant) and what is asked (for example sin(a + b) and cos(a − b)).
  2. Write the four-slot list sin a, cos a, sin b, cos b, and copy in the two given values.
  3. Turn each given value into a right triangle: sine is yr and cosine is xr, with any minus sign on x or y and r always positive.
  4. Find the missing leg with x2 + y2 = r2, then give it the sign its quadrant demands.
  5. Write each missing value as that leg over r, so all four slots are full.
  6. Substitute the four values, each in parentheses, into the sum formula or difference formula, multiply, and combine over the common bottom.
  7. Check that each answer lies between −1 and 1 and that estimates of the angles give the same sign and size.

From one value of each angle to a sum or difference

1
Does the given value carry a minus sign?
YesPut the minus on the leg (y for a sine, x for a cosine), keep r positive, and confirm the sign fits the quadrant.
NoGo on.
↓
2
Is the missing value a cosine, an x?
Yesx2 = r2 − y2. x is negative in Quadrants II and III, positive in I and IV.
NoIt is a sine, a y: y2 = r2 − x2. y is negative in Quadrants III and IV, positive in I and II.
↓
3
Does the question ask for a sine?
Yessin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b and sin(a − b) = sin a cos b − cos a sin b: the middle sign matches the question.
NoIt asks for a cosine: cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b and cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b: the middle sign is the opposite of the question's.
↓
4
Is the answer between −1 and 1?
YesEstimate the angles to confirm the sign, then stop.
NoA missing value or a product went wrong. Recheck the four-slot list and each multiplication.
  1. Say in plain words which value of each angle is given, which quadrant each angle is in, and which combination the question asks for.
  2. Draw the four-slot list sin a, cos a, sin b, cos b, and copy in the two given values with their signs.
  3. For each empty slot, read the given value as a fraction of r: a sine is yr, a cosine is xr. Any minus sign goes on x or y, never on r.
  4. Find the missing leg from x2 + y2 = r2; the square root gives its size.
  5. Give the leg its sign from the quadrant (x is negative in II and III, y is negative in III and IV), and plug back in to see x2 + y2 = r2.
  6. Write the missing value as that leg over r and fill the slot.
  7. Pick the formula that matches the question and substitute every value inside parentheses.
  8. Multiply tops and bottoms, combine over the common bottom, and simplify.
  9. Check that the answer lies between −1 and 1, and that estimates of the angles give the same sign and about the same size.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Sin a in Quadrant II and cos b in Quadrant IV

sin a = 817 with a in Quadrant II, and cos b = 45 with b in Quadrant IV. Find the exact values of sin(a + b) and cos(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = −15y = 8rP(−15, 8)Ox = −15 (15 left) y = 8 (8 up) r = 17the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point: 8 up and 15 to the left, 17 from the center, so cos a = −1517.
xyθx = 4y = −3rP(4, −3)Ox = 4 (4 right) y = −3 (3 down) r = 5the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
b's point: 4 to the right and 3 down, 5 from the center, so sin b = −35.
  1. Say what the question asks. It gives one value of each angle and the quadrant each angle points into, and it wants two exact values: the sine of the angle a+b and the cosine of the angle a−b.Naming the targets picks the formulas, sin(a + b) = sin a cos b + cos a sin b and cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, and both use all four of sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b.
  2. Fill the four-slot list with what is given: sina=817,cosa= ?, sinb= ?, cosb=45.Two slots are empty, cos a and sin b, so those are the two values to rebuild.
  3. Turn sina=817 into a point: sine is yr, so take y=8 and r=17, a point 8 above the x-axis and 17 from the center.Every point on the angle's side gives the same sine, and this choice keeps the numbers whole.
  4. Find the left-right leg: x2+82=172, so x2=289−64=225, and x is 15 or −15.The legs x and y and the slanted side r form a right triangle, so the Pythagorean theorem holds. Both 15 and −15 square to 225, so the root gives the size but not the sign.
  5. Choose the sign: a is in Quadrant II, left of the y-axis, so x=−15. Plug back in: (−15)2+82=225+64=289=172.Every point left of the y-axis has a negative x. The plug-back shows the point really is 17 from the center.
  6. So cosa=xr=−1517=−1517.Cosine is x over r, and r is a distance, always positive.
  7. Do the same for b: cosb=45=xr, so x=4 and r=5. Then y2=52−42=25−16=9, and y is 3 or −3.The same right triangle, but now the missing leg is the up-down one.
  8. b is in Quadrant IV, below the x-axis, so y=−3 and sinb=yr=−35. Plug back in: 42+(−3)2=16+9=25=52.Every point below the x-axis has a negative y.
  9. The full list: sina=817,cosa=−1517,sinb=−35,cosb=45.With every slot filled and signed, the formulas become copying.
  10. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=(817)(45)+(−1517)(−35).This is the sine sum formula: the sine of one angle times the cosine of the other, done both ways and added. Parentheses keep each sign attached to its value.
  11. =3285+4585=7785.Tops times tops (8 · 4 = 32 and 15 · 3 = 45), bottoms times bottoms (17 · 5 = 85), and a negative times a negative is positive. The bottoms match, so add the tops: 32 + 45 = 77.
  12. cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=(−1517)(45)+(817)(−35).This is the cosine difference formula: cosine times cosine plus sine times sine. For a difference the middle sign is plus.
  13. =−6085−2485=−8485.15 · 4 = 60 and 8 · 3 = 24. Each product has exactly one negative factor, so each is negative. Over the shared bottom 85: −60 − 24 = −84.
  14. Make sure both answers are finished: 77=7·11,84=2·2·3·7 and 85=5·17 share no factor, and both fractions lie between −1 and 1.A fraction is finished when its top and bottom share no factor. A sine or cosine is a coordinate on the unit circle, so it is never below −1 or above 1.
Answer
  • sin(a+b)=7785
  • cos(a−b)=−8485
Double-check Second way, by estimating the angles on a calculator in degree mode. Trying angles shows sin 28° ≈ 0.469, close to 817 ≈ 0.471, so a's reference angle is about 28° and a ≈ 180° − 28° = 152°. Trying again shows cos 37° ≈ 0.799, close to 45 = 0.8, so b is about 37° below the positive x-axis: b ≈ −37°, the same direction as 323°. Then a + b ≈ 152° − 37° = 115°, and sin 115° ≈ 0.906, matching 7785 ≈ 0.906. And a − b ≈ 152° + 37° = 189°, and cos 189° ≈ −0.988, matching −8485 ≈ −0.988. Had cos a lost its minus sign, sin(a + b) would have come out −1385 ≈ −0.153, which does not match: the estimate catches the sign slip.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 6

All four values are given

All four values are given: sin a = 817, cos a = 1517, sin b = 1517 and cos b = 817. Find sin(a + b).

Show the steps and the answer
θ15817
The corner marked θ is a, with opposite side 8 and adjacent side 15.
  1. Say what it asks: every value the formula needs is already here, so the job is to substitute and add.With no slot empty there are no square roots to take and no signs to choose.
  2. Write sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb.That is the sine sum formula.
  3. Substitute: (817)(817)+(1517)(1517).sin a = 817 pairs with cos b = 817, and cos a = 1517 pairs with sin b = 1517.
  4. =64289+225289=289289=1.8 · 8 = 64, 15 · 15 = 225 and 17 · 17 = 289; the bottoms match, so add the tops: 64 + 225 = 289.
Answer
sin(a + b) = 1
Double-check Second way, with a picture. Both values of each angle are positive, so each angle is in Quadrant I and can be drawn as a sharp corner of a right triangle. a has opposite side 8 and adjacent side 15; b has opposite side 15 and adjacent side 8. So a and b are the two sharp corners of one 8-15-17 right triangle. The square corner takes 90° of the triangle's 180°, so a + b = 90° for that choice (and a whole number of turns past 90° for any other), which is also why sin b equals cos a (the cofunction fact). sin 90° = 1, the same answer.

Rung 2 of 6

One value each, both angles in Quadrant I

sin a = 941 and cos b = 1517, with a and b both in Quadrant I. Find sin(a + b).

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = 40y = 9rP(40, 9)Ox = 40 (40 right) y = 9 (9 up) r = 41the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point is 40 across and 9 up, 41 from the center, so cos a = 4041.
  1. Say what it asks: one value of each angle is given; find the sine of the angle a+b.The sine sum formula needs sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b, so cos a and sin b must be rebuilt first.
  2. For a: sina=941=yr, so y=9 and r=41. Then x2=412−92=1681−81=1600, so x=40.x, y and r form a right triangle, and 40 · 40 = 1600. In Quadrant I x is positive, so this rung has no sign to decide.
  3. cosa=xr=4041. Plug back in: 402+92=1600+81=1681=412.Cosine is x over r, and the plug-back confirms the triangle.
  4. For b: cosb=1517=xr, so x=15 and r=17. Then y2=289−225=64, so y=8 and sinb=817.Same triangle with the up-down leg missing; Quadrant I keeps y positive.
  5. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=(941)(1517)+(4041)(817).The sine sum formula, each value in parentheses.
  6. =135697+320697=455697.9 · 15 = 135, 40 · 8 = 320 and 41 · 17 = 697. The bottoms match, so add the tops: 135 + 320 = 455. Since 455 = 5 · 7 · 13 and 697 = 17 · 41 share no factor, the fraction is finished.
Answer
sin(a+b)=455697
Double-check Second way: find the partner value cos(a + b) = cos a cos b − sin a sin b = (4041)(1517) − (941)(817) = 600697 − 72697 = 528697. The sine and the cosine of one angle always have squares that add to 1, and here 4552 + 5282 = 207025 + 278784 = 485809 = 6972, so (455697)2 + (528697)2 = 1. A slip in any product would almost never land exactly on 1.

Rung 3 of 6

One angle in Quadrant II

sin a = 2129 with a in Quadrant II, and cos b = 45 with b in Quadrant I. Find cos(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = −20y = 21rP(−20, 21)Ox = −20 (20 left) y = 21 (21 up) r = 29the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point is left of the y-axis, so its x is −20 and cos a = −2029.
  1. Say what it asks: one value of each angle is given; find the cosine of the angle a−b.The cosine difference formula, cos(a − b) = cos a cos b + sin a sin b, needs cos a and sin b, and both are missing.
  2. For a: y=21 and r=29, so x2=292−212=841−441=400, and x is 20 or −20.The right triangle with legs x and y and slanted side r; both 20 and −20 square to 400.
  3. a is in Quadrant II, left of the y-axis, so x=−20 and cosa=−2029. Plug back in: (−20)2+212=400+441=841=292.In Quadrant II every x is negative, so cosine is negative there. This sign is the gotcha of this rung.
  4. For b: x=4 and r=5, so y2=25−16=9,y=3, and sinb=35.Quadrant I keeps y positive.
  5. cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=(−2029)(45)+(2129)(35).The cosine difference formula, with plus in the middle.
  6. =−80145+63145=−17145.20 · 4 = 80, made negative by the one negative factor; 21 · 3 = 63; 29 · 5 = 145. Then −80 + 63 = −17. 17 does not divide 145 = 5 · 29, so the fraction is finished.
Answer
cos(a−b)=−17145
Double-check Second way, by estimating the angles. sin 46° ≈ 0.719 is close to 2129 ≈ 0.724, so a ≈ 180° − 46° = 134°. cos 37° ≈ 0.799 is close to 45 = 0.8, so b ≈ 37°. Then a − b ≈ 97°, a little past 90°, where cosine is slightly negative: cos 97° ≈ −0.122, close to −17145 ≈ −0.117 (the small gap comes from rounding the angles to whole degrees). Had cos a lost its minus sign, the answer would have been 143145 ≈ 0.986, nowhere near.

Rung 4 of 6

Negative given values, Quadrants III and II

sin a = −2029 with a in Quadrant III, and cos b = −817 with b in Quadrant II. Find sin(a + b) and cos(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = −21y = −20rP(−21, −20)Ox = −21 (21 left) y = −20 (20 down) r = 29the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point in Quadrant III: both legs point the negative way, so sin a and cos a are both negative.
xyθx = −8y = 15rP(−8, 15)Ox = −8 (8 left) y = 15 (15 up) r = 17the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
b's point in Quadrant II: left, so cos b is negative, and up, so sin b = 1517.
  1. Say what it asks: two exact values, sin(a+b) and cos(a−b). First see that the given signs fit: sine is negative in Quadrant III, and cosine is negative in Quadrant II.A given sign that clashed with its quadrant would mean a misread problem, so this check catches trouble before any work.
  2. For a: sina=−2029=yr, so y=−20 and r=29. Then x2=841−400=441, and x is 21 or −21.The minus belongs to y, since r is a distance and always positive. Putting the minus on r is the gotcha of this rung.
  3. Quadrant III is left of the y-axis, so x=−21 and cosa=−2129. Plug back in: (−21)2+(−20)2=441+400=841=292.In Quadrant III both x and y are negative.
  4. For b: cosb=−817=xr, so x=−8 and r=17. Then y2=289−64=225, and y is 15 or −15. Quadrant II is above the x-axis, so y=15 and sinb=1517.In Quadrant II y is positive. Plug back in: (−8)2 + 152 = 64 + 225 = 289 = 172.
  5. Full list: sina=−2029,cosa=−2129,sinb=1517,cosb=−817.Three of the four values are negative, so having them all in one place matters most on this rung.
  6. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=(−2029)(−817)+(−2129)(1517)=160493−315493=−155493.20 · 8 = 160, positive from two negatives; 21 · 15 = 315, negative from one negative; 29 · 17 = 493; and 160 − 315 = −155.
  7. cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=(−2129)(−817)+(−2029)(1517)=168493−300493=−132493.21 · 8 = 168, positive from two negatives; 20 · 15 = 300, negative from one negative; and 168 − 300 = −132.
  8. Neither fraction simplifies: 155=5·31 and 132=2·2·3·11 share no factor with 493=17·29.A fraction is finished when its top and bottom share no factor.
Answer
  • sin(a+b)=−155493
  • cos(a−b)=−132493
Double-check Second way, by estimating the angles. sin 43.6° ≈ 0.690 is close to 2029 ≈ 0.690, so a ≈ 180° + 43.6° = 223.6°. cos 61.9° ≈ 0.471 is close to 817 ≈ 0.471, so b ≈ 180° − 61.9° = 118.1°. Then a + b ≈ 341.7°, a little short of a full turn and below the x-axis, and sin 341.7° ≈ −0.314, close to −155493 ≈ −0.314. And a − b ≈ 105.5°, with cos 105.5° ≈ −0.267, close to −132493 ≈ −0.268. The signs agree, and the sizes agree up to the rounding of the angles.

Rung 5 of 6

Square roots that stay in the answer

sin a = 23 with a in Quadrant II, and cos b = 14 with b in Quadrant IV. Find sin(a + b) and cos(a − b).

Show the steps and the answer
x = cos θy = sin θa
a ends in the upper left: sin a = 23 is the height, and cos a = −53 reaches left.
x = cos θy = sin θb
b ends in the lower right: cos b = 14 reaches a little right, and sin b = −154 drops well below the axis.
  1. Say what it asks: the same two exact values as before, but these triangles do not have whole-number sides, so square roots will stay in the answers.The method does not change; only the arithmetic gets longer.
  2. For a: y=2 and r=3, so x2=9−4=5, and x is 5 or −5.No whole number squares to 5, so the leg stays as a square root.
  3. Quadrant II is left of the y-axis, so x=−5 and cosa=−53. Plug back in: (−5)2+22=5+4=9=32.x is negative in Quadrant II, and squaring a square root gives back the number inside.
  4. For b: x=1 and r=4, so y2=16−1=15, and y is 15 or −15. Quadrant IV is below the x-axis, so y=−15 and sinb=−154.y is negative in Quadrant IV. Plug back in: 12 + (−15)2 = 1 + 15 = 16 = 42.
  5. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=(23)(14)+(−53)(−154).The sine sum formula, each value in parentheses.
  6. =212+7512.Tops: 2 · 1 = 2 and 5 · 15 = 75, since two square roots multiply under one root. Bottoms: 3 · 4 = 12. Two negatives give a positive. The gotcha: keep 212 as it is rather than reducing it to 16, so the two bottoms still match.
  7. 75=25·3=53, so sin(a+b)=2+5312.25 is a perfect square inside 75, and 25 = 5 comes out of the root. The bottoms match, so the tops join over 12; 2 and 53 are not like terms, so they stay as a sum.
  8. cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=(−53)(14)+(23)(−154)=−512−21512=−5+21512.Each product has one negative factor, so both are negative. 5 and 15 are different roots and cannot be combined, and neither has a perfect square factor to pull out.
Answer
  • sin(a+b)=2+5312
  • cos(a−b)=−5+21512
Double-check Decimals first, rounded: 2+5312 ≈ 2+8.66012 ≈ 0.888 and −5+21512 ≈ −2.236+7.74612 ≈ −0.832. Second way, by estimating the angles: sin 42° ≈ 0.669 is close to 23 ≈ 0.667, so a ≈ 180° − 42° = 138°; cos 76° ≈ 0.242 is close to 14 = 0.25, so b is about 76° below the positive x-axis, b ≈ −76°. Then a + b ≈ 62°, and sin 62° ≈ 0.883; a − b ≈ 214°, and cos 214° ≈ −0.829. Both agree with the exact answers in sign and nearly in size; the small gaps come from rounding the angles to whole degrees.

Rung 6 of 6

The givens swapped, and where a + b ends

cos a = −2029 with a in Quadrant III, and sin b = 1237 with b in Quadrant II. Find sin(a + b) and cos(a + b), then name the quadrant where a + b points.

Show the steps and the answer
xyθx = −20y = −21rP(−20, −21)Ox = −20 (20 left) y = −21 (21 down) r = 29the ray from O through P (and beyond) = the terminal side
a's point in Quadrant III: 20 left and 21 down, so sin a = −2129.
27°387°same terminal side
a + b is about 387°, one full turn past 27°, so it ends where 27° ends, in Quadrant I.
  1. Say what it asks: here the given values are the other way around, a cosine for a and a sine for b. Find two exact values, sin(a+b) and cos(a+b), and then use their signs to say which quadrant the angle a+b points into.The method does not care which value is given: whichever one is missing is the one to rebuild.
  2. For a: cosa=−2029=xr, so x=−20 and r=29. Then y2=841−400=441, and y is 21 or −21. Quadrant III is below the x-axis, so y=−21 and sina=−2129.In Quadrant III both x and y are negative. Plug back in: (−20)2 + (−21)2 = 400 + 441 = 841 = 292.
  3. For b: sinb=1237=yr, so y=12 and r=37. Then x2=372−122=1369−144=1225, and x is 35 or −35. Quadrant II is left of the y-axis, so x=−35 and cosb=−3537.37 · 37 = 1369 and 35 · 35 = 1225. In Quadrant II x is negative. Plug back in: (−35)2 + 122 = 1225 + 144 = 1369 = 372.
  4. sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=(−2129)(−3537)+(−2029)(1237)=7351073−2401073=4951073.21 · 35 = 735, positive from two negatives; 20 · 12 = 240, negative from one negative; 29 · 37 = 1073; and 735 − 240 = 495.
  5. cos(a+b)=cosacosb−sinasinb=(−2029)(−3537)−(−2129)(1237)=7001073−(−2521073)=7001073+2521073=9521073.The cosine sum formula has a minus in the middle. The gotcha here is the double minus: taking away a negative is adding, so 700 + 252 = 952.
  6. Both answers are positive, so a+b points into Quadrant I.sin(a + b) is the y and cos(a + b) is the x of the point for a + b on the unit circle, and only in Quadrant I are both positive.
  7. Neither fraction simplifies: 495=3·3·5·11 and 952=2·2·2·7·17 share no factor with 1073=29·37.A fraction is finished when its top and bottom share no factor.
Answer
  • sin(a+b)=4951073
  • cos(a+b)=9521073
  • a + b points into Quadrant I
Double-check Second way, with the angles. cos 46.4° ≈ 0.690 is close to 2029 ≈ 0.690, so a ≈ 180° + 46.4° = 226.4°. sin 18.9° ≈ 0.324 is close to 1237 ≈ 0.324, so b ≈ 180° − 18.9° = 161.1°. Then a + b ≈ 226.4° + 161.1° = 387.5°: one full turn (360°) plus 27.5°, so it points the same way as 27.5°, in Quadrant I. A calculator gives sin 27.5° ≈ 0.462 and cos 27.5° ≈ 0.887, close to 4951073 ≈ 0.461 and 9521073 ≈ 0.887. As an exact test, 4952 + 9522 = 245025 + 906304 = 1151329 = 10732, so the two answers square and add to 1, as the sine and cosine of one angle must.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin a = 817 with a in Quadrant II, so cos a = 1517.
The Pythagorean theorem gives only the length 15, because 152 and (−15)2 are both 225. In Quadrant II the point is left of the y-axis, where x is negative. With the wrong sign the main example's sin(a + b) comes out −1385 instead of 7785.
✓ Instead: cosa=−1517=−1517.
✗ Not this: cosa=1−sina=1−817=917.
The identity is about squares: sin2a + cos2a = 1. Testing the wrong value: (817)2 + (917)2 = 64+81289 = 145289, which is not 1.
✓ Instead: cos2a = 1 − 64289 = 225289, so cos a = −1517 in Quadrant II.
✗ Not this: sin(a+b)=sina+sinb=817+(−35)=−1185.
Sine does not spread over a sum, any more than cosine does. This shortcut does not even get the sign right: the true value is positive.
✓ Instead: sin(a+b)=sinacosb+cosasinb=7785.
✗ Not this: sin a = −725, so y = −7 and r = −25.
r is the distance from the center to the point, and a distance is never negative. A minus on both would cancel: −7−25 = 725, a positive sine.
✓ Instead: y = −7 and r = 25. Then x2 = 625 − 49 = 576, so x is 24 or −24, and the quadrant picks.
✗ Not this: cos(a−b)=cosacosb−sinasinb.
That minus belongs to cos(a + b). With the main example's values it gives −6085 + 2485 = −3685, which is the cosine of a + b, not of a − b.
✓ Instead: cos(a−b)=cosacosb+sinasinb=−8485.

Tips and tricks

  • Fill the four-slot list, signs included, before you touch a formula. After that, the formula is copying.
  • Say it each time you take a square root: size from the triangle, sign from the quadrant.
  • Wrap every value in parentheses when you substitute, as in (−1517)(−35). The parentheses keep minus signs from falling off.
  • Fast size check: a sine or cosine always lies between −1 and 1, so an answer such as 11785 is wrong before you look further.
  • Best sign check: estimate each angle by trying values on a calculator, add or subtract the estimates, and compare the sine or cosine of that angle with your answer.
  • When the slanted sides are 17 and 5, every product has bottom 17 · 5 = 85, so the bottoms always match and only the tops need adding.
  • Keep the shared bottom while adding: 212 + 7512 stays over 12 until the end, even though 212 alone would reduce to 16.

7 The trap

Dropping the sign of the missing value. The square root gives only the size, as in 225 = 15. Writing cos a = 1517 for an angle in Quadrant II turns the main example's sin(a + b) = 7785 into −1385. Choose the sign from the quadrant in the same step where you take the root, before the value goes anywhere near a formula.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

What must you know before you can use a sine or cosine sum formula or difference formula?
  • All four values: sin a, cos a, sin b and cos b.
  • If the problem gives only one value of each angle, rebuild each missing value from a right triangle and that angle's quadrant before you substitute anything.
  • The tangent formulas are different: they need only tan a and tan b.
cos b = −725 and b is in Quadrant III. What is sin b?
  • sinb=−2425
  • The minus goes on x, so x = −7 and r = 25, because r is never negative.
  • y2 = 252 − (−7)2 = 625 − 49 = 576, so y is 24 in size.
  • In Quadrant III the point sits below the x-axis, so y = −24.
Why does the Pythagorean theorem give only the size of a missing value, never its sign?
  • It works with squares, and squaring erases a sign: 42 and (−4)2 are both 16, so 16 reports only 4.
  • It is like hearing the address 400 Main Street in a town where Main runs both east and west of the center: the number says how far, not which side. The quadrant names the side, and so the sign.
The slots are full: sin a = 725, cos a = −2425, sin b = −817, cos b = 1517. What is cos(a − b)?
  • cos(a−b)=−416425
  • The difference formula for cosine has a plus in the middle: cos a cos b + sin a sin b.
  • Substitute: (−2425)(1517) + (725)(−817) = −360425 − 56425 = −416425
  • Check: −416425 lies between −1 and 1, as every cosine must.

Lesson 7 of 7

Reading a formula backwards

Subject: MathematicsLeans on: The sine formulas, forwardsLeans on: The cosine formulas, forwardsLeans on: The tangent formulas, forwardsLeans on: Special angle valuesLeans on: Order in a productLeans on: Sine and cosine of a negative angleLeans on: Subtracting a negativeLeans on: Multiplying square rootsLeans on: Fractions with πLeans on: Exact values outside quadrant ILeans on: Radians to degreesLeans on: Calculator modeLeans on: CofunctionsLeans on: sin²θ + cos²θ = 1Leans on: Combining like termsLeans on: A minus sign in front of parenthesesLeans on: Pulling out a minus signOpen this lesson
Leans on 0Comes back in 0

1 In plain words

In the earlier lessons each sum formula and difference formula worked forwards: one thing, sin(x − y), came apart into four pieces. Reading a formula backwards is the reverse. Picture a suitcase. Unpacking it lays four things out on the bed in a set arrangement. If you walk in and see those four things in exactly that arrangement, you know which suitcase they came out of, and you can pack them back into one. This pays off when the pieces are hard to work with and the suitcase is not. You cannot find sin 83° from the special angles, yet sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23° packs into sin(83° − 23°), which is sin 60° = 32.

2 Picture it

sin83°cos23°−cos83°sin23°

=sin(83°−23°)

=sin60°=32

Reminder

Reminder: The sine formulas, forwards, The cosine formulas, forwards, The tangent formulas, forwards, Special angle values, Order in a product, Sine and cosine of a negative angle, Subtracting a negative, Multiplying square roots, Fractions with π, Exact values outside quadrant I, Radians to degrees, Calculator mode, Cofunctions, sin2θ+cos2θ=1, Combining like terms, A minus sign in front of parentheses, Pulling out a minus sign
  • The sine formulas, forwards. sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y and sin(x + y) = sin x cos y + cos x sin y. With x = 90° and y = 30°: sin 60° = (1)(32) − (0)(12) = 32.
  • The cosine formulas, forwards. cos(x − y) = cos x cos y + sin x sin y and cos(x + y) = cos x cos y − sin x sin y. With x = y = 45°: cos 0° = 12 + 12 = 1.
  • The tangent formulas, forwards. tan(x + y) = tanx+tany1−tanxtany and tan(x − y) = tanx−tany1+tanxtany. With x = y = 45°: tan 0° = 1−11+1 = 0.
  • Special angle values. sin 0° = 0, sin 30° = 12, sin 45° = 22, sin 60° = 32, sin 90° = 1. Cosine is the same list from the other end, so cos 0° = 1 and cos 60° = 12. And tan 45° = 1.
  • Order in a product. Swapping two factors does not change a product: 3 × 5 = 5 × 3 = 15, and cos 10° sin 40° = sin 40° cos 10°.
  • Sine and cosine of a negative angle. sin(−θ) = −sin θ, but cos(−θ) = cos θ: sin(−30°) = −12, while cos(−60°) = 12.
  • Subtracting a negative. Subtracting a negative number adds it: 5 − (−3) = 5 + 3 = 8.
  • Multiplying square roots. A square root times itself is the number inside: (22)(22) = 24 = 12, since 2 · 2 = 2.
  • Fractions with π. Give them the same bottom first, then reduce: π2 − π6 = 3π6 − π6 = 2π6 = π3.
  • Exact values outside quadrant I. Use the reference angle, then the quadrant's sign: cos 120° has reference angle 60°, and cosine is negative in quadrant II, so cos 120° = −12.
  • Radians to degrees. π radians is 180°, so put 180° in place of π: π4 = 180°4 = 45°.
  • Calculator mode. Degree mode reads sin(30) as sin 30° = 0.5; radian mode reads it as 30 radians and gives about −0.988 (rounded). Match the mode to the angles.
  • Cofunctions. sin(90° − t) = cos t and cos(90° − t) = sin t: cos 60° = sin 30° = 12, since 90° − 30° = 60°.
  • sin2θ+cos2θ=1. It holds for every angle: at 30°, (12)2 + (32)2 = 14 + 34 = 1.
  • Combining like terms. 7θ − 3θ = 4θ, as 7 apples minus 3 apples is 4 apples.
  • A minus sign in front of parentheses. It flips every sign inside: 10 − (6 − 2) = 10 − 6 + 2 = 6.
  • Pulling out a minus sign. a − b = −(b − a): 3 − 8 = −5, and −(8 − 3) = −5.

3 Why

An equals sign works in both directions. The difference formula says sin(x − y) and sin x cos y − cos x sin y are the same number for every pair of angles, so wherever you meet the long side you may write the short side instead, the way 3 × 4 = 12 lets you write 12 wherever you see 3 × 4. People read it this way because the long side needs four values and the short side needs one. Problems are often built so that the four values are hard to find while the single angle left over is special.

4 The rule

sinxcosy−cosxsiny=sin(x−y), for every pair of angles x and y.

Every other sum formula and difference formula can be read from right to left in the same way, the tangent ones wherever they are defined; the table lists all six.

The same idea, five ways

Say it

Sine x cosine y minus cosine x sine y is the sine of x minus y.

Write it

When you see the sine of one angle times the cosine of a second angle, minus the cosine of the first angle times the sine of the second, you may write the whole thing as the sine of the first angle minus the second.

In math
  • sinxcosy−cosxsiny=sin(x−y)
  • sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y, the same equation read forwards
  • sin a cos b − cos a sin b = sin(a − b), the same pattern with other letters
  • sin83°cos23°−cos83°sin23°=sin(83°−23°)=sin60°
  • sin(7π12)cos(π4)−cos(7π12)sin(π4)=sin(π3)
Like

Like a cashier trading four quarters for one dollar bill: the same amount of money, carried as one piece instead of four.

See it

sinxcosy−cosxsiny

=sin(x−y)

four values in, one value out

The same idea, other ways

As a picture

Start pointing right and turn 83° counterclockwise, then turn back 23°. You stop at 60°. The long expression sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23° is the sine of the place where you stop: one angle, one height on the unit circle, sin 60° = 32.

−23°terminal sideinitial side
From 83°, turning back 23° stops at 60°: the packed angle is where the two turns end.
With small numbers

You have done this with plain numbers. Nobody wants to work out 17 × 46 + 17 × 54 piece by piece. Spot the shared 17 and pack it: 17 × (46 + 54) = 17 × 100 = 1700. That is the distributive law read backwards. Reading a trig formula backwards is the same move: the pieces sin 83° and cos 23° are hard to find, and the packed angle, 60°, is special.

As a rule of thumb

Sine Same, Cosine Changes. Look at the sign between the two products. In a sine pattern it is the same as the sign between the angles; in a cosine pattern it is the opposite. So sin x cos y − cos x sin y is sin(x − y), but cos x cos y − sin x sin y is cos(x + y).

sinxcosy−cosxsiny=sin(x−y)

sin x cos y + cos x sin y = sin(x + y)

cosxcosy+sinxsiny=cos(x−y)

cosxcosy−sinxsiny=cos(x+y)

Why it must be true

An equation says its two sides are the same number. The difference formula sin(x − y) = sin x cos y − cos x sin y was proved for every pair of angles, so read from right to left it is still true: sin x cos y − cos x sin y = sin(x − y). Nothing new needs proving. You are only choosing which of two names for one number to write, and the short name is usually the one you can evaluate.

The long side you seeHow to spot itPack it into
sinxcosy−cosxsinyeach product a sine times a cosine, minus betweensin(x−y)
sin x cos y + cos x sin yeach product a sine times a cosine, plus betweensin(x + y)
cos x cos y + sin x sin ycosines together, sines together, plus betweencos(x−y)
cosxcosy−sinxsinycosines together, sines together, minus betweencos(x + y)
tanx−tany1+tanxtanytangents, minus on top, plus on the bottomtan(x−y)
tanx+tany1−tanxtanytangents, plus on top, minus on the bottomtan(x + y)

5 How

  1. Name the two functions in each product. A sine times a cosine in both products points to a sine formula. A cosine times a cosine in one product and a sine times a sine in the other point to a cosine formula. A fraction of tangents points to a tangent formula.
  2. Check that the same two angles appear in both products, that each angle switches function from one product to the other, and that no number multiplies only one product. If any check fails, stop: no formula packs it.
  3. Choose between x + y and x − y with Sine Same, Cosine Changes: a sine pattern keeps the sign between the products as the sign between the angles, a cosine pattern switches it, and a tangent fraction keeps it on top and switches it on the bottom.
  4. For a difference, put first the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine the order does not matter.
  5. Work out the one angle, giving fractions with π a common bottom, then evaluate its sine, cosine or tangent, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
  6. Check the answer a second way: a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or a test angle put into both the start and the answer.

Matching an expression to a formula and packing it

1
Are the same two angles used throughout, with no number in front of only one product?
YesGo on.
NoStop. No sum or difference formula packs it as written.
↓
2
Is it a fraction with two tangents on top and 1 with a product of the same two tangents on the bottom?
YesA tangent formula. Plus on top with minus below packs into tan(x + y). Minus on top with plus below packs into tan(x − y), where x is the angle whose tangent comes first on top. Matching signs on top and below do not pack.
NoGo on.
↓
3
Is each product a sine times a cosine, with the angle under the sine in one product under the cosine in the other?
YesA sine formula, with the sign kept. Plus between the products packs into sin(x + y). Minus packs into sin(x − y), where x is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign.
NoGo on.
↓
4
Is one product a cosine times a cosine and the other a sine times a sine?
YesA cosine formula, with the sign switched. If the sine product comes first, swap the two products after a plus, or pull out a minus sign after a minus and keep it in front. Then plus between the products packs into cos(x − y), and minus packs into cos(x + y).
NoStop. The expression does not have the shape of any sum or difference formula.
  1. Name the two functions in each product: a sine with a cosine, a cosine with a cosine and a sine with a sine, or tangents in a fraction.
  2. Check that the same two angles are used throughout and that no number multiplies only one product; in two products, check too that each angle switches function from one product to the other.
  3. Find the matching row of the table, using Sine Same, Cosine Changes to choose between x + y and x − y.
  4. For a difference, decide which angle is x: the angle whose sine, or tangent, comes before the minus sign. With cosine either order gives the same answer.
  5. Add or subtract the angles, giving fractions with π a common bottom, and reduce.
  6. Evaluate the one function from the special angles, or keep the shorter expression when the angle holds a letter.
  7. Check with a calculator decimal of the whole long side, or with a test angle.

6 Worked example

Worked example

Packing sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23°

Find the exact value of sin 83° cos 23° − cos 83° sin 23°.

Show the steps and the answer

sin83°cos23°−cos83°sin23°

sinxcosy−cosxsiny

x = 83°, y = 23°

=sin(83°−23°)=sin60°=32

30°60°√31245°45°11√2
In the 30-60-90 triangle the side opposite 60° is 3 and the hypotenuse is 2, so sin 60° = 32.
  1. Say what the question asks: one number for the whole expression, written exactly with fractions and roots, not as a rounded decimal.An exact value is the number itself, such as 32. A decimal such as 0.866 is only close to it.
  2. Name the functions in each product: sin83°cos23° is a sine times a cosine, and cos83°sin23° is a cosine times a sine.When each product holds one sine and one cosine, only a sine formula can have produced it.
  3. Check the angles: both products use 83° and 23°, and no number stands in front of either product.The formula packs only when the same two angles fill both products.
  4. The sign between the products is minus, so the pattern is sinxcosy−cosxsiny=sin(x−y).Sine Same: in a sine formula the sign between the products is the sign between the angles.
  5. x=83° and y=23°.x is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, and that product is sin 83° cos 23°.
  6. Pack it: sin83°cos23°−cos83°sin23°=sin(83°−23°)=sin60°.The two sides of the difference formula are the same number, so the long side may be traded for the short one.
  7. sin60°=32.60° is a special angle: in the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side opposite 60° is 3, and opposite over hypotenuse is 32.
Answer
32
Double-check Type the whole left side into a calculator in degree mode as one line: sin(83) × cos(23) − cos(83) × sin(23) gives 0.8660254 (rounded). Then 3 ÷ 2 gives 0.8660254 as well. The two agree, and the calculator never used the formula.

Ladder: from easy to exam-hard

Try each rung before you open its steps.

Rung 1 of 8

A sine difference

Write sin 47° cos 17° − cos 47° sin 17° as one sine, then give its exact value.

Show the steps and the answer
−17°terminal sideinitial side
From 47°, turning back 17° stops at 30°, the packed angle.
  1. Say what it asks: trade the four values for a single sine, then name that sine's exact value.Packing comes first, and the value of the packed sine comes second.
  2. Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use 47° and 17°, and a minus sits between them.That is the shape of sin x cos y − cos x sin y.
  3. x=47° and y=17°.sin 47° sits in the product before the minus sign.
  4. Pack it: sin(47°−17°)=sin30°.The difference formula read from right to left.
  5. sin30°=12.In the 30-60-90 triangle with hypotenuse 2, the side opposite 30° is 1.
Answer
  • As one sine: sin 30°
  • Exact value: 12
Double-check A calculator in degree mode gives sin 47° cos 17° − cos 47° sin 17° = 0.5000000 (rounded), which is 12.

Rung 2 of 8

A plus sign, so a sine sum

Find the exact value of sin 52° cos 38° + cos 52° sin 38°.

Show the steps and the answer
52°38°sum = 90°
52° and 38° fill a right angle exactly, which is why the packed angle is 90°.
  1. Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.Neither 52° nor 38° is a special angle, so their four values will not give an exact answer one at a time.
  2. Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use 52° and 38°, and a plus sits between them.That is the shape of sin x cos y + cos x sin y.
  3. Pack it: sin(52°+38°)=sin90°.Sine Same: a plus between the products means a plus between the angles. With a plus the order does not matter, since 52° + 38° = 38° + 52°.
  4. sin90°=1.At 90° the point on the unit circle is (0, 1), and the sine is its height.
Answer
1
Double-check A second way, with no calculator: 38° = 90° − 52°, so the cofunction facts give cos 38° = sin 52° and sin 38° = cos 52°. Put those in: sin 52° · sin 52° + cos 52° · cos 52° = sin2 52° + cos2 52°, and sin2θ + cos2θ = 1 for every angle. The expression is 1.

Rung 3 of 8

Cosine switches the sign

Find the exact value of cos 80° cos 35° + sin 80° sin 35°.

Show the steps and the answer
−35°terminal sideinitial side
From 80°, turning back 35° stops at 45°: the plus between the products stands for this turn back.
  1. Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.80° and 35° are not special angles, but the expression may pack into one angle that is.
  2. One product is a cosine times a cosine and the other a sine times a sine, both with 80° and 35°.Cosines together and sines together is the shape of a cosine formula.
  3. The sign between the products is plus, so the angles are subtracted: cosxcosy+sinxsiny=cos(x−y).Cosine Changes: in a cosine formula the sign between the angles is the opposite of the sign between the products.
  4. Pack it with x=80° and y=35°: cos(80°−35°)=cos45°.The other order, cos(35° − 80°) = cos(−45°), is the same number, because cos(−θ) = cos θ.
  5. cos45°=22.45° is a special angle, and its cosine equals its sine, 22.
Answer
22
Double-check A calculator in degree mode gives cos 80° cos 35° + sin 80° sin 35° = 0.7071068 (rounded), and 2 ÷ 2 = 0.7071068. Adding the angles by mistake would give cos 115°, about −0.4226 (rounded), a negative number, so the switch matters.

Rung 4 of 8

A tangent fraction

Find the exact value of tan33°+tan12°1−tan33°tan12°.

Show the steps and the answer

top: tan 33° + tan 12°, the same sign as the angles

bottom: 1 − tan 33° tan 12°, the sign switched

= tan(33° + 12°) = tan 45° = 1

  1. Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole fraction.tan 33° and tan 12° are not special values, but the fraction may pack into one tangent that is.
  2. Two tangents on top with a plus, and 1 minus the product of the same two tangents on the bottom.That is the shape of tanx+tany1−tanxtany = tan(x + y).
  3. Check the signs: plus on top, minus on the bottom.The top keeps the sign of the angles, as sine does, and the bottom switches it, as cosine does. Matching signs on top and bottom would not pack.
  4. Pack it: tan(33°+12°)=tan45°.The tangent sum formula read from right to left.
  5. tan45°=1.In the 45-45-90 triangle the opposite and adjacent sides are equal, so opposite over adjacent is 1.
Answer
1
Double-check With a calculator in degree mode, the top is tan 33° + tan 12° ≈ 0.861964 and the bottom is 1 − tan 33° tan 12° ≈ 0.861964 (both rounded). Top and bottom are the same number, so the fraction is 1.

Rung 5 of 8

The angles in a scrambled order

Find the exact value of cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65°.

Show the steps and the answer

cos20°sin65°−sin20°cos65°

=sin65°cos20°−cos65°sin20°

x = 65°, y = 20°

=sin45°=22

  1. Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression.20° and 65° are not special angles, but their difference, 45°, is.
  2. Each product is a cosine times a sine, both use 20° and 65°, and a minus sits between them.One sine and one cosine in each product means a sine formula, whatever order the factors are written in.
  3. Rewrite each product with the sine first: cos20°sin65°=sin65°cos20°, and sin20°cos65°=cos65°sin20°.Swapping the two factors of a product does not change it, as 3 × 5 = 5 × 3.
  4. It now reads sin65°cos20°−cos65°sin20°, so x=65° and y=20°.x is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, and that sine is sin 65°, even though 20° was printed first.
  5. Pack it: sin(65°−20°)=sin45°=22.The difference formula read from right to left, then the special angle 45°.
Answer
22
Double-check A calculator in degree mode gives cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65° = 0.7071068 (rounded), a positive number equal to 2 ÷ 2. Taking x = 20° by mistake would give sin(−45°) = −22, which is negative, so the calculator rules it out.

Rung 6 of 8

Radians with different bottoms

Find the exact value of cos(2π3) cos(π12) − sin(2π3) sin(π12).

Show the steps and the answer
135°
The point at 3π4 sits left of the vertical axis, and cosine measures left and right, so cos(3π4) is negative.
x = cos θy = sin θP
Follow the chain for cos 135°: quadrant II, reference angle 45°, table value 22, sign negative.
  1. Say what it asks: one exact number for the whole expression, with the angles in radians.The formulas work the same way in radians as in degrees.
  2. Cosines together, sines together, both with 2π3 and π12, and a minus between them.That is the shape of cos x cos y − sin x sin y.
  3. The minus between the products means the angles are added: cos(x+y), with x=2π3 and y=π12.Cosine Changes: the sign between the angles is the opposite of the sign between the products.
  4. Give the fractions a common bottom: 2π3=8π12, so 8π12+π12=9π12.Fractions add only when their bottoms match, and multiplying the top and bottom of 2π3 by 4 makes the bottom 12 without changing the value.
  5. Reduce: 9π12=3π4, dividing the top and bottom by 3.The reduced form is the one you can find on the unit circle.
  6. cos(3π4)=−22.3π4 lies in quadrant II with reference angle π4. cos(π4) = 22, and cosine is negative in quadrant II.
Answer
−22
Double-check In degrees, 2π3 = 120° and π12 = 15°, and 120° + 15° = 135°, which is 3π4. A calculator in degree mode gives cos 120° cos 15° − sin 120° sin 15° = −0.7071068 (rounded), and −2 ÷ 2 = −0.7071068.

Rung 7 of 8

Simplify, with a letter for the angle

Simplify sin(5θ) cos(2θ) − cos(5θ) sin(2θ).

Show the steps and the answer

θ = 30°

start: sin 150° cos 60° − cos 150° sin 60° = 1

answer: sin(3 · 30°) = sin 90° = 1

3 sin 30° = 32, a different number

  1. Say what it asks: rewrite the expression with as few trig values as possible. There is no single number to find, because θ can be any angle.To simplify is to make an expression shorter while keeping its value the same for every θ.
  2. Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use the angles 5θ and 2θ, and a minus sits between them.x and y can stand for any angles, including 5θ and 2θ.
  3. x=5θ and y=2θ.sin(5θ) sits in the product before the minus sign.
  4. Pack it: sin(5θ−2θ)=sin(3θ).The difference formula read from right to left, then 5θ − 2θ = 3θ, as 5 apples minus 2 apples is 3 apples.
  5. Stop at sin(3θ). Do not rewrite it as 3sinθ.The number inside does not come out in front: at θ = 30°, sin(3θ) = sin 90° = 1, but 3 sin 30° = 32.
Answer
sin(3θ)
Double-check Test θ = 30°. The start becomes sin 150° cos 60° − cos 150° sin 60° = (12)(12) − (−32)(32) = 14 + 34 = 1. The answer becomes sin(3 · 30°) = sin 90° = 1. They match.

Rung 8 of 8

Rung 8, genuinely hard: the letter cancels

Show that sin(θ + 40°) cos(θ − 20°) − cos(θ + 40°) sin(θ − 20°) has the same value for every angle θ, and find that value.

Show the steps and the answer

(θ+40°)−(θ−20°)

=θ+40°−θ+20°

= 60°

  1. Say what it asks: pack the expression and see whether θ survives. If θ cancels, the expression is one fixed number.An expression has the same value for every θ when θ no longer appears in it.
  2. Each product is a sine times a cosine, both use the angles θ+40° and θ−20°, and a minus sits between them.x and y can be whole expressions: here x = θ + 40° and y = θ − 20°.
  3. Check the order: sin(θ+40°) sits in the product before the minus sign, so x=θ+40°.In a sine difference the order decides the sign of the answer.
  4. Pack it: sin((θ+40°)−(θ−20°)).The difference formula read from right to left, with parentheses kept around each angle so that the whole of y is subtracted.
  5. Subtract with care: (θ+40°)−(θ−20°)=θ+40°−θ+20°=60°.The minus in front of (θ − 20°) flips both signs inside, so −20° becomes +20°, and θ − θ = 0.
  6. sin60°=32.60° is a special angle: opposite over hypotenuse in the 30-60-90 triangle is 32.
Answer
  • θ cancels, so the value is the same for every θ
  • The value: sin 60° = 32
Double-check Test two angles. With θ = 20°: sin 60° cos 0° − cos 60° sin 0° = (32)(1) − (12)(0) = 32. With θ = 50°: sin 90° cos 30° − cos 90° sin 30° = (1)(32) − (0)(12) = 32. Both give 32. The tempting slip θ + 40° − θ − 20° = 20° would give sin 20°, about 0.3420 (rounded), which neither test gives.

Counterexamples

What it is not, and the tempting wrong moves.

✗ Not this: sin50°cos20°−cos40°sin20°=sin(50°−20°)=12
The two products do not share the same two angles: the first pairs 50° with 20°, the second pairs 40° with 20°. The pattern needs cos 50° in the second product, so nothing packs.
✓ Instead: No single formula fits. A calculator gives about 0.4578 (rounded), not 0.5. Only sin 50° cos 20° − cos 50° sin 20° packs, into sin 30° = 12.
✗ Not this: cos 74° cos 14° + sin 74° sin 14° = cos(74° + 14°) = cos 88°
That copies the sine habit. In a cosine formula the sign changes: a plus between the products comes from a minus between the angles.
✓ Instead: cos 74° cos 14° + sin 74° sin 14° = cos(74° − 14°) = cos 60° = 12. A calculator gives 0.5 for the left side, while cos 88° is about 0.0349 (rounded).
✗ Not this: cos10°sin40°−sin10°cos40°=sin(10°−40°)=sin(−30°)=−12
The first angle of a sine difference is the angle whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign. That product is cos 10° sin 40°, so the first angle is 40°, even though 10° is printed first.
✓ Instead: Swap the factors in each product: sin 40° cos 10° − cos 40° sin 10° = sin(40° − 10°) = sin 30° = 12. A calculator gives 0.5, a positive number.
✗ Not this: sin50°sin10°−cos50°cos10°=cos(50°+10°)=12
In the cosine formula the cosine product comes before the minus sign: cos x cos y − sin x sin y. Here the sine product comes first, and that turns the whole expression into its negative.
✓ Instead: Pull out a minus sign: −(cos 50° cos 10° − sin 50° sin 10°) = −cos(50° + 10°) = −cos 60° = −12. A calculator gives −0.5.

Tips and tricks

  • Memory device: Sine Same, Cosine Changes. In a sine formula the sign between the products is the same as the sign between the angles. In a cosine formula it changes to the opposite. A tangent fraction does both: its top keeps the sign, as sine does, and its bottom changes it, as cosine does.
  • Look at the shape before the signs. If every product pairs a sine with a cosine, think sine. If the cosines sit together and the sines sit together, think cosine.
  • The giveaway in a problem: two angles that are not special but whose sum or difference is, such as 83° and 23°, which make 60°. That is a hint the expression is meant to be packed, and once the pattern is spotted the packing takes one step.
  • Check by typing the whole long side into a calculator as one line, in degree mode for degrees and radian mode for angles with π. Rounding each piece first can change the last digit and make a right answer look wrong.
  • To check a simplification with θ, put one test angle such as θ = 30° into the start and into your answer. A wrong answer almost always fails this test, though one match does not prove the step.
  • A number that multiplies both products can wait outside: 2 sin x cos y − 2 cos x sin y = 2 sin(x − y).
  • With cosine the order of the two angles does not matter, since cos(−θ) = cos θ: cos(80° − 35°) and cos(35° − 80°) are both cos 45°. With sine and tangent the order decides the sign of the answer.

7 The trap

Taking the angles in the order they are printed. In a sine difference, the first angle is the one whose sine sits in the product before the minus sign, wherever that sine is written. So cos 20° sin 65° − sin 20° cos 65° is sin(65° − 20°) = 22, not sin(20° − 65°). The wrong order gives the negative of the right answer, because sin(−45°) = −sin 45°. Before you subtract, find the sine in the product before the minus sign and put its angle first.

Flash cards

Say the answer out loud, then flip.

Pack cos 10° sin 40° − sin 10° cos 40° into one sine. Which angle goes first, and what is the value?
  • 40° goes first, because sin 40° is the sine in the product before the minus sign. Sine Same keeps the minus.
  • sin(40°−10°)=sin30°=12
  • The printed order, sin(10° − 40°), gives −12: the right size with the wrong sign.
Pack cos 5π12 cos π12 + sin 5π12 sin π12 into one cosine. What is its value?
  • Cosine Changes, so the plus between the products becomes a minus between the angles: cos(5π12 − π12).
  • The bottoms already match, so 5π12 − π12 = 4π12, and dividing top and bottom by 4 gives π3.
  • cosπ3=12
Pack tan20°+tan40°1−tan20°tan40° into one tangent. What is its value?
  • tan(20°+40°)=tan60°=3
  • The plus on top is the sign between the angles, and the minus on the bottom is the switched sign, so the fraction matches the tangent sum formula.
Which three checks tell you that four pieces came out of one suitcase, so a sum formula or difference formula can pack them?
  • The same two angles appear in both products. sin 50° cos 20° + cos 50° sin 30° fails: one product has 20°, the other 30°.
  • Each angle switches function between the products. sin 30° cos 60° + cos 60° sin 30° fails: 30° sits under a sine both times, and the sum is 14 + 14 = 12, not sin 90° = 1.
  • No number multiplies only one product. 2 sin x cos y + cos x sin y fails: the 2 stands in front of the first product only.